Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/8

20th-century prose: evaluating a view (Q5)

Practise 30 exam-style questions on 20th-century prose: evaluating a view (Q5) for Eduqas GCSE English Language (Component 1). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 30 questions
  • 10 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

10 marks

Read carefully the passage below. Then answer the question that follows.

Kipps
by H. G. Wells (1905)

This passage is from a novel. Kipps, who left home at the age of fourteen, is an apprentice at Mr Shalford's drapery shop in Folkestone, where he lives and works with the other shop assistants, including Carshot, Buggins and Minton.

[1] On Sundays he was obliged to go to church once, and commonly he went twice, for there was nothing else to do. He sat in the free seats at the back; he was too shy to sing, and not always clever enough to keep his place in the prayer-book, and he rarely listened to the sermon. But he had developed a sort of idea that going to church had a tendency to alleviate life. His aunt wanted to have him confirmed, but he evaded this ceremony for some years.

[2] In the intervals between services he walked about Folkestone with an air of looking for something. Folkestone was not so interesting on Sundays as on week-days, because the shops were shut; but on the other hand there was a sort of confusing brilliance along the front of the Leas in the afternoon. Sometimes the apprentice next above him would condescend to go with him; but when the apprentice next but one above him condescended to go with the apprentice next above him, then Kipps, being habited as yet in ready-made clothes without tails, and unsuitable therefore to appear in such company, went alone.

[3] Sometimes he would strike out into the country--still as if looking for something he missed--but the rope of meal-times haled him home again; and sometimes he would invest the major portion of the weekly allowance of a shilling that old Booch handed out to him, in a sacred concert on the pier. He would sometimes walk up and down the Leas between twenty and thirty times after supper, desiring much the courage to speak to some other person in the multitude similarly employed. Almost invariably he ended his Sunday footsore.

[4] He never read a book; there were none for him to read, and besides, in spite of Mr. Woodrow's guidance through a cheap and cheaply annotated edition of the Tempest (English Literature) he had no taste that way; he never read any newspapers, except occasionally Tit-Bits or a ha'penny "comic." His chief intellectual stimulus was an occasional argey-bargey that sprang up between Carshot and Buggins at dinner. Kipps listened as if to unparalleled wisdom and wit, and treasured all the gems of repartee in his heart against the time when he, too, should be a Buggins and have the chance and courage for speech.

[5] At times there came breaks in this routine--sale times, darkened by extra toil and work past midnight, but brightened by a sprat supper and some shillings in the way of 'premiums.' And every year--not now and then, but every year--Mr. Shalford, with parenthetic admiration of his own generosity and glancing comparisons with the austerer days when he was apprenticed, conceded Kipps no less than ten days' holiday--ten whole days every year! Many a poor soul at Portland might well envy the fortunate Kipps. Insatiable heart of man! but how those days were grudged and counted as they snatched themselves away from him one after another!

[6] Once a year came stock-taking, and at intervals gusts of "marking off" goods newly arrived. Then the splendours of Mr. Shalford's being shone with oppressive brilliancy. "System!" he would say, "system. Come! 'ussel!" and issue sharp, confusing, contradictory orders very quickly. Carshot trotted about, confused, perspiring, his big nose up in the air, his little eye on Mr. Shalford, his forehead crinkled, his lips always going to the formula "Oh, my heart and lungs!" The smart junior and the second apprentice vied with one another in obsequious alacrity. The smart junior aspired to Carshot's position, and that made him almost violently subservient to Shalford. They all snapped at Kipps. Kipps held the blotting-pad and the safety inkpot and a box of tickets, and ran and fetched things. If he put the ink down before he went to fetch things Mr. Shalford usually knocked it over, and if he took it away Mr. Shalford wanted it before he returned. "You make my tooth ache, Kipps," Mr. Shalford would say. "You gimme n'ralgia. You got no more System in you than a bad potato." And at the times when Kipps carried off the inkpot Mr. Shalford would become purple in the face and jab round with his dry pen at imaginary inkpots and swear, and Carshot would stand and vociferate, and the smart junior would run to the corner of the department and vociferate, and the second apprentice would pursue Kipps, vociferating, "Look Alive, Kipps! Look Alive! Ink, Man! Ink!"

[7] A vague self-disgust, that shaped itself as an intense hate of Shalford and all his fellow-creatures, filled the soul of Kipps during these periods of storm and stress. He felt that the whole business was unjust and idiotic, but the why and the wherefore was too much for his unfortunate brain. His mind was a welter. One desire, the desire to dodge some at least of a pelting storm of disagreeable comment, guided him through a fumbling performance of his duties. His disgust was infinite! It was not decreased by the inflamed ankles and sore feet that form a normal incident in the business of making an English draper; and the senior apprentice, Minton, a gaunt, sullen-faced youngster with close-cropped, wiry, black hair, a loose, ugly mouth, and a moustache like a smudge of ink, directed his attention to deeper aspects of the question and sealed his misery.

[8] "When you get too old to work they chuck you away," said Minton. "Lor! you find old drapers everywhere--tramps, beggars, dock labourers, 'bus conductors--Quod. Anywhere but in a crib."

[9] "Don't they get shops of their own?"

[10] "Lord! 'Ow are they to get shops of their own? They 'aven't any capital! How's a draper's shopman to save up five hundred pounds even? I tell you it can't be done. You got to stick to cribs until it's over. I tell you we're in a blessed drainpipe, and we've got to crawl along it till we die."

[11] The idea that fermented perpetually in the mind of Minton was to "hit the little beggar slap in the eye"--the little beggar being Mr. Shalford--"and see how his blessed System met that."

[12] The threat filled Kipps with splendid anticipations whenever Shalford went marking off in Minton's department. He would look at Minton and look at Shalford, and decide where he would best like Shalford hit.... But for reasons known to himself Shalford never pished and tushed with Minton, as he did at the harmless Carshot, and this interesting experiment upon the System was never attempted.

