Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/7

Non-fiction: language analysis (Q3)

Practise 30 exam-style questions on Non-fiction: language analysis (Q3) for AQA GCSE English Language (Paper 2). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 30 questions
  • 12 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

12 marks

Read the following source, then answer the question at the end.

Source B: 21st-century non-fiction
The Children Who Keep Their Families Going
by Priya Malhotra (fictional)
This is an extract from an article published in a national newspaper in 2023. The writer, a journalist, spends a morning with a thirteen-year-old girl who helps to look after her mother, who has multiple sclerosis, and her younger brother.

[1] At a quarter past six on a Tuesday morning, while most thirteen-year-olds are still asleep, Ellie is standing in her kitchen in a small Midlands town, counting her mother's tablets into a plastic box with the days of the week printed on its lids. She does it quickly, without looking at the labels. She has done it every morning since she was nine.

[2] Her mother, Jo, has multiple sclerosis, a condition that damages the nerves and can leave her exhausted, unsteady on her feet and, on bad days, unable to get out of bed. Ellie's father left when she was small. So before school, Ellie helps her mum to the bathroom, makes breakfast for her seven-year-old brother, checks that he has his reading book and walks him to the school gate. Then she runs, because her own school starts at twenty to nine and is a mile and a half away.

[3] 'People think it must be awful,' she tells me, with the patient expression of someone who has explained this many times before. 'It's not awful. It's just my life. I like knowing Mum's OK.' She shrugs. 'The worst bit is when teachers have a go at you for being late and you can't say why.'

[4] Ellie, whose name has been changed, is one of the country's young carers: children who look after a parent, brother, sister or grandparent who is ill or disabled, or who struggles with their mental health or with addiction. The last census counted around 120,000 of them in England and Wales, some as young as five. Charities believe the real figure is far higher, because many children do not know the word applies to them, and many families fear that if they ask for help, someone will try to split them up.

[5] What does that mean in practice? It means homework done at midnight, after the washing-up. It means missed school trips and missed sleepovers, because who would look after Mum? It means a child who can order a repeat prescription but has never been to a friend's birthday party. Young carers are more likely than their classmates to miss school, to fall behind and to feel lonely, anxious or worn out. Many of them are brilliant at hiding it.

[6] It is tempting to call children like Ellie inspiring, and in a sense they are. Watching her coax her mother into a chair with a joke and a cushion, I was moved almost to tears by her tenderness and her competence. But 'inspiring' can also be a way of letting the rest of us off the hook. A thirteen-year-old should not be her family's only safety net. She should not have to choose between her mother's medication and her maths test.

[7] There is help, for those who know where to look. Some councils run young carers' groups, where children can spend an evening bowling or baking with others who understand. Some schools give young carers a card that lets them keep their phone switched on in case home calls, or a quiet word with a teacher instead of a detention for lateness. Ellie's school has just started a group, and she went for the first time last week. 'It was weird,' she says, smiling properly for the first time all morning. 'Nobody asked me why I looked tired.'

You now need to refer only to Source B, paragraphs [4] to [6].

How does the writer use language to persuade the reader that young carers need more help?

Model answer

The writer moves from facts to feelings to make the reader see that young carers carry a burden no child should bear. Paragraph [4] begins with statistics: "around 120,000" children, "some as young as five". The large figure establishes the scale of the problem, while the detail of the youngest age is shocking. The writer then suggests the problem is hidden, since "the real figure is far higher", and the plain, emotive phrase "split them up" captures the fear that keeps families silent, making the reader sympathise rather than judge.

The rhetorical question "What does that mean in practice?" turns abstract numbers into lived reality. The anaphora of "It means..." builds a tricolon of concrete examples, each sentence adding weight like another chore piled on. The detail "homework done at midnight, after the washing-up" shows a child doing adult housework before she can even begin her own work. The repetition in "missed school trips and missed sleepovers" stresses what has been taken from her, and the question "because who would look after Mum?" slips into the child's own voice; the informal "Mum" makes the reader feel her loyalty. The antithesis in "a child who can order a repeat prescription but has never been to a friend's birthday party" is especially powerful, setting an adult, medical task against the simplest childhood pleasure. The short sentence "Many of them are brilliant at hiding it" uses "brilliant" with bitter irony: their skill at hiding is exactly what keeps them unhelped.

