Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/8

Creative prose: write about a time when... (Section B)

Practise 30 exam-style questions on Creative prose: write about a time when... (Section B) for Eduqas GCSE English Language (Component 1). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 30 questions
  • 40 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

40 marks

In this section you will be assessed for the quality of your creative prose writing skills.

24 marks are awarded for communication and organisation; 16 marks are awarded for vocabulary, sentence structure, spelling and punctuation.

You should aim to write about 450-600 words.

Write about an occasion when you saw a teacher outside school.

[40]

Model answer

Mr Pryce does not smile. Everyone at our school knows this, in the same way that everyone knows the vending machine by the gym steals your money and the music block is haunted. He is our deputy head: tall, grey-suited, with a voice that can silence a dinner hall from fifty metres. In my first three years there, I saw him raise one eyebrow exactly once, when Liam Baxter set off the fire alarm with a cheese toastie.

So I was not prepared for Wednesday.

It was half-term, and Gran's friend Pauline, who normally went with her to Zumba, had sprained her ankle. Mum volunteered me to go instead. "Just sit at the back and make sure she doesn't overdo it," she said, as if Gran were a toddler and not a seventy-two-year-old who once beat me at arm-wrestling.

The community centre smelled of floor polish and orange squash. About twenty people, most of them Gran's age, were stretching in leggings of every colour. I took a plastic chair in the corner and got out my phone. Then the music started - something loud and Latin, with a lot of trumpets - and the instructor bounded in through the fire door.

He was wearing a pink sweatband. He was wearing neon-yellow leggings and a T-shirt that said SHAKE IT LIKE YOU MEAN IT. He was shouting, "Good evening, my beautiful people!" And he was, beyond any possible doubt, Mr Pryce.

I slid so far down my chair that I was nearly lying on the floor.

For the next forty-five minutes, I watched the most terrifying man I knew shimmy, salsa and shout "And HIPS! And HIPS!" at a hall full of pensioners, who adored him. Gran adored him. She was in the front row, wiggling with an enthusiasm I found deeply worrying. Near the end he led a conga round the hall, and as Gran passed she grabbed my wrist and dragged me into the line, and before I could escape I was conga-ing past the window, directly behind the deputy head's bright yellow legs.

That was when he turned round and saw me.

I will never forget his face. It went through about five expressions in a second - surprise, horror, panic, calculation, resignation - and then, astonishingly, it did something I had never seen it do before. It grinned.

"Knees up at the back!" he called, and kept dancing.

Afterwards, while Gran queued for squash, he came over to my corner with a towel round his neck. I stood up straight out of habit.

"I'd appreciate it," he said quietly, "if this stayed between us."

"Which bit, sir?"

He considered this. "All of it." Then, as he walked away, he added over his shoulder, "Your gran's got better rhythm than you, by the way."

On Monday morning he took assembly in his grey suit, with his grey voice, and told us off for the state of the lunch queue. Nobody would have guessed a thing. But as we filed out of the hall, he caught my eye across a row of chairs, and for about half a second his left eye did something that I am almost certain was a wink.

I have kept his secret; this is the first time I have written it down. But something changed that Wednesday. Teachers had always seemed to me like part of the building, switched off at half past three and stored in a cupboard until morning. Now, whenever a teacher is cross with me, I picture them somewhere else - in a choir, at a car-boot sale, in neon-yellow leggings - and they become a little less frightening and a lot more human.

Gran still goes every Wednesday. Sometimes, in the holidays, I go too. I stand at the back. I am getting quite good.

Explanation

This reaches Level 5 on AO5 and AO6 because the teacher's fearsome school persona is established quickly and then overturned through precise, comic detail and a well-timed reveal; the dialogue develops both characters; and the return to school and the final reflection show how the writer's view changed. The voice engages the reader throughout, and punctuation of speech and asides is secure. Weaker answers stop at the moment of recognition or rely on a stereotype that never develops. It is longer than the 450-600 words Eduqas suggests: a tightly controlled answer of about 600 words can reach the same level.

