Question 1
40 marks'Putting students into sets by ability labels them for years. Every class should be mixed-ability.'
Write the text of a speech to be given at a meeting of your school's governors in which you argue your point of view on this statement.
(24 marks for content and organisation
16 marks for technical accuracy)
Model answer
Good evening, Chair, and members of the governing body. Thank you for inviting a student to speak on a question that is usually discussed about us, rather than with us.
I want to begin with two friends of mine. I will call them Leah and Sam, because neither of them would forgive me for using their real names. In Year 7, Leah was put in the bottom set for maths after a test she took in her second week, when she still could not find the canteen. She is now one of the sharpest problem-solvers I know - but it took her three years, and a great deal of stubbornness, to climb out of that set. Somewhere along the way she decided she was 'not a maths person', and she still says it, even now that she plainly is. Sam, on the other hand, was in a mixed-ability English class, the fastest reader in the room by a mile, and spent most of Year 8 finishing the work in ten minutes and then quietly doodling in the margin of his book. Both of them were let down. One by setting; one by its absence.
So I am not going to stand here and tell you that setting is evil, or that mixed-ability teaching is a miracle cure. The truth is more interesting than that, and I think more useful to you.
The statement says that sets label students. It is right. A label given at eleven has a way of sticking. Students in lower sets can come to see themselves as failures, and teachers - without meaning to - can expect less of them. Students in top sets can become anxious that one slip will see them moved down. And because sets often mirror family circumstances, we risk sorting students not just by ability, but by background. That should worry any governing body that cares about fairness.
But the statement goes further: it says that every class should be mixed-ability. And here I part company with it. In subjects that build step by step, like maths or a language, a teacher with thirty students who range from struggling with fractions to ready for advanced algebra faces an almost impossible task. Somebody will be lost and somebody will be bored. Often it is both, in the same lesson. Mixed-ability teaching can work brilliantly, but only with small classes, extra support staff and a great deal of planning time - and, with respect, I have seen this school's budget report.
So what would I ask you to do? Three things.
First, keep sets where they genuinely help - in the small number of subjects that build skills in a strict sequence - but nowhere else. In English, history, science and the arts, our differences can be a strength: we learn from each other's ideas, not just from the teacher.
Second, make sets flexible. Not a sentence handed down in Year 7, but a decision reviewed every term, with students able to move up as soon as they are ready. Leah should never have had to wait three years.
Third, change the language. Stop calling it the bottom set. Students know exactly what that phrase means, and so do their parents. If we must group students, let us group them by what they need to learn next, not by where they are ranked.
Some will say that this is a messy compromise. I would say it is simply honest. Every student in this school is different, and no single system will suit all of them. The real question is not 'sets or no sets?' It is 'how do we make sure that no student is defined by a decision made in their second week?'
You have the power to answer that question. I hope you will answer it in a way that Leah - and Sam - would be proud of.
Thank you.
Explanation
Speaking to governors calls for a formal, measured register and arguments that weigh evidence and consequences, so a carefully reasoned balanced view can reach the top band as readily as a one-sided one. What lifts a response is development: concrete examples of students affected by setting, anticipation of objections and practical proposals. Common pitfalls are a chatty register unsuited to the audience, vague claims that sets are 'unfair' without explanation, and a conclusion that does not answer the statement.
Mark scheme
-
24 marks
Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation).
Level 4 (19-24 marks): Compelling, convincing communication. Upper (22-24): convincing and compelling; tone, style and register assuredly matched to purpose and audience; extensive, ambitious vocabulary, sustained crafting of devices; varied, inventive structure; convincing, complex ideas; fluent paragraphs, seamless discourse markers. Lower (19-21): convincing; register convincingly matched; extensive vocabulary, conscious crafting of devices; varied, effective structure; highly engaging, developed complex ideas; consistently coherent paragraphs.
Level 3 (13-18 marks): Consistent, clear communication. Upper (16-18): consistently clear; tone, style and register consistently matched; increasingly sophisticated vocabulary, successful devices; effective structure; engaging, connected ideas; coherent paragraphs, integrated discourse markers. Lower (13-15): generally clear; register generally matched; vocabulary chosen for effect, appropriate devices; usually effective structure; connected ideas; usually coherent paragraphs.
