Question 1
10 marksRead carefully the passage below. Then answer the question that follows.
Kipps
by H. G. Wells (1905)
This passage is from a novel. Kipps, who left home at the age of fourteen, is an apprentice at Mr Shalford's drapery shop in Folkestone, where he lives and works with the other shop assistants, including Carshot, Buggins and Minton.
[1] On Sundays he was obliged to go to church once, and commonly he went twice, for there was nothing else to do. He sat in the free seats at the back; he was too shy to sing, and not always clever enough to keep his place in the prayer-book, and he rarely listened to the sermon. But he had developed a sort of idea that going to church had a tendency to alleviate life. His aunt wanted to have him confirmed, but he evaded this ceremony for some years.
[2] In the intervals between services he walked about Folkestone with an air of looking for something. Folkestone was not so interesting on Sundays as on week-days, because the shops were shut; but on the other hand there was a sort of confusing brilliance along the front of the Leas in the afternoon. Sometimes the apprentice next above him would condescend to go with him; but when the apprentice next but one above him condescended to go with the apprentice next above him, then Kipps, being habited as yet in ready-made clothes without tails, and unsuitable therefore to appear in such company, went alone.
[3] Sometimes he would strike out into the country--still as if looking for something he missed--but the rope of meal-times haled him home again; and sometimes he would invest the major portion of the weekly allowance of a shilling that old Booch handed out to him, in a sacred concert on the pier. He would sometimes walk up and down the Leas between twenty and thirty times after supper, desiring much the courage to speak to some other person in the multitude similarly employed. Almost invariably he ended his Sunday footsore.
[4] He never read a book; there were none for him to read, and besides, in spite of Mr. Woodrow's guidance through a cheap and cheaply annotated edition of the Tempest (English Literature) he had no taste that way; he never read any newspapers, except occasionally Tit-Bits or a ha'penny "comic." His chief intellectual stimulus was an occasional argey-bargey that sprang up between Carshot and Buggins at dinner. Kipps listened as if to unparalleled wisdom and wit, and treasured all the gems of repartee in his heart against the time when he, too, should be a Buggins and have the chance and courage for speech.
[5] At times there came breaks in this routine--sale times, darkened by extra toil and work past midnight, but brightened by a sprat supper and some shillings in the way of 'premiums.' And every year--not now and then, but every year--Mr. Shalford, with parenthetic admiration of his own generosity and glancing comparisons with the austerer days when he was apprenticed, conceded Kipps no less than ten days' holiday--ten whole days every year! Many a poor soul at Portland might well envy the fortunate Kipps. Insatiable heart of man! but how those days were grudged and counted as they snatched themselves away from him one after another!
[6] Once a year came stock-taking, and at intervals gusts of "marking off" goods newly arrived. Then the splendours of Mr. Shalford's being shone with oppressive brilliancy. "System!" he would say, "system. Come! 'ussel!" and issue sharp, confusing, contradictory orders very quickly. Carshot trotted about, confused, perspiring, his big nose up in the air, his little eye on Mr. Shalford, his forehead crinkled, his lips always going to the formula "Oh, my heart and lungs!" The smart junior and the second apprentice vied with one another in obsequious alacrity. The smart junior aspired to Carshot's position, and that made him almost violently subservient to Shalford. They all snapped at Kipps. Kipps held the blotting-pad and the safety inkpot and a box of tickets, and ran and fetched things. If he put the ink down before he went to fetch things Mr. Shalford usually knocked it over, and if he took it away Mr. Shalford wanted it before he returned. "You make my tooth ache, Kipps," Mr. Shalford would say. "You gimme n'ralgia. You got no more System in you than a bad potato." And at the times when Kipps carried off the inkpot Mr. Shalford would become purple in the face and jab round with his dry pen at imaginary inkpots and swear, and Carshot would stand and vociferate, and the smart junior would run to the corner of the department and vociferate, and the second apprentice would pursue Kipps, vociferating, "Look Alive, Kipps! Look Alive! Ink, Man! Ink!"
