"It is impossible for God to be both three and one."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Christians believe that God is a Trinity: one God in three persons, the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit. Critics argue that this is a contradiction, since three cannot equal one, but Christians claim that it is a mystery rather than an impossibility.
Those who agree with the statement argue that the Trinity is logically incoherent. If the Father is God, the Son is God and the Spirit is God, and yet they are different from each other, it seems there must be three gods; but if there is only one God, it seems the three must really be the same. Every analogy seems to fail: water, ice and steam suggest one thing in three forms, which the Church rejects as modalism, while a three-leaved shamrock suggests three parts rather than three persons who are each fully God. Jews and Muslims, who are also monotheists, believe the Trinity compromises God's oneness: the Shema declares, 'The LORD our God is one LORD' (Deuteronomy 6:4), and Surah 112 of the Qur'an teaches that God is One, neither begetting nor begotten. Within Christianity, Unitarians and Jehovah's Witnesses reject the Trinity, and the word itself is not found in the Bible. Atheists may see the doctrine as evidence that religious belief is not rational, and even the Catholic Church calls the Trinity a mystery, which might suggest that it is beyond reason.
However, Christians argue that the Trinity is not a contradiction, because 'one' and 'three' describe different things. God is one in being or substance and three in persons; a contradiction would arise only if Christians said that God was one and three in the same sense. The Nicene Creed, first agreed at Nicaea in 325, was carefully worded to say that the Son is 'of one Being with the Father' while remaining distinct from him. Christians also argue that the doctrine comes from the Bible's evidence rather than from abstract theory. Jesus said, 'I and my Father are one' (John 10:30) and 'he that hath seen me hath seen the Father' (John 14:9), yet he prayed to the Father and promised that the Father would send the Spirit (John 14:26). At Jesus' baptism the Father speaks, the Son is baptised and the Spirit descends like a dove (Matthew 3:16-17). St Augustine suggested that if God is love, God must be a relationship: the lover, the beloved and the love between them.
Christians also point out that it would be surprising if humans could fully understand God. Isaiah 55:8-9 teaches that God's ways are higher than ours, and even in nature there are things, such as light behaving both as a wave and as a particle, that are hard to picture without being impossible. For many Christians the Trinity also matches their experience: they know God as the creator and Father, as revealed in Jesus, and as the Spirit present within them when they pray.
In conclusion, the Trinity would be impossible if Christians claimed that God was three and one in exactly the same way, and it is understandable that Jews, Muslims and atheists find it unconvincing. However, the doctrine is carefully stated to avoid contradiction and is based on the way the Bible speaks of God. It is better described as a mystery beyond full human understanding than as an impossibility, so I disagree with the statement.
Explanation
This statement tests understanding of what the doctrine actually claims: the key point is that God is one in being and three in persons, so it is not 'three equals one' in the same sense. Strong answers also take the objections seriously, including Jewish and Muslim views of God's oneness, non-Trinitarian Christians and atheists, and use John 10:30 and John 14:6-11. Avoid analogies that accidentally describe three gods or one God in three disguises.