Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/9

Both texts: comparing ideas and how they are shown (Q1.6)

Practise 26 exam-style questions on Both texts: comparing ideas and how they are shown (Q1.6) for Eduqas GCSE English Language (Component 2). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 26 questions
  • 10 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

10 marks

Read both texts below: the blog post and the extract from John Muir's book about the mountains of California. To answer the question you must use both texts.

21st-century text

The night the wood roared
From a blog post by Ifan Penhale (fictional) on a woodland ranger's blog, 2019

In this blog post, a woodland ranger writes about a storm.

[1] At about eleven o'clock on Tuesday night, I gave up trying to sleep. My cottage stands right on the edge of the wood, and the storm that had been building all evening was now so loud that it sounded as if a train was thundering past my bedroom window, over and over again, without ever reaching its end.

[2] I have worked as the ranger here for fourteen years, and I have learned to love wind. On an ordinary blustery day, the trees creak and sigh, and the beech leaves hiss like the sea. But this was different. Gust after gust came roaring up the valley, and between them, every few minutes, I heard the sound I dread most: a sharp crack, like a rifle shot, followed by a long, tearing crash. Somewhere out in the dark, another tree was coming down.

[3] I did not go out. Every instinct told me to check on the wood, but a forest in a storm is no place for people. Branches as thick as your body can fall without warning, and whole trees can topple. So I lay awake and listened, counting the crashes and thinking about the old beech by the pond.

[4] At first light on Wednesday, the wind had dropped, and I walked out into a different wood. Thirty-two trees were down, most of them tall spruces on the exposed northern slope, lying across one another like spilt matchsticks. The main path was blocked in nine places. Then I reached the pond. The old beech, which had stood there for around 180 years, had been torn out of the ground, and its roots reared up in a great wall of earth twice my height.

[5] I sat down on its trunk and felt close to tears. I had eaten my lunch under that tree on most working days since I arrived. Children from the village school had hugged it, measured it, drawn it and written poems about it. It felt like losing an old friend.

[6] The wood will be closed for at least two weeks while we make it safe, so please respect the signs. Some trees that are still standing have cracked trunks, or broken branches hanging high above the paths. Foresters call these 'widowmakers', and the name tells you all you need to know. With the help of twelve volunteers, we have already cleared the main path, but there is a great deal more to do.

[7] And yet, as I walked round again this morning, I began to see the storm differently. Where the spruces fell, sunlight is reaching the forest floor for the first time in decades. Within a couple of summers, that bare ground will be bright with foxgloves, and young oaks and birches will be racing one another towards the light.

[8] The fallen trees matter, too. We will leave many of them exactly where they lie, because a dead tree is not a dead thing. Over the years to come, it will feed fungi, beetles and woodlice, give shelter to wrens and hedgehogs, and slowly crumble back into the soil. Storms have been reshaping woods like ours for thousands of years. The wood will not just recover. In some ways, it will be richer.

[9] As for the old beech, it will stay where it fell, roots and all. The village school has already asked if the children can visit it when the wood reopens, and I hope they will clamber over it and watch it change, year by year. For almost two centuries it towered over the pond. Now it will give it something else: a new beginning.

[10] So come and see what the storm has left behind once we reopen. But please, never come into the wood while the wind is blowing.

Glossary: ranger - a person whose job is to look after a wood or an area of countryside; spruces - tall evergreen trees with needles, related to pines; fungi - mushrooms, toadstools and similar living things, many of which feed on dead wood

19th-century text

The Mountains of California
by John Muir (1894)

John Muir, a Scottish-born naturalist who lived in America, spent many years exploring the mountains and forests of the Sierra Nevada in California. In this extract from his book, published in 1894, he describes going out into the forest during a wind-storm.

[1] One of the most beautiful and exhilarating storms I ever enjoyed in the Sierra occurred in December, 1874, when I happened to be exploring one of the tributary valleys of the Yuba River. The sky and the ground and the trees had been thoroughly rain-washed and were dry again. The day was intensely pure, one of those incomparable bits of California winter, warm and balmy and full of white sparkling sunshine, redolent of all the purest influences of the spring, and at the same time enlivened with one of the most bracing wind-storms conceivable. Instead of camping out, as I usually do, I then chanced to be stopping at the house of a friend. But when the storm began to sound, I lost no time in pushing out into the woods to enjoy it. For on such occasions Nature has always something rare to show us, and the danger to life and limb is hardly greater than one would experience crouching deprecatingly beneath a roof.

[...]

[2] Toward midday, after a long, tingling scramble through copses of hazel and ceanothus, I gained the summit of the highest ridge in the neighborhood; and then it occurred to me that it would be a fine thing to climb one of the trees to obtain a wider outlook and get my ear close to the Aeolian music of its topmost needles. But under the circumstances the choice of a tree was a serious matter. [...] After cautiously casting about, I made choice of the tallest of a group of Douglas Spruces that were growing close together like a tuft of grass, no one of which seemed likely to fall unless all the rest fell with it. Though comparatively young, they were about 100 feet high, and their lithe, brushy tops were rocking and swirling in wild ecstasy. Being accustomed to climb trees in making botanical studies, I experienced no difficulty in reaching the top of this one, and never before did I enjoy so noble an exhilaration of motion. The slender tops fairly flapped and swished in the passionate torrent, bending and swirling backward and forward, round and round, tracing indescribable combinations of vertical and horizontal curves, while I clung with muscles firm braced, like a bobolink on a reed.

[...]

[3] I kept my lofty perch for hours, frequently closing my eyes to enjoy the music by itself, or to feast quietly on the delicious fragrance that was streaming past. [...]

[4] We all travel the milky way together, trees and men; but it never occurred to me until this storm-day, while swinging in the wind, that trees are travelers, in the ordinary sense. They make many journeys, not extensive ones, it is true; but our own little journeys, away and back again, are only little more than tree-wavings--many of them not so much.

[5] When the storm began to abate, I dismounted and sauntered down through the calming woods. The storm-tones died away, and, turning toward the east, I beheld the countless hosts of the forests hushed and tranquil, towering above one another on the slopes of the hills like a devout audience. The setting sun filled them with amber light, and seemed to say, while they listened, "My peace I give unto you."

[6] As I gazed on the impressive scene, all the so-called ruin of the storm was forgotten, and never before did these noble woods appear so fresh, so joyous, so immortal.