In paragraph [6] the writer anticipates the reader's response. The concession "It is tempting to call children like Ellie inspiring, and in a sense they are" sounds fair and generous, and the gentle verb "coax" and the nouns "tenderness" and "competence" show Ellie's maturity, while "moved almost to tears" reveals the writer's own emotion. The conjunction "But" then turns the argument: the idiom "letting the rest of us off the hook" uses the inclusive "us" to accuse the reader of complacency. The metaphor of "her family's only safety net" suggests she is the last thing preventing disaster, a crushing responsibility for "A thirteen-year-old". Finally, the repeated modal "should not" makes a moral demand, and the alliteration of "her mother's medication and her maths test" fixes a painful, absurd choice in the reader's mind.

Explanation

A Level 4 response analyses how the writer shifts from statistics to concrete, emotive detail and then to a direct challenge to the reader, and how devices such as the anaphora of "It means" and the antithesis of the prescription and the birthday party work together to persuade. It explores the connotations of words like "brilliant", "coax" and "safety net". Common pitfalls are summarising Ellie's routine from paragraphs [1] and [2], and naming 'rhetorical question' or 'statistics' without explaining their effect on the reader.

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO2 (analysis of language).
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): Detailed, perceptive analysis: analyses the effects of the writer's choices of language; selects a range of judicious textual detail; sophisticated and accurate use of subject terminology.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): Clear, relevant explanation: explains clearly the effects of the writer's choices of language; selects a range of relevant textual detail; clear and accurate use of subject terminology.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): Some understanding and comment: attempts to comment on the effect of language; selects some appropriate textual detail; some use of subject terminology, mainly appropriate.
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Simple, limited comment: simple comment on the effect of language; simple references or textual details; simple use of subject terminology, not always appropriate.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The focus is how the writer persuades the reader that young carers need more help. A response about language outside paragraphs [4] to [6], or from Source A (with the right focus), is placed in the level its quality deserves but at the bottom of that level; Level 3 and above need the correct focus. Language features may include:
    - statistics "around 120,000" and "some as young as five": scale and shocking youth; "the real figure is far higher" suggests a hidden problem, backed by the authority of "Charities"
    - plain, emotive phrase "split them up": the families' fear explains their silence and creates sympathy
    - rhetorical question "What does that mean in practice?": turns statistics into lived experience and engages the reader
    - anaphora and tricolon "It means...": the cumulative weight of concrete details such as "homework done at midnight, after the washing-up"
    - repetition "missed school trips and missed sleepovers" and the embedded question "because who would look after Mum?": loss of childhood; the informal "Mum" adopts the child's loyal voice
    - antithesis "a child who can order a repeat prescription but has never been to a friend's birthday party": adult responsibility set against a lost childhood
    - list "to miss school, to fall behind and to feel lonely, anxious or worn out": escalation from practical to emotional harm
    - short sentence "Many of them are brilliant at hiding it.": irony in "brilliant"; their skill keeps them unseen and unhelped
    - concession "It is tempting to call children like Ellie inspiring, and in a sense they are": a fair, balanced voice that makes the turn more convincing
    - the gentle verb "coax", the abstract nouns "tenderness" and "competence" and "moved almost to tears": Ellie's maturity and the writer's emotion
    - idiom and inclusive pronoun in "letting the rest of us off the hook": challenges the reader's complacency
    - metaphor "her family's only safety net": she alone prevents disaster, too heavy a responsibility for a child
    - repeated modal verb "should not" and the alliteration of "her mother's medication and her maths test": a moral demand and a memorable, painful choice
    Level 4 responses analyse how the shift from facts to concrete detail to direct challenge works together to persuade, and explore connotations precisely, rather than listing features.

Question 2

12 marks

Read the following source, then answer the question at the end.

