Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/9

Transactional writing: articles and reviews (Section B)

Practise 28 exam-style questions on Transactional writing: articles and reviews (Section B) for Eduqas GCSE English Language (Component 2). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 28 questions
  • 20 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

20 marks

In this section you will be assessed for the quality of your writing skills.

12 marks are awarded for communication and organisation; 8 marks are awarded for vocabulary, sentence structure, punctuation and spelling.

Think about the purpose and audience for your writing.

You should aim to write about 300-400 words.

A teenage magazine has invited readers to write articles on topics that people have strong views about. The latest topic is lending money to friends: is it simply what good friends do, or the quickest way to lose a friend?

You decide to write an article on the topic for the teenage magazine, giving your views.

Write your article.

[20]

Model answer

"Can I Borrow a Tenner?" Why Money and Friendship Rarely Mix

It starts so innocently. You're in the queue at the cinema when your friend pats their pockets and pulls a face. "I've left my card at home. Can you lend me a tenner? I'll pay you back tomorrow." Of course you say yes. That's what friends do. Isn't it?

Six weeks later, you're still waiting, and every time you see them, that ten-pound note sits between you like an uninvited guest.

Learning the hard way

I speak from experience. Last year I lent my closest friend thirty pounds for a concert ticket, to be paid back from their birthday money. Their birthday came and went. I didn't want to sound mean, so I dropped hints; they didn't want to admit the money had gone, so they started avoiding me. For a whole month we barely spoke, all because of thirty pounds. We sorted it out in the end, but I learned my lesson.

Why it goes wrong

The trouble with lending money to a friend is that it quietly changes the friendship. Suddenly one of you is a lender and the other is a borrower, and neither role is comfortable. The person who is owed feels awkward asking; the person who owes feels guilty, then defensive, then resentful. I asked twenty-four people in my year whether they had ever fallen out with a friend over money. Fifteen said yes, and in most cases the trouble had begun with a small loan.

There is another danger, too. If the same friend borrows again and again, you can end up feeling used, even if they never meant it that way.

To be fair...

None of this means you should never help a friend. If someone's bus pass has run out and they are stranded in town, lending them the fare is simple kindness. Good friends look after each other, and refusing to help in a genuine emergency is hardly a sign of a great friendship either.

My golden rules

So, if you do lend money, protect the friendship as well as your wallet:
- Only lend what you could afford never to see again.
- Agree when it will be paid back, out loud, so there is no confusion.
- If it is only a small amount, make it a gift instead. A bag of chips is not worth a feud.
- If you are the borrower, pay it back before you spend anything else, and say thank you.

Money comes and goes, but good friends are much harder to replace. So, before you answer the next "Can I borrow a tenner?", ask yourself which of the two you would rather lose.

Explanation

This article reaches Level 5 for AO5 because its view is clear and sustained but fair: a recognisable scene and an honest anecdote lead into reasons why loans strain friendships, supported by the writer's own survey, a concession about genuine emergencies and practical rules, before an ending that returns to the opening question. Accurate punctuation of speech and the bulleted rules, controlled tenses and precise vocabulary earn 8 for AO6. Weaker answers tell the story of one falling-out without giving a view, or write generally about money with little about friendship. It is longer than the 300-400 words Eduqas suggests: a well-developed answer of about 400 words can reach the same level.

