Question 1
10 marksRead both texts below: the blog post and the extract from John Muir's book about the mountains of California. To answer the question you must use both texts.
21st-century text
The night the wood roared
From a blog post by Ifan Penhale (fictional) on a woodland ranger's blog, 2019
In this blog post, a woodland ranger writes about a storm.
[1] At about eleven o'clock on Tuesday night, I gave up trying to sleep. My cottage stands right on the edge of the wood, and the storm that had been building all evening was now so loud that it sounded as if a train was thundering past my bedroom window, over and over again, without ever reaching its end.
[2] I have worked as the ranger here for fourteen years, and I have learned to love wind. On an ordinary blustery day, the trees creak and sigh, and the beech leaves hiss like the sea. But this was different. Gust after gust came roaring up the valley, and between them, every few minutes, I heard the sound I dread most: a sharp crack, like a rifle shot, followed by a long, tearing crash. Somewhere out in the dark, another tree was coming down.
[3] I did not go out. Every instinct told me to check on the wood, but a forest in a storm is no place for people. Branches as thick as your body can fall without warning, and whole trees can topple. So I lay awake and listened, counting the crashes and thinking about the old beech by the pond.
[4] At first light on Wednesday, the wind had dropped, and I walked out into a different wood. Thirty-two trees were down, most of them tall spruces on the exposed northern slope, lying across one another like spilt matchsticks. The main path was blocked in nine places. Then I reached the pond. The old beech, which had stood there for around 180 years, had been torn out of the ground, and its roots reared up in a great wall of earth twice my height.
[5] I sat down on its trunk and felt close to tears. I had eaten my lunch under that tree on most working days since I arrived. Children from the village school had hugged it, measured it, drawn it and written poems about it. It felt like losing an old friend.
[6] The wood will be closed for at least two weeks while we make it safe, so please respect the signs. Some trees that are still standing have cracked trunks, or broken branches hanging high above the paths. Foresters call these 'widowmakers', and the name tells you all you need to know. With the help of twelve volunteers, we have already cleared the main path, but there is a great deal more to do.
[7] And yet, as I walked round again this morning, I began to see the storm differently. Where the spruces fell, sunlight is reaching the forest floor for the first time in decades. Within a couple of summers, that bare ground will be bright with foxgloves, and young oaks and birches will be racing one another towards the light.
[8] The fallen trees matter, too. We will leave many of them exactly where they lie, because a dead tree is not a dead thing. Over the years to come, it will feed fungi, beetles and woodlice, give shelter to wrens and hedgehogs, and slowly crumble back into the soil. Storms have been reshaping woods like ours for thousands of years. The wood will not just recover. In some ways, it will be richer.
[9] As for the old beech, it will stay where it fell, roots and all. The village school has already asked if the children can visit it when the wood reopens, and I hope they will clamber over it and watch it change, year by year. For almost two centuries it towered over the pond. Now it will give it something else: a new beginning.
[10] So come and see what the storm has left behind once we reopen. But please, never come into the wood while the wind is blowing.
Glossary: ranger - a person whose job is to look after a wood or an area of countryside; spruces - tall evergreen trees with needles, related to pines; fungi - mushrooms, toadstools and similar living things, many of which feed on dead wood
19th-century text
The Mountains of California
by John Muir (1894)
John Muir, a Scottish-born naturalist who lived in America, spent many years exploring the mountains and forests of the Sierra Nevada in California. In this extract from his book, published in 1894, he describes going out into the forest during a wind-storm.
[1] One of the most beautiful and exhilarating storms I ever enjoyed in the Sierra occurred in December, 1874, when I happened to be exploring one of the tributary valleys of the Yuba River. The sky and the ground and the trees had been thoroughly rain-washed and were dry again. The day was intensely pure, one of those incomparable bits of California winter, warm and balmy and full of white sparkling sunshine, redolent of all the purest influences of the spring, and at the same time enlivened with one of the most bracing wind-storms conceivable. Instead of camping out, as I usually do, I then chanced to be stopping at the house of a friend. But when the storm began to sound, I lost no time in pushing out into the woods to enjoy it. For on such occasions Nature has always something rare to show us, and the danger to life and limb is hardly greater than one would experience crouching deprecatingly beneath a roof.
[...]
