Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/7

Viewpoint writing: articles (Q5)

Practise 34 exam-style questions on Viewpoint writing: articles (Q5) for AQA GCSE English Language (Paper 2). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 34 questions
  • 40 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

40 marks

'Newspapers and television news are dinosaurs. Young people now get their news from social media, and it is just as reliable as anything printed or broadcast.'

Write an article for a news website aimed at young people in which you explain your point of view on this statement.

(24 marks for content and organisation
16 marks for technical accuracy)

Model answer

Fast, Free and Frequently Wrong: Why Your Feed Is Not the News
Social media brings us headlines in seconds. But before we bury the newspaper, we should ask who checks the facts.

Picture the scene. It is late on a school night and a video is racing around every group chat you belong to: a famous building is on fire, or a shark has been spotted in a city canal. Within an hour, you have seen it fifty times. Within two, someone points out that the clip is three years old, from another country, and the shark is a piece of floating rubbish. By then, of course, it is too late. Millions of people have already 'learned' something that never happened.

Let us be honest: the statement is half right. For most people my age, printed newspapers are something our grandparents read, and the evening news is background noise while our parents cook. We get our headlines from social media, often before the broadcasters do. When something happens anywhere in the world, someone is usually filming it. That speed is genuinely powerful. Ordinary people with phones have exposed injustices that might otherwise have stayed hidden, and young creators explain complicated stories - elections, wars, the cost of living - in ways that actually make sense to teenagers.

So no, I am not going to tell you to delete your apps and subscribe to a paper. But 'just as reliable'? That is where the argument falls apart.

The difference between a post and a report is not the format; it is the process behind it. A professional news organisation, whatever its faults, checks sources, confirms facts with more than one witness and employs editors whose job is to ask awkward questions before anything is published. When it gets something wrong, it can be challenged, complained about and made to publish a correction. An anonymous account with a million followers answers to no one. It can post a rumour at breakfast, delete it at lunch and carry on as though nothing happened.

Then there is the algorithm. Your feed does not show you what is true or important; it shows you what will keep you scrolling. Outrage spreads faster than nuance. A calm explanation of a complicated issue will lose every time to a furious thirty-second clip, which is why so many of us end up angrier but not much better informed. Worse, the feed learns what you already believe and serves you more of it, until it feels as though everyone agrees with you. Real news should sometimes tell you what you do not want to hear.

Supporters of the statement might reply that traditional media is biased too, and they have a point. Newspapers have owners; channels have agendas. But the answer to imperfect journalism is better journalism, not none at all. Many of the most-shared posts online are themselves based on work by reporters who spent months investigating a story. Take away the dinosaurs and the clever creators would have far less to talk about.

So what should we do? Use social media as a doorbell, not a front room. Let it alert you that something is happening - then go and find out properly. Before you share, ask three questions: Who made this? How do they know? Where else is it being reported? Follow some real journalists alongside your favourite creators. Read beyond the headline. It takes thirty seconds longer, and it could stop you spreading the next floating-rubbish shark.

The dinosaurs, it turns out, have evolved. Most of them live on our phones now, too. The challenge for our generation is not choosing between old and new media, but learning to tell the difference between news and noise.

Explanation

A top-band response to this statement avoids a simple 'old good, new bad' answer and explains a nuanced position, as this one does by agreeing that social media is fast and valuable while showing exactly why it is not 'just as reliable'. The writing is lifted by a vivid opening scenario, clear explanations of editing and algorithms that a young reader can follow, a fair concession about bias that is then rebutted, and a controlled analogy (a doorbell, not a front room) that turns into practical advice. Common pitfalls are sweeping claims that everything online is fake, a lecturing tone that alienates young readers, and failing to engage with the word 'reliable'.

