Question 1
16 marksRead Source A and Source B, then answer the question at the end.
Source A: 19th-century non-fiction
London Labour and the London Poor
by Henry Mayhew (1851)
Henry Mayhew was a journalist who interviewed hundreds of people who made their living on the streets of London, and published their accounts in London Labour and the London Poor (1851). In this extract an eight-year-old girl who buys watercress at Farringdon Market before dawn and sells it in bunches in the streets describes her life in her own words, as Mayhew wrote them down; in the money of the time, twelve pence (d.) made one shilling (s.).
[1] "It's very cold before winter comes on reg'lar - specially getting up of a morning. I gets up in the dark by the light of the lamp in the court. When the snow is on the ground, there's no creases. I bears the cold - you must; so I puts my hands under my shawl, though it hurts 'em to take hold of the creases, especially when we takes 'em to the pump to wash 'em. No; I never see any children crying - it's no use.
[2] "Sometimes I make a great deal of money. One day I took 1s. 6d., and the creases cost 6d.; but it isn't often I get such luck as that. I oftener makes 3d. or 4d. than 1s.; and then I'm at work, crying, 'Creases, four bunches a penny, creases!' from six in the morning to about ten. What do you mean by mechanics? - I don't know what they are. The shops buys most of me. Some of 'em says, 'Oh! I ain't a-goin' to give a penny for these;' and they want 'em at the same price as I buys 'em at.
[3] "I always give mother my money, she's so very good to me. She don't often beat me; but, when she do, she don't play with me. She's very poor, and goes out cleaning rooms sometimes, now she don't work at the fur. I ain't got no father, he's a father-in-law. No; mother ain't married again - he's a father-in-law. He grinds scissors, and he's very good to me. No; I dont mean by that that he says kind things to me, for he never hardly speaks. When I gets home, after selling creases, I stops at home. I puts the room to rights: mother don't make me do it, I does it myself. I cleans the chairs, though there's only two to clean. I takes a tub and scrubbing-brush and flannel, and scrubs the floor - that's what I do three or four times a week.
[4] "I don't have no dinner. Mother gives me two slices of bread-and-butter and a cup of tea for breakfast, and then I go till tea, and has the same. We has meat of a Sunday, and, of course, I should like to have it every day. Mother has just the same to eat as we has, but she takes more tea - three cups, sometimes. No; I never has no sweet-stuff; I never buy none - I don't like it. Sometimes we has a game of 'honey-pots' with the girls in the court, but not often. Me and Carry H---- carries the little 'uns. We plays, too, at 'kiss-in-the-ring.' I knows a good many games, but I don't play at 'em, 'cos going out with creases tires me. On a Friday night, too, I goes to a Jew's house till eleven o'clock on Saturday night. All I has to do is to snuff the candles and poke the fire. You see they keep their Sabbath then, and they won't touch anything; so they gives me my wittals and 1-1/2d., and I does it for 'em. I have a reg'lar good lot to eat. Supper of Friday night, and tea after that, and fried fish of a Saturday morning, and meat for dinner, and tea, and supper, and I like it very well.
[5] "Oh, yes; I've got some toys at home. I've a fire-place, and a box of toys, and a knife and fork, and two little chairs. The Jews gave 'em to me where I go to on a Friday, and that's why I said they was very kind to me. I never had no doll; but I misses little sister - she's only two years old. We don't sleep in the same room; for father and mother sleeps with little sister in the one pair, and me and brother and other sister sleeps in the top room. I always goes to bed at seven, 'cos I has to be up so early.
Source B: 21st-century non-fiction
The Children Who Keep Their Families Going
by Priya Malhotra (fictional)
This is an extract from an article published in a national newspaper in 2023. The writer, a journalist, spends a morning with a thirteen-year-old girl who helps to look after her mother, who has multiple sclerosis, and her younger brother.
[1] At a quarter past six on a Tuesday morning, while most thirteen-year-olds are still asleep, Ellie is standing in her kitchen in a small Midlands town, counting her mother's tablets into a plastic box with the days of the week printed on its lids. She does it quickly, without looking at the labels. She has done it every morning since she was nine.