[2] Toward midday, after a long, tingling scramble through copses of hazel and ceanothus, I gained the summit of the highest ridge in the neighborhood; and then it occurred to me that it would be a fine thing to climb one of the trees to obtain a wider outlook and get my ear close to the Aeolian music of its topmost needles. But under the circumstances the choice of a tree was a serious matter. [...] After cautiously casting about, I made choice of the tallest of a group of Douglas Spruces that were growing close together like a tuft of grass, no one of which seemed likely to fall unless all the rest fell with it. Though comparatively young, they were about 100 feet high, and their lithe, brushy tops were rocking and swirling in wild ecstasy. Being accustomed to climb trees in making botanical studies, I experienced no difficulty in reaching the top of this one, and never before did I enjoy so noble an exhilaration of motion. The slender tops fairly flapped and swished in the passionate torrent, bending and swirling backward and forward, round and round, tracing indescribable combinations of vertical and horizontal curves, while I clung with muscles firm braced, like a bobolink on a reed.
[...]
[3] I kept my lofty perch for hours, frequently closing my eyes to enjoy the music by itself, or to feast quietly on the delicious fragrance that was streaming past. [...]
[4] We all travel the milky way together, trees and men; but it never occurred to me until this storm-day, while swinging in the wind, that trees are travelers, in the ordinary sense. They make many journeys, not extensive ones, it is true; but our own little journeys, away and back again, are only little more than tree-wavings--many of them not so much.
[5] When the storm began to abate, I dismounted and sauntered down through the calming woods. The storm-tones died away, and, turning toward the east, I beheld the countless hosts of the forests hushed and tranquil, towering above one another on the slopes of the hills like a devout audience. The setting sun filled them with amber light, and seemed to say, while they listened, "My peace I give unto you."
[6] As I gazed on the impressive scene, all the so-called ruin of the storm was forgotten, and never before did these noble woods appear so fresh, so joyous, so immortal.
Glossary: exhilarating - thrilling, making you feel full of life; deprecatingly - nervously, trying to keep out of trouble; copses - small thick clumps of trees or bushes; Aeolian music - music made by the wind; bobolink - a small North American songbird; neighborhood, travelers - neighbourhood, travellers (American spellings); redolent - full of the scent; ceanothus - a flowering shrub; lithe - bending easily; abate - die down; devout - deeply religious
Both of these texts are about wind-storms in forests.
Compare:
- the writers' views about storms in forests
- how the writers get their views across to readers
You must use the text to support your comments and make it clear which text you are referring to.
[10]
Model answer
Both writers love wind, and both conclude that a storm's damage is not the end of a forest, but they disagree completely about the danger: Muir's view is joyful and spiritual, while Penhale's is practical, grieving and, in the end, hopeful.
Their attitudes to being out in a storm are opposites. Muir calls this 'One of the most beautiful and exhilarating storms I ever enjoyed', and the superlative and the verb 'enjoyed' show delight. He argues that 'the danger to life and limb is hardly greater' than indoors and mocks those who crouch 'deprecatingly beneath a roof'. Penhale, by contrast, states plainly, 'I did not go out', and gives the reason as a general rule: 'a forest in a storm is no place for people'. The direct address in 'Branches as thick as your body can fall without warning' makes the warning personal to the reader.
They also describe the storm's sound differently, which reveals their views. Muir hears 'Aeolian music' and closes his eyes 'to enjoy the music by itself', a metaphor that turns the storm into an art to be appreciated. Penhale's similes - a train 'thundering past' and 'a sharp crack, like a rifle shot' - make it violent and threatening, and 'the sound I dread most' shows fear.
Their responses to the damage are the biggest difference. Muir hardly mentions it: 'all the so-called ruin of the storm was forgotten', and 'so-called' dismisses it. Penhale records it with facts - 'Thirty-two trees were down' - and the simile 'like spilt matchsticks' and the grief of losing the beech, 'like losing an old friend', show real sorrow.
Yet both end with a positive view. Muir sees the trees 'hushed and tranquil' like 'a devout audience', and the biblical words 'My peace I give unto you' give the storm a religious meaning, ending in the triplet 'so fresh, so joyous, so immortal'. Penhale's turn comes with 'And yet', and the paradox that 'a dead tree is not a dead thing' leads to the conclusion that the wood 'will be richer'. Muir sees the storm as revealing the forest's eternal beauty; Penhale sees it as part of a natural cycle of loss and renewal.
