Question 1
10 marksRead the extract from John Muir's book about the mountains of California below. Then answer the question that follows.
19th-century text
The Mountains of California
by John Muir (1894)
John Muir, a Scottish-born naturalist who lived in America, spent many years exploring the mountains and forests of the Sierra Nevada in California. In this extract from his book, published in 1894, he describes going out into the forest during a wind-storm.
[1] One of the most beautiful and exhilarating storms I ever enjoyed in the Sierra occurred in December, 1874, when I happened to be exploring one of the tributary valleys of the Yuba River. The sky and the ground and the trees had been thoroughly rain-washed and were dry again. The day was intensely pure, one of those incomparable bits of California winter, warm and balmy and full of white sparkling sunshine, redolent of all the purest influences of the spring, and at the same time enlivened with one of the most bracing wind-storms conceivable. Instead of camping out, as I usually do, I then chanced to be stopping at the house of a friend. But when the storm began to sound, I lost no time in pushing out into the woods to enjoy it. For on such occasions Nature has always something rare to show us, and the danger to life and limb is hardly greater than one would experience crouching deprecatingly beneath a roof.
[...]
[2] Toward midday, after a long, tingling scramble through copses of hazel and ceanothus, I gained the summit of the highest ridge in the neighborhood; and then it occurred to me that it would be a fine thing to climb one of the trees to obtain a wider outlook and get my ear close to the Aeolian music of its topmost needles. But under the circumstances the choice of a tree was a serious matter. [...] After cautiously casting about, I made choice of the tallest of a group of Douglas Spruces that were growing close together like a tuft of grass, no one of which seemed likely to fall unless all the rest fell with it. Though comparatively young, they were about 100 feet high, and their lithe, brushy tops were rocking and swirling in wild ecstasy. Being accustomed to climb trees in making botanical studies, I experienced no difficulty in reaching the top of this one, and never before did I enjoy so noble an exhilaration of motion. The slender tops fairly flapped and swished in the passionate torrent, bending and swirling backward and forward, round and round, tracing indescribable combinations of vertical and horizontal curves, while I clung with muscles firm braced, like a bobolink on a reed.
[...]
[3] I kept my lofty perch for hours, frequently closing my eyes to enjoy the music by itself, or to feast quietly on the delicious fragrance that was streaming past. [...]
[4] We all travel the milky way together, trees and men; but it never occurred to me until this storm-day, while swinging in the wind, that trees are travelers, in the ordinary sense. They make many journeys, not extensive ones, it is true; but our own little journeys, away and back again, are only little more than tree-wavings--many of them not so much.
[5] When the storm began to abate, I dismounted and sauntered down through the calming woods. The storm-tones died away, and, turning toward the east, I beheld the countless hosts of the forests hushed and tranquil, towering above one another on the slopes of the hills like a devout audience. The setting sun filled them with amber light, and seemed to say, while they listened, "My peace I give unto you."
[6] As I gazed on the impressive scene, all the so-called ruin of the storm was forgotten, and never before did these noble woods appear so fresh, so joyous, so immortal.
Glossary: exhilarating - thrilling, making you feel full of life; deprecatingly - nervously, trying to keep out of trouble; copses - small thick clumps of trees or bushes; Aeolian music - music made by the wind; bobolink - a small North American songbird; neighborhood, travelers - neighbourhood, travellers (American spellings); redolent - full of the scent; ceanothus - a flowering shrub; lithe - bending easily; abate - die down; devout - deeply religious
'John Muir makes climbing a tree in a wind-storm sound safe and sensible.'
To what extent do you agree with this statement?
You should comment on:
- what is said
- how it is said
You must refer to the text to support your comments.
[10]
Model answer
I agree only partly. Muir certainly tries to make his climb sound reasonable, and his confident, joyful tone makes it seem worthwhile, but his own vivid descriptions show that it was thrilling and risky rather than safe and sensible.
Muir begins by arguing that the danger is small. He claims that 'the danger to life and limb is hardly greater than one would experience crouching deprecatingly beneath a roof', and the adverb 'deprecatingly' mocks people who hide indoors, as if they are the foolish ones. He presents the storm as an opportunity: 'Nature has always something rare to show us'.
He also shows care in choosing his tree. He admits that 'the choice of a tree was a serious matter', and 'After cautiously casting about' he picked one in a close group, 'no one of which seemed likely to fall unless all the rest fell with it'. This sounds logical, and his experience - 'Being accustomed to climb trees in making botanical studies' - suggests that he knew what he was doing. His calm, hours-long stay, 'frequently closing my eyes to enjoy the music', and his relaxed return, when he 'sauntered down', make it seem that he was never in serious trouble.