[2] Her mother, Jo, has multiple sclerosis, a condition that damages the nerves and can leave her exhausted, unsteady on her feet and, on bad days, unable to get out of bed. Ellie's father left when she was small. So before school, Ellie helps her mum to the bathroom, makes breakfast for her seven-year-old brother, checks that he has his reading book and walks him to the school gate. Then she runs, because her own school starts at twenty to nine and is a mile and a half away.
[3] 'People think it must be awful,' she tells me, with the patient expression of someone who has explained this many times before. 'It's not awful. It's just my life. I like knowing Mum's OK.' She shrugs. 'The worst bit is when teachers have a go at you for being late and you can't say why.'
[4] Ellie, whose name has been changed, is one of the country's young carers: children who look after a parent, brother, sister or grandparent who is ill or disabled, or who struggles with their mental health or with addiction. The last census counted around 120,000 of them in England and Wales, some as young as five. Charities believe the real figure is far higher, because many children do not know the word applies to them, and many families fear that if they ask for help, someone will try to split them up.
[5] What does that mean in practice? It means homework done at midnight, after the washing-up. It means missed school trips and missed sleepovers, because who would look after Mum? It means a child who can order a repeat prescription but has never been to a friend's birthday party. Young carers are more likely than their classmates to miss school, to fall behind and to feel lonely, anxious or worn out. Many of them are brilliant at hiding it.
[6] It is tempting to call children like Ellie inspiring, and in a sense they are. Watching her coax her mother into a chair with a joke and a cushion, I was moved almost to tears by her tenderness and her competence. But 'inspiring' can also be a way of letting the rest of us off the hook. A thirteen-year-old should not be her family's only safety net. She should not have to choose between her mother's medication and her maths test.
[7] There is help, for those who know where to look. Some councils run young carers' groups, where children can spend an evening bowling or baking with others who understand. Some schools give young carers a card that lets them keep their phone switched on in case home calls, or a quiet word with a teacher instead of a detention for lateness. Ellie's school has just started a group, and she went for the first time last week. 'It was weird,' she says, smiling properly for the first time all morning. 'Nobody asked me why I looked tired.'
For this question, you need to refer to the whole of Source A, together with the whole of Source B.
Compare how the writers convey their different perspectives on children who take on adult responsibilities in their families.
In your answer, you could:
- compare their different perspectives on these children and their responsibilities
- compare the methods the writers use to convey their perspectives
- support your response with references to both texts.
Model answer
Both texts give us a child's own voice, but they convey very different perspectives on that child's responsibilities. Mayhew lets the watercress girl speak almost without interruption, and she presents her hard life simply as the way things are; Malhotra records Ellie's acceptance too, but surrounds it with her own argument that no child should carry such a burden.
The girl's attitude to hardship is stoical to the point of being shocking. "I bears the cold - you must", she says, and the blunt "must" shows she has never imagined an alternative; children do not cry because "it's no use". Ellie's words are strikingly similar - "It's not awful. It's just my life" - yet the writers frame them differently. Mayhew adds no comment, keeping the girl's non-standard grammar ("I gets up in the dark") and even traces of his own questions ("What do you mean by mechanics?"), so that her innocence speaks for itself and the reader must supply the outrage. Malhotra intervenes directly: "A thirteen-year-old should not be her family's only safety net."
Both children take pride in caring for their families. The girl gives her money to her mother because "she's so very good to me" and insists "mother don't make me do it, I does it myself". Ellie says "I like knowing Mum's OK". Malhotra, however, presents this devotion more critically: her opening image of Ellie counting tablets "without looking at the labels" shows a competence that is admirable but troubling, because she "has done it every morning since she was nine".
The loss of childhood is conveyed through understatement in Source A and through rhetoric in Source B. The girl knows many games but says "I don't play at 'em, 'cos going out with creases tires me", and "I never had no doll"; these details hurt more because she does not dwell on them. Malhotra uses anaphora - "It means homework done at midnight... It means missed school trips" - and the rhetorical question "who would look after Mum?" to make the losses unmistakable, ending with the antithesis of a child who can "order a repeat prescription but has never been to a friend's birthday party".
Purpose and context explain these methods. Mayhew wrote in 1851 for middle-class readers who had probably never spoken to a street child, in an age with no welfare state; her account of pennies, bread-and-butter and a kind household that gives her "my wittals" exposes a life with no safety net at all. Malhotra writes when help exists but is hidden, so she uses statistics ("around 120,000") and rejects the comfortable word "inspiring" as "a way of letting the rest of us off the hook". Her ending is cautiously hopeful, as Ellie smiles "properly for the first time all morning" at the young carers' group. The girl's extract ends in flat routine - "I always goes to bed at seven, 'cos I has to be up so early" - offering no hope of change at all.