Mark scheme
  1. 24 marks

    Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation).
    Level 5 (20-24 marks): the writing is fully coherent and controlled (plot and characterisation are developed with detail, originality and imagination); the writing is clearly and imaginatively organised (narrative is sophisticated and fully engages the reader's interest); structure and grammatical features are used ambitiously to give the writing cohesion and coherence; communication is ambitious and consistently conveys precise meaning
    Level 4 (15-19 marks): the writing is clearly controlled and coherent (plot and characterisation show convincing detail and some originality and imagination); the writing is clearly organised (narrative is purposefully shaped and developed); structure and grammatical features are used accurately to support cohesion and coherence; communication shows some ambition and conveys precise meaning
    Level 3 (10-14 marks): the writing is mostly controlled and coherent (plot and characterisation show some detail and development); the writing is organised (narrative has shape and direction); structure and grammatical features are used with some accuracy to convey meaning; communication is clear but limited in ambition
    Level 2 (5-9 marks): there is some control and coherence (some control of plot and characterisation); there is some organisation (narrative is beginning to have some shape and development); structure and grammatical features are used to convey meaning; communication is limited but clear
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): there is basic control and coherence (a basic sense of plot and characterisation); there is basic organisation (paragraphs may be used to show obvious divisions); there is some use of structure and grammatical features to convey meaning; communication is limited but some meaning is conveyed
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid approaches): the response is a recount, real or imagined, of an occasion when the writer saw or met a teacher away from school: in a supermarket, a cafe, a gym or class, at a concert, a match, a wedding or a party, on holiday, as a neighbour, or with their own children or parents. The encounter may be embarrassing, comic, touching or revealing (the teacher in an unexpected role, out of their usual clothes, in difficulty, or kinder or stranger than at school). The best answers explore how seeing the teacher in a new light changes the writer's view, and a return to school can make an effective ending. Eduqas's guidance for narrative writing: good answers may be characterised by a clear and coherent perspective (first or third person); content is relevant; content is sustained and coherent and possibly imaginative; a clear sense of direction and structure; appropriate and well-selected details give substance to the narrative; close observation of the behaviour and emotions of characters; convincing use of dialogue to develop plot and characterisation; consistent awareness of the reader. Eduqas's guidance also values "establishing a relationship with the reader/engaging the reader via devices such as asides, statements, questions, humour, a distinctive voice", which suits this task well. Level 5 (20-24) answers establish the teacher's school persona quickly and then overturn it through precise, well-chosen detail and dialogue; sustain a distinctive voice; develop the encounter rather than merely reporting it; and reflect on what changed. Less successful answers rely on a stereotype (the strict teacher) that never develops, stop at the moment of recognition, or turn the teacher into a cartoon with no believable behaviour. Eduqas's specification: this response should be a narrative / recount; candidates who write purely descriptively, or use a form other than that specified, such as poetry or drama, will not be able to access the full mark range.

  2. 16 marks

    Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
    Level 5 (14-16 marks): there is appropriate and effective variation of sentence structures; virtually all sentence construction is controlled and accurate; a range of punctuation is used confidently and accurately; virtually all spelling, including that of complex irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is totally secure; a wide range of appropriate, ambitious vocabulary is used to create effect or convey precise meaning
    Level 4 (11-13 marks): sentence structure is varied to achieve particular effects; control of sentence construction is secure; a range of punctuation is used accurately; spelling, including that of irregular words, is secure; control of tense and agreement is secure; vocabulary is ambitious and used with precision
    Level 3 (7-10 marks): there is variety in sentence structure; control of sentence construction is mostly secure; a range of punctuation is used, mostly accurately; most spelling, including that of irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is mostly secure; vocabulary is beginning to develop and is used with some precision
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): some variety of sentence structure; there is some control of sentence construction; some control of a range of punctuation; the spelling is usually accurate; control of tense and agreement is generally secure; there is some range of vocabulary
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): limited range of sentence structure; control of sentence construction is limited; there is some attempt to use punctuation; some spelling is accurate; control of tense and agreement is limited; limited range of vocabulary
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Eduqas's guidance: expression is clear, fluent and controlled (the best answers will show ambition and sophistication in expression as well as a high degree of accuracy); there are few, if any, errors (no more than a sprinkling of mistakes); tenses are consistent; vocabulary is used precisely and appropriately to convey meaning; punctuation is used accurately and appropriately (and unobtrusively). Look for: dialogue between the writer and the teacher punctuated accurately, with "sir" or "miss" in lower case inside speech; deliberate patterns such as a run of parallel sentences ("He was wearing...") used once, for effect; capitals or speech marks for a slogan or sign; semi-colons and dashes to manage asides; a present-tense frame (the teacher's reputation at the start, the reflection at the end) kept clearly separate from the past-tense narrative; precise vocabulary for movement and expression (shimmy, resignation, astonishingly). A response with nothing worthy of credit scores 0 on both points.