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO5 (content and organisation). (Eduqas's band descriptors continue in the comments.)
    Level 5 (11-12 marks): shows sophisticated understanding of the purpose and format of the task; shows sustained awareness of the reader / intended audience; appropriate register is confidently adapted to purpose / audience; content is ambitious, pertinent and sophisticated
    Level 4 (8-10 marks): shows consistent understanding of the purpose and format of the task; shows secure awareness of the reader/intended audience; register is appropriately and consistently adapted to purpose/audience; content is well-judged and detailed
    Level 3 (5-7 marks): shows clear understanding of the purpose and format of the task; shows clear awareness of the reader / intended audience; register is appropriately adapted to purpose / audience; content is developed and appropriate reasons are given in support of opinions / ideas
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): shows some awareness of the purpose and format of the task; shows awareness of the reader / intended audience; a clear attempt to adapt register to purpose / audience; some reasons are given in support of opinions and ideas
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): basic awareness of the purpose and format of the task; some basic awareness of the reader / intended audience; some attempt to adapt register to purpose / audience (e.g. degree of formality); some relevant content despite uneven coverage of the topic
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Eduqas's band descriptors, continued: Level 5: ideas are convincingly developed and supported by a range of relevant details; there is sophistication in the shape and structure of the writing; communication has ambition and sophistication. Level 4: ideas are organised and coherently developed with supporting detail; there is clear shape and structure in the writing (paragraphs are used effectively to give sequence and organisation); communication has clarity, fluency and some ambition. Level 3: ideas are organised into coherent arguments; there is some shape and structure in the writing (paragraphs are used to give sequence and organisation); communication has clarity and fluency. Level 2: limited development of ideas; some sequencing of ideas into paragraphs (structure / direction may be uncertain); communication has some clarity and fluency. Level 1: content may be thin and brief; simple sequencing of ideas (paragraphs may be used to show obvious divisions or group ideas into some order); there is some basic clarity but communication of meaning is limited. Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid approaches). Successful responses may include some of the following features: - a clear understanding of the purpose of the task: to give a view (or a range of views) on lending money to friends for teenage readers, supported by reasons, information and examples; - a clear sense of engagement with the intended audience through devices such as anecdotes, recognisable situations, rhetorical questions, asides, humour and direct address that give a distinctive voice to the article; - a clear and coherent viewpoint (for lending, against it, or a balanced view that reaches a clear conclusion), developed point by point; - a range of appropriate and well-selected details: why friends lend (kindness, trust, emergencies, sharing costs on a day out), what can go wrong (forgotten debts, awkwardness about asking, guilt and avoidance, feeling used, pressure to lend, friends with very different amounts of money), the borrower's responsibilities, and practical ways to protect a friendship (lending only what you can afford to lose, agreeing when it will be repaid, giving rather than lending small amounts, talking openly); figures presented as the writer's own (a survey of classmates); - counter-arguments acknowledged and answered; - a headline and paragraphs (perhaps with subheadings or a short list) that give the article a logical structure and direction, with a decisive ending; - the article is of appropriate length and is a sufficiently detailed and developed response. Less successful responses may be characterised by some of the following features: - the content is thin and/or brief, or lacks substance and range; - a limited or uncertain sense of purpose, for example a story about one falling-out with no wider view, or a general article about saving money that never deals with friends; - limited awareness of, or focus on, teenage readers; - simple assertion ('never lend money to anyone') with little development or evidence; - a viewpoint that is not sustained, or a weak or limited structure that lacks a clear sense of direction.

  2. 8 marks

    Levels of response (8 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
    Level 5 (8 marks): there is appropriate and effective variation of sentence structures; virtually all sentence construction is controlled and accurate; a range of punctuation is used confidently and accurately; virtually all spelling, including that of complex irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is totally secure; a wide range of appropriate, ambitious vocabulary is used to create effect or convey precise meaning
    Level 4 (6-7 marks): sentence structure is varied to achieve particular effects; control of sentence construction is secure; a range of punctuation is used accurately; spelling, including that of irregular words, is secure; control of tense and agreement is secure; vocabulary is ambitious and used with precision
    Level 3 (4-5 marks): there is variety in sentence structure; control of sentence construction is mostly secure; a range of punctuation is used, mostly accurately; most spelling, including that of irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is mostly secure; vocabulary is beginning to develop and is used with some precision
    Level 2 (2-3 marks): some variety of sentence structure; there is some control of sentence construction; some control of a range of punctuation; the spelling is usually accurate; control of tense and agreement is generally secure; there is some range of vocabulary
    Level 1 (1 mark): limited range of sentence structure; control of sentence construction is limited; there is some attempt to use punctuation; some spelling is accurate; control of tense and agreement is limited; limited range of vocabulary
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Eduqas's guidance: expression is clear, fluent and controlled (the best responses will show ambition and sophistication in expression as well as a high degree of accuracy); there are few, if any, errors (no more than a sprinkling of mistakes); sentence control and range is good; tenses are consistent; vocabulary is used precisely and appropriately to convey meaning; punctuation is used accurately and appropriately (and unobtrusively). Look for: a confident, opinionated register with controlled sentence variety (questions, short emphatic sentences, longer complex sentences that weigh up points); quoted requests and conversations punctuated accurately; a list of rules or tips kept grammatically parallel; tense controlled between anecdotes and the present-tense argument; accurate apostrophes in contractions and possessives; precise vocabulary (awkward, resentful, borrower, generosity) spelt correctly. A response with nothing worthy of credit scores 0 on both points.