Glossary: exhilarating - thrilling, making you feel full of life; deprecatingly - nervously, trying to keep out of trouble; copses - small thick clumps of trees or bushes; Aeolian music - music made by the wind; bobolink - a small North American songbird; neighborhood, travelers - neighbourhood, travellers (American spellings); redolent - full of the scent; ceanothus - a flowering shrub; lithe - bending easily; abate - die down; devout - deeply religious

Both of these texts are about wind-storms in forests.

Compare:
- the writers' views about storms in forests
- how the writers get their views across to readers

You must use the text to support your comments and make it clear which text you are referring to.

[10]

Model answer

Both writers love wind, and both conclude that a storm's damage is not the end of a forest, but they disagree completely about the danger: Muir's view is joyful and spiritual, while Penhale's is practical, grieving and, in the end, hopeful.

Their attitudes to being out in a storm are opposites. Muir calls this 'One of the most beautiful and exhilarating storms I ever enjoyed', and the superlative and the verb 'enjoyed' show delight. He argues that 'the danger to life and limb is hardly greater' than indoors and mocks those who crouch 'deprecatingly beneath a roof'. Penhale, by contrast, states plainly, 'I did not go out', and gives the reason as a general rule: 'a forest in a storm is no place for people'. The direct address in 'Branches as thick as your body can fall without warning' makes the warning personal to the reader.

They also describe the storm's sound differently, which reveals their views. Muir hears 'Aeolian music' and closes his eyes 'to enjoy the music by itself', a metaphor that turns the storm into an art to be appreciated. Penhale's similes - a train 'thundering past' and 'a sharp crack, like a rifle shot' - make it violent and threatening, and 'the sound I dread most' shows fear.

Their responses to the damage are the biggest difference. Muir hardly mentions it: 'all the so-called ruin of the storm was forgotten', and 'so-called' dismisses it. Penhale records it with facts - 'Thirty-two trees were down' - and the simile 'like spilt matchsticks' and the grief of losing the beech, 'like losing an old friend', show real sorrow.

Yet both end with a positive view. Muir sees the trees 'hushed and tranquil' like 'a devout audience', and the biblical words 'My peace I give unto you' give the storm a religious meaning, ending in the triplet 'so fresh, so joyous, so immortal'. Penhale's turn comes with 'And yet', and the paradox that 'a dead tree is not a dead thing' leads to the conclusion that the wood 'will be richer'. Muir sees the storm as revealing the forest's eternal beauty; Penhale sees it as part of a natural cycle of loss and renewal.

The forms help to explain these differences. Muir writes a personal account in elevated, Romantic language to share a spiritual experience. Penhale, a ranger writing a blog for visitors, mixes feeling with facts and instructions such as 'please respect the signs', so the post both moves readers and keeps them safe.

Explanation

This comparison is demanding because the two writers reach similar positive conclusions from opposite attitudes. Top-band answers compare throughout: enjoying the storm outdoors against warning people away, music against violent noise, dismissing the damage against grieving it, and spiritual peace against ecological renewal, with comment on methods such as superlatives, similes, the biblical quotation and the turn at 'And yet'. Weaker answers summarise each text separately.

Mark scheme
  1. 10 marks

    Levels of response (10 marks). AO3: comparison.
    Level 5 (9-10 marks): Give 9-10 marks to those who make comparisons that are sustained and detailed, with a wide range of valid comments, showing clear understanding about how the writers get their views across to readers.
    Level 4 (7-8 marks): Give 7-8 marks to those who make detailed comparisons about the views the writers have about storms in forests and make valid comments on how the writers get their views across to readers.
    Level 3 (5-6 marks): Give 5-6 marks to those who identify similarities and differences in the writers' views about storms in forests making some comparisons and/or commenting on how the writers get their views across to readers.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): Give 3-4 marks to those who identify some of the main similarities and differences in the writers' views about storms in forests and/or make some simple comments on how the writers get their views across to readers.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): Give 1-2 marks to those who identify a basic similarity and/or difference in the writers' views about storms in forests. Marks in this band may only deal with one text or not make it clear to which text is being referred.
    0 marks: Give 0 marks for responses where there is nothing worthy of credit.

    Max 2 if the response only deals with one text or does not make clear which text it is referring to (Eduqas places such answers in the 1-2 mark band: 'Marks in this band may only deal with one text or not make it clear to which text is being referred.'). Indicative content (not a checklist; the question must be marked in levels of response - look for and reward valid alternatives). Details that candidates may explore or respond to:
    Views in the blog post:
    - the writer loves wind ('I have learned to love wind') but finds this storm frightening: 'the sound I dread most'
    - storms make forests dangerous for people: 'a forest in a storm is no place for people'; 'never come into the wood while the wind is blowing'
    - storms cause real loss: 'Thirty-two trees were down'; the beech 'torn out of the ground'; 'like losing an old friend'
    - but storms are a natural part of a wood's life: 'Storms have been reshaping woods like ours for thousands of years'
    - storms bring light and new life: 'sunlight is reaching the forest floor'; 'a dead tree is not a dead thing'; the wood 'will be richer'; 'a new beginning'
    Views in Muir's account:
    - storms are beautiful and thrilling: 'One of the most beautiful and exhilarating storms I ever enjoyed'
    - storms are to be enjoyed outdoors, and the danger is small: 'hardly greater than one would experience crouching deprecatingly beneath a roof'
    - 'Nature has always something rare to show us'
    - the storm reveals music and scent: 'Aeolian music', 'the delicious fragrance'
    - the storm teaches him that 'trees are travelers'
    - the damage does not matter: 'all the so-called ruin of the storm was forgotten'
    - after the storm the forest is peaceful and holy: 'like a devout audience'; 'My peace I give unto you'; 'so fresh, so joyous, so immortal'
    How the writers get their views across:
    - the blog post: first person and conversational; similes (a train, 'like a rifle shot', 'like spilt matchsticks', 'like losing an old friend'); facts and numbers; instructions ('please respect the signs'); the structural turn 'And yet'; paradox; short sentences
    - Muir: first person, with elevated, Romantic and religious language; superlatives; personification ('passionate torrent', the trees 'like a devout audience'); simile ('like a bobolink on a reed'); a quotation from the Bible; long, flowing sentences; a triplet at the end
    Similarities and differences:
    - both love wind and find beauty in it; both personify the trees; both end positively, seeing the storm's damage as not the end (Muir's 'so-called ruin', the blog's 'new beginning')
    - Muir goes out into the storm and climbs a tree; the ranger stays indoors and warns readers to keep away
    - Muir feels joy throughout; the ranger feels dread and grief before hope
    - Muir's view is spiritual; the ranger's is practical and ecological

Question 2

10 marks

Read both texts below: the blog post and the account. To answer the question you must use both texts.