Question 2

40 marks

In this section you will be assessed for the quality of your creative prose writing skills.

24 marks are awarded for communication and organisation; 16 marks are awarded for vocabulary, sentence structure, spelling and punctuation.

You should aim to write about 450-600 words.

Write about a time when you put a friend's needs before your own.

[40]

Model answer

Jamie asked me on the wall behind the leisure centre, where we had been sitting after school since we were eight.

"What would you do?" he said.

He had the letter in his hand. It had come that morning from a specialist music school near Manchester, two hundred miles away: a full scholarship, starting in September, for "exceptional young musicians". Jamie had auditioned in March, on his cello, and had told nobody except me and his mum, because he had been certain he would not get in.

He had got in.

I knew what I should say. I also knew what I wanted to say, and they were not the same thing. Jamie was the person I walked to school with, the person who had visited me every single day when I had my appendix out, the person who knew which songs made me cry and never mentioned it. If he went, there would be no more wall. There would be video calls that got shorter and less frequent until, one day, they stopped.

"I don't know," I said. "What do you want to do?"

He shrugged and looked at his trainers. "Everybody's telling me to go. Mum. Mr Kemp. My grandad rang from Belfast to say it was the chance of a lifetime." He picked at a loose piece of stone on the wall. "That's why I'm asking you. You're the only one who'll tell me the truth."

That was the worst part. He trusted me.

"Let me think about it," I said. "I'll tell you tomorrow."

That night I lay awake for hours. I made a list of reasons for him to stay: his football team, his little brother, his friends, me. It was a short list, and the most important reason on it was really a reason for me, not for him. The reasons for going did not need writing down. I had heard them every week for six years: through his open bedroom window as I walked past his house, in the music block at lunchtime, on the stage at every school concert while the rest of us sat stunned on plastic chairs.

I thought about the concert in Year 9, when he had played something so slow and sad that Mrs Pritchard, who taught PE and had never been known to cry, had to leave the hall. I thought about our small school orchestra, and how he always held back so that the rest of us could keep up.

Some people are too big for the places they start in. I had known that about Jamie for years. I had just never wanted to say it.

The next afternoon, on the wall, I told him. "You have to go," I said. "You'd be an idiot not to. And I'd never forgive you."

He looked at me for a long time. "You'd hate it if I went."

"Yes," I said. "I'd hate it. Go anyway."

He laughed, and then he did something he had never done in eight years of friendship: he hugged me, awkwardly, sideways, nearly knocking us both off the wall.

He left in September. For a while, it was every bit as hard as I had expected. The wall was just a wall. The video calls did get shorter. But in December a link arrived on my phone: a recording of his new school's winter concert. Before his solo, Jamie leaned towards the microphone and said, "This one's for someone who told me the truth, even though it cost them."

I watched it on the wall behind the leisure centre, in the cold, on my own. I played it three times.

It is strange to think that the most important thing I have ever said to anyone was something I did not want to say. I would say it again tomorrow.

Explanation

This reaches Level 5 on AO5 and AO6 because the cost of putting Jamie first is made concrete through specific memories, the tension between selfishness and honesty drives the story to a clear climax on the wall, and the concert recording gives a moving consequence and a reflective ending. Long reflective sentences are controlled and dialogue is accurate. Weaker answers simply claim that the writer was unselfish, or report events in which neither friend develops. It is longer than the 450-600 words Eduqas suggests: a tightly controlled answer of about 600 words can reach the same level.