Glossary: draper - a shopkeeper who sells cloth and clothing; Portland - a prison in Dorset; Quod - slang for prison; crib - slang for a job; vociferate - to shout loudly; Tit-Bits - a popular weekly magazine of the time; argey-bargey - (slang) a noisy argument; habited - dressed; 'ussel - Mr Shalford's way of saying 'hustle': hurry up; haled - pulled, dragged; repartee - quick, witty replies; alacrity - eager speed; subservient - too ready to obey; welter - a confused mess; pished and tushed - said 'pish!' and 'tush!', snapped impatiently; obsequious - too eager to please; n'ralgia - Mr Shalford's way of saying 'neuralgia', a sharp pain in the nerves; the Leas - the clifftop promenade at Folkestone; sprat - a small, cheap fish

To answer this question, read paragraphs 8 to 12 and consider the passage as a whole.

'Although the passage is often funny, the writer's real aim is to make the reader angry about the way shop workers like Kipps are treated.'

To what extent do you agree with this view?

You should write about:
- your thoughts and feelings about how Kipps and the other shop workers are presented in paragraphs 8 to 12 and in the passage as a whole
- how the writer has created these thoughts and feelings

You must refer to the text to support your answer.

[10]

Model answer

I agree, though I would put it slightly differently: the comedy is not a distraction from the writer's anger but the way he expresses it. This is satire, and the laughter makes the injustice sharper.

Paragraphs 8 to 12 contain the bleakest lines in the passage. Minton's 'When you get too old to work they chuck you away' uses the casual verb 'chuck', as if workers were rubbish, and his list of where old drapers end up finishes with 'Quod', prison. His rhetorical question, 'How's a draper's shopman to save up five hundred pounds even?', and the flat 'I tell you it can't be done' show that there is no escape. The metaphor 'we're in a blessed drainpipe, and we've got to crawl along it till we die' is the most powerful image in the passage: dark, narrow, degrading and lifelong. Kipps's innocent question, 'Don't they get shops of their own?', makes the reality sadder, because we see how little he understands his own future.

The rest of the passage supports this reading. Kipps's Sundays are empty, his allowance is a shilling, and his holiday of 'ten whole days every year!' is set beside the lives of prisoners at Portland. The narrator calmly calls 'inflamed ankles and sore feet' 'a normal incident in the business of making an English draper', and this deadpan irony provokes indignation precisely because it pretends that suffering is normal.

Of course, the passage is very funny. Mr Shalford's 'bad potato' insult and the chain of shouting turn the shop into a farce, and Minton's fantasy of hitting 'the little beggar slap in the eye' is comic. The ending is an anticlimax: Kipps enjoys 'splendid anticipations', but 'this interesting experiment upon the System was never attempted'. The mock-scientific language makes us smile.

Yet that anticlimax is also the point. Minton's rebellion is only talk, and Kipps can only daydream about where 'he would best like Shalford hit'. The workers are powerless, and the comedy exposes that powerlessness. The humour makes Shalford ridiculous, but it never makes his treatment of the apprentices acceptable; instead it shows how absurd and unjust his 'System' is.

So the writer's aim is serious. We laugh throughout, but the laughter is uncomfortable, and the image that stays with us is not the bad potato but the drainpipe.

Explanation

Top-band answers take a clear stance and support it from the whole passage, weighing Minton's drainpipe and the ironic 'normal incident' of sore feet against the comedy of Shalford and the anticlimax of the experiment that 'was never attempted'; the most perceptive see that the humour itself can carry the criticism. Common errors are retelling, writing only about Kipps's feelings, and ignoring paragraphs 8 to 12.

Mark scheme
  1. 10 marks

    Levels of response (10 marks). AO4: evaluation.
    Level 5 (9-10 marks): Give 9-10 marks to those who give a persuasive evaluation of the text and its effects, supported by convincing, well selected examples and purposeful textual references. These responses will show engagement and involvement, where candidates take an overview to make accurate and perceptive comments on the text as a whole. They will also explore how the writer has created thoughts and feelings with insight.
    Level 4 (7-8 marks): Give 7-8 marks to those who give a critical evaluation of the text and its effects, supported by well-selected textual references. These responses will show critical awareness and clear engagement with the text. They will also explore how the writer has created thoughts and feelings.
    Level 3 (5-6 marks): Give 5-6 marks to those who give an evaluation of the text and its effects, supported by appropriate textual references. These responses will show some critical awareness of the text as a whole and how the writer has created thoughts and feelings.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): Give 3-4 marks to those who give a personal opinion supported by straightforward textual references. These responses will show limited interaction with the text as a whole and/or how the writer has created thoughts and feelings.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): Give 1-2 marks to those who express a simple personal opinion with linked, basic textual reference.
    0 marks: Give 0 marks for responses where there is nothing worthy of credit.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; the question must be marked in levels of response - look for and reward valid alternatives). Candidates may agree, disagree or partly agree, as long as the line of argument is clear and supported from the whole passage. Areas for possible evaluation:
    - Minton's bleak view: 'When you get too old to work they chuck you away' ('chuck', as if workers were rubbish); his list of where old drapers end up finishes with 'Quod' (prison)
    - no escape: the rhetorical question 'How's a draper's shopman to save up five hundred pounds even?' and 'I tell you it can't be done'
    - the metaphor 'we're in a blessed drainpipe, and we've got to crawl along it till we die'
    - Kipps's innocent question 'Don't they get shops of their own?' makes the reality sadder
    - deadpan irony that invites indignation: 'inflamed ankles and sore feet that form a normal incident in the business of making an English draper'
    - the ironic holiday: 'ten whole days every year!' and the comparison with prisoners at 'Portland'
    - Kipps's empty Sundays, his shilling allowance and his lack of education
    - Shalford's bullying, and Kipps's sense that 'the whole business was unjust and idiotic'
    - against the view: the passage is often very funny - the bad potato, the chain of 'vociferate', Minton's fantasy of hitting 'the little beggar slap in the eye'
    - the anticlimax: 'this interesting experiment upon the System was never attempted' (mock-scientific language)
    - Kipps's 'splendid anticipations' are comic, and Shalford 'never pished and tushed with Minton'
    - the narrator's affectionate irony may produce pity or amusement rather than anger
    - Minton is described unattractively ('gaunt, sullen-faced', 'a moustache like a smudge of ink'), so his bitter view could be seen as exaggerated
    - a perceptive reading: the comedy is satire - the humour exposes the injustice, so laughter and anger work together
    The key to this question is to sustain a coherent stance.

