Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/8

Creative prose: stories that begin or end... (Section B)

Practise 30 exam-style questions on Creative prose: stories that begin or end... (Section B) for Eduqas GCSE English Language (Component 1). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 30 questions
  • 40 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

40 marks

In this section you will be assessed for the quality of your creative prose writing skills.

24 marks are awarded for communication and organisation; 16 marks are awarded for vocabulary, sentence structure, spelling and punctuation.

You should aim to write about 450-600 words.

Write a story which begins:

Our form tutor came in, closed the door behind her and asked us all to sit down.

[40]

Model answer

Our form tutor came in, closed the door behind her and asked us all to sit down. We were already sitting down. That was the first sign that something was seriously wrong.

Miss Adebayo did not close doors. In two years, I had never once seen her do it. Her door stood open all day, held back by a rubber doorstop shaped like a wedge of cheese. Now it clicked shut, the cheese lay abandoned on the carpet, and the silence in 10F became thick enough to spread on toast.

She did not sit at her desk. She stood in front of it, hugging a brown folder to her chest.

"I need to talk to you about something important," she said. "And I need you to listen carefully."

Around the room, I watched twenty-eight consciences begin to stir. Jayden, who had superglued the board pens to the whiteboard "by accident" in October, slid so low in his chair that only his eyebrows showed above the desk. Tia, who ran a profitable trade in sweets from her locker, began quietly zipping up her bag. Harvey and Kai, who did everything together, exchanged one of their silent looks and went pale in perfect unison.

As for me, I could feel the absence of my planner like a missing tooth. On Monday, along with everyone else's, it had gone into the pile on Miss Adebayo's desk for her weekly check.

The previous Thursday, I had forgotten my history homework for the third time that term. Mr Grant had written a note in my planner that needed a parent's signature. Mum had been on a late shift, and I had been tired, and the pen had been right there, and Mum's signature - a loopy M followed by a confident wiggle - had looked so easy. It took me four attempts on the back of a maths worksheet. On the fifth, it was perfect. I had been proud of it, which, looking back, was probably the worst part.

What was in the folder? Why had she closed the door? Did forgers go to prison? I was fairly sure they did. I pictured Mum visiting me, shaking her head through a pane of thick glass.

"This isn't easy to say," Miss Adebayo began, and her voice caught.

Jayden made a small noise like a deflating balloon.

"Some of you will have noticed that I've been off a few times this term. For appointments." She took a deep breath, and suddenly her eyes were shining. "The thing is... I'm having a baby. In May. So after Easter I won't be your tutor for a while, and I wanted you to hear it from me first."

For one second, nobody moved. Then 10F exploded. Tia screamed. Harvey and Kai drummed on their desks. Jayden rose from behind his eyebrows and shouted, "Can we call it Jayden?" Even Noah, who had not spoken voluntarily since Year 7, said, "Congratulations, miss," and went red to the tips of his ears.

I laughed with everyone else, mostly from relief. My heart was still pounding, but now it was a happy, ridiculous pounding, the kind you get at the top of a roller coaster when you discover that the safety bar is down after all.

When the bell rang, we surged towards the door, still arguing about names. I had almost made it into the corridor when I heard her voice.

"Not you, Charlie. Just a minute."

I turned round. Miss Adebayo was sitting at her desk now. The brown folder was closed. In her hand, however, was a planner. My planner.

"Your mum," she said mildly, "has lovely handwriting."

"Thanks," I croaked. "I'll tell her."

"Please do." She tapped the page. "She also spells Wednesday exactly the way you do. Without the first d."

Behind me, the door stood wide open again, propped back by its cheerful cheese. I have never felt so trapped by an open door in my life.

Explanation

The response earns Level 5 on AO5 because it stays inside the moment the opening creates: suspense is built through the class's guilty reactions and the narrator's own secret, released by a well-placed anticlimax, then sharpened by a final twist that was prepared for earlier (the planner in the weekly check). The voice is confident and comic, with rhetorical questions and asides. On AO6, the past perfect separates the earlier forgery from the scene, dialogue is accurately punctuated and minor sentences are used deliberately. A common error is to reveal the news in the first paragraph and leave nothing to build towards. It is longer than the 450-600 words Eduqas suggests: a tightly controlled answer of about 600 words can reach the same level.

