"Hindus need murtis in order to worship God."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Many Hindus would agree that murtis are central to worship. In the Bhagavad Gita Krishna says that the path of those whose minds are set on the unmanifest is more difficult, because the unmanifest goal is hard for embodied beings to reach (12.5). Human beings live through their senses, so a murti gives them a form on which to focus their minds and hearts. Many Hindus believe that after the prana pratishtha ceremony the deity is truly present in the murti, so that worshippers receive darshan, seeing and being seen by God. Sri Vaishnavas speak of the murti as an archa-avatara, a form in which God graciously descends so that people can worship him. Almost every part of Hindu worship centres on the murti: in puja the deity is offered flowers, food, water and incense; in arati a lamp is waved before it; in temples the murti is woken, bathed, dressed and fed, and the food becomes prasad, God's blessing. Temples are built around the murti in the garbhagriha, the inner shrine, and nearly every Hindu home has a shrine with murtis or pictures of the family's deities. Festivals such as Ganesh Chaturthi, Durga Puja and the Rath Yatra procession, held by ISKCON even in London, involve murtis. For these Hindus, worship without a murti would feel incomplete.
However, the word 'need' is very strong, and there are good reasons to disagree. Hindus believe that Brahman is everywhere and within the heart (Katha Upanishad 5:2), so God can be worshipped anywhere, without any physical form. The Arya Samaj, founded by Swami Dayananda Saraswati in 1875, rejects murti worship altogether, pointing to the Vedic teaching that 'there is no likeness of him' (Yajurveda 32.3), and worships through the havan, the sacred fire, and Vedic prayers. The Brahmo Samaj also rejected the use of murtis. Advaita Hindus believe that the highest truth is nirguna Brahman, beyond all forms, so murti worship is a helpful stage but not essential; meditation and knowledge are the way to realise the atman's oneness with Brahman. Krishna himself says that those devoted to the unmanifest also reach him (12.3-4). Many forms of Hindu worship do not require a murti at all: chanting Om or the Gayatri Mantra, japa with mala beads, singing bhajans and kirtan, meditation and yoga, and seva, serving others as a way of serving God. Krishna says that what matters is the love with which an offering is made (9.26), not the object in front of the worshipper. Even Shaivas often worship Shiva through the lingam, which is a symbol rather than a human-like form.
Weighing these arguments, murtis are clearly extremely important and helpful for most Hindus, and for some traditions, such as ISKCON or the Swaminarayan movement, deity worship is at the very heart of religious life. However, Hindu scriptures and traditions show that God can be worshipped in many ways, and that the murti is a means of worshipping the divine rather than something without which worship is impossible. Hinduism has always recognised different paths for different people.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. Most Hindus find murtis extremely valuable, and Bhagavad Gita 12.5 suggests that worship with form suits embodied human beings. But Hindus do not need murtis in order to worship God, because Brahman is present everywhere and within every heart, and can be worshipped through meditation, mantra, service and love.
Explanation
The key word is 'need': a top answer shows how central murtis are (Bhagavad Gita 12.5, prana pratishtha, darshan, puja) and then shows that worship is possible without them (Brahman everywhere, Advaita meditation, the Arya Samaj, mantra and seva). The strongest answers reach a judgement that distinguishes 'very helpful' from 'necessary'. One-sided descriptions of puja stay at Level 2.