Question 1
40 marksIn this section you will be assessed for the quality of your creative prose writing skills.
24 marks are awarded for communication and organisation; 16 marks are awarded for vocabulary, sentence structure, spelling and punctuation.
You should aim to write about 450-600 words.
Use this title for your writing:
The Family Meeting.
[40]
Model answer
In our house, family meetings were Dad's invention. He called one whenever something needed Discussing - with a capital D - and they always followed the same pattern. Dad stood at the end of the kitchen table, Mum sighed, my brother Ethan put his hood up, and I counted the minutes until I could leave. Topics had included the electricity bill, the state of the bathroom and, most memorably, Who Had Eaten All The Crisps.
So when a typed notice appeared on the fridge one Thursday - FAMILY MEETING. SATURDAY. 10 A.M. ATTENDANCE COMPULSORY - none of us paid much attention. It was only when Dad read it and said slowly, "I didn't write this," that we began to worry.
At ten o'clock on Saturday we filed into the kitchen to find the blinds down, Mum's laptop connected to the television and my nine-year-old sister, Maisie, standing beside it in her school cardigan, holding the remote control like a conductor's baton.
"Thank you for coming," she said gravely. "Please be seated."
Ethan snorted. Maisie gave him a look so withering that he actually sat down.
The first slide said, in purple bubble writing, THE STATE OF THIS FAMILY: A PRESENTATION BY MAISIE CLARKE, AGED NINE AND THREE-QUARTERS. The second slide was a pie chart.
"This shows who chooses what we watch on Friday nights," Maisie explained. An enormous blue slice represented Dad. A slightly smaller red one was Ethan. I was a thin yellow sliver. Maisie was not there at all.
"Where are you, love?" asked Mum.
"Exactly," said Maisie.
What followed was the most thorough demolition of a family I have ever witnessed. Slide four, BATHROOM QUEUE, was a timeline of a school morning in which Ethan spent forty-one minutes in the shower and Maisie spent "zero minutes, because there was no hot water left". Slide six was called PROMISES and listed, with dates, every time one of us had said "maybe at the weekend". There were eleven. Four were mine. Slide eight showed a photograph of our hamster above the words HE IS THE ONLY ONE WHO LISTENS.
By then Dad had his hand over his mouth and his shoulders were shaking. Ethan had taken his hood down. I was laughing too, until I noticed that my sister was not laughing at all. She was clicking through the slides with grim determination, chin set, the tips of her ears turning pink, the way they always did just before she cried.
The final slide had no clip art. It was white, with seven black words in the middle:
NOBODY ASKS ME HOW MY DAY WAS.
The kitchen went very quiet. The fridge hummed. Somewhere outside, a car alarm started and stopped.
I thought about the past week. Monday: netball. Tuesday: revision. Wednesday, Thursday and Friday: bedroom door shut, headphones on. I tried to remember a single thing Maisie had said to me, and I could not, and the shame of it was like swallowing a stone.
It was Dad who moved first. He walked to the end of the table - his end - pulled out his chair and offered it to her.
"Maisie," he said, "how was your day?"
She looked at him suspiciously. "It's Saturday. It's only just started."
"How was your week, then?"
And she told us. She told us about her best friend moving to Leeds, and the spelling test she had got full marks in, and a dream about a giant snail that wore a hat. It took nearly an hour, and nobody left the table once.
We still have family meetings, but now they happen on Sunday evenings and everybody takes a turn to be in charge. Ethan's are short and mostly about food. Mine involve a list. Maisie's, inevitably, involve slides.
Last week's included a pie chart. I checked: everybody had a slice.
Explanation
The response earns Level 5 on AO5 because the meeting is carefully shaped: the comic slides build in absurdity until the final slide turns the story, and the narrator's guilty reflection and Dad's gesture lead to a resolved ending that returns to the pie chart. On AO6 the dialogue, capitals and colons are handled accurately and sentence lengths are varied for effect. Weaker answers tend to summarise the announcement or include many characters without distinguishing them. It is longer than the 450-600 words Eduqas suggests: a tightly controlled answer of about 600 words can reach the same level.
Mark scheme
-
24 marks
Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation).