However, his descriptions of the climb suggest real danger. The trees were 'about 100 feet high', and their tops were 'rocking and swirling in wild ecstasy'. The long list of movements, 'bending and swirling backward and forward, round and round', and the metaphor of the 'passionate torrent' of wind create a sense of wild, uncontrollable motion. The simile 'like a bobolink on a reed' makes him seem tiny and fragile, and the phrase 'clung with muscles firm braced' shows the physical effort of holding on.
His reasons are not entirely sensible, either. The idea came on impulse - 'it occurred to me that it would be a fine thing' - and his main purpose was pleasure: 'never before did I enjoy so noble an exhilaration of motion'. Even 'seemed likely' admits that he could not be sure the trees would stand.
Overall, Muir makes the climb sound joyful, even spiritual, ending with the woods 'so fresh, so joyous, so immortal'. His careful choice of tree suggests good judgement, but the vivid danger in his own words shows that it was a thrilling adventure rather than a safe and sensible one.
Explanation
Top-band answers weigh Muir's arguments and care (the claim about the roof, the 'serious matter' of choosing a tree, his experience) against the danger his own language reveals (the height, the 'wild ecstasy' of the swaying tops, the bobolink simile) and his pleasure-seeking motive. They reach a clear overview about how far the account persuades. Weak answers simply agree that he enjoyed it, which does not answer the question about safety.
Mark scheme
-
10 marks
Levels of response (10 marks). AO4: evaluation.
Level 5 (9-10 marks): Give 9-10 marks to those who give a detailed and persuasive evaluation of the statement, supported by a wide range of convincing, well-selected examples and purposeful textual references. These responses will show engagement and involvement with the text/question and take an overview to make perceptive comments on the text.
Level 4 (7-8 marks): Give 7-8 marks to those who give a detailed, critical evaluation of the statement, supported by well-selected textual references. They will show critical awareness and clear engagement with the text, using a good range of relevant details.
Level 3 (5-6 marks): Give 5-6 marks to those who give a view about the statement supported by appropriate textual references. These responses will show some critical exploration of, and response to, a range of relevant details.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): Give 3-4 marks to those who give some simple views about the statement supported by straightforward textual references. These responses may show some exploration of, and response to, some of the details in the passage although coverage may be limited.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): Give 1-2 marks to those who select some basic textual details and/or express a simple personal opinion. Responses in this band may be brief and limited and /or struggle to engage with the text and/or the question.
0 marks: Give 0 marks for responses where there is nothing worthy of credit.Indicative content (not a checklist; the question must be marked in levels of response - look for and reward valid alternatives). Candidates may agree, disagree or partly agree, as long as the view is supported from across the extract. Details that candidates may evaluate or comment on:
Safe and sensible:
- Muir claims the risk is small: 'the danger to life and limb is hardly greater than one would experience crouching deprecatingly beneath a roof'; 'deprecatingly' mocks those who stay indoors
- he presents the storm as an opportunity: 'Nature has always something rare to show us'
- he took care: 'the choice of a tree was a serious matter'; 'After cautiously casting about'
- his reasoning about the group of spruces: 'no one of which seemed likely to fall unless all the rest fell with it'
- his experience: 'Being accustomed to climb trees in making botanical studies, I experienced no difficulty'
- a purpose beyond thrills: 'to obtain a wider outlook and get my ear close to the Aeolian music'
- calm enjoyment for hours: 'frequently closing my eyes to enjoy the music by itself, or to feast quietly on the delicious fragrance'
- a relaxed return: 'I dismounted and sauntered down through the calming woods'
Risky and not sensible:
- the height and the violent motion: 'about 100 feet high'; tops 'rocking and swirling in wild ecstasy'; 'bending and swirling backward and forward, round and round'; the 'passionate torrent' of wind
- he 'clung with muscles firm braced, like a bobolink on a reed' - the simile makes him tiny and fragile
- the climb was an impulse: 'it occurred to me that it would be a fine thing to climb one of the trees'
- his main motive is pleasure: 'never before did I enjoy so noble an exhilaration of motion'
- 'seemed likely' admits uncertainty; 'the choice of a tree was a serious matter' admits risk
- the storm did cause damage: 'all the so-called ruin of the storm was forgotten'
- an overview might note that Muir's joyful, spiritual language ('so fresh, so joyous, so immortal') persuades the reader the experience was worthwhile, which is not the same as safe or sensible; a modern reader may disagree with his claim about the danger