Mark scheme
  1. 24 marks

    Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation).
    Level 5 (20-24 marks): the writing is fully coherent and controlled (plot and characterisation are developed with detail, originality and imagination); the writing is clearly and imaginatively organised (narrative is sophisticated and fully engages the reader's interest); structure and grammatical features are used ambitiously to give the writing cohesion and coherence; communication is ambitious and consistently conveys precise meaning
    Level 4 (15-19 marks): the writing is clearly controlled and coherent (plot and characterisation show convincing detail and some originality and imagination); the writing is clearly organised (narrative is purposefully shaped and developed); structure and grammatical features are used accurately to support cohesion and coherence; communication shows some ambition and conveys precise meaning
    Level 3 (10-14 marks): the writing is mostly controlled and coherent (plot and characterisation show some detail and development); the writing is organised (narrative has shape and direction); structure and grammatical features are used with some accuracy to convey meaning; communication is clear but limited in ambition
    Level 2 (5-9 marks): there is some control and coherence (some control of plot and characterisation); there is some organisation (narrative is beginning to have some shape and development); structure and grammatical features are used to convey meaning; communication is limited but clear
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): there is basic control and coherence (a basic sense of plot and characterisation); there is basic organisation (paragraphs may be used to show obvious divisions); there is some use of structure and grammatical features to convey meaning; communication is limited but some meaning is conveyed
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid approaches): a narrative that begins with the exact words 'Our form tutor came in, closed the door behind her and asked us all to sit down.' and develops that moment: the story should centre on what the tutor says and how the class react (Eduqas's Summer 2023 report noted that some candidates 'almost ignored the trip to the supermarket' in a given opening). First-person narrator, a member of the form. The news is open: good or bad, serious or comic, about the school, a teacher, a classmate, a trip, an event or something the class has done. The best answers usually keep to a short time frame - a single registration, a lesson or a day - rather than following the news across months (Eduqas's Summer 2024 report on the school opening 'It was my first day at this school...': 'Less successful responses sprawled across months or even years'). Eduqas's guidance for narrative writing: good answers may be characterised by a clear and coherent perspective (first or third person); content is relevant; content is sustained and coherent and possibly imaginative; a clear sense of direction and structure; appropriate and well-selected details give substance to the narrative; close observation of the behaviour and emotions of characters; convincing use of dialogue to develop plot and characterisation; consistent awareness of the reader. Level 5 (20-24) for this task: tension is built through the class's reactions and the narrator's thoughts before the news is revealed; a range of classmates is sketched quickly through telling details; the reveal is well placed (a twist, an anticlimax or a genuine shock) and the ending does more than restate it - for example a final exchange with the tutor; the narrative voice is confident and engaging, perhaps with humour or asides to the reader. Eduqas's specification: this response should be a narrative / recount; candidates who write purely descriptively, or use a form other than that specified, such as poetry or drama, will not be able to access the full mark range.

  2. 16 marks

    Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
    Level 5 (14-16 marks): there is appropriate and effective variation of sentence structures; virtually all sentence construction is controlled and accurate; a range of punctuation is used confidently and accurately; virtually all spelling, including that of complex irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is totally secure; a wide range of appropriate, ambitious vocabulary is used to create effect or convey precise meaning
    Level 4 (11-13 marks): sentence structure is varied to achieve particular effects; control of sentence construction is secure; a range of punctuation is used accurately; spelling, including that of irregular words, is secure; control of tense and agreement is secure; vocabulary is ambitious and used with precision
    Level 3 (7-10 marks): there is variety in sentence structure; control of sentence construction is mostly secure; a range of punctuation is used, mostly accurately; most spelling, including that of irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is mostly secure; vocabulary is beginning to develop and is used with some precision
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): some variety of sentence structure; there is some control of sentence construction; some control of a range of punctuation; the spelling is usually accurate; control of tense and agreement is generally secure; there is some range of vocabulary
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): limited range of sentence structure; control of sentence construction is limited; there is some attempt to use punctuation; some spelling is accurate; control of tense and agreement is limited; limited range of vocabulary
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Eduqas's guidance: expression is clear, fluent and controlled (the best answers will show ambition and sophistication in expression as well as a high degree of accuracy); there are few, if any, errors (no more than a sprinkling of mistakes); tenses are consistent; vocabulary is used precisely and appropriately to convey meaning; punctuation is used accurately and appropriately (and unobtrusively). Look for: control of internal monologue: rhetorical questions punctuated with question marks, and brackets or dashes for asides; the past perfect for what the narrator had done earlier ('had forgotten', 'had written') against the simple past of the scene; dialogue and reported speech accurately set out; a range of sentence types, including minor sentences used deliberately; accurate spelling of school vocabulary (registration, conscience, embarrassed, separate, Wednesday). A response with nothing worthy of credit scores 0 on both points.