21st-century text

Two hundred and twelve photos of an empty branch
From a blog post by Josie Fairbairn (fictional) on a wildlife website, 2024

This blog post was written for a wildlife website by a young photographer who spent months trying to photograph a kingfisher.

[1] The first time I saw a kingfisher, I was so busy fumbling for my phone that I missed it completely. The second time, I got a photo of a blurry orange smudge and a great deal of river. I deleted it, then wished I hadn't, because it was the closest I came for the next four months.

[2] I'm sixteen, and until last spring my phone was mostly for messages and music. Then, on a walk along the river behind our estate, a streak of electric blue shot past me, low over the water, and landed on a dead branch on the far bank. It sat there for perhaps five seconds - a tiny, perfect bird, orange underneath, with a beak like a dagger - and then it was gone. I decided, there and then, that I was going to photograph it.

[3] It turns out that wanting to photograph a kingfisher and actually doing it are two very different things. Kingfishers are small, fast and easily disturbed. My phone camera, which takes lovely pictures of my friends and my dinner, turned a bird on the far bank into three blue pixels.

[4] So I saved up. With my birthday money I bought a clip-on zoom lens for my phone, a small tripod and a camouflage net, and I borrowed my grandad's folding fishing stool. Most mornings before school I sat under the net on the riverbank, perfectly still, with my phone pointed at that dead branch.

[5] I took two hundred and twelve photos of the branch with no kingfisher on it. I took photos of a moorhen, a very confused dog and my own thumb. Twice the kingfisher landed just as I was packing up to go home. I nearly gave up more times than I can count.

[6] What saved me was a notebook. Every time I saw the kingfisher, I wrote down the time, the weather and exactly where it landed. After a few weeks, I noticed a pattern: it nearly always came to the branch between half past six and seven in the morning, and hardly ever on windy days. So I stopped chasing it and started waiting for it at the right time.

[7] Kingfishers are protected by law, and it is illegal to disturb them at or near their nest, so I only ever watched that one fishing branch, from my own side of the river, and kept well away from anywhere they might be nesting.

[8] On a Sunday in June, at 6.42 in the morning, it happened. The kingfisher landed, tilted its head, dived, and came back to the branch with a tiny silver fish in its beak. My phone was already set to take a burst. Out of forty-three pictures, one was perfect: every feather sharp, the fish shining, a single drop of water hanging from the bird's beak.

[9] I didn't shout. I didn't move. I just sat there shaking, with tears in my eyes, until the kingfisher flew off downstream.

[10] That photo is now printed and pinned above my bed, and it came second in a county wildlife photography competition for under-eighteens. People often ask what camera I used, as if the camera did all the work. It didn't. The camera just has to be ready. The rest is patience, a notebook and getting up very early indeed.

[11] And the two hundred and twelve photos of the empty branch? They are still on my phone. I can't bring myself to delete them.

Glossary: kingfisher - a small, brightly coloured bird that dives into rivers to catch fish; pixels - the tiny dots of colour that make up a digital picture; moorhen - a dark water bird with a red and yellow beak; burst - a quick series of photos taken one after another

19th-century text

The Pencil of Nature
by William Henry Fox Talbot (1844)

William Henry Fox Talbot was one of the inventors of photography. In 1844 he began to publish The Pencil of Nature, the first book of photographs to be sold to the public. Near the start of the book he gave this account of how he first had the idea.

[1] One of the first days of the month of October 1833, I was amusing myself on the lovely shores of the Lake of Como, in Italy, taking sketches with Wollaston's Camera Lucida, or rather I should say, attempting to take them: but with the smallest possible amount of success. For when the eye was removed from the prism--in which all looked beautiful--I found that the faithless pencil had only left traces on the paper melancholy to behold.

[2] After various fruitless attempts, I laid aside the instrument and came to the conclusion, that its use required a previous knowledge of drawing, which unfortunately I did not possess.

[3] I then thought of trying again a method which I had tried many years before. This method was, to take a Camera Obscura, and to throw the image of the objects on a piece of transparent tracing paper laid on a pane of glass in the focus of the instrument. On this paper the objects are distinctly seen, and can be traced on it with a pencil with some degree of accuracy, though not without much time and trouble.

[...]

[4] Such, then, was the method which I proposed to try again, and to endeavour, as before, to trace with my pencil the outlines of the scenery depicted on the paper. And this led me to reflect on the inimitable beauty of the pictures of nature's painting which the glass lens of the Camera throws upon the paper in its focus--fairy pictures, creations of a moment, and destined as rapidly to fade away.

[5] It was during these thoughts that the idea occurred to me...how charming it would be if it were possible to cause these natural images to imprint themselves durably, and remain fixed upon the paper!

[6] And why should it not be possible? I asked myself.

[...]

[7] Such was the idea that came into my mind. Whether it had ever occurred to me before amid floating philosophic visions, I know not, though I rather think it must have done so, because on this occasion it struck me so forcibly. I was then a wanderer in classic Italy, and, of course, unable to commence an inquiry of so much difficulty: but, lest the thought should again escape me between that time and my return to England, I made a careful note of it in writing, and also of such experiments as I thought would be most likely to realize it, if it were possible.

[8] And since, according to chemical writers, the nitrate of silver is a substance peculiarly sensitive to the action of light, I resolved to make a trial of it, in the first instance, whenever occasion permitted on my return to England.

[...]

[9] In January 1834, I returned to England from my continental tour, and soon afterwards I determined to put my theories and speculations to the test of experiment, and see whether they had any real foundation.

[10] Accordingly I began by procuring a solution of nitrate of silver, and with a brush spread some of it upon a sheet of paper, which was afterwards dried. When this paper was exposed to the sunshine, I was disappointed to find that the effect was very slowly produced in comparison with what I had anticipated.