Level 2 (7-12 marks): Some successful communication. Upper (10-12): some sustained success; sustained attempt to match tone, style and register; conscious vocabulary, some devices; some structural features; increasingly varied linked ideas; some paragraphs and discourse markers. Lower (7-9): some success; attempts to match register; begins to vary vocabulary; attempts structural features; some linked ideas; attempts paragraphs.
Level 1 (1-6 marks): Simple, limited communication. Upper (4-6): communicates simply; simple awareness of tone and register; simple vocabulary and devices; simple structural features; one or two ideas, simply linked; random paragraphing. Lower (1-3): limited communication; occasional sense of register; simple vocabulary; little or no structure; one or two unlinked ideas; no paragraphs.
0 marks: nothing to reward.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Purpose: to argue a point of view on setting by ability, persuading the governors, who make decisions about the school, to act on it. Audience: the school's governing body - adults responsible for the school, who will expect a formal, measured and well-reasoned register; a student speaker can use this to bring a perspective they lack. Form: the text of a speech: formal address ('Good evening, Chair, and members of the governing body'), first and second person, an opening that establishes the speaker's standing and position, a logical sequence of points, and a close that asks the governors to act. Points for the statement might include: sets decided early can stick and shape how students see themselves; teachers may expect less of lower sets; top-set students can feel pressure and fear of moving down; sets can mirror family background, so they risk widening gaps; mixed classes let students learn from each other and build respect; labels such as 'bottom set' are damaging. Points against might include: in subjects that build step by step, such as maths and languages, a wide range of ability in one room is very hard to teach; some students are held back and others left behind; setting lets teachers pitch work and pace precisely; able students may be bored and struggling students overwhelmed; mixed-ability teaching needs small classes, extra staff and planning time that schools may not have. A balanced view might argue for setting in a few subjects only, with frequent review and movement between sets. A top-band response: a sustained, developed line of argument, which may be a carefully weighed balanced view that reaches clear recommendations; concrete examples or anecdotes of students affected; anticipation of objections and rebuttal; rhetorical questions, tripling and contrast used with restraint suited to a formal audience; cohesive paragraphs with seamless discourse markers; a structure that builds to practical proposals and a memorable close. Credit for tone, style and register depends on how well the writing is matched to a governors' meeting. Students may agree, disagree or take a balanced view: reward the quality of the writing, not the opinion.
-
16 marks
Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
Level 4 (13-16 marks): sentence demarcation consistently secure and consistently accurate; a wide range of punctuation used with a high level of accuracy; a full range of appropriate sentence forms for effect; Standard English used consistently and appropriately, with secure control of complex grammatical structures; a high level of accuracy in spelling, including ambitious vocabulary; extensive and ambitious vocabulary.
Level 3 (9-12 marks): sentence demarcation mostly secure and mostly accurate; a range of punctuation, mostly used with success; a variety of sentence forms for effect; Standard English mostly used appropriately, with mostly controlled grammatical structures; generally accurate spelling, including complex and irregular words; increasingly sophisticated vocabulary.
Level 2 (5-8 marks): sentence demarcation mostly secure and sometimes accurate; some control of a range of punctuation; attempts a variety of sentence forms; some use of Standard English, with some control of agreement; some accurate spelling of more complex words; varied vocabulary.
Level 1 (1-4 marks): occasional sentence demarcation; some evidence of conscious punctuation; a simple range of sentence forms; occasional use of Standard English, with limited control of agreement; accurate basic spelling; simple vocabulary.
0 marks: nothing to reward.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Technical accuracy is judged across the whole response: secure sentence demarcation (no comma splices or run-on sentences); a range of punctuation used accurately, including question marks on rhetorical questions, commas after fronted adverbials and in lists, apostrophes for omission and possession ('the school's budget', 'students' confidence'), colons, semicolons and dashes; a range of sentence forms for effect, including short emphatic sentences and controlled complex sentences; Standard English and secure grammar suited to a formal audience of governors; accurate spelling, including topic words such as 'ability', 'separate', 'expectation', 'curriculum' and 'governing'; and an extensive, precise vocabulary. Deliberate fragments used for rhetorical effect are acceptable when clearly controlled. A response with nothing meaningful to assess scores 0 on both points.