"It is more helpful for Hindus to worship God with form than to meditate on God without form."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Many Hindus would agree. In the Bhagavad Gita, Arjuna asks Krishna whether it is better to worship him in his personal form or to meditate on the unmanifest, formless reality. Krishna replies that those who fix their minds on him with faith are the most devoted (12.2), and that the path of the unmanifest is more difficult, because the unmanifest goal is hard for embodied beings to reach (12.5). Human beings live in physical bodies and think through the senses, so it is natural to relate to God through a form. Saguna forms of the divine, such as Krishna, Rama, Shiva or Durga, can be loved and trusted. Murtis provide a focus for worship, and many Hindus believe that after the prana pratishtha ceremony the deity is truly present in the murti. Puja, arati, darshan and festivals such as Janmashtami involve the senses, the family and the whole community, and prasad shares God's blessing. Bhakti is also open to everyone, whatever their education, caste or gender; Krishna accepts even a leaf, a flower, a fruit or water offered with love (9.26). For Vaishnavas, Shaivas and Shaktas the personal God is not a lower step but the highest truth: Krishna says he is the foundation of Brahman (14.27), and ISKCON teaches that the impersonal Brahman is only a partial realisation of Krishna.
However, others would disagree. Advaita Vedanta, following Adi Shankara, teaches that the highest truth is nirguna Brahman, beyond all forms and qualities. Worship of a form is valuable, but it is a preparation for the realisation that the atman is Brahman, which comes through jnana (knowledge) and meditation. The Upanishads describe Brahman as 'neti neti' - 'not this, not this' - so any form, however beautiful, limits the infinite. Brahman is within the heart (Katha Upanishad 2.20), so meditation can lead directly to the divine within, without needing anything outside. Krishna himself says that those devoted to the unmanifest also reach him (12.3-4); he does not say their path is wrong, only harder. Some Hindus, such as the Arya Samaj, reject murti worship altogether, pointing to the Vedic teaching that 'there is no likeness of him' (Yajurveda 32.3), and worship the formless God through the havan and prayer. There is also a danger that worshippers may mistake the form for the whole of God, rather than seeing it as a way to the divine.
Much depends on what 'more helpful' means. For most Hindus, worship with form is clearly more practical and more emotionally satisfying, which is why murti puja is the most common form of Hindu worship in homes and mandirs. But for a person with the temperament and discipline for meditation, such as a sannyasin, meditation on the formless may be more helpful. Hindu tradition recognises different paths - bhakti, jnana, karma and raja yoga - precisely because people are different.
In conclusion, I agree that worshipping God with form is more helpful for most Hindus, as Bhagavad Gita 12.5 suggests, because it suits embodied human beings and makes love of God possible. However, I do not think it is more helpful for everyone, and the two approaches need not be rivals. Ramakrishna taught that God is both with form and without form, like ice and water, which are the same substance. Many Hindus worship a murti and also meditate, seeing both as ways to the one Brahman.