Source B: 21st-century non-fiction
Nobody Helps in This House
by Rob Kettering (fictional)
This is an extract from a blog post written in 2023 by a father of two teenagers. He describes how his family changed the way they share the housework.

[1] Confession time. For the first eleven years of my marriage, I genuinely believed I was good at housework. I put the bins out on Tuesday nights. I cooked a mean spaghetti bolognese on Saturdays. I hoovered, thoroughly, whenever my mother-in-law was coming. If you had asked me, I would have told you with a straight face that Sam and I shared the chores 'pretty much fifty-fifty'. We both work full time - she teaches, I'm a pharmacist - and we have two children, Ella, now fifteen, and Jake, thirteen. I was, I thought, a thoroughly modern man.

[2] Then, one Sunday evening three years ago, Sam handed me a list. She had spent a week writing down every household job she did that I didn't, and it covered both sides of four sheets of paper. Some of it was the obvious stuff: washing, ironing, cleaning the bathroom. But most of it was invisible. Remembering that Jake needed new football boots. Booking the dentist. Noticing that we were low on toilet roll before we ran out. Signing the school trip forms, buying presents for other children's birthday parties, knowing which of our children would eat peas this week. I hadn't been sharing the housework at all. I had been doing a few jobs while Sam ran the house.

[3] It turns out we were depressingly normal. A few years ago the Office for National Statistics calculated that women in Britain do, on average, around 60 per cent more unpaid work than men - the cooking, the cleaning, the caring and all the rest. Researchers even have a name for the invisible part: the 'mental load'. It is the job of being the one who remembers, and it is exhausting precisely because nobody ever sees it being done.

[4] So we called a family meeting. (The children were thrilled. Ella rolled her eyes so hard I feared for her health.) We wrote every single job on a whiteboard, including the invisible ones, and shared them out - not just between Sam and me, but among all four of us. Jake negotiated like a trade union official, swapping 'unloading the dishwasher' for 'feeding the cat' and demanding extra screen time as compensation for cleaning the bathroom sink. Ella now cooks dinner every Wednesday. The first few Wednesdays involved a great deal of smoke. Last week she made a Thai green curry that was better than anything I have ever produced.

[5] It hasn't been perfect. The whiteboard has caused more arguments than any other object in our house, and there was one dark fortnight when nobody would admit to being in charge of the recycling. But something has changed. I know where we keep the spare light bulbs. I know when the car insurance runs out. I have discovered, at the age of forty-four, the inside of our oven.

[6] Most of all, we have banned one word. Nobody in our house 'helps' with the housework any more. You can't help in your own home, any more than you can help with your own life. Helping suggests that it is really somebody else's job and you are doing them a favour. A home is not an army, with one person giving the orders while everyone else obeys or, worse, stands about waiting to be told. The housework is simply the price of living together, and in our house, at last, we all pay it.

You now need to refer only to Source B, paragraphs [4] to [6].

How does the writer use language to describe how his family changed the way they share the housework?

Model answer

The writer describes the change in his family with self-deprecating humour, using comic exaggeration to make a serious point about fairness. The decision is announced in a mock-formal register: "So we called a family meeting." This bureaucratic phrase makes family life sound like a business, which is funny but also serious. The parenthesis "(The children were thrilled. Ella rolled her eyes so hard I feared for her health.)" uses sarcasm and hyperbole to capture recognisable teenage reluctance. The emphatic "every single job" and "including the invisible ones" stress that nothing was left out.

The simile "Jake negotiated like a trade union official" extends the workplace language: a teenager demanding "compensation for cleaning the bathroom sink" is comic, but it also shows that housework is real work with a value. The understatement "The first few Wednesdays involved a great deal of smoke" makes Ella's failures affectionate rather than embarrassing, and the self-deprecating comparison that her curry "was better than anything I have ever produced" shows a father's pride.