Glossary: Camera Lucida - a drawing aid: the artist looks through a glass prism and sees the view laid over the paper, then traces it; Camera Obscura - a box with a lens that throws a picture of the view onto a sheet of glass or paper inside it; melancholy - sad; inimitable - too good to be copied; durably - so that it lasts; nitrate of silver - a chemical that darkens when light falls on it; endeavour - try; philosophic - scientific (in Talbot's time, science was often called 'natural philosophy'); commence - begin; lest - in case; realize it - make it happen; speculations - ideas that have not yet been tested; procuring - getting; faithless - letting him down; depicted - shown; forcibly - strongly; continental tour - a journey round Europe; peculiarly - especially; anticipated - expected

Both of these texts are about trying to capture pictures of the natural world.

Compare:
- Talbot's and Josie Fairbairn's thoughts and feelings about trying to capture pictures of the natural world
- how they get their thoughts and feelings across to their readers

You must use the text to support your comments and make it clear which text you are referring to.

[10]

Model answer

Both writers are moved by the beauty of nature and frustrated by their failures to capture it, and both find a way forward through careful thought. But Talbot, writing as a scientist and inventor, is excited by an idea, while Josie Fairbairn, writing as a young enthusiast, is moved by a single perfect moment.

Both begin with failure, and both use humour against themselves. Talbot admits 'the smallest possible amount of success' and blames 'the faithless pencil', whose marks were 'melancholy to behold'; the personification and formal phrasing make his frustration wry and dignified. Josie's failures are closer to slapstick, from 'fumbling for my phone' to 'a blurry orange smudge and a great deal of river'. The precise number, 'two hundred and twelve photos of the branch with no kingfisher on it', and the comic list ('a very confused dog and my own thumb') show the same frustration in a modern, informal voice.

Both are moved by nature's beauty and by how quickly it passes. Talbot reflects on 'the inimitable beauty of the pictures of nature's painting', calling them 'fairy pictures, creations of a moment, and destined as rapidly to fade away'; the metaphor shows wonder mixed with a sense of loss. Josie feels the same about the kingfisher, 'a tiny, perfect bird' that stayed 'perhaps five seconds ... and then it was gone'. For both, the wish to capture a picture comes from knowing that the moment will vanish.

Both show determination, but in different ways. Talbot's moment of inspiration is an exclamation, 'how charming it would be', followed by the confident rhetorical question 'And why should it not be possible?' Josie's determination is shown through action: 'I decided, there and then', 'So I saved up', and sitting 'perfectly still' most mornings. Both rely on writing things down: Talbot 'made a careful note of it in writing' 'lest the thought should again escape me', and Josie says 'What saved me was a notebook'.

Their feelings at the end are different. Talbot's extract ends in disappointment - 'the effect was very slowly produced in comparison with what I had anticipated'. Josie's ends in triumph and emotion: the short sentences 'I didn't shout. I didn't move.' and the image of sitting 'shaking, with tears in my eyes' show overwhelming joy. Josie thinks the equipment matters less than the person - 'as if the camera did all the work. It didn't.' - whereas Talbot's whole problem is finding the right method and materials.

Talbot's long, formal sentences convey a thoughtful mind excited by possibility, while Josie's short sentences, humour and personal voice convey patience rewarded - but both share the longing to hold on to a fleeting moment of natural beauty.

Explanation

This is a demanding comparison because the writers' situations are so different. Top-band answers find the real links - failure laughed at, wonder at fleeting beauty, determination, written notes - and the key differences (Talbot's disappointment against Josie's joy, idea against moment), and explain how each writer's style conveys these feelings. Answers that summarise each text separately or compare equipment rather than thoughts and feelings rarely reach Level 4.

Mark scheme
  1. 10 marks

    Levels of response (10 marks). AO3: comparison.
    Level 5 (9-10 marks): Give 9-10 marks to those who make comparisons that are sustained and detailed about the thoughts and feelings of Talbot and Josie Fairbairn and go on to show a clear understanding of the different ways in which these thoughts and feelings are conveyed.
    Level 4 (7-8 marks): Give 7-8 marks to those who make detailed comparisons [about] the thoughts and feelings of Talbot and Josie Fairbairn and offer some valid comments about how these thoughts and feelings are conveyed.
    Level 3 (5-6 marks): Give 5-6 marks to those who identify similarities and differences in the thoughts and feelings of Talbot and Josie Fairbairn and/or make some attempt to comment on how these thoughts and feelings are conveyed.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): Give 3-4 marks to those who identify some similarities and differences in the thoughts and feelings of Talbot and Josie Fairbairn and/or make a simple attempt to explore how these thoughts and feelings are conveyed.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): Give 1-2 marks to those who identify a basic similarity and/or difference in the thoughts and feelings of Talbot and Josie Fairbairn. Marks in this band may only deal with one text or not make it clear to which text is being referred.
    0 marks: Give 0 marks for responses where there is nothing worthy of credit.

    Max 2 if the response only deals with one text or does not make clear which text it is referring to (Eduqas places such answers in the 1-2 mark band: 'Marks in this band may only deal with one text or not make it clear to which text is being referred.'). Indicative content (not a checklist; the question must be marked in levels of response - look for and reward valid alternatives). Details that candidates may explore or respond to:
    Josie Fairbairn's thoughts and feelings:
    - frustration and embarrassment at early failures: 'a blurry orange smudge and a great deal of river'; 'two hundred and twelve photos'
    - wonder at the kingfisher: 'a streak of electric blue'; 'a tiny, perfect bird'
    - awareness that the moment is fleeting: 'perhaps five seconds'
    - determination: 'I decided, there and then'; 'So I saved up'; nearly giving up
    - satisfaction in working out a pattern: 'What saved me was a notebook'
    - respect for the bird and the law: staying away from nesting places
    - overwhelming joy at success: 'I didn't shout. I didn't move.'; 'shaking, with tears in my eyes'
    - the belief that patience matters more than equipment: 'as if the camera did all the work. It didn't.'
    Talbot's thoughts and feelings:
    - frustration and self-mockery at his failed sketches: 'the smallest possible amount of success'; 'the faithless pencil'; 'melancholy to behold'; 'unfortunately'
    - wonder at nature's images: 'the inimitable beauty of the pictures of nature's painting'; 'fairy pictures, creations of a moment'
    - awareness that they are fleeting: 'destined as rapidly to fade away'
    - excitement at his idea: 'how charming it would be'; 'And why should it not be possible?'; 'struck me so forcibly'
    - careful, determined planning: 'I made a careful note of it in writing'; 'I resolved to make a trial of it'
    - disappointment at the end: 'the effect was very slowly produced in comparison with what I had anticipated'
    How they get their thoughts and feelings across:
    - Josie: informal first person, humour, precise numbers, comic lists, short sentences, a vivid metaphor and simile, a rhetorical question at the end
    - Talbot: formal, measured first person; long complex sentences; personification; metaphor ('fairy pictures'); an exclamation and a rhetorical question at the moment of inspiration; scientific vocabulary
    Similarities and differences: both begin with failure and use humour against themselves; both are moved by fleeting natural beauty; both rely on written notes; Talbot is excited by an idea and a new process, Josie by one perfect moment; Talbot's extract ends in disappointment, Josie's in triumph; Talbot's problem is the method and materials, while Josie thinks the camera matters less than patience.