Mark scheme
  1. 24 marks

    Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation).
    Level 4 (19-24 marks): Compelling, convincing communication. Upper (22-24): convincing and compelling; tone, style and register assuredly matched to purpose and audience; extensive, ambitious vocabulary, sustained crafting of devices; varied, inventive structure; convincing, complex ideas; fluent paragraphs, seamless discourse markers. Lower (19-21): convincing; register convincingly matched; extensive vocabulary, conscious crafting of devices; varied, effective structure; highly engaging, developed complex ideas; consistently coherent paragraphs.
    Level 3 (13-18 marks): Consistent, clear communication. Upper (16-18): consistently clear; tone, style and register consistently matched; increasingly sophisticated vocabulary, successful devices; effective structure; engaging, connected ideas; coherent paragraphs, integrated discourse markers. Lower (13-15): generally clear; register generally matched; vocabulary chosen for effect, appropriate devices; usually effective structure; connected ideas; usually coherent paragraphs.
    Level 2 (7-12 marks): Some successful communication. Upper (10-12): some sustained success; sustained attempt to match tone, style and register; conscious vocabulary, some devices; some structural features; increasingly varied linked ideas; some paragraphs and discourse markers. Lower (7-9): some success; attempts to match register; begins to vary vocabulary; attempts structural features; some linked ideas; attempts paragraphs.
    Level 1 (1-6 marks): Simple, limited communication. Upper (4-6): communicates simply; simple awareness of tone and register; simple vocabulary and devices; simple structural features; one or two ideas, simply linked; random paragraphing. Lower (1-3): limited communication; occasional sense of register; simple vocabulary; little or no structure; one or two unlinked ideas; no paragraphs.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Purpose: to explain a point of view on whether news from social media is as reliable as newspapers and television news. Audience: young readers of a news website - digitally fluent, likely to get much of their news from social media themselves and perhaps distrustful of 'old' media; the tone should respect their experience without being preachy. Form: an online article with a headline and strapline, a hook, short-to-medium paragraphs, perhaps subheadings or a set of practical tips, and a conclusion. Students may agree, disagree or take a balanced view: reward the quality of the writing, not the opinion. Points that support the statement might include: social media is fast and often first with breaking news; eyewitness footage can expose events and injustices; young creators explain complicated stories in accessible ways; traditional media has owners, biases and agendas of its own; social media gives a voice to people traditionally ignored by the press; many established news organisations publish on social media too. Points against it might include: posts are rarely fact-checked or edited; misinformation spreads, including old or doctored clips; algorithms reward outrage over accuracy and create echo chambers; anonymous accounts are not accountable and need not print corrections; much of what is shared depends on the work of professional journalists; reliability depends on the source, not the platform. A top-band response is likely to: take a nuanced, clearly signalled line (for example, that social media is a useful alert but not a reliable source on its own); open with a vivid scenario of misinformation spreading; concede what the statement gets right and then rebut its claim of equal reliability; explain how journalism and algorithms actually work; use controlled devices (an extended analogy, rhetorical questions, a list of questions to ask before sharing); and end by turning the 'dinosaur' image back on the statement. Weaker responses tend to assert that 'social media is all fake news' or that 'newspapers are boring' without explanation.

  2. 16 marks

    Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
    Level 4 (13-16 marks): sentence demarcation consistently secure and consistently accurate; a wide range of punctuation used with a high level of accuracy; a full range of appropriate sentence forms for effect; Standard English used consistently and appropriately, with secure control of complex grammatical structures; a high level of accuracy in spelling, including ambitious vocabulary; extensive and ambitious vocabulary.
    Level 3 (9-12 marks): sentence demarcation mostly secure and mostly accurate; a range of punctuation, mostly used with success; a variety of sentence forms for effect; Standard English mostly used appropriately, with mostly controlled grammatical structures; generally accurate spelling, including complex and irregular words; increasingly sophisticated vocabulary.
    Level 2 (5-8 marks): sentence demarcation mostly secure and sometimes accurate; some control of a range of punctuation; attempts a variety of sentence forms; some use of Standard English, with some control of agreement; some accurate spelling of more complex words; varied vocabulary.
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): occasional sentence demarcation; some evidence of conscious punctuation; a simple range of sentence forms; occasional use of Standard English, with limited control of agreement; accurate basic spelling; simple vocabulary.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Technical accuracy is judged across the whole response, separately from the quality of the ideas. Look for: secure sentence demarcation (no comma splices or run-on sentences); a wide range of punctuation used accurately (colons, semi-colons, dashes, question marks in a list of questions, inverted commas around quoted words such as 'just as reliable', apostrophes such as 'grandparents' paper'); a full range of sentence forms for effect, including short sentences for emphasis and complex sentences that explain cause and effect; Standard English with secure control of grammar, including agreement and consistent tense; accurate spelling, including ambitious vocabulary the task invites (e.g. 'misinformation', 'accountable', 'algorithm', 'independent', 'nuance'); and extensive, precise vocabulary. An online article for young readers can be lively, but it should remain in Standard English. A response with nothing meaningful to assess scores 0 on both points.