Paragraph [5] begins with the honest short sentence "It hasn't been perfect." The hyperbole that the whiteboard "has caused more arguments than any other object in our house" and the mock-dramatic "one dark fortnight" turn a row about recycling into a comic crisis. The conjunction in "But something has changed." marks the turning point, and the anaphora of "I know where" and "I know when" builds a list of newly learned details, showing his growing awareness of the invisible work. The paragraph ends with bathos: "I have discovered, at the age of forty-four, the inside of our oven." The verb "discovered" makes him sound like an explorer, and delaying "the inside of our oven" to the end of the sentence creates a comic punchline at his own expense.

The tone becomes more serious in paragraph [6]. The dramatic statement "we have banned one word" focuses on the word 'helps', and the parallel analogy "You can't help in your own home, any more than you can help with your own life" sounds logical. The metaphor "A home is not an army" rejects a household run on orders, and the financial metaphor "the price of living together" insists that the cost should be shared. The closing words "at last, we all pay it" suggest both relief and a quiet admission of his own past failure.

Explanation

A Level 4 response analyses how the writer's humour (the mock-formal "family meeting", the trade-union simile, the bathos of "the inside of our oven") makes his point about shared responsibility persuasive rather than preachy, and how the tone becomes more serious in paragraph [6]. It explores the effect of the metaphors of the army and of the "price" of living together. Common pitfalls are retelling who does which chore, writing about Sam's list in paragraph [2], and identifying humour without explaining how it works.

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO2 (analysis of language).
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): Detailed, perceptive analysis: analyses the effects of the writer's choices of language; selects a range of judicious textual detail; sophisticated and accurate use of subject terminology.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): Clear, relevant explanation: explains clearly the effects of the writer's choices of language; selects a range of relevant textual detail; clear and accurate use of subject terminology.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): Some understanding and comment: attempts to comment on the effect of language; selects some appropriate textual detail; some use of subject terminology, mainly appropriate.
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Simple, limited comment: simple comment on the effect of language; simple references or textual details; simple use of subject terminology, not always appropriate.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The focus is how the family changed the way they share the housework. A response about language outside paragraphs [4] to [6], or from Source A (with the right focus), is placed in the level its quality deserves but at the bottom of that level; Level 3 and above need the correct focus. Language features may include:
    - mock-formal register "So we called a family meeting.": family life treated like a business; comic but serious
    - sarcasm and hyperbole in the parenthesis "(The children were thrilled. Ella rolled her eyes so hard I feared for her health.)": recognisable teenage reluctance
    - emphatic "every single job" and "including the invisible ones": nothing is left out, including the unnoticed work
    - simile "negotiated like a trade union official" and the workplace vocabulary of "compensation": comic, but presents housework as real work with a value
    - understatement "The first few Wednesdays involved a great deal of smoke" and the self-deprecating "better than anything I have ever produced": affection and pride
    - short, honest sentence "It hasn't been perfect."
    - hyperbole "more arguments than any other object in our house" and the mock-dramatic "one dark fortnight": a domestic row made into a comic crisis
    - turning point "But something has changed."
    - anaphora "I know where" / "I know when": growing awareness built through short parallel sentences
    - bathos and delayed punchline "I have discovered, at the age of forty-four, the inside of our oven.": the explorer's verb "discovered" mocks his former ignorance
    - "we have banned one word": a dramatic statement focusing on the word 'helps'
    - parallel analogy "You can't help in your own home, any more than you can help with your own life": a logical argument
    - metaphor "A home is not an army" with "giving the orders" and "waiting to be told": rejection of a hierarchy
    - financial metaphor "the price of living together" and "we all pay it", with "at last": fairness, relief and an admission of past failure
    Level 4 responses analyse how humour and self-mockery make the point about shared responsibility persuasive, and how the tone shifts in paragraph [6], rather than listing features.

Question 3

12 marks

Read the following source, then answer the question at the end.

Source B: 19th-century non-fiction
Rural Rides
by William Cobbett (1830)
William Cobbett, a farmer's son who became a campaigning journalist, rode on horseback through the English countryside in the 1820s to see for himself how farmers and farm labourers were living, and published his journals as Rural Rides (1830). In this entry, from September 1823, he rides across Romney Marsh in Kent. Cobbett believed that the government was making labourers poorer and emptying the villages, and he scorned writers who claimed that the population of England was growing. (15s. means fifteen shillings.)