Mark scheme
  1. 24 marks

    Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation).
    Level 5 (20-24 marks): the writing is fully coherent and controlled (plot and characterisation are developed with detail, originality and imagination); the writing is clearly and imaginatively organised (narrative is sophisticated and fully engages the reader's interest); structure and grammatical features are used ambitiously to give the writing cohesion and coherence; communication is ambitious and consistently conveys precise meaning
    Level 4 (15-19 marks): the writing is clearly controlled and coherent (plot and characterisation show convincing detail and some originality and imagination); the writing is clearly organised (narrative is purposefully shaped and developed); structure and grammatical features are used accurately to support cohesion and coherence; communication shows some ambition and conveys precise meaning
    Level 3 (10-14 marks): the writing is mostly controlled and coherent (plot and characterisation show some detail and development); the writing is organised (narrative has shape and direction); structure and grammatical features are used with some accuracy to convey meaning; communication is clear but limited in ambition
    Level 2 (5-9 marks): there is some control and coherence (some control of plot and characterisation); there is some organisation (narrative is beginning to have some shape and development); structure and grammatical features are used to convey meaning; communication is limited but clear
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): there is basic control and coherence (a basic sense of plot and characterisation); there is basic organisation (paragraphs may be used to show obvious divisions); there is some use of structure and grammatical features to convey meaning; communication is limited but some meaning is conveyed
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid approaches): the response is a recount, real or imagined, of a time when the writer put a friend first at some cost to themselves: giving honest advice they did not want to give, giving up a place, a prize, a ticket or a plan, staying with a friend through a difficult time instead of doing something they wanted, sharing something precious, or stepping aside so that the friend could succeed. The tension lies in the writer's own wants against the friend's needs, and perhaps in whether the friend ever knows what it cost. Endings may be bittersweet, rewarding or uncertain. Sensitive situations should be handled with care. Eduqas's guidance for narrative writing: good answers may be characterised by a clear and coherent perspective (first or third person); content is relevant; content is sustained and coherent and possibly imaginative; a clear sense of direction and structure; appropriate and well-selected details give substance to the narrative; close observation of the behaviour and emotions of characters; convincing use of dialogue to develop plot and characterisation; consistent awareness of the reader. Level 5 (20-24) answers dramatise the choice (a dilemma explored through specific shared memories rather than a list of pros and cons), convey the friendship through precise detail, place the decision or sacrifice as the climax, show its consequences, and reflect on what it meant without a sermon. Less successful answers simply claim that the writer was unselfish without showing what it cost, or report events in which neither friend develops. Eduqas's specification: this response should be a narrative / recount; candidates who write purely descriptively, or use a form other than that specified, such as poetry or drama, will not be able to access the full mark range.

  2. 16 marks

    Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
    Level 5 (14-16 marks): there is appropriate and effective variation of sentence structures; virtually all sentence construction is controlled and accurate; a range of punctuation is used confidently and accurately; virtually all spelling, including that of complex irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is totally secure; a wide range of appropriate, ambitious vocabulary is used to create effect or convey precise meaning
    Level 4 (11-13 marks): sentence structure is varied to achieve particular effects; control of sentence construction is secure; a range of punctuation is used accurately; spelling, including that of irregular words, is secure; control of tense and agreement is secure; vocabulary is ambitious and used with precision
    Level 3 (7-10 marks): there is variety in sentence structure; control of sentence construction is mostly secure; a range of punctuation is used, mostly accurately; most spelling, including that of irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is mostly secure; vocabulary is beginning to develop and is used with some precision
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): some variety of sentence structure; there is some control of sentence construction; some control of a range of punctuation; the spelling is usually accurate; control of tense and agreement is generally secure; there is some range of vocabulary
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): limited range of sentence structure; control of sentence construction is limited; there is some attempt to use punctuation; some spelling is accurate; control of tense and agreement is limited; limited range of vocabulary
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Eduqas's guidance: expression is clear, fluent and controlled (the best answers will show ambition and sophistication in expression as well as a high degree of accuracy); there are few, if any, errors (no more than a sprinkling of mistakes); tenses are consistent; vocabulary is used precisely and appropriately to convey meaning; punctuation is used accurately and appropriately (and unobtrusively). Look for: reflective complex sentences with secure subordination, balanced by short sentences at moments of decision; dialogue set out with a new line for each speaker; past perfect for the friendship's history, with the present tense kept for general truths and the closing reflection; quotation of a letter or message punctuated correctly; precise vocabulary (scholarship, exceptional, stunned) spelt correctly; no comma splices in the long sentences of the night-time dilemma. A response with nothing worthy of credit scores 0 on both points.

Question 3

40 marks

In this section you will be assessed for the quality of your creative prose writing skills.

24 marks are awarded for communication and organisation; 16 marks are awarded for vocabulary, sentence structure, spelling and punctuation.

You should aim to write about 450-600 words.

Write about a time when you were stuck somewhere with a group of strangers.

[40]

Model answer

Before my first coach journey on my own, Mum gave me three rules.

"Text me when you set off. Text me when you get there. And do not, under any circumstances, talk to strangers."

I kept the first rule. The third did not survive the afternoon. At half past one, something went bang beneath my seat, the coach filled with a smell like burnt toast and we limped onto the hard shoulder.