Question 2

40 marks

In this section you will be assessed for the quality of your creative prose writing skills.

24 marks are awarded for communication and organisation; 16 marks are awarded for vocabulary, sentence structure, spelling and punctuation.

You should aim to write about 450-600 words.

Write a story which begins:

The woman at the till gave me twenty pounds too much change.

[40]

Model answer

The woman at the till gave me twenty pounds too much change. I did not notice at first. Zac and I were in town on a Saturday afternoon to buy a birthday present for my little sister, and I paid for a unicorn jigsaw with a twenty-pound note. The assistant was young, with a nervous smile and a badge that said TRAINEE - THANK YOU FOR YOUR PATIENCE. She counted the change into my hand so quickly that I simply stuffed it into my pocket.

It was only outside, by the fountain, when I took it out to check, that I saw it: a twenty-pound note, a ten-pound note, two pound coins and a penny. The jigsaw had cost seven ninety-nine. I should have had twelve pounds and one penny.

Zac saw it at the same moment. His eyes lit up.

"Result," he said.

"She's given me too much."

"Exactly. Result." He was already looking across the square at the sports shop, where a pair of trainers I had wanted since Christmas stood in the window on a little plastic stand. "That's nearly half of those. It's a massive shop. They won't even notice."

He had a point. The extra note felt different from the rest of the money: lighter, somehow, as if it had dropped out of the sky. Nobody had seen. Nobody would ever know. I thought about the trainers. I thought about the concert in March that I had told everyone I could not afford.

Then I thought about Mum.

When I was nine, Mum had worked on the tills at the big supermarket by the ring road. One evening she had come home late and sat down at the kitchen table without taking off her coat. Her till had been fifteen pounds short when they counted it, and the manager had taken the money out of her wages. I remember that she did not cry. She just sat there, turning her name badge over and over in her fingers, and then got up and made our tea as if nothing had happened. Somehow that was the worst part.

"Well?" said Zac.

"I'm taking it back."

He groaned so loudly that a pigeon took off from the fountain. "You're unbelievable."

"You don't have to come."

He came anyway, muttering all the way.

Inside the shop, the queue had gone. The trainee was standing beside her till while a man in a shirt and tie counted notes from her drawer into neat piles. Her face was white. As I watched, he stopped, frowned and counted one pile again.

I went up to the counter and held out the note.

"Sorry," I said. "I think you gave me too much change. About ten minutes ago. The unicorn jigsaw."

For a second, nobody moved. Then the trainee's whole body seemed to loosen, like a balloon when you let the air out, and she put both hands over her face. The man in the tie looked at the note, then at me, then at her.

"Well," he said slowly. "That solves that." He slotted the note back into the drawer. "Thank you. Not many people would have bothered."

Over his shoulder, the trainee mouthed the words "thank you". Her eyes were shining.

Outside, Zac was quiet for a long time. We walked past the sports shop. Neither of us looked in the window.

"Your mum," he said eventually. "The supermarket thing. You told me about it once, in Year 5."

"Did I?"

"Yeah." He kicked a bottle top along the pavement. "I forgot."

That evening, Mum asked why I was in such a good mood, and I said it was nothing. I have never told her what happened that Saturday. But I think about the trainee more often than I would have expected, and every time I do, I see Mum at the kitchen table in her coat, turning her name badge over and over, and I am glad I went back.

Explanation

This reaches Level 5 on AO5 because the dilemma set up by the opening is explored honestly: the temptation is made real (Zac's arguments, the trainers in the window), the memory of Mum's till gives the narrator a convincing reason, and returning the money is a turning point with visible consequences for the trainee. The ending reflects without lecturing. On AO6, amounts are written consistently, the past perfect marks the memory clearly and short sentences show the narrator's indecision. Weaker answers decide in one line and leave nothing at stake. It is longer than the 450-600 words Eduqas suggests: a tightly controlled answer of about 600 words can reach the same level.