Question 2

20 marks

In this section you will be assessed for the quality of your writing skills.

12 marks are awarded for communication and organisation; 8 marks are awarded for vocabulary, sentence structure, punctuation and spelling.

Think about the purpose and audience for your writing.

You should aim to write about 300-400 words.

Write a lively guide to being an older brother or sister for a school/college magazine.

Write your guide.

[20]

Model answer

The Big Sibling Handbook

Congratulations! You never applied for this job, and nobody interviewed you for it. One day you were the centre of the universe; the next, there was a small, loud person in a car seat who had stolen your spotlight. Welcome to life as an older sibling. I have done this job for eleven years (two younger brothers, one younger sister, zero days off), so here is what I have learned.

Rule 1: You are a role model, like it or not

Your younger siblings are always watching. They copy the way you talk, the music you play and, unfortunately, the words you say when you stub your toe. When my youngest brother was four, he announced at nursery that his favourite food was "whatever my big sister is eating". It was flattering, but it was also a warning. If you want them to be kind, honest and brave, you have to go first.

Rule 2: Guard your territory - politely

Every older sibling needs somewhere to escape to. Mine is my bedroom, and the rule is simple: knock first. Shouting "GET OUT!" works for about thirty seconds. A clear rule, explained calmly and backed up with a deal ("You can come in on Saturday mornings to watch cartoons"), works for years.

Rule 3: Choose your battles

Yes, it is infuriating when they borrow your charger, eat the last biscuit or tell Mum about something you did three years ago. But not every crime deserves a war. Ask yourself whether it will matter next week. If it won't, let it go.

Rule 4: Be the one they can talk to

There will be things your siblings can't tell your parents: a falling-out with a friend, a worry about school, a fear they think sounds silly. If they know you won't laugh or gossip, they will come to you. Last year my sister admitted she was being left out at lunchtime. I couldn't fix it overnight, but I helped her find an art club, and now she has a whole new group of friends. That conversation mattered more than any argument we have ever had. (If they tell you something serious, though, make sure a trusted adult knows.)

Rule 5: Enjoy it

It is easy to treat younger siblings as a nuisance, but they can also be the best company in the world. Who else will build a den out of every cushion in the house, laugh at your terrible jokes and believe you are the coolest person alive?

So be patient, be fair and be there. One day they will be taller than you, and you will be glad you did this job well.

Explanation

This guide reaches Level 5 for AO5 because its wry, affectionate voice suits student readers, and each of its five rules is a genuine piece of advice, developed with examples and, where it matters most, with anecdotes from the writer's own family (the nursery announcement, the sister left out at lunchtime), moving from the general to the particular as a good guide should. It earns 8 for AO6 through controlled imperatives, accurate punctuation of speech and asides, and consistent tenses. Weaker guides list one-line tips ('be nice') without explanation, or turn into a story or a complaint about younger siblings. It is longer than the 300-400 words Eduqas suggests: a well-developed answer of about 400 words can reach the same level.