The driver, a young man with a hopeful moustache, stood up. "Sorry, folks. Motorway rules: everybody off, over the barrier and up the bank. Shouldn't be long now."

He was wrong. We were there for three hours.

It was the hottest afternoon of the summer. The bank was steep and scratchy, and the traffic roared past so close that every lorry dragged a hot, gritty wind across our faces.

Within twenty minutes, we had become a small, sunburnt village. Three lads lay in a row with their football shirts over their faces. A woman in her seventies, wearing a straw hat with a plastic cherry on the brim, spread out a tartan blanket as if she had been expecting this all morning. And a man in a grey suit stood apart from everybody, his jacket over one arm, murmuring into his phone and straightening a tie that was already straight.

The woman in the hat was Bernadette. She had been a primary school teacher for thirty-eight years, and it showed: she handed out egg sandwiches to anyone nearby and ordered one of the lads to put his shirt back on "before you burn to a crisp, young man". He did, too.

"Shouldn't be long now," the driver told us, for the third time.

It was Bernadette who found out about the man in the suit. His name was Desmond, and at four o'clock he had a job interview - his first in nine months. The company had agreed to see him by video call instead, wherever he happened to be.

"From here?" I said, before I could stop myself. So much for rule three.

Desmond looked at the barrier, the traffic and the dead grass. "From here," he said. He tried to laugh, but it did not quite work.

Without anyone deciding it, forty strangers turned a motorway verge into an interview room. Bernadette fired practice questions at Desmond. "Why do you want this job?" she demanded. "And don't you dare say the money." One of the football lads built a wall of rucksacks to keep the wind off the microphone. We sat him facing the road, so that the screen showed only grass and sky behind him, and I was given the most important job: holding the phone perfectly still.

At four o'clock, the call connected, and forty people held their breath. We could not stop the lorries; whenever one thundered past, Desmond paused, smiled politely and waited for it to go. My arms began to ache. A bead of sweat crept down my neck, and I did not dare wipe it away.

Then one of the interviewers asked, "Can you tell us about a time when you stayed calm under pressure?"

For a second, Desmond's eyes flicked over the phone to the rest of us, crouched silently along the bank.

"Funny you should ask," he said.

When the call ended, twenty-five minutes later, he put his head in his hands, and the whole bank burst into applause. Ten minutes after that, the replacement coach finally pulled in. "Told you it wouldn't be long," said the driver, and nobody had the heart to argue.

At the coach station, everyone scattered. Bernadette strode off towards the taxis, still in charge of something. Desmond shook my hand solemnly and thanked me for the steadiest hands on the motorway, and then he was gone, one grey suit in a crowd of hundreds.

I never found out whether he got the job. I hope he did.

I texted Mum when I arrived, exactly as promised, and told her the journey had been fine. She still thinks I kept all three rules. I have never told her that breaking the third was the best thing I did all summer.

Explanation

This is a Level 5 response on AO5: Mum's three rules frame the recount and return at the end, the driver's repeated 'Shouldn't be long now' marks the passing of time, each stranger is individualised in a few precise details ('a plastic cherry on the brim', 'straightening a tie that was already straight'), and the turning point grows naturally out of the situation rather than from melodrama. On AO6, sentence and paragraph lengths vary for effect, dialogue is punctuated accurately, colons, a semi-colon and a dash are used with control, and tenses are secure. Weaker answers introduce too many characters, spend too long on the journey or turn the wait into an implausible disaster. It is longer than the 450-600 words Eduqas suggests: a tightly controlled answer of about 600 words can reach the same level.