Question 2

10 marks

Read carefully the passage below. Then answer the question that follows.

Jeremy
by Hugh Walpole (1919)

This passage is from a novel set in Polchester, an imaginary cathedral town in the south-west of England, in the 1890s. Heavy snow has kept eight-year-old Jeremy Cole and his sisters, Mary and Helen, indoors in the nursery for two days, and Mary has started to read aloud to him. The children's nurse, Mrs Preston, is nicknamed 'the Jampot'.

[1] He had been staring down into the garden with a gaze half abstracted, half speculative, listening with one ear to Mary, with the other to the stir of the fire, the heavy beat of the clock and the rustlings of Martha the canary.

[2] He watched the snowy expanse of garden, the black gate, the road beyond. A vast wave of pale grey light, the herald of approaching dusk, swept the horizon, the snowy roofs, the streets, and Jeremy felt some contact with the strange air, the mysterious omens that the first snows of the winter spread about the land. He watched as though he were waiting for something to happen.

[3] The creature came up very slowly over the crest of Orange Street. No one else was in sight, no cart, no horse, no weather-beaten wayfarer. At first the dog was only a little black smudge against the snow; then, as he arrived at the Coles' garden-gate, Jeremy could see him very distinctly. He was, it appeared, quite alone; he had been, it was evident, badly beaten by the storm. Intended by nature to be a rough and hairy dog, he now appeared before God and men a shivering battered creature, dripping and wind-tossed, bedraggled and bewildered. And yet, even in that first distant glimpse, Jeremy discerned a fine independence. He was a short stumpy dog, in no way designed for dignified attitudes and patronising superiority; nevertheless, as he now wandered slowly up the street, his nose was in the air and he said to the whole world: "The storm may have done its best to defeat me--it has failed. I am as I was. I ask charity of no man. I know what is due to me."

[4] It was this that attracted Jeremy; he had himself felt thus after a slippering from his father, or idiotic punishments from the Jampot, and the uninvited consolations of Mary or Helen upon such occasions had been resented with so fierce a bitterness that his reputation for sulkiness had been soundly established with all his circle.

[5] Mary was reading...! "'an old Sheep, sitting in an arm-chair, knitting, and every now and then leaving off to look at her through a great pair of spec-t-a-c-les spectacles!'"

[6] He touched her arm and whispered:

[7] "I say, Mary, stop a minute--look at that dog down there."

[8] They both stared down into the garden. The dog had stopped at the gate; it sniffed at the bars, sniffed at the wall beyond, then very slowly but with real dignity continued its way up the road.

[9] "Poor thing," said Jeremy. "It IS in a mess." Then to their astonishment the dog turned back and, sauntering down the road again as though it had nothing all day to do but to wander about, and as though it were not wet, shivering and hungry, it once more smelt the gate.

[10] "Oh," said Mary and Jeremy together.

[11] "It's like Mother," said Jeremy, "when she's going to see someone and isn't sure whether it's the right house."

[12] Then, most marvellous of unexpected climaxes, the dog suddenly began to squeeze itself between the bottom bar of the gate and the ground. The interval was fortunately a large one; a moment later the animal was in the Coles' garden.

[13] The motives that led Jeremy to behave as he did are uncertain. It may have been something to do with the general boredom of the afternoon, it may have been that he felt pity for the bedraggled aspect of the animal--most probable reason of all, was that devil-may-care independence flung up from the road, as it were, expressly at himself.

[14] The dog obviously did not feel any great respect for the Cole household. He wandered about the garden, sniffing and smelling exactly as though the whole place belonged to him, and a ridiculous stump of tail, unsubdued by the weather, gave him the ludicrous dignity of a Malvolio.

[15] "I'm going down," whispered Jeremy, flinging a cautious glance at Helen who was absorbed in her sewing.

[16] Mary's eyes grew wide with horror and admiration. "You're not going out," she whispered. "In the snow. Oh, Jeremy. They WILL be angry."

[17] "I don't care," whispered Jeremy back again. "They can be."

[18] Indeed, before Mary's frightened whisper he had not intended to do more than creep down into the pantry and watch the dog at close range; now it was as though Mary had challenged him. He knew that it was the most wicked thing that he could do--to go out into the snow without a coat and in his slippers. He might even, according to Aunt Amy, die of it, but as death at present meant no more to him than a position of importance and a quantity of red-currant jelly and chicken, THAT prospect did not deter him. He left the room so quietly that Helen did not even lift her eyes.

[19] Then upon the landing he waited and listened. The house had all the lighted trembling dusk of the snowy afternoon; there was no sound save the ticking of the clocks. He might come upon the Jampot at any moment, but this was just the hour when she liked to drink her cup of tea in the kitchen; he knew from deep and constant study every movement of her day. Fortune favoured him. He reached without trouble the little dark corkscrew servants' staircase. Down this he crept, and found himself beside the little gardener's door. Although here there was only snow-lit dusk, he felt for the handle of the lock, found it, turned it, and was, at once, over the steps, into the garden.