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO5 (content and organisation). (Eduqas's band descriptors continue in the comments.)
    Level 5 (11-12 marks): shows sophisticated understanding of the purpose and format of the task; shows sustained awareness of the reader / intended audience; appropriate register is confidently adapted to purpose / audience; content is ambitious, pertinent and sophisticated
    Level 4 (8-10 marks): shows consistent understanding of the purpose and format of the task; shows secure awareness of the reader/intended audience; register is appropriately and consistently adapted to purpose/audience; content is well-judged and detailed
    Level 3 (5-7 marks): shows clear understanding of the purpose and format of the task; shows clear awareness of the reader / intended audience; register is appropriately adapted to purpose / audience; content is developed and appropriate reasons are given in support of opinions / ideas
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): shows some awareness of the purpose and format of the task; shows awareness of the reader / intended audience; a clear attempt to adapt register to purpose / audience; some reasons are given in support of opinions and ideas
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): basic awareness of the purpose and format of the task; some basic awareness of the reader / intended audience; some attempt to adapt register to purpose / audience (e.g. degree of formality); some relevant content despite uneven coverage of the topic
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Eduqas's band descriptors, continued: Level 5: ideas are convincingly developed and supported by a range of relevant details; there is sophistication in the shape and structure of the writing; communication has ambition and sophistication. Level 4: ideas are organised and coherently developed with supporting detail; there is clear shape and structure in the writing (paragraphs are used effectively to give sequence and organisation); communication has clarity, fluency and some ambition. Level 3: ideas are organised into coherent arguments; there is some shape and structure in the writing (paragraphs are used to give sequence and organisation); communication has clarity and fluency. Level 2: limited development of ideas; some sequencing of ideas into paragraphs (structure / direction may be uncertain); communication has some clarity and fluency. Level 1: content may be thin and brief; simple sequencing of ideas (paragraphs may be used to show obvious divisions or group ideas into some order); there is some basic clarity but communication of meaning is limited. Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid approaches). Successful responses may include some of the following features: - a sustained sense of register and purpose which meets the requirement for a guide written for a student audience (for example, an affectionate, witty or wry approach that still gives genuine advice); - a clear sense of engagement with the intended audience through devices such as direct address, personal anecdotes, examples and asides that give a distinctive approach to the guide; - a clear and coherent approach, for example a set of rules or sections, each giving a clear piece of advice that is developed and illustrated; - a range of appropriate and well-selected details, suggestions and tactics: being a role model, patience, setting boundaries and protecting privacy, sharing space, belongings and parents' attention, dealing with arguments and choosing battles, helping with homework or worries, keeping confidences while knowing when an adult must be told, having fun together, and the rewards of the relationship; the guide may consider different situations (a new baby, a step-sibling, a large age gap); - the ability to move from the general to the particular (specific examples used within a coherent approach to the topic); - guide features (title, subheadings, numbered rules or bullet points) that support, rather than replace, developed paragraphs; - the guide is of appropriate length and is a sufficiently detailed and developed response. Less successful responses may be characterised by some of the following features: - the content is thin and/or brief, or lacks substance and range; - a limited or uncertain sense of purpose, for example a story about the writer's family, or a complaint about younger siblings, with little or no advice; - limited awareness of, or focus on, the student readers; - tips listed but not explained or developed ('be nice', 'don't argue'); - a weak or limited structure that lacks a clear sense of direction.

  2. 8 marks

    Levels of response (8 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
    Level 5 (8 marks): there is appropriate and effective variation of sentence structures; virtually all sentence construction is controlled and accurate; a range of punctuation is used confidently and accurately; virtually all spelling, including that of complex irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is totally secure; a wide range of appropriate, ambitious vocabulary is used to create effect or convey precise meaning
    Level 4 (6-7 marks): sentence structure is varied to achieve particular effects; control of sentence construction is secure; a range of punctuation is used accurately; spelling, including that of irregular words, is secure; control of tense and agreement is secure; vocabulary is ambitious and used with precision
    Level 3 (4-5 marks): there is variety in sentence structure; control of sentence construction is mostly secure; a range of punctuation is used, mostly accurately; most spelling, including that of irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is mostly secure; vocabulary is beginning to develop and is used with some precision
    Level 2 (2-3 marks): some variety of sentence structure; there is some control of sentence construction; some control of a range of punctuation; the spelling is usually accurate; control of tense and agreement is generally secure; there is some range of vocabulary
    Level 1 (1 mark): limited range of sentence structure; control of sentence construction is limited; there is some attempt to use punctuation; some spelling is accurate; control of tense and agreement is limited; limited range of vocabulary
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Eduqas's guidance: expression is clear, fluent and controlled (the best responses will show ambition and sophistication in expression as well as a high degree of accuracy); there are few, if any, errors (no more than a sprinkling of mistakes); sentence control and range is good; tenses are consistent; vocabulary is used precisely and appropriately to convey meaning; punctuation is used accurately and appropriately (and unobtrusively). Look for: imperatives for advice balanced with statements and questions; numbered rules or subheadings set out consistently; quoted speech and signs punctuated accurately; tense controlled between past anecdotes and present-tense advice; brackets or dashes for asides; accurate apostrophes in contractions and possessives; precise vocabulary (responsibility, patience, territory, infuriating) spelt correctly. A response with nothing worthy of credit scores 0 on both points.