Mark scheme
  1. 24 marks

    Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation).
    Level 5 (20-24 marks): the writing is fully coherent and controlled (plot and characterisation are developed with detail, originality and imagination); the writing is clearly and imaginatively organised (narrative is sophisticated and fully engages the reader's interest); structure and grammatical features are used ambitiously to give the writing cohesion and coherence; communication is ambitious and consistently conveys precise meaning
    Level 4 (15-19 marks): the writing is clearly controlled and coherent (plot and characterisation show convincing detail and some originality and imagination); the writing is clearly organised (narrative is purposefully shaped and developed); structure and grammatical features are used accurately to support cohesion and coherence; communication shows some ambition and conveys precise meaning
    Level 3 (10-14 marks): the writing is mostly controlled and coherent (plot and characterisation show some detail and development); the writing is organised (narrative has shape and direction); structure and grammatical features are used with some accuracy to convey meaning; communication is clear but limited in ambition
    Level 2 (5-9 marks): there is some control and coherence (some control of plot and characterisation); there is some organisation (narrative is beginning to have some shape and development); structure and grammatical features are used to convey meaning; communication is limited but clear
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): there is basic control and coherence (a basic sense of plot and characterisation); there is basic organisation (paragraphs may be used to show obvious divisions); there is some use of structure and grammatical features to convey meaning; communication is limited but some meaning is conveyed
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid approaches): a narrative that begins with the exact words 'The woman at the till gave me twenty pounds too much change.' and develops what the narrator does about it (Eduqas's Summer 2023 report noted that some candidates 'almost ignored the trip to the supermarket' in a given opening). First-person narrator. The opening sets up a dilemma without dictating the choice: keeping the money, returning it, being persuaded by a friend, spending it and regretting it, or finding out what happened to the assistant. The narrator's reasons, memories and the people around them can all shape the decision. The best answers make the temptation and the arguments on each side feel real, keep the time frame tight (an afternoon, perhaps its aftermath), and avoid turning the story into a lecture. Eduqas's guidance for narrative writing: good answers may be characterised by a clear and coherent perspective (first or third person); content is relevant; content is sustained and coherent and possibly imaginative; a clear sense of direction and structure; appropriate and well-selected details give substance to the narrative; close observation of the behaviour and emotions of characters; convincing use of dialogue to develop plot and characterisation; consistent awareness of the reader. Level 5 (20-24) for this task: the narrator's thoughts and feelings are explored honestly through close observation (the money in a pocket, the assistant's face, a friend's reaction); the decision is a genuine turning point and its consequences are shown; minor characters come alive through dialogue; the ending reflects on the choice without moralising (Eduqas's Summer 2023 report: the best responses to a given opening 'showed an eye for authentic detail and usually avoided the unconvincingly melodramatic in favour of close observation'). Eduqas's specification: this response should be a narrative / recount; candidates who write purely descriptively, or use a form other than that specified, such as poetry or drama, will not be able to access the full mark range.

  2. 16 marks

    Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
    Level 5 (14-16 marks): there is appropriate and effective variation of sentence structures; virtually all sentence construction is controlled and accurate; a range of punctuation is used confidently and accurately; virtually all spelling, including that of complex irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is totally secure; a wide range of appropriate, ambitious vocabulary is used to create effect or convey precise meaning
    Level 4 (11-13 marks): sentence structure is varied to achieve particular effects; control of sentence construction is secure; a range of punctuation is used accurately; spelling, including that of irregular words, is secure; control of tense and agreement is secure; vocabulary is ambitious and used with precision
    Level 3 (7-10 marks): there is variety in sentence structure; control of sentence construction is mostly secure; a range of punctuation is used, mostly accurately; most spelling, including that of irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is mostly secure; vocabulary is beginning to develop and is used with some precision
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): some variety of sentence structure; there is some control of sentence construction; some control of a range of punctuation; the spelling is usually accurate; control of tense and agreement is generally secure; there is some range of vocabulary
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): limited range of sentence structure; control of sentence construction is limited; there is some attempt to use punctuation; some spelling is accurate; control of tense and agreement is limited; limited range of vocabulary
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Eduqas's guidance: expression is clear, fluent and controlled (the best answers will show ambition and sophistication in expression as well as a high degree of accuracy); there are few, if any, errors (no more than a sprinkling of mistakes); tenses are consistent; vocabulary is used precisely and appropriately to convey meaning; punctuation is used accurately and appropriately (and unobtrusively). Look for: amounts of money written consistently (twenty pounds, seven ninety-nine); the narrator's thoughts and the dialogue clearly distinguished; the past perfect used to signal a memory ('Mum had worked', 'had taken') before a return to the simple past; sentence variety to show indecision (questions, short sentences); precise vocabulary (trainee, supervisor, receipt, conscience) spelt correctly. A response with nothing worthy of credit scores 0 on both points.