[20] Here, with a vengeance, he felt the full romance and danger of his enterprise. It was horribly cold; he had been in the nursery for two whole days, wrapped up and warm, and now the snowy world seemed to leap up at him and drag him down as though into an icy well. Mysterious shadows hovered over the garden; the fountain pointed darkly against the sky, and he could feel from the feathery touches upon his face that the snow had begun to fall again.

Glossary: abstracted - lost in thought, not paying attention; smudge - a dirty-looking mark; bedraggled - wet, dirty and untidy; slippering - a beating with a slipper, once a common punishment for children; Malvolio - a proud, self-important character in Shakespeare's play Twelfth Night; corkscrew staircase - a narrow spiral staircase

To answer this question, read paragraphs 19 and 20 and consider the passage as a whole.

'The writer presents Jeremy's adventure as a joke: the reader is meant to laugh at him, not to worry about him.'

To what extent do you agree with this view?

You should write about:
- your thoughts and feelings about how Jeremy and his adventure are presented in paragraphs 19 and 20 and in the passage as a whole
- how the writer has created these thoughts and feelings

You must refer to the text to support your answer.

[10]

Model answer

I partly agree. The writer certainly invites us to laugh, but the humour is affectionate, and by the end the adventure becomes genuinely exciting and even frightening, so we do worry about Jeremy.

Much of the passage is comic. The narrator describes small events in grand, mock-heroic language: the dog squeezing under the gate is the 'most marvellous of unexpected climaxes', and its stumpy tail gives it 'the ludicrous dignity of a Malvolio'. Jeremy's seriousness is gently mocked too. His 'reputation for sulkiness' is 'soundly established with all his circle', and his idea of death as 'a position of importance and a quantity of red-currant jelly and chicken' is funny because he so obviously cannot imagine real danger. Even in paragraph 19 the language is playful: he knows the Jampot's habits 'from deep and constant study', as if he were a spy, and 'Fortune favoured him' sounds like a line from a heroic tale. So the view is right that the writer often makes us smile at him.

However, I do not think we are meant only to laugh. Paragraph 19 builds real suspense. He 'waited and listened', and the silence - 'no sound save the ticking of the clocks' - makes every movement feel risky, while 'He might come upon the Jampot at any moment' keeps the threat of discovery alive. The list of actions, 'felt for the handle of the lock, found it, turned it, and was, at once, over the steps, into the garden', speeds up the pace so that we share his excitement.

Paragraph 20 then turns more serious. 'It was horribly cold' is blunt, and the contrast with being 'wrapped up and warm' for 'two whole days' makes the shock physical. The personification of the snowy world, which 'seemed to leap up at him and drag him down as though into an icy well', makes the garden hostile, even dangerous, and the 'Mysterious shadows' and the fountain pointing 'darkly' create an eerie atmosphere. Since we know he is out 'without a coat and in his slippers', the reader does feel concern.

We also take Jeremy seriously because the writer gives him real feelings: pity for the 'Poor thing', and the sense that the dog's independence was 'flung up from the road... expressly at himself'. Overall, the writer laughs with Jeremy rather than at him. Comedy and danger work together, so the adventure feels both funny and important, just as it would to a child.

Explanation

The best answers sustain a coherent argument across the whole passage, for example that the humour is affectionate but the final paragraphs create real suspense and danger, and they explain how the writer achieves both effects (mock-heroic narration, short tense actions, threatening imagery). A common weakness is to agree that it is funny without testing the view against paragraphs 19 and 20.

Mark scheme
  1. 10 marks

    Levels of response (10 marks). AO4: evaluation.
    Level 5 (9-10 marks): Give 9-10 marks to those who give a persuasive evaluation of the text and its effects, supported by convincing, well selected examples and purposeful textual references. These responses will show engagement and involvement, where candidates take an overview to make accurate and perceptive comments on the text as a whole. They will also explore how the writer has created thoughts and feelings with insight.
    Level 4 (7-8 marks): Give 7-8 marks to those who give a critical evaluation of the text and its effects, supported by well-selected textual references. These responses will show critical awareness and clear engagement with the text. They will also explore how the writer has created thoughts and feelings.
    Level 3 (5-6 marks): Give 5-6 marks to those who give an evaluation of the text and its effects, supported by appropriate textual references. These responses will show some critical awareness of the text as a whole and how the writer has created thoughts and feelings.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): Give 3-4 marks to those who give a personal opinion supported by straightforward textual references. These responses will show limited interaction with the text as a whole and/or how the writer has created thoughts and feelings.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): Give 1-2 marks to those who express a simple personal opinion with linked, basic textual reference.
    0 marks: Give 0 marks for responses where there is nothing worthy of credit.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; the question must be marked in levels of response - look for and reward valid alternatives). Areas for possible evaluation:
    - the narrator often uses grand, mock-heroic language for small events ('most marvellous of unexpected climaxes'; 'the ludicrous dignity of a Malvolio'; the dog's imagined speech)
    - Jeremy's own seriousness is gently mocked ('his reputation for sulkiness had been soundly established with all his circle')
    - the comic simile 'It's like Mother...' shows his humour
    - his childish idea of death ('a position of importance and a quantity of red-currant jelly and chicken') shows he cannot imagine real danger
    - he plans like a spy ('from deep and constant study every movement of her day'); 'Fortune favoured him' sounds like a heroic tale
    - 'with a vengeance, he felt the full romance and danger of his enterprise' - grand words for a trip into his own garden
    - but paragraph 19 builds real suspense ('he waited and listened'; 'no sound save the ticking of the clocks'; 'He might come upon the Jampot at any moment')
    - the list of actions ('felt for the handle of the lock, found it, turned it') speeds up the pace and shares his excitement
    - paragraph 20 turns serious: 'It was horribly cold'; the contrast with being 'wrapped up and warm' for 'two whole days'
    - the snowy world 'seemed to leap up at him and drag him down as though into an icy well' - personification that makes the garden hostile
    - 'Mysterious shadows hovered'; 'the fountain pointed darkly'; 'the snow had begun to fall again' - an eerie, uneasy atmosphere
    - he is out 'without a coat and in his slippers' - a real risk for a child
    - Jeremy has real feelings that we take seriously: pity ('Poor thing'), pride, resentment of punishment ('a slippering from his father'), boredom
    - overview: the writer laughs with Jeremy rather than at him; comedy and danger work together, and the passage ends with the adventure only just beginning
    The key to this question is to sustain a coherent stance.