Question 3

20 marks

In this section you will be assessed for the quality of your writing skills.

12 marks are awarded for communication and organisation; 8 marks are awarded for vocabulary, sentence structure, punctuation and spelling.

Think about the purpose and audience for your writing.

You should aim to write about 300-400 words.

A teenage magazine has a page called 'The Two-Week Test'. Each month, a reader spends two weeks using an app that promises to improve part of their life, such as their fitness, their sleep, their spending or the time they spend on their phone, and then reviews it.

Write a review for the page of an app you have tested in this way.

Write your review.

[20]

Model answer

THE TWO-WEEK TEST: NODWELL
The promise: "Better sleep in fourteen nights."
The tester: me, aged sixteen, owner of a body clock that thinks midnight is mid-afternoon.

This year, I have been going to bed at eleven and falling asleep at about half past one, usually halfway through a video about how volcanoes work. So when the magazine asked me to test Nodwell, a sleep app that claims to fix your nights in a fortnight, I was not sceptical. I was desperate.

Setting it up is easy. You tell Nodwell what time you need to wake up, and it builds a "wind-down plan": a reminder ninety minutes before bed, a dimmed night-time screen, a library of sleep sounds and a sleep score every morning, which it works out by listening to you through your phone's microphone. Yes, that is as creepy as it sounds. The free version also plays adverts, which seems an odd choice for an app that wants you to relax.

Week one was a disaster, and that was mostly my fault. Every night the reminder popped up - "Time to start winding down!" - and every night I ignored it. My first three sleep scores (52, 48 and 55 out of 100) made grim reading. The irony was not lost on me: I was lying in bed, wide awake, staring at an app that was telling me to stop staring at my phone.

In week two, I actually followed the plan. Phone face down by ten. The "Rainy Bus Shelter" sound (strange, but oddly soothing). The same alarm every day, even at the weekend. Slowly, something changed. By night ten I was asleep before midnight, and my score had crept into the seventies. More importantly, I stopped nodding off in double Chemistry.

So does Nodwell work? Honestly, yes and no. The app does not perform magic: most of its advice - a regular bedtime, less screen time, a calm routine - is exactly what parents and teachers have been telling us for years. What it does is turn that advice into a game, with numbers to beat, and that turned out to be what I needed. On the other hand, the full version costs four pounds ninety-nine a month after the free trial, and I am still not convinced that a phone listening to me all night is a brilliant idea.

VERDICT: three and a half out of five. Nodwell is a good coach, but you still have to do the training. Try the free version first, switch off the microphone tracking if it bothers you, and do not expect a miracle on night one. By night fourteen, though, you might just fall asleep before the volcano erupts.

Explanation

The model reaches Level 5 because the two-week trial gives it a clear, purposeful structure (promise, set-up, week one, week two, verdict), and it offers readers both information (features, cost, privacy) and an honest opinion that admits the reviewer's own part in the results. The self-mocking voice suits a teenage magazine, and the verdict is balanced and practical. Weaker answers describe the app like an advert, forget the testing, or turn into a general article about sleep or screen time. It is longer than the 300-400 words Eduqas suggests: a well-developed answer of about 400 words can reach the same level.