Question 2

40 marks

'Wind turbines and solar farms are spoiling Britain's most beautiful countryside. Clean energy matters, but not at the cost of the landscapes that make this country special.'

Write an article for a magazine about the British countryside in which you argue your point of view on this statement.

(24 marks for content and organisation
16 marks for technical accuracy)

Model answer

The Real Threat to Our Hills Isn't Spinning
Wind turbines and solar panels change the view. Climate change will change everything else.

From the top of the ridge near my aunt's farm, you can see three counties on a clear day. You can also see, on the far hillside, a line of eleven white wind turbines turning slowly against the sky. The first time I climbed up there, they annoyed me. They seemed out of place: tall, mechanical, modern intruders in a landscape of drystone walls and grazing sheep. I understand completely why so many readers of this magazine feel the same.

But the longer I looked, the more I began to wonder what exactly I thought they were spoiling.

The countryside we love is not untouched. It never has been. Those drystone walls were built by people. Many bare, heathery uplands were once covered in forest, cleared over thousands of years for farming and fuel. The canals, railway viaducts and stone farmhouses we now find so picturesque were once the cutting-edge infrastructure of their day, and some people hated them too. When the railways first sliced through the valleys, critics complained that they would destroy the beauty of the countryside forever. Today, we photograph the viaducts and put them on postcards.

The landscape has always been a working landscape. The question is not whether it changes, but how - and for what.

This is where the statement gets its priorities upside down. It treats clean energy as a nice idea that must give way to the view. But the greatest threat to Britain's countryside is not a wind turbine; it is the climate change that wind turbines are designed to slow. Hotter, drier summers are already parching moorland and sparking wildfires on hills that should be damp underfoot. Heavier storms are sending floods through villages and washing away riverbanks. Plants and birds that define our countryside are under pressure as temperatures rise. If we refuse clean energy to protect the view, we may find that we have kept the frame and lost the picture.

That does not mean that anything goes. Readers who worry about badly placed developments have a point. A huge solar farm on the best farmland, or a row of turbines in the heart of a national park, can do real harm, and local people deserve a genuine say in what is built near them. Developers should be required to choose sites carefully, to share the benefits with nearby communities - cheaper electricity, local funds, new jobs - and to restore the land fully when the equipment reaches the end of its life. Solar panels can go on warehouse roofs and car parks long before they go on meadows. Offshore wind, far out beyond the coast, can do much of the heavy lifting.

But we must also be honest about the alternative. Every turbine we reject on a hillside is power we will have to find somewhere else: from gas burned in power stations, perhaps, or imported at the mercy of distant conflicts and rising prices. There is nothing beautiful about that.

There is also, if we are willing to see it, a kind of beauty in the turbines themselves. They are quiet monuments to a country trying to do the right thing. Their slow, elegant turning is a reminder that the wind sweeping across the hills - the same wind that walkers have battled for centuries - can now keep our lights on without warming the planet.

So next time you reach the top of a ridge and see those white blades turning, I hope you will pause before you frown. Ask yourself what the view would look like in fifty years if they were not there. The landscape that makes this country special is worth protecting. That is exactly why we need them.

Explanation

This response reaches the top band because it argues against the statement without ever sneering at the readers who agree with it: it begins by sharing their irritation, then changes their perspective through history (the once-hated railway viaducts) and through the argument that climate change, not turbines, is the real threat to the landscape. Concessions are specific and conditional, the metaphor of keeping 'the frame' but losing 'the picture' crystallises the argument, and the ending returns to the ridge of the opening with a final twist. Common pitfalls are vague slogans about saving the planet, dismissing concern for the landscape as selfish, and failing to adapt tone to readers who love the countryside.