Question 3

10 marks

Read both texts below: the newspaper article and the newspaper column. To answer the question you must use both texts.

21st-century text

The warehouse that never sleeps: my night as a picker
From a newspaper article by Nicola Brayshaw (fictional) in a national newspaper, 2024

For this article, a journalist worked a night shift in a large warehouse that sends out goods that people have ordered online.

[1] At ten to six on a Tuesday evening, as everyone else heads home, I join a queue of about 400 people shuffling into a warehouse on the edge of a Midlands town. The building is so long that I cannot see the far end of it. Inside, it is always daytime: the lights never go off, and the conveyor belts never stop.

[2] I have signed up with an employment agency to work one night shift, from six in the evening until half past four in the morning, as a "picker". The job is simple to explain and hard to do. A handheld scanner shows you an item and a shelf number. You walk to the shelf, find the item, scan it, drop it into a plastic tub and walk on. The scanner also sets your target: 110 items an hour.

[3] My trainer, Marta, is 34 and has worked here for six years. She is small and quick, and she moves between the shelves like a dancer. "Don't run," she warns me. "Everyone runs on their first night. By midnight, they can't walk."

[4] She is right. By nine o'clock my feet are throbbing. By eleven, the scanner has started to beep at me, a sharp little reminder that I am falling behind. The noise never lets up: the rumble of the belts, the clatter of the tubs, the hiss of the packing machines. To speak to the person next to you, you lean in close and shout.

[5] What do we pick? Everything. Phone cases, dog beds, birthday candles, a pink inflatable flamingo at ten past three in the morning. Somebody, somewhere, clicked "buy" and went to bed. If you have ever ordered something late at night and found it on your doorstep the next afternoon, someone like Marta fetched it from a shelf in the middle of the night.

[6] There are two half-hour breaks, at half past nine and half past one. But the canteen is a seven-minute walk from the far end of the building, so a half-hour break means sixteen minutes sitting down. Most people bring food from home: a cereal bar, a sandwich, cold pasta in a plastic box. With twenty people queuing for two microwaves, few of them bother to heat anything up.

[7] In the canteen I meet Eli, 19, who works four nights a week to pay his way through college. "I sleep on the bus home, then I sleep all morning, then I go to my lessons," he says. "You get used to it. But you never stop being tired." Beside him, Janet, 61, is doing a crossword. She has worked nights for eleven years. "The work's honest," she says. "It's the hours that wear you out, not the job."

[8] Nobody I meet is miserable. There is plenty of laughter at break time. In the last hour, when I get hopelessly lost, a man I have never spoken to walks me to the right shelf without a word, then hurries back to his own. But when I ask people what the job is like, the same word comes up again and again: tired.

[9] At half past four, a hooter sounds. My phone tells me I have walked 23 kilometres. I have picked 812 items, far below my target; Marta, who has also trained two other new starters tonight, has picked more than a thousand. Outside, the sky is still black, and the first lorries of the morning are already queuing at the gates.

[10] I am not going to tell you to stop shopping online. I do it myself, and these jobs matter to the people who do them. But the next time you choose next-day delivery for something that could easily wait a week, picture the warehouse at three in the morning: the scanners beeping, the belts rumbling, and a 61-year-old woman walking yet another aisle. Then ask yourself whether you really need it tomorrow.

Glossary: picker - a warehouse worker who collects the items for each order from the shelves; employment agency - a business that finds workers for other businesses

19th-century text

The Working-Girls of New York
by Fanny Fern (1868)

Fanny Fern was the pen-name of Sara Willis, who wrote a popular weekly column for a New York newspaper. This column, about young women who worked in the factories of New York, was collected in her book Folly as It Flies in 1868.

[1] Nowhere more than in New York does the contest between squalor and splendor so sharply present itself. This is the first reflection of the observing stranger who walks its streets. Particularly is this noticeable with regard to its women. Jostling on the same pavement with the dainty fashionist is the care-worn working-girl. [...]

[2] Let me tell you what ails the working-girls. While yet your breakfast is progressing, and your toilet unmade, comes forth through Chatham Street and the Bowery, a long procession of them by twos and threes to their daily labor. Their breakfast, so called, has been hastily swallowed in a tenement house, where two of them share, in a small room, the same miserable bed. Of its quality you may better judge, when you know that each of these girls pays but three dollars a week for board, to the working man and his wife where they lodge.

[3] [...] They have risen unrefreshed, as a matter of course, and their ill-cooked breakfast does not mend the matter. They emerge from the doorway where their passage is obstructed by "nanny goats" and ragged children rooting together in the dirt, and pass out into the street. They shiver as the sharp wind of early morning strikes their temples. There is no look of youth on their faces; hard lines appear there. Their brows are knit; their eyes are sunken; their dress is flimsy, and foolish, and tawdry; always a hat, and feather or soiled artificial flower upon it; the hair dressed with an abortive attempt at style; a soiled petticoat; a greasy dress, a well-worn sacque or shawl, and a gilt breast-pin and earrings.

[4] Now follow them to the large, black-looking building, where several hundred of them are manufacturing hoop-skirts. If you are a woman you have worn plenty; but you little thought what passed in the heads of these girls as their busy fingers glazed the wire, or prepared the spools for covering them, or secured the tapes which held them in their places. You could not stay five minutes in that room, where the noise of the machinery used is so deafening, that only by the motion of the lips could you comprehend a person speaking.

[5] Five minutes! Why, these young creatures bear it, from seven in the morning till six in the evening; week after week, month after month, with only half an hour at midday to eat their dinner of a slice of bread and butter or an apple, which they usually eat in the building, some of them having come a long distance. As I said, the roar of machinery in that room is like the roar of Niagara. Observe them as you enter. Not one lifts her head. They might as well be machines, for any interest or curiosity they show, save always to know what o'clock it is. Pitiful! pitiful, you almost sob to yourself, as you look at these young girls. Young? Alas! it is only in years that they are young.