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO5 (content and organisation). (Eduqas's band descriptors continue in the comments.)
    Level 5 (11-12 marks): shows sophisticated understanding of the purpose and format of the task; shows sustained awareness of the reader / intended audience; appropriate register is confidently adapted to purpose / audience; content is ambitious, pertinent and sophisticated
    Level 4 (8-10 marks): shows consistent understanding of the purpose and format of the task; shows secure awareness of the reader/intended audience; register is appropriately and consistently adapted to purpose/audience; content is well-judged and detailed
    Level 3 (5-7 marks): shows clear understanding of the purpose and format of the task; shows clear awareness of the reader / intended audience; register is appropriately adapted to purpose / audience; content is developed and appropriate reasons are given in support of opinions / ideas
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): shows some awareness of the purpose and format of the task; shows awareness of the reader / intended audience; a clear attempt to adapt register to purpose / audience; some reasons are given in support of opinions and ideas
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): basic awareness of the purpose and format of the task; some basic awareness of the reader / intended audience; some attempt to adapt register to purpose / audience (e.g. degree of formality); some relevant content despite uneven coverage of the topic
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Eduqas's band descriptors, continued: Level 5: ideas are convincingly developed and supported by a range of relevant details; there is sophistication in the shape and structure of the writing; communication has ambition and sophistication. Level 4: ideas are organised and coherently developed with supporting detail; there is clear shape and structure in the writing (paragraphs are used effectively to give sequence and organisation); communication has clarity, fluency and some ambition. Level 3: ideas are organised into coherent arguments; there is some shape and structure in the writing (paragraphs are used to give sequence and organisation); communication has clarity and fluency. Level 2: limited development of ideas; some sequencing of ideas into paragraphs (structure / direction may be uncertain); communication has some clarity and fluency. Level 1: content may be thin and brief; simple sequencing of ideas (paragraphs may be used to show obvious divisions or group ideas into some order); there is some basic clarity but communication of meaning is limited. Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid approaches). Successful responses may include some of the following features: - a clear understanding of the purpose of the task - to give information and opinion - shaped by the page's format: what the app promises, how it works, what happened during the two weeks and whether it kept its promise; - a lively, personal register suited to a teenage magazine, with a distinctive voice (asides, self-mockery, questions, direct address) and an effective reader-writer relationship with readers who may be thinking of downloading the app; - a clear and coherent approach: the two-week trial gives a natural structure (the promise, setting up, the first week, the second week, the verdict) and a sense of change, or of no change; - a range of well-selected details: specific features, reminders, scores or results, costs (free version, adverts, subscription), ease of use, and honest reflection on the reviewer's own part in the results; - awareness of wider issues readers may care about, such as privacy, the irony of using a phone to cut down on phone use, or whether the app's advice is simply common sense; - sensible, safe advice: a top-band answer does not recommend extreme diets, dangerous exercise or other harmful habits; - a clear verdict saying who the app suits and how to get the best from it; - a sufficiently detailed and developed response. Level 5 for this task: information and opinion are well balanced, the reviewer's honesty makes the judgement convincing, the structure reflects the two weeks clearly and the voice engages a teenage reader throughout. Less successful responses may be characterised by: - describing the app's features like an advert or an app-store page, with no sense of testing it; - a day-by-day diary with little evaluation; - a general article about sleep, fitness or screen time that hardly mentions the app; - generalised opinions ('it was good', 'it really helped') without examples; - no verdict or recommendation.

  2. 8 marks

    Levels of response (8 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
    Level 5 (8 marks): there is appropriate and effective variation of sentence structures; virtually all sentence construction is controlled and accurate; a range of punctuation is used confidently and accurately; virtually all spelling, including that of complex irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is totally secure; a wide range of appropriate, ambitious vocabulary is used to create effect or convey precise meaning
    Level 4 (6-7 marks): sentence structure is varied to achieve particular effects; control of sentence construction is secure; a range of punctuation is used accurately; spelling, including that of irregular words, is secure; control of tense and agreement is secure; vocabulary is ambitious and used with precision
    Level 3 (4-5 marks): there is variety in sentence structure; control of sentence construction is mostly secure; a range of punctuation is used, mostly accurately; most spelling, including that of irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is mostly secure; vocabulary is beginning to develop and is used with some precision
    Level 2 (2-3 marks): some variety of sentence structure; there is some control of sentence construction; some control of a range of punctuation; the spelling is usually accurate; control of tense and agreement is generally secure; there is some range of vocabulary
    Level 1 (1 mark): limited range of sentence structure; control of sentence construction is limited; there is some attempt to use punctuation; some spelling is accurate; control of tense and agreement is limited; limited range of vocabulary
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Eduqas's guidance: expression is clear, fluent and controlled (the best responses will show ambition and sophistication in expression as well as a high degree of accuracy); there are few, if any, errors (no more than a sprinkling of mistakes); tenses are consistent; vocabulary is used precisely and appropriately to convey meaning; punctuation is used accurately and appropriately (and unobtrusively). Look for: tense control across a trial: the past for what happened during the two weeks, the present for what the app does and for the verdict, and modal verbs for advice; consistent punctuation of the app's name, its reminders and any scores; numbers and prices handled consistently; ambitious but precise vocabulary (sceptical, irony, notification, subscription), spelt correctly; a lively voice achieved through sentence variety, minor sentences and asides rather than text-speak, abbreviations or emojis; subheadings or clear paragraphing for the stages of the test. A response with nothing worthy of credit scores 0 on both points.