Explanation
A Level 4 answer compares how the perspectives are conveyed, not just the facts of each child's life: it notices that both children accept their responsibilities as normal, and analyses how Mayhew's uncommented monologue and Malhotra's explicit argument lead readers to judge that acceptance. Judicious, embedded quotations from both sources and awareness of context, such as the absence of any welfare system in 1851, lift a response further. Common pitfalls are treating Source A as Mayhew's own experience, simply listing the girl's hardships, and writing about one source after the other with no real comparison.
Mark scheme
-
16 marks
Levels of response (16 marks). AO3 (comparison of ideas and perspectives).
Level 4 (13-16 marks): Perceptive, detailed comparison: compares ideas and perspectives in a perceptive way; analyses how the writers' methods are used; selects a range of judicious supporting detail from both texts; shows a detailed and perceptive understanding of the different (or similar) ideas and perspectives in both texts.
Level 3 (9-12 marks): Clear, relevant comparison: compares ideas and perspectives in a clear and relevant way; explains clearly how the writers' methods are used; selects relevant detail to support from both texts; shows a clear understanding of the different (or similar) ideas and perspectives in both texts.
Level 2 (5-8 marks): Some attempts at comparison: attempts to compare ideas and perspectives; some comment on how the writers' methods are used; selects some appropriate textual detail, not always supporting, from one or both texts; shows some understanding of the ideas and perspectives.
Level 1 (1-4 marks): Simple, limited comment: simple cross-reference of ideas and perspectives; simple identification of the writers' methods; simple reference(s) or textual detail(s) from one or both texts; simple awareness of ideas and/or perspectives.
0 marks: nothing to reward.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): An answer that deals with only one text has a maximum of 2 marks at Level 1 quality and 6 marks at Level 2 quality; Level 3 and above need both texts. References to the writers' methods may be implicit. In Source A the perspective is mainly the girl's, given in her own words as Mayhew recorded them; credit answers that write about 'the girl', 'the writer' or 'Mayhew', and perceptive answers may consider Mayhew's choice to let her speak without comment. Perspectives: the watercress girl (Source A, 1851) accepts cold, hunger and work as normal, without self-pity, and takes pride in helping her mother; Malhotra (Source B, 2023) admires Ellie's tenderness and competence but argues that no child should carry such responsibility and that the rest of society must help. Points of comparison may include: acceptance - "I bears the cold - you must" and "it's no use", against Ellie's "It's not awful. It's just my life", which Malhotra then questions; framing - Mayhew's monologue without authorial comment, keeping non-standard grammar ("I gets up in the dark") and traces of his questions ("What do you mean by mechanics?"), so the reader must judge, against Malhotra's explicit argument ("A thirteen-year-old should not be her family's only safety net"; "She should not have to choose between her mother's medication and her maths test"); loyalty and pride - "I always give mother my money, she's so very good to me", "mother don't make me do it, I does it myself", and Ellie's "I like knowing Mum's OK"; lost childhood - understatement in "I never had no doll" and "I don't play at 'em, 'cos going out with creases tires me", against Malhotra's anaphora ("It means homework done at midnight... It means missed school trips"), the rhetorical question "who would look after Mum?" and the child who can "order a repeat prescription" but has never been to a party; openings - the girl's dawn "by the light of the lamp in the court" and her sums in pennies, Ellie counting tablets "at a quarter past six"; evidence - personal testimony against Malhotra's statistics ("around 120,000") and research on young carers; praise - Malhotra's rejection of "inspiring" as "a way of letting the rest of us off the hook"; endings - the flat routine of "I always goes to bed at seven, 'cos I has to be up so early", against Ellie smiling "properly for the first time all morning" at the new group; context - 1851, when child labour was ordinary, there was no welfare state and Mayhew's middle-class readers had rarely heard such voices, against 2023, when help exists but is often hidden. Level 4 responses compare perceptively how the two writers' methods shape the reader's judgement of the children's acceptance, with judicious detail from both texts; Level 3 responses explain the different perspectives clearly; answers that simply list each child's hardships are unlikely to rise above Level 2.