Question 3

10 marks

Read carefully the passage below. Then answer the question that follows.

Wax
by Ethel Lina White (1935)

This passage is from the opening of a mystery novel. In the middle of the night, the porter of the Riverpool Waxwork Gallery has woken his wife, Mrs Ames, by saying that he may have left a candle burning in the gallery.

[1] But Mrs. Ames had surged out of bed and was slipping into her shoes. Having achieved his object, her husband drew the blanket over his head. Salving his conscience by repeating, "I doubted it," he went to sleep again.

[2] With her tweed coat buttoned over her nightdress, and her hat, adorned with an eye veil, perched on top of her curlers, Mrs. Ames went out into the night. She was not nervous of the darkness, while the Gallery was only the length of a short street away.

[3] Directly she turned the key in the great lock and pushed open the massive mahogany doors, she felt that she was really at home. She had brought her pocket-torch, for she knew that if she switched on the light, a policeman might notice the illumination and feel it his duty to investigate. And, as she was one of those free and fearless souls who strew the grass of public parks with chocolate paper and cigarette stumps, she had an instinctive distrust of the law.

[4] She entered the Gallery, and then stood on the threshold--aware of a change. This was not the familiar place she knew so well.

[5] It seemed to be full of people. Seen in the light from the street lamp, which streamed in through the high window, their faces were those of men and women of character and intelligence. They stood in groups as though in conversation, or sat apart in solitary reverie.

[6] But they neither spoke nor moved.

[7] When she had seen them last, a few hours ago, under the dim electric globes, they had been a collection of ordinary waxworks, representing conventional historical personages and Victorian celebrities. Only a few were in really good condition, while some were ancient, with blurred features and threadbare clothes.

[8] But now, they were all restored to health and electric with life. Napoleon frowned as he planned a new campaign. Charles II. mistook her for an orange-girl and ogled her. Henry VIII. shook with silent laughter.

[9] Mrs. Ames felt absurdly abashed by the transformation. She knew she had only to snap on the light to shatter the illusion. Restrained by the memory of the policeman, she did her best to put the figures back in their proper places.

[10] "Hallo, dearies," she called. "Mother's popped in to see you."

[11] Her voice echoed queerly under the domed mahogany roof. She had a vague impression that the Waxworks resented her liberty, as she hurried towards the Hall of Horrors.

[12] A crack of light which outlined its doors told her that her husband had been too optimistic about his memory. This smaller Gallery had not been wired, for it held no lurid attractions. She rushed inside, to see a guttering candle stuck upon the floor.

[13] Although no damage had been done, her indignation swept away imagination. But after she had blown out the flame, she became dimly afraid of her surroundings.

[14] There was no special reason for her to feel nervous. The Hall of Horrors housed only a small number of selected murderers, whom, normally, she despised. These figures were not spectacular, like her cherished Royalties. They wore dull coats and trousers, and could easily be mistaken for nonentities such as Gladstone and Tennyson.

[15] But, as she threw her torch over them, a pinprick of light gleamed in each glassy eye, imparting a fiction of life. They seemed to be looking at her with intent and furtive speculation, as though she were the object of a private and peculiarly personal inventory.

[16] Suddenly she remembered that she was among a company of--poisoners.

[17] Although she was furious with herself for her weakness, her nerve crashed. It was in vain that she reminded herself that these were, in reality, her very own Waxworks. She treated them as her children. It was true that they were a neglected family, for she was an amiable sloven; but, occasionally, she brushed their clothes and hair, or cleaned their faces with a lick of spit.

[18] Now, however, as she hurried down the Gallery, she felt that they had grown alien and aloof. They seemed to regard her with unfriendly eyes, as though she had interrupted some secret and exciting mystery.

[19] They resented her presence. At this hour, the gallery belonged to Them.

[20] Mrs. Ames lost no time in taking their hint. She shuffled through the door, locked it behind her, and ran down the street in flapping shoes. Less than five minutes later, she woke up her husband, to relate her experience.

[21] "I was never so scared in my life. They weren't like the Waxworks I knew. All the time I was there, they were watching me, just as if it was their place, and I'd no right there...Go on, laugh. You've been safe and warm in bed, after trying to burn the gallery down...But you listen to me, Ames. I tell you, those figures were up to some business of their own. And I felt in my bones that it was no good business either."

Glossary: eye veil - a short net veil fixed to the front of a hat; Gladstone and Tennyson - a famous Victorian prime minister and a famous Victorian poet; orange-girl - a girl who sold oranges in theatres in the time of King Charles II; guttering - (of a candle) flickering and about to go out; furtive - secretive, sly; sloven - an untidy, careless person; abashed - embarrassed; reverie - a daydream; ogled - stared at with open admiration; Directly - here, as soon as

To answer this question, read paragraphs 18 to 21 and consider the passage as a whole.

'The writer creates a frightening opening to the novel, even though nothing really happens in it.'

To what extent do you agree with this view?

You should write about:
- your thoughts and feelings about how Mrs Ames's night visit to the Gallery is presented in paragraphs 18 to 21 and in the passage as a whole
- how the writer has created these thoughts and feelings

You must refer to the text to support your answer.

[10]

Model answer

I largely agree that nothing really happens - no waxwork ever moves - but I think that is exactly why the opening is unsettling rather than truly frightening. The writer creates fear through Mrs Ames's imagination and an ominous final speech, while comedy keeps reminding us not to take it too seriously.