Question 3

40 marks

In this section you will be assessed for the quality of your creative prose writing skills.

24 marks are awarded for communication and organisation; 16 marks are awarded for vocabulary, sentence structure, spelling and punctuation.

You should aim to write about 450-600 words.

Write a story which ends:

...and at last Zainab knew who had been leaving the notes.

[40]

Model answer

The first note appeared on a wet Monday in November, stuck to the middle of the whiteboard in Room 9 like a small yellow flag.

GOOD LUCK IN THE MATHS TEST, it said, in neat green capitals. YOU KNOW MORE THAN YOU THINK.

Everybody assumed it was Mr Vaughan. He was 10C's form tutor, and he was exactly the kind of teacher who wore a tie with penguins on it. But when he came in and saw the note, he peeled it off the board, read it twice and frowned.

"Not me," he said. "I don't do sticky notes. I do sarcasm."

The next morning there was another one: WHAT DO YOU CALL A FISH WITH NO EYES? A FSH. The morning after that, it said: THE KITCHEN STAFF WORK HARDER THAN ANY OF US. SAY THANK YOU TODAY. By Friday, the lunch queue had never been so polite, and 10C could talk about nothing else.

The theories spread faster than a cold. It was the cleaner. It was the caretaker. It was a Year 13 doing it for a dare. It was, according to Osian, the ghost of a boy who had been kept in for detention in 1974 and never let out.

Zainab did not believe in ghosts. She believed in evidence.

She started a list at the back of her planner. The notes were always there before Mr Vaughan arrived at a quarter past eight, so the writer had to be in school before that. They were always in the same green pen. And the writer noticed things. They knew that Carys had a netball trial on Wednesday (GO ON, CARYS), that it was Mr Vaughan's fiftieth birthday (HAPPY BIRTHDAY, SIR. FIFTY IS THE NEW FORTY) and that the boys at the back had lost their cup match nine-nil (THERE IS ALWAYS NEXT YEAR). Whoever it was saw everything.

Then came the note that Zainab did not show to anyone.

The mock results had come out the week before. She had got thirty-one per cent in chemistry, the lowest mark she had ever had in anything, and at break she had locked herself in a toilet cubicle and cried as quietly as she could. She was certain that nobody had noticed. But the next morning, in the middle of the whiteboard, there was a note that said: Z - ONE BAD TEST IS ONE BAD TEST. IT IS NOT YOU.

She peeled it off before anyone else could read it and kept her head down all through registration. Somebody had seen her. Somebody who noticed everything and said nothing.

That evening, she asked her little brother whether anyone from Year 10 went to breakfast club. Idris was in Year 7 and went every morning, because Mum started work at seven.

"Only one," he said, through a mouthful of pasta. "He sits on his own and does crosswords."

There was only one person in 10C it could be, and he was the last person anyone would have guessed. Gethin Rowlands sat at the back by the radiator, with his hood half up and his sleeves pulled down over his hands, and he had said perhaps a dozen words to the whole form since September. Zainab had sat in the same room as him every morning for three months, and she could not have told anyone what his voice sounded like.

On Tuesday, she set her alarm for six. She caught the early bus in the dark, walked through the empty corridors past the cleaner's trolley and the ticking radiators, and stopped outside Room 9. The light was on. Through the narrow window in the door, she could see someone standing at the whiteboard with his back to her, writing slowly and carefully, the way people write when the words matter.

He stepped back to read what he had written, and she saw him smile: a small, private, pleased smile that she had never once seen in registration. Then he turned round, saw her face at the window and froze, the green pen still in his hand, and at last Zainab knew who had been leaving the notes.

Explanation

The mystery is built fairly: the timing of the notes, the green pen and the breakfast club give the reader the clues, and the note about Zainab's chemistry mark makes the search personal, so the final line lands as a discovery that also changes how she sees Gethin. That planning and the closely observed detail earn Level 5 for AO5. For AO6, the notes are set out consistently in capitals, tenses are secure and the long final sentence controls the pace of the reveal. Weaker answers give the writer away early or solve the mystery by coincidence. It is longer than the 450-600 words Eduqas suggests: a tightly controlled answer of about 600 words can reach the same level.

