Question 1
20 marksIn this section you will be assessed for the quality of your writing skills.
12 marks are awarded for communication and organisation; 8 marks are awarded for vocabulary, sentence structure, punctuation and spelling.
Think about the purpose and audience for your writing.
You should aim to write about 300-400 words.
This is part of a letter that appeared in your local newspaper:
'Every December, the houses in my street compete to put up the most dazzling Christmas lights: flashing reindeer, giant inflatable snowmen and thousands of bulbs left on all night. At a time when we are all being told to save energy, these displays are wasteful and tasteless, and they keep neighbours awake. They should be switched off for good.'
Write a letter to the newspaper responding to this view.
Write your letter.
[20]
Model answer
Dear Editor,
On the first Saturday of every December, a small crowd gathers at the end of my road. Children in bobble hats count down from ten, an elderly neighbour presses a switch, and an ordinary semi-detached house bursts into colour. Last year, the family who live there collected more than six hundred pounds for a local children's charity from the visitors who came to admire their display. I thought of that evening when I read last week's letter describing such displays as 'wasteful and tasteless' and demanding that they be 'switched off for good'.
Let me say at once that your correspondent makes some fair points. Nobody should have to sleep with a flashing reindeer outside their bedroom window, and lights left blazing until dawn benefit no one, because no one is awake to enjoy them. At a time when many families are anxious about their energy bills, waste is hard to justify.
However, banning displays altogether would be an overreaction. Most modern Christmas lights use LED bulbs, which need only a fraction of the electricity of old-fashioned filament bulbs, and a cheap plug-in timer can switch a display off at a sensible hour. The problem, in other words, is not the lights themselves but the way a few people use them.
It is also worth asking what we would lose. December is the darkest month of the year, and for people who live alone it can also be the loneliest. Displays like the one at the end of my road give families a reason to wander out after tea, chat to neighbours they barely know and share something cheerful. As for tastelessness, beauty is in the eye of the beholder: one person's garish inflatable snowman is a five-year-old's highlight of the week.
What I would suggest is a simple neighbourly agreement. Displays could be switched off by ten o'clock, flashing lights could be kept away from neighbours' windows, and anyone planning something especially ambitious could talk to the people next door first. Your newspaper could even encourage this by publishing a map of displays that raise money for local causes.
Christmas lights will never be to everyone's taste, but a little consideration on both sides would allow our streets to keep their sparkle without keeping anyone awake. That seems a far brighter solution than switching off the joy altogether.
Yours faithfully,
Tobias
Explanation
This reaches Level 5 for AO5 because it is a balanced letter that still reaches a clear decision: it accepts the correspondent's fair points (sleep, waste), answers them with relevant detail (LED bulbs, timers, the charity switch-on) and ends with practical, neighbourly proposals suited to local readers. For AO6 it shows a wide range of punctuation and controlled, varied sentences with virtually no errors. A common weakness is to sit on the fence, listing points on both sides without ever deciding.
Mark scheme
-
12 marks
Levels of response (12 marks). AO5 (content and organisation). (Eduqas's band descriptors continue in the comments.)
Level 5 (11-12 marks): shows sophisticated understanding of the purpose and format of the task; shows sustained awareness of the reader / intended audience; appropriate register is confidently adapted to purpose / audience; content is ambitious, pertinent and sophisticated
Level 4 (8-10 marks): shows consistent understanding of the purpose and format of the task; shows secure awareness of the reader/intended audience; register is appropriately and consistently adapted to purpose/audience; content is well-judged and detailed
Level 3 (5-7 marks): shows clear understanding of the purpose and format of the task; shows clear awareness of the reader / intended audience; register is appropriately adapted to purpose / audience; content is developed and appropriate reasons are given in support of opinions / ideas
Level 2 (3-4 marks): shows some awareness of the purpose and format of the task; shows awareness of the reader / intended audience; a clear attempt to adapt register to purpose / audience; some reasons are given in support of opinions and ideas
Level 1 (1-2 marks): basic awareness of the purpose and format of the task; some basic awareness of the reader / intended audience; some attempt to adapt register to purpose / audience (e.g. degree of formality); some relevant content despite uneven coverage of the topic
