"Shrines such as Walsingham distract Christians from worshipping God."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Some Christians would agree with this statement. At the Reformation in the sixteenth century, Protestant reformers argued that shrines, relics and pilgrimages encouraged superstition and drew devotion away from God, and in England the shrine at Walsingham was destroyed in 1538. Many Evangelicals and other Protestants today are uneasy about the devotion to Mary at Walsingham, such as processions with her statue and praying the rosary. They believe that only God should be worshipped and point to the commandment not to make 'any graven image' and bow down to it (Exodus 20:4-5). They also stress that Christ is the 'one mediator between God and men' (1 Timothy 2:5), so Christians do not need Mary or the saints to pray for them. Jesus taught that true worship is 'in spirit and in truth' and not tied to holy places (John 4:21-24). There is also a risk that pilgrims focus on hoped-for miracles at the holy well, or on souvenirs and sightseeing, rather than on God himself. Quakers would add that every place is equally holy, so special shrines are unnecessary.
However, Catholics, Orthodox Christians and many Anglicans would strongly disagree. They distinguish between worship, which is given to God alone, and the honour given to Mary as the Mother of God. Mary herself said that 'all generations shall call me blessed' (Luke 1:48), and at the wedding at Cana she directed people to Jesus: 'Whatsoever he saith unto you, do it' (John 2:5). At Walsingham the Holy House recalls the Annunciation and therefore the Incarnation, when God became human, so it leads pilgrims to think about God's love rather than away from it. The central act of worship at both the Catholic and the Anglican shrines is the Mass or Eucharist, in which worship is offered to God. Pilgrims also pray, read the Bible, make their confession and walk the Stations of the Cross, all of which focus on God. Many people say that being in a place where Christians have prayed for nearly a thousand years helps them to concentrate and feel God's presence, just as the people of Israel rejoiced to go to God's house in Jerusalem (Psalm 122:1). Walsingham has also become a place of reconciliation, where Catholics, Anglicans and Orthodox pray in the same village, reflecting Jesus' prayer that his followers 'may be one' (John 17:21).
Whether a shrine distracts may depend on the individual. A visitor who goes only for souvenirs or a day out may well be distracted, but someone who goes to pray may find that a shrine deepens their worship. The same could be said of any church building or act of worship.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. The Protestant concerns about superstition and devotion to Mary are serious and sincerely held, and Christians should make sure that honour given to Mary never replaces the worship of God. However, the main purpose of Walsingham is to help people worship God, especially through the Eucharist and reflection on the Incarnation. For many Christians it is a help rather than a distraction, while those who do not find shrines helpful are free to worship God elsewhere.
Explanation
The best answers explain the Protestant objections accurately (Exodus 20:4-5, 1 Timothy 2:5, the Reformation) and the Catholic and Anglo-Catholic reply, especially the difference between worshipping God and honouring Mary. Strong evaluation considers what actually happens at Walsingham, such as the Eucharist, and whether distraction depends on the pilgrim. Avoid claiming that Catholics worship Mary, which they do not believe they do.