Mark scheme
  1. 24 marks

    Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation).
    Level 5 (20-24 marks): the writing is fully coherent and controlled (plot and characterisation are developed with detail, originality and imagination); the writing is clearly and imaginatively organised (narrative is sophisticated and fully engages the reader's interest); structure and grammatical features are used ambitiously to give the writing cohesion and coherence; communication is ambitious and consistently conveys precise meaning
    Level 4 (15-19 marks): the writing is clearly controlled and coherent (plot and characterisation show convincing detail and some originality and imagination); the writing is clearly organised (narrative is purposefully shaped and developed); structure and grammatical features are used accurately to support cohesion and coherence; communication shows some ambition and conveys precise meaning
    Level 3 (10-14 marks): the writing is mostly controlled and coherent (plot and characterisation show some detail and development); the writing is organised (narrative has shape and direction); structure and grammatical features are used with some accuracy to convey meaning; communication is clear but limited in ambition
    Level 2 (5-9 marks): there is some control and coherence (some control of plot and characterisation); there is some organisation (narrative is beginning to have some shape and development); structure and grammatical features are used to convey meaning; communication is limited but clear
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): there is basic control and coherence (a basic sense of plot and characterisation); there is basic organisation (paragraphs may be used to show obvious divisions); there is some use of structure and grammatical features to convey meaning; communication is limited but some meaning is conveyed
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid approaches): a narrative, most naturally in the third person (or told by a friend or sibling of Zainab), that builds a mystery around anonymous notes and solves it in the final line. The notes might be kind, funny, puzzling or unsettling, and might appear on a whiteboard, a doorstep or a car windscreen, in library books, a lunchbox or a garden shed; the writer might be a quiet classmate, a neighbour, a younger sibling, an elderly relative, a teacher, a rival or someone Zainab has suspected all along. The story must end with the given words, so the discovery has to be the final beat: the best answers plan backwards from the reveal, planting fair clues and perhaps a false trail, so that the answer is surprising but makes sense; Eduqas's examiners' reports note that answers with a given ending need a clear sense of the structure of their narrative so that the ending does not feel disjointed. Eduqas's guidance for narrative writing: good answers may be characterised by a clear and coherent perspective (first or third person); content is relevant; content is sustained and coherent and possibly imaginative; a clear sense of direction and structure; appropriate and well-selected details give substance to the narrative; close observation of the behaviour and emotions of characters; convincing use of dialogue to develop plot and characterisation; consistent awareness of the reader. Level 5 (20-24) responses: a clear investigative shape (a pattern of notes, theories, a method, then a turning point that makes the mystery personal); notes quoted briefly so that they reveal the character of their writer; a Zainab with a distinctive way of thinking; and a final scene paced so that the given words land at the moment of discovery rather than after a long explanation. Weaker responses list notes with no development, give the answer away early or solve the mystery by coincidence. Eduqas's specification: this response should be a narrative / recount; candidates who write purely descriptively, or use a form other than that specified, such as poetry or drama, will not be able to access the full mark range.

  2. 16 marks

    Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
    Level 5 (14-16 marks): there is appropriate and effective variation of sentence structures; virtually all sentence construction is controlled and accurate; a range of punctuation is used confidently and accurately; virtually all spelling, including that of complex irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is totally secure; a wide range of appropriate, ambitious vocabulary is used to create effect or convey precise meaning
    Level 4 (11-13 marks): sentence structure is varied to achieve particular effects; control of sentence construction is secure; a range of punctuation is used accurately; spelling, including that of irregular words, is secure; control of tense and agreement is secure; vocabulary is ambitious and used with precision
    Level 3 (7-10 marks): there is variety in sentence structure; control of sentence construction is mostly secure; a range of punctuation is used, mostly accurately; most spelling, including that of irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is mostly secure; vocabulary is beginning to develop and is used with some precision
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): some variety of sentence structure; there is some control of sentence construction; some control of a range of punctuation; the spelling is usually accurate; control of tense and agreement is generally secure; there is some range of vocabulary
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): limited range of sentence structure; control of sentence construction is limited; there is some attempt to use punctuation; some spelling is accurate; control of tense and agreement is limited; limited range of vocabulary
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Eduqas's guidance: expression is clear, fluent and controlled (the best answers will show ambition and sophistication in expression as well as a high degree of accuracy); there are few, if any, errors (no more than a sprinkling of mistakes); tenses are consistent; vocabulary is used precisely and appropriately to convey meaning; punctuation is used accurately and appropriately (and unobtrusively). Look for: the notes set out clearly and consistently within the prose (in capitals or quotation marks), with their own punctuation accurate; a consistent third-person past tense, with the past perfect for events before the main action ("she had locked herself in"); speech punctuated correctly and kept distinct from the notes; a long, controlled final sentence that delays the reveal; precise, unshowy vocabulary for clues and reactions; the given words copied exactly. A response with nothing worthy of credit scores 0 on both points.