Mark scheme
  1. 24 marks

    Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation).
    Level 5 (20-24 marks): the writing is fully coherent and controlled (plot and characterisation are developed with detail, originality and imagination); the writing is clearly and imaginatively organised (narrative is sophisticated and fully engages the reader's interest); structure and grammatical features are used ambitiously to give the writing cohesion and coherence; communication is ambitious and consistently conveys precise meaning
    Level 4 (15-19 marks): the writing is clearly controlled and coherent (plot and characterisation show convincing detail and some originality and imagination); the writing is clearly organised (narrative is purposefully shaped and developed); structure and grammatical features are used accurately to support cohesion and coherence; communication shows some ambition and conveys precise meaning
    Level 3 (10-14 marks): the writing is mostly controlled and coherent (plot and characterisation show some detail and development); the writing is organised (narrative has shape and direction); structure and grammatical features are used with some accuracy to convey meaning; communication is clear but limited in ambition
    Level 2 (5-9 marks): there is some control and coherence (some control of plot and characterisation); there is some organisation (narrative is beginning to have some shape and development); structure and grammatical features are used to convey meaning; communication is limited but clear
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): there is basic control and coherence (a basic sense of plot and characterisation); there is basic organisation (paragraphs may be used to show obvious divisions); there is some use of structure and grammatical features to convey meaning; communication is limited but some meaning is conveyed
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid approaches): the task invites a first-person recount, real or imagined, of a time when the writer was trapped or held up in one place with people they did not know: a broken-down lift, a train stopped in a tunnel, a cancelled flight or ferry, a fairground ride that stopped at the top, a coach broken down on the motorway, a shelter during a downpour or a building locked down for an emergency. The situation provides built-in tension (how long will it last, will anyone panic, what is happening outside?) and a small cast of contrasting characters. Good answers usually establish the place and the strangers quickly, develop the group's changing mood (awkward silence, irritation, fear, humour, cooperation), include a crisis or turning point within the wait, and end with the release and a reflection: what the writer noticed about other people, or about themselves, and what was left behind when the group went its separate ways. A circular structure, a clock running through the piece or a focus on one stranger in particular can all work well. Eduqas's guidance for narrative writing: good answers may be characterised by a clear and coherent perspective (first or third person); content is relevant; content is sustained and coherent and possibly imaginative; a clear sense of direction and structure; appropriate and well-selected details give substance to the narrative; close observation of the behaviour and emotions of characters; convincing use of dialogue to develop plot and characterisation; consistent awareness of the reader. Level 5 (20-24) for this task: each stranger is individualised economically through precise details, gesture and speech; the setting, whether cramped or exposed, is used to build atmosphere; the passing of time is controlled so that the piece develops rather than repeats; the writer's own feelings change convincingly; the ending is understated and thoughtful. Less successful responses introduce too many people to develop, turn the situation into an implausible disaster, or spend most of the answer on getting there and very little on being stuck. Eduqas's specification: this response should be a narrative / recount; candidates who write purely descriptively, or use a form other than that specified, such as poetry or drama, will not be able to access the full mark range.

  2. 16 marks

    Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
    Level 5 (14-16 marks): there is appropriate and effective variation of sentence structures; virtually all sentence construction is controlled and accurate; a range of punctuation is used confidently and accurately; virtually all spelling, including that of complex irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is totally secure; a wide range of appropriate, ambitious vocabulary is used to create effect or convey precise meaning
    Level 4 (11-13 marks): sentence structure is varied to achieve particular effects; control of sentence construction is secure; a range of punctuation is used accurately; spelling, including that of irregular words, is secure; control of tense and agreement is secure; vocabulary is ambitious and used with precision
    Level 3 (7-10 marks): there is variety in sentence structure; control of sentence construction is mostly secure; a range of punctuation is used, mostly accurately; most spelling, including that of irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is mostly secure; vocabulary is beginning to develop and is used with some precision
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): some variety of sentence structure; there is some control of sentence construction; some control of a range of punctuation; the spelling is usually accurate; control of tense and agreement is generally secure; there is some range of vocabulary
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): limited range of sentence structure; control of sentence construction is limited; there is some attempt to use punctuation; some spelling is accurate; control of tense and agreement is limited; limited range of vocabulary
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Eduqas's guidance: expression is clear, fluent and controlled (the best answers will show ambition and sophistication in expression as well as a high degree of accuracy); there are few, if any, errors (no more than a sprinkling of mistakes); tenses are consistent; vocabulary is used precisely and appropriately to convey meaning; punctuation is used accurately and appropriately (and unobtrusively). Look for: conversation among several speakers punctuated clearly, so the reader always knows who is speaking; brackets, dashes and colons used accurately to add details about the strangers; a controlled past tense with the past perfect used correctly for anything that happened before the wait began; a range of sentence structures, including short sentences to mark moments of panic or relief; precise vocabulary for the place, the conditions and the strangers' behaviour, spelt correctly (claustrophobic, breathe, exhausted, embarrassed, reassuring, separate). A response with nothing worthy of credit scores 0 on both points.

Question 4

40 marks

In this section you will be assessed for the quality of your creative prose writing skills.