[1] At three miles from Appledore I came through Snargate, a village with five houses, and with a church capable of containing two thousand people! The vagabonds tell us, however, that we have a wonderful increase of population! These vagabonds will be hanged by-and-by, or else justice will have fled from the face of the earth.

[2] At Brenzett (a mile further on) I with great difficulty got a rasher of bacon for breakfast. The few houses that there are are miserable in the extreme. The church here (only a mile from the last) nearly as large; and nobody to go to it. What! will the vagabonds attempt to make us believe that these churches were built for nothing! "Dark ages" indeed those must have been, if these churches were erected without there being any more people than there are now. But who built them? Where did the means, where did the hands come from? This place presents another proof of the truth of my old observation: rich land and poor labourers. From the window of the house, in which I could scarcely get a rasher of bacon, and not an egg, I saw numberless flocks and herds fatting, and the fields loaded with corn!

[3] The next village, which was two miles further on, was Old Romney, and along here I had, for great part of the way, corn-fields on one side of me and grass-land on the other. I asked what the amount of the crop of wheat would be. They told me better than five quarters to the acre. I thought so myself. I have a sample of the red wheat and another of the white. They are both very fine. They reap the wheat here nearly two feet from the ground; and even then they cut it three feet long! I never saw corn like this before. It very far exceeds the corn under Portsdown Hill, that at Gosport and Tichfield. They have here about eight hundred large, very large, sheaves to an acre. I wonder how long it will be after the end of the world before Mr. Birbeck will see the American "Prairies" half so good as this Marsh. In a garden here I saw some very fine onions, and a prodigious crop; sure sign of most excellent land. At this Old Romney there is a church (two miles only from the last, mind!) fit to contain one thousand five hundred people, and there are, for the people of the parish to live in, twenty-two, or twenty-three, houses! And yet the vagabonds have the impudence to tell us that the population of England has vastly increased! Curious system that depopulates Romney Marsh and peoples Bagshot Heath! It is an unnatural system. It is the vagabond's system. It is a system that must be destroyed, or that will destroy the country.

[4] The rotten borough of New Romney came next in my way; and here, to my great surprise, I found myself upon the sea-beach; for I had not looked at a map of Kent for years, and, perhaps, never. I had got a list of places from a friend in Sussex, whom I asked to give me a route to Dover, and to send me through those parts of Kent which he thought would be most interesting to me. Never was I so much surprised as when I saw a sail. This place, now that the squanderings of the THING are over, is, they say, become miserably poor.

[5] From New Romney to Dimchurch is about four miles: all along I had the sea-beach on my right, and, on my left, sometimes grass-land and sometimes corn-land. They told me here, and also further back in the Marsh, that they were to have 15s. an acre for reaping wheat.

You now need to refer only to Source B, paragraphs [1] to [2].

How does the writer use language to convey his anger about what he sees in the countryside?

Model answer

Cobbett conveys his anger through outraged exclamations, contemptuous name-calling and pointed contrasts that turn what he sees into evidence against those who claim the population is growing. He opens with a juxtaposition of numbers: Snargate is "a village with five houses, and with a church capable of containing two thousand people!" The exclamation mark shows his indignation, and the absurd mismatch suggests the village was once far larger, so readers see the decline for themselves. He then attacks his opponents with the derogatory noun "vagabonds", which brands educated writers as idle wanderers. The phrase "a wonderful increase of population!" is bitterly sarcastic, and the inclusive "tell us" positions the reader alongside him as a victim of their lies. The hyperbolic threat "These vagabonds will be hanged by-and-by, or else justice will have fled from the face of the earth" personifies justice as fleeing, giving his fury an almost biblical grandeur.

