"Belief in karma is the best motivation for living a moral life."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Karma, the law of action and reaction, is central to Hindu ethics, but Hindus and non-religious people disagree about whether it is the best reason for being good.
On one side, karma provides a clear and powerful motivation. Hindus believe that every intentional action has consequences: as the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad (4.4.5) puts it, as a person acts, so they become. Good actions bring happiness and a better rebirth, while harmful actions bring suffering in this life or a future one, so nobody can escape the effects of their choices. This gives people a strong reason to tell the truth, help others and practise ahimsa, even when no one else is watching. It also gives a sense of justice and personal responsibility: a person cannot blame God or fate, because karma results from their own freely chosen actions. Belief in karma is shared by Buddhists, Jains and Sikhs, which suggests it has inspired moral living for many millions of people over thousands of years.
On the other side, the Bhagavad Gita itself suggests that acting for good results is not the highest motive. Krishna teaches that a person has a right to their actions but not to their fruits (2.47), and that by acting without attachment one attains the Supreme (3.19). This is nishkama karma: doing one's dharma because it is right, not to earn good karma. Indeed, even good karma binds the atman to samsara, since rewards in heavenly realms are temporary (9.21). If a person is good only to gain a better rebirth, their motive is still self-interest.
Many Hindus would say the best motivation is love. The Bhagavata Purana (1.2.6) teaches that the highest dharma is devotion to God that is unmotivated and uninterrupted, and Vaishnava devotees serve others because they love Krishna and see him in all beings. Others stress compassion based on the atman: if the same self is present in all beings (Bhagavad Gita 5.18), harming another is like harming oneself, as Advaitins teach. The divine qualities in Bhagavad Gita 16.1-3, such as compassion for all beings and freedom from anger, are valued for their own sake.
Non-religious people such as Humanists would also disagree with the statement. Humanists UK argues that people can be good without religion, basing morality on reason, empathy and concern for the well-being of others, and many atheists say that being moral to gain a reward or avoid a punishment in a future life is a poor reason: we should help others because they matter. Some also worry that karma can be misused to blame those who suffer for their misfortune, which could reduce compassion.
In conclusion, belief in karma is certainly a strong motivation, and for many Hindus it is a helpful starting point, especially when teaching children about the consequences of their actions. However, I do not think it is the best motivation. The Gita's own teaching points beyond it to duty done without selfish desire, and to love of God and of all beings. The highest moral life, for Hindus and for many non-religious people, is one in which good actions flow from compassion rather than from calculating rewards.