24 marks are awarded for communication and organisation; 16 marks are awarded for vocabulary, sentence structure, spelling and punctuation.

You should aim to write about 450-600 words.

Write about an occasion when you met someone famous.

[40]

Model answer

I spent forty minutes telling Hester Quayle exactly what was wrong with her book. In my defence, I had no idea who she was.

It was a Saturday in March, and I was on my way home from my cousin's in Manchester. My train was delayed, the station cafe had sold out of everything except flapjacks, and the only free seat on the platform was next to an elderly woman in a purple raincoat with an enormous, battered suitcase. When the train finally arrived, I helped her lift the suitcase on board. It weighed roughly the same as a fridge.

"Books," she said, seeing my face. "Occupational hazard."

We ended up sitting opposite each other. She asked where I was going, and what I liked at school, and when I said English, she asked what we were reading in class.

"The Tidewater House," I said, and groaned before I could stop myself.

Her eyebrows went up. "You don't like it?"

I should have stopped there. I did not. I had been stuck with The Tidewater House since September, and I had a great many feelings about it. I told her that the first fifty pages were just a woman staring at the sea. I told her that the main character, Edith, was so annoying that I wanted to climb into the book and shake her. I told her that the ending made no sense at all, because why would Edith burn the letters after spending three hundred pages trying to find them?

She listened to all of this very carefully. Every so often she nodded, or asked a question - "What would you have done instead?" or "Did anything in it work for you?" - and she seemed genuinely interested in my answers, which I put down to her being the kind of old lady who enjoys talking to young people on trains.

"The storm chapter," I admitted eventually. "That was good. When Edith's out on the rocks and she can't see the lighthouse any more. I actually read that one twice."

She smiled at that, a slow, pleased smile, and looked out of the window for a while.

It was only when we pulled into her station that I found out. She stood up, and I hauled her suitcase out of the luggage rack by the doors, and as I lifted it clear, the zip burst open. Books slid out across the floor of the carriage: twenty or thirty copies of the same book. The same cover. The same grey sea. The same lighthouse. The Tidewater House, by Hester Quayle.

On the back of every single one was a photograph of the woman in the purple raincoat.

I have never wanted the ground to swallow me so badly. I stood there, holding a copy of the book I had spent forty minutes insulting, while its author knelt on the floor of the carriage and calmly stacked the rest.

"I'm so sorry," I managed. "I didn't - I wouldn't have -"

"Nonsense," she said briskly. "That was the most useful conversation I've had in years. Do you know how rarely anyone tells me the truth?" She took the copy, pulled out a pen and wrote something on the title page. Then she handed it back, picked up her suitcase and stepped down onto the platform as the doors began to beep.

I did not open it until the train was moving. In sloping blue ink, she had written: "To my sternest critic. Edith burned the letters because she no longer needed them. Read it again. H.Q."

I did read it again. It took me two weeks, and I will not pretend that it suddenly became my favourite book. But knowing that a real person had written it - a person who had listened to a stranger tear it apart and then said thank you - changed the way I read it. Edith still annoyed me. But I think, finally, I understood her.

Last month, I lent my signed copy to a friend. I warned her that the first fifty pages are just a woman staring at the sea.

Then I told her to keep going.

Explanation

This reaches Level 5 on AO5 because the famous person is revealed through a cleverly structured conversation: the reader suspects the truth before the narrator does, the bursting suitcase delivers a comic and well-timed reveal, and the inscription turns embarrassment into a thoughtful ending. On AO6, the extensive dialogue is punctuated and laid out accurately, including interrupted speech, and short sentences are used for the moment of realisation. Weaker answers spend too long on the build-up or describe the celebrity's career instead of the meeting. It is longer than the 450-600 words Eduqas suggests: a tightly controlled answer of about 600 words can reach the same level.