Glossary: toilet - here, washing and getting dressed; fashionist - a fashionable woman; tenement house - a crowded, run-down building divided into small rooms for poor families; board - meals and a room to live in; tawdry - cheap and showy; hoop-skirts - wide skirts held out by hoops of wire; squalor - dirt and poverty; splendor - American spelling of splendour: great richness and grandeur; labor - American spelling of labour: work; Chatham Street and the Bowery - streets in a poor part of New York; lodge - rent a room; obstructed - blocked; temples - the sides of the forehead; abortive - failed; sacque - a loose jacket; gilt - covered with a thin layer of gold; glazed - coated; comprehend - understand; Niagara - the Niagara Falls, a huge waterfall; save - except; ails - is wrong with; knit - drawn together in a frown; spools - reels; breast-pin - a brooch

Both of these texts are about people who work long hours making or sending out goods for other people.

Compare:
- what impressions the writers create of the workers and their lives
- how the writers create these impressions

You must use the text to support your comments and make it clear which text you are referring to.

[10]

Model answer

Both writers create the impression that the workers' lives are exhausting and that comfortable readers rarely think about them. However, Fanny Fern presents the working-girls as silent, pitiable victims, while Nicola Brayshaw presents the warehouse workers as tired but cheerful individuals.

Both show long, draining hours. Fern's girls work 'from seven in the morning till six in the evening; week after week, month after month', and the repetition makes their lives seem endless. The pickers in the newspaper article work 'from six in the evening until half past four in the morning', and the clock-time structure, 'By nine o'clock... By eleven', shows the tiredness building. Both writers stress the short breaks and poor food: Fern's girls have 'only half an hour' for 'a slice of bread and butter or an apple', while the pickers get 'sixteen minutes sitting down' and eat 'cold pasta in a plastic box'.

Both workplaces are deafening. In Fern's factory, 'only by the motion of the lips could you comprehend a person speaking', and the simile 'like the roar of Niagara' makes the noise overwhelming. In the warehouse, the onomatopoeic list 'the rumble of the belts, the clatter of the tubs, the hiss of the packing machines' shows a noise that never stops.

The impressions of the workers themselves are very different. Fern's girls look old before their time: 'There is no look of youth on their faces', and 'their eyes are sunken'. They are described from outside, often harshly, as in 'flimsy, and foolish, and tawdry', and they never speak; Fern even says 'They might as well be machines'. By contrast, Brayshaw gives the workers names, ages and voices. Marta 'moves between the shelves like a dancer', a simile of skill and grace, and Eli and Janet speak for themselves: 'you never stop being tired' and 'It's the hours that wear you out, not the job'. Brayshaw also notes that 'Nobody I meet is miserable', so these workers seem dignified rather than pitiful.

Both writers link the workers to the reader's own purchases. Fern tells her readers, 'If you are a woman you have worn plenty' of hoop-skirts, and Brayshaw reminds us that a parcel arriving the next afternoon means 'someone like Marta fetched it'. Fern's exclamations, 'Pitiful! pitiful', and the rhetorical question 'Young? Alas!' aim to move readers to tears, whereas Brayshaw calmly asks us to 'ask yourself whether you really need it tomorrow'. Fern creates pity; Brayshaw creates respect as well as concern.

Explanation

The best answers compare throughout - hours, breaks, noise, the workers' appearance and voices, and the link to the reader - and explain how each impression is created, for example Fern's address to a well-off reader and her exclamations against Brayshaw's quotations and first-hand experience. A common weakness is listing the hardships in each text without comparing the very different impressions of the workers as people.

Mark scheme
  1. 10 marks

    Levels of response (10 marks). AO3: comparison.
    Level 5 (9-10 marks): Give 9-10 marks to those who make sustained and detailed comparisons about the impressions of the workers and their lives created by each writer, showing clear understanding about how these impressions are created.
    Level 4 (7-8 marks): Give 7-8 marks to those who make detailed comparisons about the impressions of the workers and their lives created by each writer and make valid comments on how these impressions are created.
    Level 3 (5-6 marks): Give 5-6 marks to those who identify similarities and differences in the impressions of the workers and their lives created by each writer, making some comparisons and/or commenting on how these impressions are created.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): Give 3-4 marks to those who identify some of the similarities and/or differences in the impressions of the workers and their lives created by each writer and/or make some simple comments on how these impressions are created.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): Give 1-2 marks to those who identify a basic similarity or difference in the impressions of the workers and their lives created by each writer. Marks in this band may only deal with one text or only deal with relevant impressions from one text or not make it clear to which text is being referred.
    0 marks: Give 0 marks for responses where there is nothing worthy of credit.

    Max 2 if the response only deals with one text or does not make clear which text it is referring to (Eduqas places such answers in the 1-2 mark band: 'Marks in this band may only deal with one text or only deal with relevant impressions from one text or not make it clear to which text is being referred.'). Indicative content (not a checklist; the question must be marked in levels of response - look for and reward valid alternatives). Details that candidates may explore or respond to:
    Impressions in the newspaper article (the warehouse workers):
    - exhausted by long night hours: 'from six in the evening until half past four in the morning'; 'you never stop being tired'; the single word 'tired'
    - under pressure: the target of '110 items an hour'; the scanner's beep
    - short breaks and poor food: 'sixteen minutes sitting down'; 'cold pasta in a plastic box'
    - skilled and quick: Marta 'moves between the shelves like a dancer' and picks 'more than a thousand'
    - individuals with names, ages and voices: Eli, 19, working to pay his way through college; Janet, 61, with her crossword; 'The work's honest'
    - cheerful and kind: 'Nobody I meet is miserable'; 'plenty of laughter'; the stranger who walks the writer to the right shelf
    Impressions in the newspaper column (the working-girls):
    - poor and badly housed: two share 'the same miserable bed'; 'three dollars a week'; the tenement doorway with goats and 'ragged children'
    - badly fed and tired: 'hastily swallowed', 'ill-cooked' breakfast; 'risen unrefreshed'; dinner of 'a slice of bread and butter or an apple'
    - old before their time: 'There is no look of youth on their faces'; 'their eyes are sunken'; 'it is only in years that they are young'
    - cheaply and badly dressed: 'flimsy, and foolish, and tawdry'; 'an abortive attempt at style'
    - worn down by endless hours and deafening noise: 'week after week, month after month'; 'like the roar of Niagara'
    - dehumanised and silent: 'They might as well be machines'; 'Not one lifts her head'; none of them speaks
    How the impressions are created:
    - the article: first-person participation and present tense; quotations from the workers; statistics; a clock-time structure; onomatopoeia; humour (the flamingo); short emphatic sentences; direct address at the end ('picture the warehouse at three in the morning')
    - the column: address to a well-off reader ('If you are a woman you have worn plenty'); contrast with the reader's comfort ('While yet your breakfast is progressing'); a guided tour ('Now follow them', 'Observe them as you enter'); lists of appearance; the simile 'like the roar of Niagara' and the comparison with 'machines'; exclamations and rhetorical questions ('Pitiful! pitiful'; 'Young? Alas!')
    Similarities and differences:
    - both show long, draining hours, little rest, poor food and deafening noise; both link the workers to the reader's own purchases
    - the girls are nameless, voiceless objects of pity seen from outside; the warehouse workers are named individuals with humour and pride; Fern stresses poverty, squalor and lost youth, Brayshaw tiredness rather than misery; Fern's tone is emotional and indignant, Brayshaw's measured and wry

