Question 1
40 marks'Newspapers and television news are dinosaurs. Young people now get their news from social media, and it is just as reliable as anything printed or broadcast.'
Write an article for a news website aimed at young people in which you explain your point of view on this statement.
(24 marks for content and organisation
16 marks for technical accuracy)
Model answer
Fast, Free and Frequently Wrong: Why Your Feed Is Not the News
Social media brings us headlines in seconds. But before we bury the newspaper, we should ask who checks the facts.
Picture the scene. It is late on a school night and a video is racing around every group chat you belong to: a famous building is on fire, or a shark has been spotted in a city canal. Within an hour, you have seen it fifty times. Within two, someone points out that the clip is three years old, from another country, and the shark is a piece of floating rubbish. By then, of course, it is too late. Millions of people have already 'learned' something that never happened.
Let us be honest: the statement is half right. For most people my age, printed newspapers are something our grandparents read, and the evening news is background noise while our parents cook. We get our headlines from social media, often before the broadcasters do. When something happens anywhere in the world, someone is usually filming it. That speed is genuinely powerful. Ordinary people with phones have exposed injustices that might otherwise have stayed hidden, and young creators explain complicated stories - elections, wars, the cost of living - in ways that actually make sense to teenagers.
So no, I am not going to tell you to delete your apps and subscribe to a paper. But 'just as reliable'? That is where the argument falls apart.
The difference between a post and a report is not the format; it is the process behind it. A professional news organisation, whatever its faults, checks sources, confirms facts with more than one witness and employs editors whose job is to ask awkward questions before anything is published. When it gets something wrong, it can be challenged, complained about and made to publish a correction. An anonymous account with a million followers answers to no one. It can post a rumour at breakfast, delete it at lunch and carry on as though nothing happened.
Then there is the algorithm. Your feed does not show you what is true or important; it shows you what will keep you scrolling. Outrage spreads faster than nuance. A calm explanation of a complicated issue will lose every time to a furious thirty-second clip, which is why so many of us end up angrier but not much better informed. Worse, the feed learns what you already believe and serves you more of it, until it feels as though everyone agrees with you. Real news should sometimes tell you what you do not want to hear.
Supporters of the statement might reply that traditional media is biased too, and they have a point. Newspapers have owners; channels have agendas. But the answer to imperfect journalism is better journalism, not none at all. Many of the most-shared posts online are themselves based on work by reporters who spent months investigating a story. Take away the dinosaurs and the clever creators would have far less to talk about.
So what should we do? Use social media as a doorbell, not a front room. Let it alert you that something is happening - then go and find out properly. Before you share, ask three questions: Who made this? How do they know? Where else is it being reported? Follow some real journalists alongside your favourite creators. Read beyond the headline. It takes thirty seconds longer, and it could stop you spreading the next floating-rubbish shark.
The dinosaurs, it turns out, have evolved. Most of them live on our phones now, too. The challenge for our generation is not choosing between old and new media, but learning to tell the difference between news and noise.
Explanation
A top-band response to this statement avoids a simple 'old good, new bad' answer and explains a nuanced position, as this one does by agreeing that social media is fast and valuable while showing exactly why it is not 'just as reliable'. The writing is lifted by a vivid opening scenario, clear explanations of editing and algorithms that a young reader can follow, a fair concession about bias that is then rebutted, and a controlled analogy (a doorbell, not a front room) that turns into practical advice. Common pitfalls are sweeping claims that everything online is fake, a lecturing tone that alienates young readers, and failing to engage with the word 'reliable'.
Mark scheme
-
24 marks
Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation).
Level 4 (19-24 marks): Compelling, convincing communication. Upper (22-24): convincing and compelling; tone, style and register assuredly matched to purpose and audience; extensive, ambitious vocabulary, sustained crafting of devices; varied, inventive structure; convincing, complex ideas; fluent paragraphs, seamless discourse markers. Lower (19-21): convincing; register convincingly matched; extensive vocabulary, conscious crafting of devices; varied, effective structure; highly engaging, developed complex ideas; consistently coherent paragraphs.
Level 3 (13-18 marks): Consistent, clear communication. Upper (16-18): consistently clear; tone, style and register consistently matched; increasingly sophisticated vocabulary, successful devices; effective structure; engaging, connected ideas; coherent paragraphs, integrated discourse markers. Lower (13-15): generally clear; register generally matched; vocabulary chosen for effect, appropriate devices; usually effective structure; connected ideas; usually coherent paragraphs.
