"The creation accounts give humans the right to use the world for their own benefit."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
The creation accounts in Genesis give humans an important role in God's world. The question is whether that role is a right to use the world for human benefit, or a responsibility to care for it on God's behalf.
Some arguments support the statement. In Genesis 1:28 God tells humans to 'replenish the earth, and subdue it: and have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the fowl of the air, and over every living thing'. The words 'subdue' and 'dominion' suggest authority and control. God also gives humans 'every herb bearing seed' for food (1:29), and after the flood animals too are given as food (Genesis 9:3). In Genesis 2 the man names the animals (2:19-20), a sign of authority, and is told to 'dress' the garden (2:15), so farming, building and using natural resources are part of God's plan. Some Christians argue that meeting human needs - food, homes, medicine and lifting people out of poverty - is a legitimate and even necessary use of the world, and that humans, made in God's image, have a higher status than other creatures. In the past, some Christians did read dominion as permission to use nature freely.
However, most Christians today argue that the accounts give humans a responsibility rather than an unlimited right. The earth belongs to God: 'The earth is the LORD's, and the fulness thereof' (Psalm 24:1). Humans are placed in Eden not only to 'dress' it but also 'to keep it' (2:15) - to guard and protect it. Dominion means ruling as God's representatives, so humans should treat creation as God would, and God saw every part of creation as 'good' (Genesis 1). Pope Francis's Laudato Si' (2015) rejects the idea that dominion justifies absolute domination and calls Christians to care for 'our common home'. The Orthodox Patriarch Bartholomew has taught that damaging the natural world is a sin, and Evangelical Christians founded A Rocha to protect habitats. 'Benefit' must also include the poor and future generations: Christian Aid and Tearfund point out that climate change harms the poorest people most, so careless use of the world fails the command to love our neighbour (Mark 12:31). The story of the Fall even shows the ground being cursed as a consequence of human disobedience (Genesis 3:17), a warning that misusing God's gifts brings harm.
Non-religious people reject the idea of any God-given right. Humanists argue that we must use the world responsibly because our survival, and that of future generations, depends on it, and thinkers such as Peter Singer argue that the interests of animals must be taken into account. For them the issue is responsibility based on reason and compassion, not permission from God.
In conclusion, the creation accounts do allow humans to use the world to meet their genuine needs: farming and using resources are part of God's purpose. But they do not give an unlimited right to use it for our own benefit, because the world belongs to God and humans are stewards who will be accountable to him. I therefore disagree with the statement as it stands: Genesis gives humans permission to use the world, but only as responsible stewards.