Question 4

10 marks

Read both texts below: the blog post and the lecture. To answer the question you must use both texts.

21st-century text

'Is it going to explode?' What children have taught me about science
From a blog post by Penny Selby (fictional) on a science website, 2024

In this blog post, Penny Selby writes about the science shows she presents to young audiences.

[1] The question came from the second row, from a boy of about six with jam on his chin. "Is it going to explode?" "Not today," I said. He looked so disappointed that I nearly rewrote my whole show on the spot.

[2] For eight years I have been taking science shows into schools, libraries and village halls: more than 400 of them, at a rough count, for audiences aged from four to ninety-four. A show lasts about forty-five minutes, although I rarely finish on time, because the questions keep coming. People expect me to arrive with rockets and smoke machines. Instead, I begin almost every show with a single tea light.

[3] I light it, set it on the table and ask the simplest question I know: what is actually burning? Almost every hand shoots up. "The string!" Then I blow the flame out and hold a lit match in the thin trail of smoke, a few centimetres above the wick. The flame leaps down the smoke and the candle lights again. The gasp from forty children at once is, honestly, my favourite sound in the world. What is really burning, of course, is the wax, turned into a gas by the heat. After that, I hold a cold metal spoon in the flame for a moment, and it comes out black with soot: tiny pieces of carbon that did not burn.

[4] Next comes a balloon filled with water, which I hold over the flame while the front row covers their ears. It does not pop, because the water soaks up the heat before the rubber can get hot enough to burst. Then I lower an empty jam jar over the tea light, and we count together as the flame shrinks, flickers and dies. Fire needs air. Now they have seen it, not just been told it.

[5] Nobody touches the flame except me. A fire blanket and a bucket of water stand beside my table at every show, and I finish by saying, very firmly, that none of this should ever be tried at home without an adult. Science is exciting precisely because it is real, and real things deserve respect.

[6] Over the years I have learned a few rules. Never talk down to children: they can smell it a mile off. Let them guess before you explain, because a wrong guess they have made themselves teaches them more than a right answer they have simply been given. And never pretend to know something you don't. When a girl asked me last spring, "Miss, why is the bottom of the flame blue?" I told her that I wanted to check before I answered, and I emailed the answer to her school the next morning.

[7] As for the noise: a science show for six-year-olds is not a quiet lecture. There is shouting, wriggling and endless questions, most of them excellent. Once, a whole row of reception children insisted on singing Happy Birthday to my tea light before I was allowed to blow it out. I let them. It seemed only fair.

[8] At the end of that show, the boy with jam on his chin came to find me. "It didn't explode," he said, very seriously, "but it was still the best thing ever." I will take that.

Glossary: tea light - a small, flat candle in a metal case; wick - the string in the middle of a candle; reception children - children in their first year at primary school

19th-century text

The Chemical History of a Candle
by Michael Faraday (1861)

Michael Faraday was a famous scientist. At Christmas 1860 he gave a series of lectures for young people at the Royal Institution in London, about the science of a burning candle. This is the beginning of his first lecture, which was taken down as he spoke and printed in 1861.

[1] I purpose, in return for the honour you do us by coming to see what are our proceedings here, to bring before you, in the course of these lectures, the Chemical History of a Candle. I have taken this subject on a former occasion; and were it left to my own will, I should prefer to repeat it almost every year--so abundant is the interest that attaches itself to the subject, so wonderful are the varieties of outlet which it offers into the various departments of philosophy. There is not a law under which any part of this universe is governed which does not come into play, and is touched upon in these phenomena. There is no better, there is no more open door by which you can enter into the study of natural philosophy, than by considering the physical phenomena of a candle. I trust, therefore, I shall not disappoint you in choosing this for my subject rather than any newer topic, which could not be better, were it even so good.

[2] And before proceeding, let me say this also--that though our subject be so great, and our intention that of treating it honestly, seriously, and philosophically, yet I mean to pass away from all those who are seniors amongst us. I claim the privilege of speaking to juveniles as a juvenile myself. I have done so on former occasions--and, if you please, I shall do so again. And though I stand here with the knowledge of having the words I utter given to the world, yet that shall not deter me from speaking in the same familiar way to those whom I esteem nearest to me on this occasion.

[3] And now, my boys and girls, I must first tell you of what candles are made. Some are great curiosities. I have here some bits of timber, branches of trees particularly famous for their burning. And here you see a piece of that very curious substance taken out of some of the bogs in Ireland, called candle-wood,--a hard, strong, excellent wood, evidently fitted for good work as a resister of force, and yet withal burning so well that where it is found they make splinters of it, and torches, since it burns like a candle, and gives a very good light indeed. [...]

[4] But we must speak of candles as they are in commerce. Here are a couple of candles commonly called dips. They are made of lengths of cotton cut off, hung up by a loop, dipped into melted tallow, taken out again and cooled, then re-dipped until there is an accumulation of tallow round the cotton. In order that you may have an idea of the various characters of these candles, you see these which I hold in my hand--they are very small, and very curious. They are, or were, the candles used by the miners in coal mines. In olden times the miner had to find his own candles; and it was supposed that a small candle would not so soon set fire to the fire-damp in the coal mines as a large one; and for that reason, as well as for economy's sake, he had candles made of this sort--20, 30, 40, or 60 to the pound. They have been replaced since then by the steel-mill, and then by the Davy-lamp, and other safety-lamps of various kinds.