Question 4

40 marks

In this section you will be assessed for the quality of your creative prose writing skills.

24 marks are awarded for communication and organisation; 16 marks are awarded for vocabulary, sentence structure, spelling and punctuation.

You should aim to write about 450-600 words.

Write a story which ends:

...and I took a deep breath and knocked on the door.

[40]

Model answer

Nan moved into the care home in September. By February, I still had not visited her.

I had reasons. I had plenty of reasons. I had mock exams, football on Saturdays and a cough that lasted most of November. Mum went every Sunday afternoon and came back quiet, and every Sunday she asked whether I wanted to come next week, and every Sunday I said, "Maybe," and we both knew what that meant.

The truth was that I was scared. Not of the care home, with its long corridors and its smell of gravy and disinfectant, although I did not like the sound of that. I was scared of Nan.

Or not of Nan, exactly. Of the person she was turning into.

From the time I was five, Nan had looked after me every day after school. She taught me to make pancakes and to cheat at cards. She knew the name of every bird in her garden and every player in the Welsh rugby team, and she sang along to the radio in a voice like a creaky gate. But two years ago she had started forgetting things. Small things at first: her keys, her glasses, the day of the week. Then bigger things. She left the gas on. She got lost walking back from the corner shop, a walk she had done every day for forty years. The last time I saw her before she moved, she looked at me for a long moment across her kitchen table and asked, very politely, whether I was the boy who came to read the meter.

I laughed, as if it were a joke. Then I went home and cried in the shower so that nobody would hear.

What if she did not know me at all now? What if I walked into her room and she looked straight through me? I could not bear it. So I stayed away, and I told myself it did not matter, because she would not know whether I had been or not.

It was Mum who changed my mind, although she did not mean to. One evening she came home and put a carrier bag on the kitchen table. Inside was Nan's old biscuit tin, the one with faded roses on the lid.

"I found it at the back of her wardrobe when we were clearing out her house," Mum said. "She keeps asking for it, so I said we'd take it in on Sunday."

When Mum had gone upstairs, I opened it. I expected buttons, or old receipts. Instead, it was full of me. Every birthday card I had ever made her, with my wobbly felt-tip letters. School photographs from Reception onwards, the colours fading. A certificate for swimming twenty-five metres. A picture of a robin I had painted when I was seven, with "To Nan, my best friend" written underneath in green.

She had kept all of it. She had kept it in her wardrobe, and she kept asking for it, and I had been too much of a coward even to visit her.

On Sunday, I told Mum I was coming. She did not say anything, but she squeezed my arm very hard in the car.

The care home was warmer and brighter than I had imagined. There were paintings in the corridors, and somewhere a television was showing an old film, and a man in a cardigan was laughing at it. Mum stopped at the desk to sign us in and told me to go on ahead: Room 14, at the end on the left.

I walked down the corridor with the biscuit tin held against my chest. Outside her door, I stopped. Through it, faintly, I could hear the radio, and Nan singing along, a little out of tune, in her voice like a creaky gate.

I did not know who she would think I was. I did not know whether she would remember the robin, or the cards, or the pancakes. But I remembered, and I decided that today it would have to be enough for both of us. I held the tin tighter, and I took a deep breath and knocked on the door.

Explanation

The narrator's fear is explained honestly through one precise memory (being mistaken for the meter reader), and the biscuit tin is a turning point that changes his mind, so the knock is the story's climax rather than an add-on. The creaky-gate voice, planted early and heard again through the door, gathers the narrative together, which is Level 5 for AO5. For AO6, the past perfect, rhetorical questions and patterned sentences are controlled and vocabulary is restrained and precise. Weaker answers explain what happens after the door opens. It is longer than the 450-600 words Eduqas suggests: a tightly controlled answer of about 600 words can reach the same level.