[7] A vague self-disgust, that shaped itself as an intense hate of Shalford and all his fellow-creatures, filled the soul of Kipps during these periods of storm and stress. He felt that the whole business was unjust and idiotic, but the why and the wherefore was too much for his unfortunate brain. His mind was a welter. One desire, the desire to dodge some at least of a pelting storm of disagreeable comment, guided him through a fumbling performance of his duties. His disgust was infinite! It was not decreased by the inflamed ankles and sore feet that form a normal incident in the business of making an English draper; and the senior apprentice, Minton, a gaunt, sullen-faced youngster with close-cropped, wiry, black hair, a loose, ugly mouth, and a moustache like a smudge of ink, directed his attention to deeper aspects of the question and sealed his misery.
[8] "When you get too old to work they chuck you away," said Minton. "Lor! you find old drapers everywhere--tramps, beggars, dock labourers, 'bus conductors--Quod. Anywhere but in a crib."
[9] "Don't they get shops of their own?"
[10] "Lord! 'Ow are they to get shops of their own? They 'aven't any capital! How's a draper's shopman to save up five hundred pounds even? I tell you it can't be done. You got to stick to cribs until it's over. I tell you we're in a blessed drainpipe, and we've got to crawl along it till we die."
[11] The idea that fermented perpetually in the mind of Minton was to "hit the little beggar slap in the eye"--the little beggar being Mr. Shalford--"and see how his blessed System met that."
[12] The threat filled Kipps with splendid anticipations whenever Shalford went marking off in Minton's department. He would look at Minton and look at Shalford, and decide where he would best like Shalford hit.... But for reasons known to himself Shalford never pished and tushed with Minton, as he did at the harmless Carshot, and this interesting experiment upon the System was never attempted.
Glossary: draper - a shopkeeper who sells cloth and clothing; Portland - a prison in Dorset; Quod - slang for prison; crib - slang for a job; vociferate - to shout loudly; Tit-Bits - a popular weekly magazine of the time; argey-bargey - (slang) a noisy argument; habited - dressed; 'ussel - Mr Shalford's way of saying 'hustle': hurry up; haled - pulled, dragged; repartee - quick, witty replies; alacrity - eager speed; subservient - too ready to obey; welter - a confused mess; pished and tushed - said 'pish!' and 'tush!', snapped impatiently; obsequious - too eager to please; n'ralgia - Mr Shalford's way of saying 'neuralgia', a sharp pain in the nerves; the Leas - the clifftop promenade at Folkestone; sprat - a small, cheap fish
To answer this question, read paragraphs 8 to 12 and consider the passage as a whole.
'Although the passage is often funny, the writer's real aim is to make the reader angry about the way shop workers like Kipps are treated.'
To what extent do you agree with this view?
You should write about:
- your thoughts and feelings about how Kipps and the other shop workers are presented in paragraphs 8 to 12 and in the passage as a whole
- how the writer has created these thoughts and feelings
You must refer to the text to support your answer.
[10]
Model answer
I agree, though I would put it slightly differently: the comedy is not a distraction from the writer's anger but the way he expresses it. This is satire, and the laughter makes the injustice sharper.
Paragraphs 8 to 12 contain the bleakest lines in the passage. Minton's 'When you get too old to work they chuck you away' uses the casual verb 'chuck', as if workers were rubbish, and his list of where old drapers end up finishes with 'Quod', prison. His rhetorical question, 'How's a draper's shopman to save up five hundred pounds even?', and the flat 'I tell you it can't be done' show that there is no escape. The metaphor 'we're in a blessed drainpipe, and we've got to crawl along it till we die' is the most powerful image in the passage: dark, narrow, degrading and lifelong. Kipps's innocent question, 'Don't they get shops of their own?', makes the reality sadder, because we see how little he understands his own future.
The rest of the passage supports this reading. Kipps's Sundays are empty, his allowance is a shilling, and his holiday of 'ten whole days every year!' is set beside the lives of prisoners at Portland. The narrator calmly calls 'inflamed ankles and sore feet' 'a normal incident in the business of making an English draper', and this deadpan irony provokes indignation precisely because it pretends that suffering is normal.