In paragraph [2] his eyewitness details build the case. The parentheses "(a mile further on)" and "(only a mile from the last)" stress how close these huge churches are, and "only" emphasises how many there must once have been. His own difficulty in getting "a rasher of bacon" makes the poverty personal, and the intensifying phrase "miserable in the extreme" sums up the houses. The elliptical clause "nearly as large; and nobody to go to it" has no main verb, so its blunt, clipped rhythm mirrors the emptiness he describes.

His anger then erupts in the interjection "What!" and the exclamatory question "will the vagabonds attempt to make us believe that these churches were built for nothing!", which sounds like a speaker shouting at a meeting. The ironic "Dark ages" mocks those who look down on the past, and the rhetorical questions "But who built them? Where did the means, where did the hands come from?" use repetition and the synecdoche of "hands" for labourers to force the reader to admit that the population has fallen.

Finally, the antithesis "rich land and poor labourers" condenses his argument into a memorable slogan. The last sentence juxtaposes his struggle to find "a rasher of bacon, and not an egg" with "numberless flocks and herds fatting, and the fields loaded with corn!" The hyperbole "numberless" and the verbs "fatting" and "loaded" stress abundance, so the reader shares his outrage that animals grow fat while people go hungry.

Explanation

A Level 4 response analyses how Cobbett's combative, exclamatory voice, his contemptuous repetition of "vagabonds" and his pointed juxtapositions (a tiny village with a vast church; hungry people beside "numberless flocks") work together to turn his observations into an argument. It explores the effect of sentence forms such as the elliptical "nearly as large; and nobody to go to it" and the rhetorical questions. Common pitfalls are summarising his journey, not recognising the sarcasm in "a wonderful increase of population!", and writing about the wheat crop or the 'unnatural system' in paragraph [3].

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO2 (analysis of language).
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): Detailed, perceptive analysis: analyses the effects of the writer's choices of language; selects a range of judicious textual detail; sophisticated and accurate use of subject terminology.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): Clear, relevant explanation: explains clearly the effects of the writer's choices of language; selects a range of relevant textual detail; clear and accurate use of subject terminology.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): Some understanding and comment: attempts to comment on the effect of language; selects some appropriate textual detail; some use of subject terminology, mainly appropriate.
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Simple, limited comment: simple comment on the effect of language; simple references or textual details; simple use of subject terminology, not always appropriate.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The focus is the writer's anger about what he sees in the countryside. A response about language outside paragraphs [1] to [2], or from Source A (with the right focus), is placed in the level its quality deserves but at the bottom of that level; Level 3 and above need the correct focus. Language features may include:
    - juxtaposition of numbers with an exclamation, "a village with five houses, and with a church capable of containing two thousand people!": evidence of decline that readers see for themselves
    - derogatory noun "vagabonds", repeated: contempt for those who claim the population is growing
    - sarcasm "a wonderful increase of population!" and the inclusive "tell us": the reader positioned beside him as a victim of their lies
    - hyperbolic threat and personification "These vagabonds will be hanged by-and-by, or else justice will have fled from the face of the earth": fury with an almost biblical grandeur
    - eyewitness parentheses "(a mile further on)" and "(only a mile from the last)": precise evidence; "only" stresses how many large churches there are
    - personal hardship "with great difficulty got a rasher of bacon" and the intensifying "miserable in the extreme"
    - elliptical, verbless clause "nearly as large; and nobody to go to it": a clipped rhythm that mirrors the emptiness
    - interjection and exclamatory question "What! will the vagabonds attempt to make us believe that these churches were built for nothing!": the voice of a speaker shouting at a meeting
    - irony in "Dark ages" and "indeed": mockery of those who look down on the past
    - rhetorical questions and repetition "But who built them? Where did the means, where did the hands come from?", with the synecdoche "hands" for labourers
    - antithesis and slogan "rich land and poor labourers", introduced as "my old observation": confident authority
    - final juxtaposition of "a rasher of bacon, and not an egg" with "numberless flocks and herds fatting, and the fields loaded with corn!": hyperbole and the verbs "fatting" and "loaded" stress abundance beside hunger
    - informal, combative, exclamatory register throughout
    Level 4 responses analyse how exclamation, contempt and pointed juxtaposition turn his observations into an angry argument, and how sentence forms convey his mood, rather than listing features.