Mark scheme
  1. 24 marks

    Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation).
    Level 4 (19-24 marks): Compelling, convincing communication. Upper (22-24): convincing and compelling; tone, style and register assuredly matched to purpose and audience; extensive, ambitious vocabulary, sustained crafting of devices; varied, inventive structure; convincing, complex ideas; fluent paragraphs, seamless discourse markers. Lower (19-21): convincing; register convincingly matched; extensive vocabulary, conscious crafting of devices; varied, effective structure; highly engaging, developed complex ideas; consistently coherent paragraphs.
    Level 3 (13-18 marks): Consistent, clear communication. Upper (16-18): consistently clear; tone, style and register consistently matched; increasingly sophisticated vocabulary, successful devices; effective structure; engaging, connected ideas; coherent paragraphs, integrated discourse markers. Lower (13-15): generally clear; register generally matched; vocabulary chosen for effect, appropriate devices; usually effective structure; connected ideas; usually coherent paragraphs.
    Level 2 (7-12 marks): Some successful communication. Upper (10-12): some sustained success; sustained attempt to match tone, style and register; conscious vocabulary, some devices; some structural features; increasingly varied linked ideas; some paragraphs and discourse markers. Lower (7-9): some success; attempts to match register; begins to vary vocabulary; attempts structural features; some linked ideas; attempts paragraphs.
    Level 1 (1-6 marks): Simple, limited communication. Upper (4-6): communicates simply; simple awareness of tone and register; simple vocabulary and devices; simple structural features; one or two ideas, simply linked; random paragraphing. Lower (1-3): limited communication; occasional sense of register; simple vocabulary; little or no structure; one or two unlinked ideas; no paragraphs.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Purpose: to argue a point of view on whether wind turbines and solar farms spoil the countryside, and whether landscape should come before clean energy. Audience: readers of a magazine about the British countryside - people who love the landscape, walk in it or live in it, and are likely to be wary of development; the writer must respect their attachment to it, whichever side they take. Form: a magazine article with a headline and perhaps a strapline, a hook (often a scene or view), developed paragraphs and a conclusion. Students may agree, disagree or take a balanced view: reward the quality of the writing, not the opinion. Points that support the statement might include: the visual impact of tall turbines and large solar farms on treasured landscapes; noise and disruption during building; loss of farmland; possible effects on tourism and on wildlife; local people often feel they have little say, while profits go to distant companies; alternatives such as offshore wind and panels on roofs and car parks. Points against it might include: climate change is a far greater threat to the countryside (drought, wildfire, floods, loss of species); the landscape has always been shaped by people and by the technology of each age; energy security and the cost of imported fuel; turbines and panels can be removed at the end of their life; developments can bring local benefits; careful siting can limit the harm. A top-band response is likely to: show understanding of the audience's love of landscape; use vivid description and a personal scene; bring in a historical perspective (once-hated features now admired); concede legitimate concerns with conditions attached; hold a clear line; use devices with control (contrast, metaphor such as keeping the frame and losing the picture, rhetorical questions); and end with a resonant image. Weaker responses tend to talk vaguely about 'saving the planet' without engaging with landscape concerns, or dismiss those concerns as selfish.

  2. 16 marks

    Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
    Level 4 (13-16 marks): sentence demarcation consistently secure and consistently accurate; a wide range of punctuation used with a high level of accuracy; a full range of appropriate sentence forms for effect; Standard English used consistently and appropriately, with secure control of complex grammatical structures; a high level of accuracy in spelling, including ambitious vocabulary; extensive and ambitious vocabulary.
    Level 3 (9-12 marks): sentence demarcation mostly secure and mostly accurate; a range of punctuation, mostly used with success; a variety of sentence forms for effect; Standard English mostly used appropriately, with mostly controlled grammatical structures; generally accurate spelling, including complex and irregular words; increasingly sophisticated vocabulary.
    Level 2 (5-8 marks): sentence demarcation mostly secure and sometimes accurate; some control of a range of punctuation; attempts a variety of sentence forms; some use of Standard English, with some control of agreement; some accurate spelling of more complex words; varied vocabulary.
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): occasional sentence demarcation; some evidence of conscious punctuation; a simple range of sentence forms; occasional use of Standard English, with limited control of agreement; accurate basic spelling; simple vocabulary.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Technical accuracy is judged across the whole response, separately from the quality of the ideas. Look for: secure sentence demarcation (no comma splices or run-on sentences); a wide range of punctuation used accurately (colons, semi-colons, dashes, commas in descriptive lists, apostrophes such as 'Britain's' and 'aunt's'); a full range of sentence forms for effect, including short pointed sentences and long descriptive or concessive sentences; Standard English with secure control of grammar, including agreement and consistent tense; accurate spelling, including ambitious vocabulary the task invites (e.g. 'turbines', 'picturesque', 'landscape', 'renewable', 'infrastructure'); and extensive, precise vocabulary, including descriptive vocabulary for landscape. A response with nothing meaningful to assess scores 0 on both points.