Question 4

20 marks

In this section you will be assessed for the quality of your writing skills.

12 marks are awarded for communication and organisation; 8 marks are awarded for vocabulary, sentence structure, punctuation and spelling.

Think about the purpose and audience for your writing.

You should aim to write about 300-400 words.

Write a review for your school/college magazine of a film or TV series that has been made from a book you have read. Say how well it does justice to the book.

Write your review.

[20]

Model answer

BOOK v SCREEN: UNDER LANTERN WATER

When I heard that Under Lantern Water, Nell Pryor's novel about a village drowned beneath a reservoir, was being turned into a six-part TV series, I felt equal amounts of excitement and dread. This is the book I have lent to more friends than any other (only two copies have ever come back). Would the series do it justice, or ruin it?

For anyone who has not read it, the story follows fourteen-year-old Mali, who is sent to stay at her grandmother's farm in a Welsh valley while her mum is in hospital. In a summer of drought, the water in the reservoir drops so low that the rooftops of the old village reappear, and at night Mali begins to hear a church bell ringing somewhere beneath the water. That is all I will say, because the joy of the book is not knowing what comes next.

Visually, the series is stunning. The shots of the half-drowned village, its chimneys poking out of cracked grey mud, are even eerier than I had imagined, and the sound of the underwater bell, slow and muffled, genuinely made the hairs on my arms stand up. The first two episodes follow the book almost scene by scene, and the young actor who plays Mali captures her stubbornness perfectly.

However, something important gets lost. In the novel, we live inside Mali's head. Her sarcastic, frightened, funny voice is what makes the book special, and on screen, without it, she sometimes seems sulky rather than brave. Worse, the series replaces her grandmother, Nain, with a bland aunt who has no memories of the village at all. In the book, Nain is the link between past and present; without her, the middle episodes drag, padded out with scenes of people frowning at old maps.

Then there is the ending. Without giving too much away, I can tell you that the series changes it, swapping the book's quiet, haunting final chapter for a storm and a dramatic rescue. It looks spectacular, but it feels like a different story. Several people in my class who had not read the book loved it; those of us who had were furious.

So, does the series do the book justice? Partly. It gets the atmosphere right and the heart wrong.

The book: five stars. The series: three. If you have already read Under Lantern Water, watch the series for its beautiful images and spine-tingling sound, but be ready to argue with the ending. If you have not, do yourself a favour and read the book first. Then you will know exactly what the series is missing.

Explanation

This reaches Level 5 because it is a genuine review of an adaptation: it gives just enough of the story for readers who have not read the book, then weighs specific strengths of the series (the drowned village, the sound of the bell) against specific losses (Mali's voice, the missing grandmother, the changed ending) and explains why each matters. It avoids spoilers and ends with a clear recommendation. Weaker answers retell the plot, review only the film or series, or list differences without saying what difference they make. It is longer than the 300-400 words Eduqas suggests: a well-developed answer of about 400 words can reach the same level.