Glossary: purpose - (here) intend; natural philosophy - science; phenomena - things that can be seen to happen; steel-mill, Davy-lamp - devices that gave miners light underground more safely than a candle flame; tallow - hard animal fat, used to make cheap candles; fire-damp - a gas found in coal mines that explodes if it meets a flame; pass away from - here, leave aside; not speak to; seniors - older people; esteem - think of; deter - put off; withal - at the same time; for economy's sake - to save money

Both of these texts are about introducing young people to science.

Compare:
- what the two writers tell readers about how to make science interesting for young people
- how the writers get their views across to their readers

You must use the text to support your comments and make it clear which text you are referring to.

[10]

Model answer

Both writers believe that the best way to interest young people in science is to start with something simple and real, and both want to speak to children as equals; however, Penny Selby stresses fun, questions and safety, while Faraday stresses the seriousness and grandeur of his subject.

Both choose a candle over anything new or flashy. Selby says that people expect 'rockets and smoke machines', but she begins with 'a single tea light', and the contrast shows her belief that ordinary things can amaze. Faraday similarly hopes he 'shall not disappoint' his audience by choosing the candle 'rather than any newer topic', and argues through repetition that 'There is no better, there is no more open door' into science. Selby's view is practical - the tea light makes children gasp - whereas Faraday's is philosophical: he claims that every law of the universe is 'touched upon' in a burning candle.

Both also believe in speaking to young people on their level. Selby's rule, the imperative 'Never talk down to children', with the idiom 'they can smell it a mile off', is matched by Faraday's promise to speak 'as a juvenile myself' and 'in the same familiar way'. Yet their tones differ: Selby's blog post is chatty and humorous, while Faraday's lecture is polite and formal ('I purpose', 'I trust'), and he insists on treating the subject 'honestly, seriously, and philosophically'.

Their methods differ too. Selby believes in letting children guess first, because a wrong guess teaches more than 'a right answer they have simply been given', and in showing rather than telling: 'Now they have seen it, not just been told it.' She gets this view across through present-tense demonstrations and the children's own words, such as 'The string!'. Faraday also shows real objects, using pointing words like 'here you see' and 'these which I hold in my hand', and he chooses things that are 'great curiosities'; but he explains them himself rather than asking his audience to guess.

Finally, Selby adds two views that Faraday does not mention: that science must be safe ('Nobody touches the flame except me') because 'real things deserve respect', and that noise and questions are welcome. She ends with an anecdote, the boy who found her show 'the best thing ever', as evidence that her methods work, while Faraday's evidence is his own enthusiasm, which would make him repeat the subject 'almost every year'. Overall, both share a belief in simple objects and respect for young audiences, but Selby's view of science teaching is lively and interactive, and Faraday's serious and full of wonder.

Explanation

Top-band answers compare the writers' views point by point (simple objects, speaking to children as equals, showing versus telling, fun and safety versus seriousness) and how each gets them across, such as Selby's anecdotes, imperatives and humour against Faraday's formal address, repetition and pointing words. A common weakness is describing the experiments and objects, which belongs in Q1.5, instead of comparing the writers' views.

Mark scheme
  1. 10 marks

    Levels of response (10 marks). AO3: comparison.
    Level 5 (9-10 marks): Give 9-10 marks to those who make comparisons that are sustained and detailed, with a wide range of valid comments, showing clear understanding about how the writers get their views across to readers.
    Level 4 (7-8 marks): Give 7-8 marks to those who make detailed comparisons about the views the writers have about how to make science interesting for young people and make valid comments on how the writers get their views across to readers.
    Level 3 (5-6 marks): Give 5-6 marks to those who identify similarities and differences in the writers' views about how to make science interesting for young people making some comparisons and/or commenting on how the writers get their views across to readers.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): Give 3-4 marks to those who identify some of the main similarities and differences in the writers' views about how to make science interesting for young people and/or make some simple comments on how the writers get their views across to readers.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): Give 1-2 marks to those who identify a basic similarity and/or difference in the writers' views about how to make science interesting for young people. Marks in this band may only deal with one text or not make it clear to which text is being referred.
    0 marks: Give 0 marks for responses where there is nothing worthy of credit.

    Max 2 if the response only deals with one text or does not make clear which text it is referring to (Eduqas places such answers in the 1-2 mark band: 'Marks in this band may only deal with one text or not make it clear to which text is being referred.'). Indicative content (not a checklist; the question must be marked in levels of response - look for and reward valid alternatives). Details that candidates may explore or respond to:
    Penny Selby's views (blog post):
    - begin with something simple and real ('a single tea light'), not 'rockets and smoke machines';
    - ask questions and let children guess before explaining;
    - show rather than tell: 'Now they have seen it, not just been told it';
    - 'Never talk down to children';
    - be honest: 'never pretend to know something you don't';
    - welcome noise and questions and keep it fun (the Happy Birthday anecdote);
    - science must be safe and respected: 'real things deserve respect'.
    Michael Faraday's views (lecture):
    - the candle is the best way in: 'There is no better, there is no more open door';
    - the subject is so rich that he would repeat it 'almost every year'; every law of the universe is 'touched upon' in it;
    - an old, familiar subject is better than 'any newer topic';
    - speak to young people 'as a juvenile myself', 'in the same familiar way';
    - treat the subject 'honestly, seriously, and philosophically';
    - show real, curious objects ('Some are great curiosities') and explain how things are made and used.
    How they get their views across:
    - Selby: a chatty blog post; anecdotes and children's quoted words; present-tense demonstrations; imperatives as rules; humour; a circular structure;
    - Faraday: a spoken lecture; formal, polite language ('I purpose', 'I trust'); repetition and metaphor; direct address ('my boys and girls'); pointing words as he holds up objects ('here you see').
    Similarities and differences:
    - both prefer a simple candle to newer, flashier things, and both use real objects;
    - both believe in speaking to young people as equals (Selby's 'Never talk down', Faraday's 'as a juvenile');
    - both value honesty;
    - Selby stresses fun, noise, questions and safety; Faraday stresses seriousness and the grandeur of the subject;
    - Selby lets children guess; Faraday mostly shows and tells;
    - Selby writes about her methods for the readers of a science website; Faraday speaks directly to his young audience.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.