"It is impossible to practise ahimsa fully in today's world."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Ahimsa means non-violence: not harming any living being in thought, word or deed. It is a central Hindu value, but some argue that practising it fully is impossible today.
There are reasons to agree. Simply living involves harm: farming, even of vegetables, kills insects and destroys habitats, and walking, cooking and cleaning kill tiny creatures. Modern life adds more problems. Many everyday products involve harm to animals, such as leather, some medicines tested on animals, and dairy farming, in which cows are often slaughtered when their milk declines, which troubles many Hindus who revere the cow. Our clothes, phones and food may be produced by exploited workers or in ways that damage the environment, harming countless living beings. Society also seems to need some use of force: police and armed forces protect people, and the Bhagavad Gita itself is set on a battlefield, where Krishna tells Arjuna that as a kshatriya his duty is to fight a righteous war (2.31). Even harsh words online can be a form of violence. So complete ahimsa appears to be an impossible ideal.
However, there are strong arguments against the statement. Many Hindus would say that ahimsa is about intention and minimising harm, not about achieving perfection. Karma depends on the intention behind actions, and Krishna teaches that duty done without selfish desire or malice does not bind the atman (2.47). Ahimsa is listed as part of true knowledge (13.8) and as a divine quality (16.2), which implies that people can develop it. Many Hindus show that a high degree of ahimsa is possible today: millions are vegetarian, ISKCON devotees avoid meat, fish and eggs, and some Hindus in Britain support projects that produce milk from cows that will never be slaughtered. Gandhi showed that ahimsa can work even on a national scale, using satyagraha in the campaign for Indian independence, and he inspired later nonviolent movements, such as the civil rights movement in the USA. In some ways the modern world makes ahimsa easier, with plant-based foods, cruelty-free products and peaceful ways to resolve disputes through law and negotiation.
There is also diversity in what 'fully' means. For many Hindus ahimsa allows force in self-defence or to protect the innocent, under the rules of dharma yuddha, so a soldier doing their duty without hatred is not breaking ahimsa. Others, following Gandhi, see the Gita's battle as a symbol of the inner struggle and aim at complete non-violence. Advaitins stress that seeing the one self in all beings removes hatred, which is the root of violence, and the Isha Upanishad teaches that one who sees all beings in the self feels no hatred.
In conclusion, I think it is true that no one living in a body can avoid all harm, in today's world or any other. But it does not follow that ahimsa cannot be practised fully. If ahimsa means a whole-hearted commitment to avoid unnecessary harm in thought, word and deed, then many Hindus do practise it fully, and the modern world offers more ways than ever to do so.
Explanation
A strong answer defines what 'fully' could mean: avoiding all harm (which seems impossible) or committing wholeheartedly to avoid unnecessary harm (which many Hindus achieve). Level 5 answers use Hindu teaching on intention and karma, the Gita's battlefield setting, and examples such as Gandhi and vegetarianism on both sides, then reach a justified conclusion. Lists of things Hindus avoid, without evaluation, stay at Level 2 or 3.