Question 4

12 marks

Read the following source, then answer the question at the end.

Source A: 19th-century non-fiction
Woman's Dress
by Oscar Wilde (1884)
In 1884 the writer Oscar Wilde (1854-1900) gave public lectures on dress, arguing that clothes should be healthy, comfortable and beautiful rather than merely fashionable. This is an extract from a letter he wrote to the Pall Mall Gazette, published on 14 October 1884, replying to readers who had written to the newspaper about his ideas; it begins with the newspaper's own introduction.

[1] MR. OSCAR WILDE, who asks us to permit him 'that most charming of all pleasures, the pleasure of answering one's critics,' sends us the following remarks: -

[2] THE "Girl Graduate" must of course have precedence, not merely for her sex but for her sanity: her letter is extremely sensible. She makes two points: that high heels are a necessity for any lady who wishes to keep her dress clean from the Stygian mud of our streets, and that without a tight corset the ordinary number of petticoats and etceteras' cannot be properly or conveniently held up. Now, it is quite true that as long as the lower garments are suspended from the hips a corset is an absolute necessity; the mistake lies in not suspending all apparel from the shoulders. In the latter case a corset becomes useless, the body is left free and unconfined for respiration and motion, there is more health, and consequently more beauty. Indeed all the most ungainly and uncomfortable articles of dress that fashion has ever in her folly prescribed, not the tight corset merely, but the farthingale, the vertugadin, the hoop, the crinoline, and that modern monstrosity the so-called "dress improver" also, all of them have owed their origin to the same error, the error of not seeing that it is from the shoulders, and from the shoulders only, that all garments should be hung.

[3] And as regards high heels, I quite admit that some additional height to the shoe or boot is necessary if long gowns are to be worn in the street; but what I object to is that the height should be given to the heel only, and not to the sole of the foot also. The modern high-heeled boot is, in fact, merely the clog of the time of Henry VI., with the front prop left out, and its inevitable effect is to throw the body forward, to shorten the steps, and consequently to produce that want of grace which always follows want of freedom.

[4] Why should clogs be despised? Much art has been expended on clogs. They have been made of lovely woods, and delicately inlaid with ivory, and with mother-of-pearl. A clog might be a dream of beauty, and, if not too high or too heavy, most comfortable also. But if there be any who do not like clogs, let them try some adaptation of the trouser of the Turkish lady, which is loose round the limb and tight at the ankle.

[5] The "Girl Graduate," with a pathos to which I am not insensible, entreats me not to apotheosize "that awful, befringed, beflounced, and bekilted divided skirt." Well, I will acknowledge that the fringes, the flounces, and the kilting do certainly defeat the whole object of the dress, which is that of ease and liberty; but I regard these things as mere wicked superfluities, tragic proofs that the divided skirt is ashamed of its own division. The principle of the dress is good, and, though it is not by any means perfection, it is a step towards it.

You now need to refer only to Source A, paragraphs [2] to [3].

How does the writer use language to convey his views on fashionable women's clothing?

Model answer

Wilde conveys his view that fashionable clothing is unhealthy and ugly by combining courteous concession with witty, authoritative argument. He opens graciously: the "Girl Graduate" deserves precedence "not merely for her sex but for her sanity", a balanced phrase whose alliteration turns a compliment into a joke, and "extremely sensible" makes him seem generous to his critics. Even in summarising her points, the language is playful. The hyperbolic allusion to "the Stygian mud of our streets" compares London's roads to the River Styx in the classical underworld, a mock-epic touch, and the vague "petticoats and etceteras" makes the layers of fashionable dress sound comically endless.