Mark scheme
  1. 24 marks

    Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation).
    Level 5 (20-24 marks): the writing is fully coherent and controlled (plot and characterisation are developed with detail, originality and imagination); the writing is clearly and imaginatively organised (narrative is sophisticated and fully engages the reader's interest); structure and grammatical features are used ambitiously to give the writing cohesion and coherence; communication is ambitious and consistently conveys precise meaning
    Level 4 (15-19 marks): the writing is clearly controlled and coherent (plot and characterisation show convincing detail and some originality and imagination); the writing is clearly organised (narrative is purposefully shaped and developed); structure and grammatical features are used accurately to support cohesion and coherence; communication shows some ambition and conveys precise meaning
    Level 3 (10-14 marks): the writing is mostly controlled and coherent (plot and characterisation show some detail and development); the writing is organised (narrative has shape and direction); structure and grammatical features are used with some accuracy to convey meaning; communication is clear but limited in ambition
    Level 2 (5-9 marks): there is some control and coherence (some control of plot and characterisation); there is some organisation (narrative is beginning to have some shape and development); structure and grammatical features are used to convey meaning; communication is limited but clear
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): there is basic control and coherence (a basic sense of plot and characterisation); there is basic organisation (paragraphs may be used to show obvious divisions); there is some use of structure and grammatical features to convey meaning; communication is limited but some meaning is conveyed
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid approaches): the task invites a first-person recount, real or imagined, of a meeting with a well-known person: a sports star, musician, actor, author, television presenter, online creator or local celebrity, met at a planned event (a signing, a match, a stage door, a charity day) or by chance (on a train, in a shop, at a service station, on holiday). Because a real meeting is fleeting, the best answers build anticipation or surprise, slow the encounter down, and let something unexpected happen: the writer fails to recognise them, says the wrong thing, sees a different side of them, or finds that the meeting matters for an unexpected reason. Answers may be comic, awkward, touching or disillusioning. The famous person may be real or invented; either is acceptable, and an invented celebrity is not a weakness. A strong ending reflects on fame, on the gap between the public figure and the real person, or on what the writer learned. Eduqas's guidance for narrative writing: good answers may be characterised by a clear and coherent perspective (first or third person); content is relevant; content is sustained and coherent and possibly imaginative; a clear sense of direction and structure; appropriate and well-selected details give substance to the narrative; close observation of the behaviour and emotions of characters; convincing use of dialogue to develop plot and characterisation; consistent awareness of the reader. Level 5 (20-24) for this task: the famous person is presented as an individual through precise observation and dialogue, not through a list of their achievements; the encounter has a clear dramatic shape with a turning point or reveal; the writer's feelings are conveyed with honesty and humour or subtlety; the ending is satisfying and gives the meeting meaning. Less successful responses spend most of the answer queueing or describing the person's career, rely on screaming fans and cliches, or end the moment the celebrity leaves. Eduqas's specification: this response should be a narrative / recount; candidates who write purely descriptively, or use a form other than that specified, such as poetry or drama, will not be able to access the full mark range.

  2. 16 marks

    Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
    Level 5 (14-16 marks): there is appropriate and effective variation of sentence structures; virtually all sentence construction is controlled and accurate; a range of punctuation is used confidently and accurately; virtually all spelling, including that of complex irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is totally secure; a wide range of appropriate, ambitious vocabulary is used to create effect or convey precise meaning
    Level 4 (11-13 marks): sentence structure is varied to achieve particular effects; control of sentence construction is secure; a range of punctuation is used accurately; spelling, including that of irregular words, is secure; control of tense and agreement is secure; vocabulary is ambitious and used with precision
    Level 3 (7-10 marks): there is variety in sentence structure; control of sentence construction is mostly secure; a range of punctuation is used, mostly accurately; most spelling, including that of irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is mostly secure; vocabulary is beginning to develop and is used with some precision
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): some variety of sentence structure; there is some control of sentence construction; some control of a range of punctuation; the spelling is usually accurate; control of tense and agreement is generally secure; there is some range of vocabulary
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): limited range of sentence structure; control of sentence construction is limited; there is some attempt to use punctuation; some spelling is accurate; control of tense and agreement is limited; limited range of vocabulary
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Eduqas's guidance: expression is clear, fluent and controlled (the best answers will show ambition and sophistication in expression as well as a high degree of accuracy); there are few, if any, errors (no more than a sprinkling of mistakes); tenses are consistent; vocabulary is used precisely and appropriately to convey meaning; punctuation is used accurately and appropriately (and unobtrusively). Look for: dialogue that carries much of the story, laid out and punctuated accurately, including interrupted speech (dashes) and speech within narrative; titles of books, films or songs given capital letters consistently; a secure past tense, with past perfect for earlier events; sentence variety for comic or dramatic effect, including a short sentence for the reveal; precise vocabulary for manner and reaction, spelt correctly (recognise, embarrassed, mortified, signature, conscious, genuinely). A response with nothing worthy of credit scores 0 on both points.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.