"The World Council of Churches has failed to unite Christians."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Some would agree with this statement. The World Council of Churches was founded in 1948 with the aim of calling churches to visible unity in one faith and one eucharistic fellowship, yet more than seventy-five years later Christians remain divided into many denominations. The Catholic Church, the largest Christian church in the world, is not a member, and many Evangelical and Pentecostal churches, among the fastest growing in the world, have also stayed outside, preferring networks such as the World Evangelical Alliance. Some Orthodox churches, including the Georgian and Bulgarian Orthodox churches, left the WCC in the late 1990s. In many cases Christians of different churches still cannot share communion, and new divisions have opened over issues such as women's ordination and sexuality. Some critics, especially conservative Evangelicals, argue that the WCC has become too political and too liberal, focusing on social issues rather than the gospel; its grants to movements fighting racism in southern Africa in the 1970s were controversial. To these critics, the lack of visible unity shows that the WCC has not achieved its main purpose and that Jesus' prayer 'That they all may be one' (John 17:21) remains unfulfilled.
However, others would argue that the WCC has achieved a great deal. It brings together more than 300 churches, including most Orthodox churches and many Anglican, Lutheran, Methodist, Reformed and Baptist churches, in common prayer and action, something unimaginable a century ago when many of these churches regarded each other with deep suspicion. Although the Catholic Church is not a member, it works closely with the WCC, is a full member of its Faith and Order Commission and prepares the Week of Prayer for Christian Unity jointly with it. Theological dialogue, such as the document Baptism, Eucharist and Ministry (1982), helped many churches recognise each other's baptism and understand each other better. The WCC has also united Christians in action: its Programme to Combat Racism opposed apartheid, and it has worked for peace in places such as Korea, Colombia and South Sudan, supported refugees and campaigned for climate justice. Many Christians argue that unity does not have to mean uniformity; churches can be reconciled while keeping their different traditions, just as Paul described one body with many parts (1 Corinthians 12:12). The WCC is also only one part of the wider Ecumenical Movement, which includes Churches Together, the Taizé Community and agreements such as the Catholic-Lutheran Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification (1999).
The answer depends on what 'unite' means. If it means creating one single church, the WCC has not succeeded. If it means bringing divided churches into fellowship, cooperation and mutual respect, it has achieved a great deal.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. The WCC has not achieved full visible unity, and important churches remain outside it, but it has transformed relationships between churches that once condemned each other and has helped Christians to pray, think and act together. Full unity may still be a long way off, but the WCC has made real progress towards the unity for which Jesus prayed.
Explanation
A strong answer uses accurate knowledge of the WCC (its aim, membership, those outside it, its dialogue and its justice work) to weigh real limitations against real achievements. The best evaluation asks what 'unity' means: one church, or reconciled diversity. Do not claim the Catholic Church is a member; credit answers that note its close cooperation.