His argument is presented with confident logic. "Now, it is quite true that" concedes a point before "the mistake lies in" corrects it, giving him the authority of a teacher. The list "the body is left free and unconfined for respiration and motion, there is more health, and consequently more beauty" links freedom to health and health to beauty, and the connective "consequently" makes this sound like a law. The personification "fashion has ever in her folly prescribed" presents fashion as a foolish woman, or a bad doctor, and the alliteration stresses her silliness. The list "the farthingale, the vertugadin, the hoop, the crinoline" uses exotic historical names to suggest centuries of the same mistake, building to the alliterative climax "that modern monstrosity". The scornful "so-called" exposes the irony of a "dress improver" that improves nothing, and the repetition in "the same error, the error of" and "from the shoulders, and from the shoulders only" hammers his point home.

In paragraph [3] he again concedes, "I quite admit", before stating firmly "what I object to". The deflating comparison "merely the clog of the time of Henry VI., with the front prop left out" reveals the fashionable boot as an old, defective design, and "merely" belittles it. The tricolon of infinitives, "to throw the body forward, to shorten the steps, and consequently to produce", traces the harmful effects step by step. His conclusion is an epigram: "that want of grace which always follows want of freedom". The repetition of "want" links beauty and liberty, summing up his belief that clothes which restrict women's bodies can never be truly beautiful.

Explanation

A Level 4 response analyses how Wilde blends courtesy and wit with confident logic, for example the playful balance of "not merely for her sex but for her sanity", the personification of fashion's "folly", the scornful "so-called" and the closing epigram linking grace and freedom, and how connectives such as "consequently" make his opinions sound like laws. It explores the effect of historical references such as the farthingale and the clog. Common pitfalls are summarising the argument about corsets without analysing language, attributing the Girl Graduate's points to Wilde, and writing about clogs and the divided skirt in paragraphs [4] and [5].

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO2 (analysis of language).
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): Detailed, perceptive analysis: analyses the effects of the writer's choices of language; selects a range of judicious textual detail; sophisticated and accurate use of subject terminology.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): Clear, relevant explanation: explains clearly the effects of the writer's choices of language; selects a range of relevant textual detail; clear and accurate use of subject terminology.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): Some understanding and comment: attempts to comment on the effect of language; selects some appropriate textual detail; some use of subject terminology, mainly appropriate.
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Simple, limited comment: simple comment on the effect of language; simple references or textual details; simple use of subject terminology, not always appropriate.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The focus is the writer's views on fashionable women's clothing. A response about language outside paragraphs [2] to [3], or from Source B (with the right focus), is placed in the level its quality deserves but at the bottom of that level; Level 3 and above need the correct focus. Language features may include:
    - witty balanced phrase and alliteration "not merely for her sex but for her sanity", with "extremely sensible": courtesy to a critic that makes him seem generous
    - classical allusion and hyperbole "the Stygian mud of our streets": London's roads as the River Styx of the underworld; mock-epic humour
    - vague, comic "petticoats and etceteras": the endless layers of fashionable dress
    - concession and correction "Now, it is quite true that" ... "the mistake lies in": the authority of a teacher
    - list linking cause and effect "the body is left free and unconfined for respiration and motion, there is more health, and consequently more beauty": freedom, health and beauty connected; "consequently" makes it sound like a law
    - personification and alliteration "fashion has ever in her folly prescribed": fashion as a foolish woman or a bad doctor
    - superlatives "the most ungainly and uncomfortable articles of dress"
    - list of historical garments "the farthingale, the vertugadin, the hoop, the crinoline": centuries of the same mistake, building to the alliterative climax "that modern monstrosity"
    - scornful "so-called" before "dress improver": irony, since it improves nothing
    - repetition "the same error, the error of" and "from the shoulders, and from the shoulders only": emphatic insistence
    - concession "I quite admit" followed by "what I object to": a reasonable but firm voice
    - deflating comparison "merely the clog of the time of Henry VI., with the front prop left out": the fashionable boot revealed as an old, defective design
    - tricolon of infinitives "to throw the body forward, to shorten the steps, and consequently to produce": harmful effects traced step by step
    - epigram "that want of grace which always follows want of freedom": the repetition of "want" links beauty and liberty
    Level 4 responses analyse how courtesy, wit and confident logic work together to persuade, and how the formal register shapes his authority, rather than listing features.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.