Mark scheme
  1. 24 marks

    Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation).
    Level 5 (20-24 marks): the writing is fully coherent and controlled (plot and characterisation are developed with detail, originality and imagination); the writing is clearly and imaginatively organised (narrative is sophisticated and fully engages the reader's interest); structure and grammatical features are used ambitiously to give the writing cohesion and coherence; communication is ambitious and consistently conveys precise meaning
    Level 4 (15-19 marks): the writing is clearly controlled and coherent (plot and characterisation show convincing detail and some originality and imagination); the writing is clearly organised (narrative is purposefully shaped and developed); structure and grammatical features are used accurately to support cohesion and coherence; communication shows some ambition and conveys precise meaning
    Level 3 (10-14 marks): the writing is mostly controlled and coherent (plot and characterisation show some detail and development); the writing is organised (narrative has shape and direction); structure and grammatical features are used with some accuracy to convey meaning; communication is clear but limited in ambition
    Level 2 (5-9 marks): there is some control and coherence (some control of plot and characterisation); there is some organisation (narrative is beginning to have some shape and development); structure and grammatical features are used to convey meaning; communication is limited but clear
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): there is basic control and coherence (a basic sense of plot and characterisation); there is basic organisation (paragraphs may be used to show obvious divisions); there is some use of structure and grammatical features to convey meaning; communication is limited but some meaning is conveyed
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid approaches): a first-person narrative that ends on a threshold, with the narrator about to face something they have been avoiding. The door might lead to an apology, a confession, an audition or interview, a first visit to someone ill or elderly, a reunion with an estranged friend or relative, a new home or school, a neighbour whose window has been broken, or a mysterious house. Because the story stops before the door opens, the whole narrative must be about the build-up: why the narrator is afraid and what finally makes them act. The story must end with the given words, and the best answers plan the narrative so that the knock is its climax rather than an afterthought; Eduqas's examiners' reports note that answers with a given ending need a clear sense of the structure of their narrative so that the ending does not feel disjointed. Eduqas's guidance for narrative writing: good answers may be characterised by a clear and coherent perspective (first or third person); content is relevant; content is sustained and coherent and possibly imaginative; a clear sense of direction and structure; appropriate and well-selected details give substance to the narrative; close observation of the behaviour and emotions of characters; convincing use of dialogue to develop plot and characterisation; consistent awareness of the reader. In Level 5 (20-24): a convincing reason for the narrator's fear, revealed with honesty rather than melodrama; a turning point (a discovery, a conversation, an object) that changes the narrator's mind; details planted early that return at the door (a sound, a phrase, an object), so the ending gathers the story together; and an open ending that still feels complete. Weaker responses spend most of the answer on a journey to the door or explain what happens next. Eduqas's specification: this response should be a narrative / recount; candidates who write purely descriptively, or use a form other than that specified, such as poetry or drama, will not be able to access the full mark range.

  2. 16 marks

    Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
    Level 5 (14-16 marks): there is appropriate and effective variation of sentence structures; virtually all sentence construction is controlled and accurate; a range of punctuation is used confidently and accurately; virtually all spelling, including that of complex irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is totally secure; a wide range of appropriate, ambitious vocabulary is used to create effect or convey precise meaning
    Level 4 (11-13 marks): sentence structure is varied to achieve particular effects; control of sentence construction is secure; a range of punctuation is used accurately; spelling, including that of irregular words, is secure; control of tense and agreement is secure; vocabulary is ambitious and used with precision
    Level 3 (7-10 marks): there is variety in sentence structure; control of sentence construction is mostly secure; a range of punctuation is used, mostly accurately; most spelling, including that of irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is mostly secure; vocabulary is beginning to develop and is used with some precision
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): some variety of sentence structure; there is some control of sentence construction; some control of a range of punctuation; the spelling is usually accurate; control of tense and agreement is generally secure; there is some range of vocabulary
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): limited range of sentence structure; control of sentence construction is limited; there is some attempt to use punctuation; some spelling is accurate; control of tense and agreement is limited; limited range of vocabulary
    0 marks: nothing worthy of credit

    Eduqas's guidance: expression is clear, fluent and controlled (the best answers will show ambition and sophistication in expression as well as a high degree of accuracy); there are few, if any, errors (no more than a sprinkling of mistakes); tenses are consistent; vocabulary is used precisely and appropriately to convey meaning; punctuation is used accurately and appropriately (and unobtrusively). Look for: the past perfect used accurately for the history behind the present action; rhetorical questions in the narrator's thoughts punctuated correctly; lists and repeated structures controlled with commas; restrained, precise vocabulary for difficult feelings; a clear layout for written items such as a note or a card; the given words copied exactly. A response with nothing worthy of credit scores 0 on both points.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.