In the final paragraphs the sense of threat is strong. The waxworks have 'grown alien and aloof', the alliteration stressing their coldness, and they regard her 'with unfriendly eyes, as though she had interrupted some secret and exciting mystery'. The short sentences 'They resented her presence. At this hour, the gallery belonged to Them.' and the capital letter in 'Them' make the figures sound like a sinister power. Her own words, 'I was never so scared in my life', and especially 'those figures were up to some business of their own', end the passage on a note of menace, and 'I felt in my bones' suggests instinct rather than evidence, which is somehow more disturbing.

Looking at the whole passage, though, it is true that nothing really happens. The only real event is a candle left burning by her careless husband, which she puts out briskly. Everything else is appearance: the room 'seemed' full of people, she has 'a vague impression' that the figures resent her, the torchlight gives only 'a fiction of life', and the writer even tells us that 'they neither spoke nor moved'. The fear is all in her mind.

The comedy also softens the fear. Mrs Ames sets out with her hat 'perched on top of her curlers', greets the figures with 'Mother's popped in to see you' and cleans their faces 'with a lick of spit'. Even her escape in 'flapping shoes' is slightly ridiculous, and 'Go on, laugh' almost invites the reader to join in.

Yet the writer does not let us dismiss her completely. The narrator says she 'lost no time in taking their hint', as if the hostility were real, and the climax, 'a company of--poisoners', is genuinely chilling. As the opening of a mystery novel, the passage succeeds because it plants doubt: we cannot be sure she is only imagining things. So I would call it an eerie, comic opening rather than a frightening one, and the absence of events is its strength, because the tension lies in what might be going on.

Explanation

Strong answers weigh both parts of the view and keep a coherent stance - for example, that the opening is eerie rather than frightening because the fear is all in Mrs Ames's mind. They use purposeful references from paragraphs 18 to 21 and the whole passage, showing how the writer builds menace (the hostile eyes, 'Them', the ominous last line) while comedy and words such as 'seemed' undercut it. Weaker answers simply list the frightening moments.

Mark scheme
  1. 10 marks

    Levels of response (10 marks). AO4: evaluation.
    Level 5 (9-10 marks): Give 9-10 marks to those who give a persuasive evaluation of the text and its effects, supported by convincing, well selected examples and purposeful textual references. These responses will show engagement and involvement, where candidates take an overview to make accurate and perceptive comments on the text as a whole. They will also explore how the writer has created thoughts and feelings with insight.
    Level 4 (7-8 marks): Give 7-8 marks to those who give a critical evaluation of the text and its effects, supported by well-selected textual references. These responses will show critical awareness and clear engagement with the text. They will also explore how the writer has created thoughts and feelings.
    Level 3 (5-6 marks): Give 5-6 marks to those who give an evaluation of the text and its effects, supported by appropriate textual references. These responses will show some critical awareness of the text as a whole and how the writer has created thoughts and feelings.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): Give 3-4 marks to those who give a personal opinion supported by straightforward textual references. These responses will show limited interaction with the text as a whole and/or how the writer has created thoughts and feelings.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): Give 1-2 marks to those who express a simple personal opinion with linked, basic textual reference.
    0 marks: Give 0 marks for responses where there is nothing worthy of credit.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; the question must be marked in levels of response - look for and reward valid alternatives). Areas for possible evaluation: - the waxworks seem hostile: 'alien and aloof' (alliteration), 'unfriendly eyes', 'as though she had interrupted some secret and exciting mystery'; - the short sentences of paragraph 19 ('They resented her presence.') and the capitalised 'Them' make the figures sound like a sinister power; - she flees: 'Mrs. Ames lost no time in taking their hint'; she 'ran down the street in flapping shoes'; - her own words convey fear: 'I was never so scared in my life', 'they were watching me', 'those figures were up to some business of their own', 'I felt in my bones that it was no good business either' - an ominous ending that sets up the mystery; - earlier moments build fear: 'This was not the familiar place she knew so well'; 'But they neither spoke nor moved.'; the glinting eyes; 'a company of--poisoners'; 'her nerve crashed'; - but nothing supernatural actually happens: the figures never move ('they neither spoke nor moved'), and the writer keeps using words of appearance ('seemed', 'as though', 'a vague impression', 'illusion', 'a fiction of life'); - the only real event is a candle left burning by her husband - a danger she deals with briskly; - comedy undercuts the fear: her hat 'perched on top of her curlers', the littering 'free and fearless souls', 'Mother's popped in to see you', Charles II ogling her, 'nonentities such as Gladstone and Tennyson', 'a lick of spit', 'flapping shoes', 'Go on, laugh'; - 'Go on, laugh' invites the reader to laugh too - or to wonder whether she is right; - the narrator half-agrees with her ('lost no time in taking their hint' treats the waxworks' hostility as real); - as the opening of a mystery novel, the passage creates suspense about what may happen later: the fear lies in what might be going on, not in events; - a balanced view: little happens, but the writer makes the reader uneasy through atmosphere, imagination and an ominous last line, while comedy keeps the fear in check. The key to this question is to sustain a coherent stance.

Question 4

10 marks

Read carefully the passage below. Then answer the question that follows.

Rebecca of Sunnybrook Farm
by Kate Douglas Wiggin (1903)

This passage is from a novel set in the state of Maine, USA. Rebecca Randall, a young girl, is being sent away from her family's farm to live with her two aunts in the village of Riverboro. Her mother has put her on the stage coach and asked the driver, Mr Jeremiah Cobb, to keep an eye on her.

[1] The old stage coach was rumbling along the dusty road that runs from Maplewood to Riverboro. The day was as warm as midsummer, though it was only the middle of May, and Mr. Jeremiah Cobb was favoring the horses as much as possible, yet never losing sight of the fact that he carried the mail. The hills were many, and the reins lay loosely in his hands as he lolled back in his seat and extended one foot and leg luxuriously over the dashboard. His brimmed hat of worn felt was well pulled over his eyes, and he revolved a quid of tobacco in his left cheek.