The forms help to explain these differences. Muir writes a personal account in elevated, Romantic language to share a spiritual experience. Penhale, a ranger writing a blog for visitors, mixes feeling with facts and instructions such as 'please respect the signs', so the post both moves readers and keeps them safe.
Explanation
This comparison is demanding because the two writers reach similar positive conclusions from opposite attitudes. Top-band answers compare throughout: enjoying the storm outdoors against warning people away, music against violent noise, dismissing the damage against grieving it, and spiritual peace against ecological renewal, with comment on methods such as superlatives, similes, the biblical quotation and the turn at 'And yet'. Weaker answers summarise each text separately.
Mark scheme
-
10 marks
Levels of response (10 marks). AO3: comparison.
Level 5 (9-10 marks): Give 9-10 marks to those who make comparisons that are sustained and detailed, with a wide range of valid comments, showing clear understanding about how the writers get their views across to readers.
Level 4 (7-8 marks): Give 7-8 marks to those who make detailed comparisons about the views the writers have about storms in forests and make valid comments on how the writers get their views across to readers.
Level 3 (5-6 marks): Give 5-6 marks to those who identify similarities and differences in the writers' views about storms in forests making some comparisons and/or commenting on how the writers get their views across to readers.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): Give 3-4 marks to those who identify some of the main similarities and differences in the writers' views about storms in forests and/or make some simple comments on how the writers get their views across to readers.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): Give 1-2 marks to those who identify a basic similarity and/or difference in the writers' views about storms in forests. Marks in this band may only deal with one text or not make it clear to which text is being referred.
0 marks: Give 0 marks for responses where there is nothing worthy of credit.Max 2 if the response only deals with one text or does not make clear which text it is referring to (Eduqas places such answers in the 1-2 mark band: 'Marks in this band may only deal with one text or not make it clear to which text is being referred.'). Indicative content (not a checklist; the question must be marked in levels of response - look for and reward valid alternatives). Details that candidates may explore or respond to:
Views in the blog post:
- the writer loves wind ('I have learned to love wind') but finds this storm frightening: 'the sound I dread most'
- storms make forests dangerous for people: 'a forest in a storm is no place for people'; 'never come into the wood while the wind is blowing'
- storms cause real loss: 'Thirty-two trees were down'; the beech 'torn out of the ground'; 'like losing an old friend'
- but storms are a natural part of a wood's life: 'Storms have been reshaping woods like ours for thousands of years'
- storms bring light and new life: 'sunlight is reaching the forest floor'; 'a dead tree is not a dead thing'; the wood 'will be richer'; 'a new beginning'
Views in Muir's account:
- storms are beautiful and thrilling: 'One of the most beautiful and exhilarating storms I ever enjoyed'
- storms are to be enjoyed outdoors, and the danger is small: 'hardly greater than one would experience crouching deprecatingly beneath a roof'
- 'Nature has always something rare to show us'
- the storm reveals music and scent: 'Aeolian music', 'the delicious fragrance'
- the storm teaches him that 'trees are travelers'
- the damage does not matter: 'all the so-called ruin of the storm was forgotten'
- after the storm the forest is peaceful and holy: 'like a devout audience'; 'My peace I give unto you'; 'so fresh, so joyous, so immortal'
How the writers get their views across:
- the blog post: first person and conversational; similes (a train, 'like a rifle shot', 'like spilt matchsticks', 'like losing an old friend'); facts and numbers; instructions ('please respect the signs'); the structural turn 'And yet'; paradox; short sentences
- Muir: first person, with elevated, Romantic and religious language; superlatives; personification ('passionate torrent', the trees 'like a devout audience'); simile ('like a bobolink on a reed'); a quotation from the Bible; long, flowing sentences; a triplet at the end
Similarities and differences:
- both love wind and find beauty in it; both personify the trees; both end positively, seeing the storm's damage as not the end (Muir's 'so-called ruin', the blog's 'new beginning')
- Muir goes out into the storm and climbs a tree; the ranger stays indoors and warns readers to keep away
- Muir feels joy throughout; the ranger feels dread and grief before hope
- Muir's view is spiritual; the ranger's is practical and ecological