Of course, the passage is very funny. Mr Shalford's 'bad potato' insult and the chain of shouting turn the shop into a farce, and Minton's fantasy of hitting 'the little beggar slap in the eye' is comic. The ending is an anticlimax: Kipps enjoys 'splendid anticipations', but 'this interesting experiment upon the System was never attempted'. The mock-scientific language makes us smile.
Yet that anticlimax is also the point. Minton's rebellion is only talk, and Kipps can only daydream about where 'he would best like Shalford hit'. The workers are powerless, and the comedy exposes that powerlessness. The humour makes Shalford ridiculous, but it never makes his treatment of the apprentices acceptable; instead it shows how absurd and unjust his 'System' is.
So the writer's aim is serious. We laugh throughout, but the laughter is uncomfortable, and the image that stays with us is not the bad potato but the drainpipe.
Explanation
Top-band answers take a clear stance and support it from the whole passage, weighing Minton's drainpipe and the ironic 'normal incident' of sore feet against the comedy of Shalford and the anticlimax of the experiment that 'was never attempted'; the most perceptive see that the humour itself can carry the criticism. Common errors are retelling, writing only about Kipps's feelings, and ignoring paragraphs 8 to 12.
Mark scheme
-
10 marks
Levels of response (10 marks). AO4: evaluation.
Level 5 (9-10 marks): Give 9-10 marks to those who give a persuasive evaluation of the text and its effects, supported by convincing, well selected examples and purposeful textual references. These responses will show engagement and involvement, where candidates take an overview to make accurate and perceptive comments on the text as a whole. They will also explore how the writer has created thoughts and feelings with insight.
Level 4 (7-8 marks): Give 7-8 marks to those who give a critical evaluation of the text and its effects, supported by well-selected textual references. These responses will show critical awareness and clear engagement with the text. They will also explore how the writer has created thoughts and feelings.
Level 3 (5-6 marks): Give 5-6 marks to those who give an evaluation of the text and its effects, supported by appropriate textual references. These responses will show some critical awareness of the text as a whole and how the writer has created thoughts and feelings.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): Give 3-4 marks to those who give a personal opinion supported by straightforward textual references. These responses will show limited interaction with the text as a whole and/or how the writer has created thoughts and feelings.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): Give 1-2 marks to those who express a simple personal opinion with linked, basic textual reference.
0 marks: Give 0 marks for responses where there is nothing worthy of credit.Indicative content (not a checklist; the question must be marked in levels of response - look for and reward valid alternatives). Candidates may agree, disagree or partly agree, as long as the line of argument is clear and supported from the whole passage. Areas for possible evaluation:
- Minton's bleak view: 'When you get too old to work they chuck you away' ('chuck', as if workers were rubbish); his list of where old drapers end up finishes with 'Quod' (prison)
- no escape: the rhetorical question 'How's a draper's shopman to save up five hundred pounds even?' and 'I tell you it can't be done'
- the metaphor 'we're in a blessed drainpipe, and we've got to crawl along it till we die'
- Kipps's innocent question 'Don't they get shops of their own?' makes the reality sadder
- deadpan irony that invites indignation: 'inflamed ankles and sore feet that form a normal incident in the business of making an English draper'
- the ironic holiday: 'ten whole days every year!' and the comparison with prisoners at 'Portland'
- Kipps's empty Sundays, his shilling allowance and his lack of education
- Shalford's bullying, and Kipps's sense that 'the whole business was unjust and idiotic'
- against the view: the passage is often very funny - the bad potato, the chain of 'vociferate', Minton's fantasy of hitting 'the little beggar slap in the eye'
- the anticlimax: 'this interesting experiment upon the System was never attempted' (mock-scientific language)
- Kipps's 'splendid anticipations' are comic, and Shalford 'never pished and tushed with Minton'
- the narrator's affectionate irony may produce pity or amusement rather than anger
- Minton is described unattractively ('gaunt, sullen-faced', 'a moustache like a smudge of ink'), so his bitter view could be seen as exaggerated
- a perceptive reading: the comedy is satire - the humour exposes the injustice, so laughter and anger work together
The key to this question is to sustain a coherent stance.