Level 5 (20-24 marks): the writing is fully coherent and controlled (plot and characterisation are developed with detail, originality and imagination); the writing is clearly and imaginatively organised (narrative is sophisticated and fully engages the reader's interest); structure and grammatical features are used ambitiously to give the writing cohesion and coherence; communication is ambitious and consistently conveys precise meaning
Level 4 (15-19 marks): the writing is clearly controlled and coherent (plot and characterisation show convincing detail and some originality and imagination); the writing is clearly organised (narrative is purposefully shaped and developed); structure and grammatical features are used accurately to support cohesion and coherence; communication shows some ambition and conveys precise meaning
Level 3 (10-14 marks): the writing is mostly controlled and coherent (plot and characterisation show some detail and development); the writing is organised (narrative has shape and direction); structure and grammatical features are used with some accuracy to convey meaning; communication is clear but limited in ambition
Level 2 (5-9 marks): there is some control and coherence (some control of plot and characterisation); there is some organisation (narrative is beginning to have some shape and development); structure and grammatical features are used to convey meaning; communication is limited but clear
Level 1 (1-4 marks): there is basic control and coherence (a basic sense of plot and characterisation); there is basic organisation (paragraphs may be used to show obvious divisions); there is some use of structure and grammatical features to convey meaning; communication is limited but some meaning is conveyed
0 marks: nothing worthy of creditIndicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid approaches): a narrative (or a recount, real or imagined) centred on a family meeting: an announcement (a move, a new job, a new rule, an illness, a holiday), a meeting called to sort out a problem (chores, money, screen time, arguments), a meeting called by an unexpected person, or a meeting that goes badly wrong. The narrator could be a teenager, a younger sibling or a parent, or a third-person narrator could observe the whole family. The meeting could form the whole story in real time, or the story could move from the build-up through the meeting to its consequences. The tone may be comic, serious or a mixture of the two. Eduqas's guidance for narrative writing: good answers may be characterised by a clear and coherent perspective (first or third person); content is relevant; content is sustained and coherent and possibly imaginative; a clear sense of direction and structure; appropriate and well-selected details give substance to the narrative; close observation of the behaviour and emotions of characters; convincing use of dialogue to develop plot and characterisation; consistent awareness of the reader. Level 5 (20-24) for this title: the meeting is dramatised in detail, with each family member given a distinct voice and recognisable behaviour; a shift in tone (for example from comedy to something more serious) is handled with control; the narrator reflects on what is revealed; the ending shows that something has changed. Less successful responses summarise what was announced, crowd the scene with characters who are not distinguished, or use dialogue that does not move the story on ('limited or inappropriate use of dialogue' is among Eduqas's features of less successful answers). Eduqas's specification: this response should be a narrative / recount; candidates who write purely descriptively, or use a form other than that specified, such as poetry or drama, will not be able to access the full mark range.
-
16 marks
Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
Level 5 (14-16 marks): there is appropriate and effective variation of sentence structures; virtually all sentence construction is controlled and accurate; a range of punctuation is used confidently and accurately; virtually all spelling, including that of complex irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is totally secure; a wide range of appropriate, ambitious vocabulary is used to create effect or convey precise meaning
Level 4 (11-13 marks): sentence structure is varied to achieve particular effects; control of sentence construction is secure; a range of punctuation is used accurately; spelling, including that of irregular words, is secure; control of tense and agreement is secure; vocabulary is ambitious and used with precision
Level 3 (7-10 marks): there is variety in sentence structure; control of sentence construction is mostly secure; a range of punctuation is used, mostly accurately; most spelling, including that of irregular words, is correct; control of tense and agreement is mostly secure; vocabulary is beginning to develop and is used with some precision
Level 2 (4-6 marks): some variety of sentence structure; there is some control of sentence construction; some control of a range of punctuation; the spelling is usually accurate; control of tense and agreement is generally secure; there is some range of vocabulary
Level 1 (1-3 marks): limited range of sentence structure; control of sentence construction is limited; there is some attempt to use punctuation; some spelling is accurate; control of tense and agreement is limited; limited range of vocabulary
0 marks: nothing worthy of creditEduqas's guidance: expression is clear, fluent and controlled (the best answers will show ambition and sophistication in expression as well as a high degree of accuracy); there are few, if any, errors (no more than a sprinkling of mistakes); tenses are consistent; vocabulary is used precisely and appropriately to convey meaning; punctuation is used accurately and appropriately (and unobtrusively). Look for: dialogue with several speakers, each starting a new line and punctuated correctly; capital letters, colons and quotation used accurately to present notices and slide titles; a mixture of long, complex sentences and short ones for impact ('Four were mine.'); a consistent past tense, moving to the present only for the closing present-day paragraphs; precise vocabulary for tone and manner ('gravely', 'withering', 'demolition'); correct spelling of words such as 'presentation', 'compulsory', 'definitely' and 'embarrassed'. A response with nothing worthy of credit scores 0 on both points.