Level 2 (7-12 marks): Some successful communication. Upper (10-12): some sustained success; sustained attempt to match tone, style and register; conscious vocabulary, some devices; some structural features; increasingly varied linked ideas; some paragraphs and discourse markers. Lower (7-9): some success; attempts to match register; begins to vary vocabulary; attempts structural features; some linked ideas; attempts paragraphs.
Level 1 (1-6 marks): Simple, limited communication. Upper (4-6): communicates simply; simple awareness of tone and register; simple vocabulary and devices; simple structural features; one or two ideas, simply linked; random paragraphing. Lower (1-3): limited communication; occasional sense of register; simple vocabulary; little or no structure; one or two unlinked ideas; no paragraphs.
0 marks: nothing to reward.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Purpose: to explain a point of view on whether news from social media is as reliable as newspapers and television news. Audience: young readers of a news website - digitally fluent, likely to get much of their news from social media themselves and perhaps distrustful of 'old' media; the tone should respect their experience without being preachy. Form: an online article with a headline and strapline, a hook, short-to-medium paragraphs, perhaps subheadings or a set of practical tips, and a conclusion. Students may agree, disagree or take a balanced view: reward the quality of the writing, not the opinion. Points that support the statement might include: social media is fast and often first with breaking news; eyewitness footage can expose events and injustices; young creators explain complicated stories in accessible ways; traditional media has owners, biases and agendas of its own; social media gives a voice to people traditionally ignored by the press; many established news organisations publish on social media too. Points against it might include: posts are rarely fact-checked or edited; misinformation spreads, including old or doctored clips; algorithms reward outrage over accuracy and create echo chambers; anonymous accounts are not accountable and need not print corrections; much of what is shared depends on the work of professional journalists; reliability depends on the source, not the platform. A top-band response is likely to: take a nuanced, clearly signalled line (for example, that social media is a useful alert but not a reliable source on its own); open with a vivid scenario of misinformation spreading; concede what the statement gets right and then rebut its claim of equal reliability; explain how journalism and algorithms actually work; use controlled devices (an extended analogy, rhetorical questions, a list of questions to ask before sharing); and end by turning the 'dinosaur' image back on the statement. Weaker responses tend to assert that 'social media is all fake news' or that 'newspapers are boring' without explanation.
-
16 marks
Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
Level 4 (13-16 marks): sentence demarcation consistently secure and consistently accurate; a wide range of punctuation used with a high level of accuracy; a full range of appropriate sentence forms for effect; Standard English used consistently and appropriately, with secure control of complex grammatical structures; a high level of accuracy in spelling, including ambitious vocabulary; extensive and ambitious vocabulary.
Level 3 (9-12 marks): sentence demarcation mostly secure and mostly accurate; a range of punctuation, mostly used with success; a variety of sentence forms for effect; Standard English mostly used appropriately, with mostly controlled grammatical structures; generally accurate spelling, including complex and irregular words; increasingly sophisticated vocabulary.
Level 2 (5-8 marks): sentence demarcation mostly secure and sometimes accurate; some control of a range of punctuation; attempts a variety of sentence forms; some use of Standard English, with some control of agreement; some accurate spelling of more complex words; varied vocabulary.
Level 1 (1-4 marks): occasional sentence demarcation; some evidence of conscious punctuation; a simple range of sentence forms; occasional use of Standard English, with limited control of agreement; accurate basic spelling; simple vocabulary.
0 marks: nothing to reward.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Technical accuracy is judged across the whole response, separately from the quality of the ideas. Look for: secure sentence demarcation (no comma splices or run-on sentences); a wide range of punctuation used accurately (colons, semi-colons, dashes, question marks in a list of questions, inverted commas around quoted words such as 'just as reliable', apostrophes such as 'grandparents' paper'); a full range of sentence forms for effect, including short sentences for emphasis and complex sentences that explain cause and effect; Standard English with secure control of grammar, including agreement and consistent tense; accurate spelling, including ambitious vocabulary the task invites (e.g. 'misinformation', 'accountable', 'algorithm', 'independent', 'nuance'); and extensive, precise vocabulary. An online article for young readers can be lively, but it should remain in Standard English. A response with nothing meaningful to assess scores 0 on both points.