[2] There was one passenger in the coach,--a small dark-haired person in a glossy buff calico dress. She was so slender and so stiffly starched that she slid from space to space on the leather cushions, though she braced herself against the middle seat with her feet and extended her cotton-gloved hands on each side, in order to maintain some sort of balance. Whenever the wheels sank farther than usual into a rut, or jolted suddenly over a stone, she bounded involuntarily into the air, came down again, pushed back her funny little straw hat, and picked up or settled more firmly a small pink sun shade, which seemed to be her chief responsibility,--unless we except a bead purse, into which she looked whenever the condition of the roads would permit, finding great apparent satisfaction in that its precious contents neither disappeared nor grew less. Mr. Cobb guessed nothing of these harassing details of travel, his business being to carry people to their destinations, not, necessarily, to make them comfortable on the way. Indeed he had forgotten the very existence of this one unnoteworthy little passenger.

[...]

[3] Suddenly he heard a small voice above the rattle and rumble of the wheels and the creaking of the harness. At first he thought it was a cricket, a tree toad, or a bird, but having determined the direction from which it came, he turned his head over his shoulder and saw a small shape hanging as far out of the window as safety would allow. A long black braid of hair swung with the motion of the coach; the child held her hat in one hand and with the other made ineffectual attempts to stab the driver with her microscopic sunshade.

[4] "Please let me speak!" she called.

[5] Mr. Cobb drew up the horses obediently.

[6] "Does it cost any more to ride up there with you?" she asked. "It's so slippery and shiny down here, and the stage is so much too big for me, that I rattle round in it till I'm 'most black and blue. And the windows are so small I can only see pieces of things, and I've 'most broken my neck stretching round to find out whether my trunk has fallen off the back. It's my mother's trunk, and she's very choice of it."

[7] Mr. Cobb waited until this flow of conversation, or more properly speaking this flood of criticism, had ceased, and then said jocularly:--

[8] "You can come up if you want to; there ain't no extry charge to sit side o' me." Whereupon he helped her out, "boosted" her up to the front seat, and resumed his own place.

[9] Rebecca sat down carefully, smoothing her dress under her with painstaking precision, and putting her sunshade under its extended folds between the driver and herself. This done she pushed back her hat, pulled up her darned white cotton gloves, and said delightedly:--

[10] "Oh! this is better! This is like traveling! I am a real passenger now, and down there I felt like our setting hen when we shut her up in a coop. I hope we have a long, long ways to go?"

[...]

[11] At this moment the thought gradually permeated Mr. Jeremiah Cobb's slow-moving mind that the bird perched by his side was a bird of very different feather from those to which he was accustomed in his daily drives. He put the whip back in its socket, took his foot from the dashboard, pushed his hat back, blew his quid of tobacco into the road, and having thus cleared his mental decks for action, he took his first good look at the passenger, a look which she met with a grave, childlike stare of friendly curiosity.

[12] The buff calico was faded, but scrupulously clean, and starched within an inch of its life. From the little standing ruffle at the neck the child's slender throat rose very brown and thin, and the head looked small to bear the weight of dark hair that hung in a thick braid to her waist. She wore an odd little vizored cap of white leghorn, which may either have been the latest thing in children's hats, or some bit of ancient finery furbished up for the occasion. It was trimmed with a twist of buff ribbon and a cluster of black and orange porcupine quills, which hung or bristled stiffly over one ear, giving her the quaintest and most unusual appearance. Her face was without color and sharp in outline. As to features, she must have had the usual number, though Mr. Cobb's attention never proceeded so far as nose, forehead, or chin, being caught on the way and held fast by the eyes. Rebecca's eyes were like faith,--"the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen." Under her delicately etched brows they glowed like two stars, their dancing lights half hidden in lustrous darkness. Their glance was eager and full of interest, yet never satisfied; their steadfast gaze was brilliant and mysterious, and had the effect of looking directly through the obvious to something beyond, in the object, in the landscape, in you. They had never been accounted for, Rebecca's eyes. The school teacher and the minister at Temperance had tried and failed; the young artist who came for the summer to sketch the red barn, the ruined mill, and the bridge ended by giving up all these local beauties and devoting herself to the face of a child,--a small, plain face illuminated by a pair of eyes carrying such messages, such suggestions, such hints of sleeping power and insight, that one never tired of looking into their shining depths, nor of fancying that what one saw there was the reflection of one's own thought.

[13] Mr. Cobb made none of these generalizations; his remark to his wife that night was simply to the effect that whenever the child looked at him she knocked him galley-west.

Glossary: stage coach - a horse-drawn coach carrying passengers and mail on a regular route; quid of tobacco - a lump of tobacco for chewing; calico - cheap cotton cloth; jocularly - jokingly; leghorn - fine plaited straw; knocked him galley-west - (American slang) left him completely amazed; setting hen - a hen sitting on her eggs to hatch them; vizored cap - a cap with a peak at the front; favoring, traveling, color, vizored - American spellings of favouring, travelling, colour, visored

To answer this question, read paragraphs 12 and 13 and consider the passage as a whole.

'Until the last two paragraphs, Rebecca seems an ordinary little girl; only at the end does the writer show that she is extraordinary.'

To what extent do you agree with this view?

You should write about:
- your thoughts and feelings about how Rebecca is presented in paragraphs 12 and 13 and in the passage as a whole
- how the writer has created these thoughts and feelings

You must refer to the text to support your answer.

[10]

Model answer

I largely disagree. The final two paragraphs certainly make Rebecca's extraordinary quality explicit, but the writer signals it long before, and even at the end she is still, in many ways, a plain and ordinary child. What the writer shows is not a sudden change but Mr Cobb, and the reader, gradually noticing what was there all along.