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO5 (content and organisation). (Eduqas's band descriptors continue in the comments.)
    Level 5 (11-12 marks): shows sophisticated understanding of the purpose and format of the task; shows sustained awareness of the reader / intended audience; appropriate register is confidently adapted to purpose / audience; content is ambitious, pertinent and sophisticated
    Level 4 (8-10 marks): shows consistent understanding of the purpose and format of the task; shows secure awareness of the reader/intended audience; register is appropriately and consistently adapted to purpose/audience; content is well-judged and detailed
    Level 3 (5-7 marks): shows clear understanding of the purpose and format of the task; shows clear awareness of the reader / intended audience; register is appropriately adapted to purpose / audience; content is developed and appropriate reasons are given in support of opinions / ideas
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): shows some awareness of the purpose and format of the task; shows awareness of the reader / intended audience; a clear attempt to adapt register to purpose / audience; some reasons are given in support of opinions and ideas
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): basic awareness of the purpose and format of the task; some basic awareness of the reader / intended audience; some attempt to adapt register to purpose / audience (e.g. degree of formality); some relevant content despite uneven coverage of the topic
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Eduqas's band descriptors, continued: Level 5: ideas are convincingly developed and supported by a range of relevant details; there is sophistication in the shape and structure of the writing; communication has ambition and sophistication. Level 4: ideas are organised and coherently developed with supporting detail; there is clear shape and structure in the writing (paragraphs are used effectively to give sequence and organisation); communication has clarity, fluency and some ambition. Level 3: ideas are organised into coherent arguments; there is some shape and structure in the writing (paragraphs are used to give sequence and organisation); communication has clarity and fluency. Level 2: limited development of ideas; some sequencing of ideas into paragraphs (structure / direction may be uncertain); communication has some clarity and fluency. Level 1: content may be thin and brief; simple sequencing of ideas (paragraphs may be used to show obvious divisions or group ideas into some order); there is some basic clarity but communication of meaning is limited. Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid approaches). Successful responses may include some of the following features: - a clear understanding of the purpose of the task - to give information and opinion - about an adaptation: how well the film or series turns the book into something new, and which readers should choose first; - a register suited to a school/college magazine, with a distinctive voice and an awareness of different readers: some will have read the book, some will have seen the adaptation, some neither; - a clear and coherent approach that compares the two throughout rather than reviewing one and then the other; - enough of the story, characters and setting for a newcomer to follow, without giving away the ending: Eduqas's Summer 2019 examiners' report noted that weaker reviews gave either too few details of plot or characters or so many that they became hard to follow, and that more assured writers began with a general overview and then offered details about a particular episode or about the central characters; - a range of precise details about the adaptation: particular scenes, changes to characters or events, performances (an actor need not be named), visual style, music and sound, pacing and the ending, with an explanation of the effect of each change; - balanced judgement, recognising what the adaptation does well as well as what it loses; - a logical structure and direction leading to a clear verdict and recommendation; - a sufficiently detailed and developed response. Level 5 for this task: the comparison is sustained and evaluative, the reviewer explains why changes matter, and the review engages readers whether or not they know the book. Less successful responses may be characterised by: - retelling the plot at length; - reviewing only the film or series, or only the book; - listing differences without saying how they change the story; - giving away the ending; - simple assertion ('the book is always better') with little support.

  2. 8 marks

    Levels of response (8 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
    Level 5 (8 marks): there is appropriate and effective variation of sentence structures; virtually all sentence construction is controlled and accurate; a range of punctuation is used confidently and accurately; virtually all spelling, including that of complex irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is totally secure; a wide range of appropriate, ambitious vocabulary is used to create effect or convey precise meaning
    Level 4 (6-7 marks): sentence structure is varied to achieve particular effects; control of sentence construction is secure; a range of punctuation is used accurately; spelling, including that of irregular words, is secure; control of tense and agreement is secure; vocabulary is ambitious and used with precision
    Level 3 (4-5 marks): there is variety in sentence structure; control of sentence construction is mostly secure; a range of punctuation is used, mostly accurately; most spelling, including that of irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is mostly secure; vocabulary is beginning to develop and is used with some precision
    Level 2 (2-3 marks): some variety of sentence structure; there is some control of sentence construction; some control of a range of punctuation; the spelling is usually accurate; control of tense and agreement is generally secure; there is some range of vocabulary
    Level 1 (1 mark): limited range of sentence structure; control of sentence construction is limited; there is some attempt to use punctuation; some spelling is accurate; control of tense and agreement is limited; limited range of vocabulary
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Eduqas's guidance: expression is clear, fluent and controlled (the best responses will show ambition and sophistication in expression as well as a high degree of accuracy); there are few, if any, errors (no more than a sprinkling of mistakes); tenses are consistent; vocabulary is used precisely and appropriately to convey meaning; punctuation is used accurately and appropriately (and unobtrusively). Look for: the titles of the book and the adaptation set out consistently (capital letters, and inverted commas used either throughout or not at all); the present tense for discussing what happens in a story (the heroine discovers, the series cuts) and the past for the reviewer's own reading and watching; precise critical vocabulary (adaptation, faithful, atmosphere, pacing, narrator, protagonist), spelt correctly; complex sentences that weigh one version against the other; apostrophes in possessives such as the book's ending and the author's first novel. A response with nothing worthy of credit scores 0 on both points.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.