0 marks: nothing worthy of creditEduqas's band descriptors, continued: Level 5: ideas are convincingly developed and supported by a range of relevant details; there is sophistication in the shape and structure of the writing; communication has ambition and sophistication. Level 4: ideas are organised and coherently developed with supporting detail; there is clear shape and structure in the writing (paragraphs are used effectively to give sequence and organisation); communication has clarity, fluency and some ambition. Level 3: ideas are organised into coherent arguments; there is some shape and structure in the writing (paragraphs are used to give sequence and organisation); communication has clarity and fluency. Level 2: limited development of ideas; some sequencing of ideas into paragraphs (structure / direction may be uncertain); communication has some clarity and fluency. Level 1: content may be thin and brief; simple sequencing of ideas (paragraphs may be used to show obvious divisions or group ideas into some order); there is some basic clarity but communication of meaning is limited. Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid approaches). Agreeing, disagreeing or a balanced view that reaches a clear decision can all reach the top level if argued convincingly. Successful responses may include some of the following features: - a sustained sense of register and purpose, which meets the requirement of a letter to a local newspaper: a serious approach offering a clear and sustained viewpoint, with a fitting salutation and sign-off (for example 'Dear Editor' and 'Yours faithfully'); - an opening that explains why the writer is responding, reacts to the original letter and states a view (Eduqas's November 2024 report: why the letter had been written, the reaction to the original letter and the writer's views 'was all that was needed for an effective opening paragraph'); - agreeing: the energy used and its cost; lights left on all night; light and noise disturbing neighbours' sleep; displays that become competitive or garish; the effect on the night sky and on wildlife; - disagreeing: energy-saving LED bulbs and timers; the cheer that lights bring in the darkest weeks of the year; community spirit, neighbours meeting, families walking out together; money raised for charity by popular displays; taste as a matter of opinion; - a balanced view that reaches a decision, for example keeping displays but switching them off at a set time or agreeing limits with neighbours; - a range of well-selected details to give substance to the opinions: a particular display or street, the reactions of children or older neighbours, practical suggestions; - a clear understanding of the intended audience (local readers, including the correspondent's neighbours and people who put up displays) and of the reader-writer relationship: tactful, local and practical; - a logical structure in which paragraphs develop the argument and lead to a brief, convincing conclusion; a sufficiently detailed and developed letter of about 300-400 words. Less successful responses may be characterised by: - thin and/or brief content; - a limited or uncertain sense of register, purpose and format (for example, a description of Christmas rather than an argument about the displays); - simple assertion (for example, that Christmas lights are fun) or points that only repeat the original letter (Eduqas's November 2024 report: weaker letters were 'sometimes only repeating what had been said in the original letter, but with little development'); - a viewpoint that is not sustained consistently, perhaps agreeing and disagreeing without reaching a decision; a limited or uncertain structure. Addresses are not required in this typed practice; credit them if they are set out correctly.
-
8 marks
Levels of response (8 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
Level 5 (8 marks): there is appropriate and effective variation of sentence structures; virtually all sentence construction is controlled and accurate; a range of punctuation is used confidently and accurately; virtually all spelling, including that of complex irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is totally secure; a wide range of appropriate, ambitious vocabulary is used to create effect or convey precise meaning
Level 4 (6-7 marks): sentence structure is varied to achieve particular effects; control of sentence construction is secure; a range of punctuation is used accurately; spelling, including that of irregular words, is secure; control of tense and agreement is secure; vocabulary is ambitious and used with precision
Level 3 (4-5 marks): there is variety in sentence structure; control of sentence construction is mostly secure; a range of punctuation is used, mostly accurately; most spelling, including that of irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is mostly secure; vocabulary is beginning to develop and is used with some precision
Level 2 (2-3 marks): some variety of sentence structure; there is some control of sentence construction; some control of a range of punctuation; the spelling is usually accurate; control of tense and agreement is generally secure; there is some range of vocabulary
Level 1 (1 mark): limited range of sentence structure; control of sentence construction is limited; there is some attempt to use punctuation; some spelling is accurate; control of tense and agreement is limited; limited range of vocabulary
0 marks: nothing worthy of creditEduqas's guidance: expression is clear, fluent and controlled (the best responses will show ambition and sophistication in expression as well as a high degree of accuracy); there are few, if any, errors (no more than a sprinkling of mistakes); tenses are consistent; vocabulary is used precisely and appropriately to convey meaning; punctuation is used accurately and appropriately (and unobtrusively). Look for: a list of three actions in one controlled sentence ('Children in bobble hats count down from ten, an elderly neighbour presses a switch, and an ordinary semi-detached house bursts into colour'); a colon introducing an illustration ('in the eye of the beholder: one person's garish inflatable snowman'); apostrophes for possession, singular and plural ('last week's letter', 'neighbours' windows'); a subordinate clause placed for effect ('because no one is awake to enjoy them'); precise vocabulary ('overreaction', 'garish', 'consideration'); correct spelling of 'neighbours', 'electricity', 'ambitious' and 'sensible'. A response with nothing worthy of credit scores 0 on both points.