There is some truth in the view. At first we see her through Mr Cobb's indifference: he 'had forgotten the very existence of this one unnoteworthy little passenger', and when she calls to him he mistakes her for 'a cricket, a tree toad, or a bird'. The writer makes her seem tiny and easy to overlook.

However, the narrator's tone suggests otherwise. Describing her sun shade as 'her chief responsibility' is affectionately mock-serious, inviting interest in her. In paragraph 5 the driver 'obediently' stops for her, and her speech is anything but ordinary: her hyperbole ('broken my neck') and her simile of the 'setting hen' shut in a coop reveal an unusually vivid imagination. By paragraph 11 Mr Cobb has already realised that she is 'a bird of very different feather', so the turning point comes before the last two paragraphs.

Paragraph 12 also keeps ordinary details in view. Her dress is 'faded', though 'starched within an inch of its life', and her cap may be 'some bit of ancient finery furbished up for the occasion', details which suggest a poor family making an effort. The comic understatement that 'she must have had the usual number' of features, and the phrase 'a small, plain face', show that she is not conventionally beautiful.

What is extraordinary is her eyes. The simile 'like faith', followed by the solemn quoted words 'the substance of things hoped for', gives them an almost spiritual power, and 'they glowed like two stars' makes them luminous. The tricolon 'such messages, such suggestions, such hints of sleeping power' builds to the idea that her greatness is still to come, and the direct address in 'in you' draws the reader under her gaze. The writer proves her effect through other people: the teacher and the minister 'tried and failed', and the artist abandons the local scenery for her face.

Finally, paragraph 13 deflates the lyrical description with Mr Cobb's plain verdict that she 'knocked him galley-west'. The humour confirms that she affects even a slow, ordinary man. Rebecca is extraordinary from the start; the ending simply lets us see it clearly.

Explanation

The best answers take a clear position and hold it, testing the statement against the whole passage: Mr Cobb's early indifference, her lively speech, the turn in paragraph 11, the ordinary details and the extraordinary eyes in paragraph 12, and the humour of paragraph 13. They explain how the writer creates our feelings (the delayed description, the similes, the tricolon, the bathos). Weaker answers simply agree and describe her eyes, or retell the passage.

Mark scheme
  1. 10 marks

    Levels of response (10 marks). AO4: evaluation.
    Level 5 (9-10 marks): Give 9-10 marks to those who give a persuasive evaluation of the text and its effects, supported by convincing, well selected examples and purposeful textual references. These responses will show engagement and involvement, where candidates take an overview to make accurate and perceptive comments on the text as a whole. They will also explore how the writer has created thoughts and feelings with insight.
    Level 4 (7-8 marks): Give 7-8 marks to those who give a critical evaluation of the text and its effects, supported by well-selected textual references. These responses will show critical awareness and clear engagement with the text. They will also explore how the writer has created thoughts and feelings.
    Level 3 (5-6 marks): Give 5-6 marks to those who give an evaluation of the text and its effects, supported by appropriate textual references. These responses will show some critical awareness of the text as a whole and how the writer has created thoughts and feelings.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): Give 3-4 marks to those who give a personal opinion supported by straightforward textual references. These responses will show limited interaction with the text as a whole and/or how the writer has created thoughts and feelings.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): Give 1-2 marks to those who express a simple personal opinion with linked, basic textual reference.
    0 marks: Give 0 marks for responses where there is nothing worthy of credit.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; the question must be marked in levels of response - look for and reward valid alternatives). Areas for possible evaluation:
    - at first she is seen through Mr Cobb's indifference: he 'had forgotten the very existence of this one unnoteworthy little passenger'; he mistakes her voice for 'a cricket, a tree toad, or a bird' (this supports the view);
    - but the narrator's mock-serious tone in paragraph 2 (the sun shade as 'her chief responsibility', the purse's 'precious contents') already makes her a figure of affectionate interest;
    - she gets her way: 'Mr. Cobb drew up the horses obediently';
    - her speech in paragraphs 6 and 10 is vivid and imaginative (hyperbole such as 'broken my neck'; the 'setting hen' simile): not an ordinary child's;
    - Mr Cobb realises that she is 'a bird of very different feather' in paragraph 11, before the final two paragraphs;
    - paragraph 12 keeps ordinary, humble details: the calico is 'faded, but scrupulously clean, and starched within an inch of its life' (hyperbole; care despite poverty); the 'odd little vizored cap' may be 'some bit of ancient finery furbished up for the occasion'; 'Her face was without color and sharp in outline'; 'a small, plain face';
    - comic understatement: 'she must have had the usual number' of features;
    - her eyes are what is extraordinary: the simile 'Rebecca's eyes were like faith' and the solemn quoted words 'the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen' (a quotation from the Bible; candidates need not know the source to comment on the spiritual language); 'they glowed like two stars' (simile); 'their dancing lights half hidden in lustrous darkness'; 'brilliant and mysterious';
    - 'looking directly through the obvious to something beyond, in the object, in the landscape, in you' (a list of three; the direct address 'you' draws the reader in);
    - the writer proves her power through other people: 'They had never been accounted for'; the teacher and the minister 'had tried and failed'; the young artist gave up 'all these local beauties' for 'the face of a child';
    - the tricolon 'such messages, such suggestions, such hints of sleeping power and insight' ('sleeping power' suggests her greatness is still to come);
    - paragraph 13 returns to Mr Cobb's plain speech: 'Mr. Cobb made none of these generalizations'; she 'knocked him galley-west' (bathos and humour that confirm her effect on an ordinary man);
    - the description is delayed until Mr Cobb finally looks at her, so the reader discovers her as he does (some support for the view);
    - a possible stance: largely disagree - the writer hints throughout that she is extraordinary, and in the final paragraphs she is still a plain, poor little girl; or largely agree - only the final description reveals how remarkable she is.
    The key to this question is to sustain a coherent stance.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.