Question 3

40 marks

'Popular tourist cities are being overwhelmed by visitors. Every tourist should pay a daily charge to visit them, and the money should go to the people who live there.'

Write an article for a travel magazine in which you argue your point of view on this statement.

(24 marks for content and organisation
16 marks for technical accuracy)

Model answer

The Price of Paradise: Why I'm Happy to Pay a Tourist Tax
We love the world's great cities. But we are loving some of them to death - and a small daily charge could help to save them.

The first time I saw Venice, it was through a forest of selfie sticks. My family had squeezed onto a narrow bridge with what seemed like half of Europe, all of us craning to photograph the same gondola sliding beneath us. Behind us, an elderly woman with a shopping bag was trying, patiently and hopelessly, to get home. She lived there. We were simply passing through. I have never forgotten the look on her face.

As readers of this magazine, we are travellers. We believe in the value of seeing the world, and rightly so. But we also need to be honest about what our love of travel is doing to the places we adore. In the most popular destinations, residents complain of streets so crowded they cannot walk them, rents driven sky-high by holiday lets, local shops replaced by souvenir stalls and cities that feel less like homes than theme parks. In some places, residents have even held protests against the visitors on whom their economies depend. When the people who live in a place start holding up banners asking you to go home, something has gone badly wrong.

A daily tourist charge will not fix every one of these problems, but it is one of the fairest and simplest tools available.

Consider who pays for tourism now. Every visitor uses the streets, the public toilets, the bins, the transport and the emergency services, all of which are largely paid for by local taxpayers. Day-trippers who arrive by coach or cruise ship and leave by evening may spend very little while adding a great deal to the wear and tear. A small daily charge - the price of a coffee, perhaps - would mean that visitors contribute to the upkeep of the places they enjoy. That is not a punishment. It is a fair fare.

Many destinations already do something similar. Cities such as Amsterdam and Barcelona add a charge to hotel stays, and Venice has experimented with a fee for day-trippers at its busiest times. Tourists still come in their millions. What matters is how the money is spent, and the statement is right to insist that it should go to the people who live there: affordable housing for local families, repairs to historic streets, support for local businesses and better public transport. Spent wisely, the money could make residents feel that tourism is something that works for them, not something that happens to them.

The objections are worth answering. Some say a charge would price poorer travellers out. But a few euros a day is a small fraction of the cost of a flight or a hotel room, and children and students could easily be exempted. Others argue that it would not reduce crowds at all. On its own, perhaps not. But combined with other measures - limits on cruise ships, booking systems for the most fragile sites, encouragement to visit outside the peak season - it can help to spread the pressure, and the money raised can pay for those measures too.

There is a deeper reason why travellers should welcome the idea. A tourist charge reminds us that we are guests. It invites us to slow down, to stay longer, to explore beyond the famous squares and to treat a city not as a backdrop for our photographs but as someone else's home.

I would happily pay a few euros to walk through Venice again. I would happily pay more if I knew that it would help that woman with her shopping bag get home a little more easily. Paradise has a price. It is time visitors started paying their share of it.

Explanation

This response reaches the top band because it persuades travel lovers from the inside: the opening image of the resident on the crowded bridge shifts the reader's perspective, and the argument then moves logically from who pays for tourism now to how the money should be spent. Real practices are mentioned in general terms rather than with invented figures, objections are met with practical answers such as exemptions, and the wordplay ('a fair fare') and the return to the woman with her shopping bag show assured crafting. Common pitfalls are describing a holiday instead of arguing, attacking tourists in a way that alienates the audience, and quoting statistics that cannot be trusted.

Mark scheme
  1. 24 marks

    Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation).
    Level 4 (19-24 marks): Compelling, convincing communication. Upper (22-24): convincing and compelling; tone, style and register assuredly matched to purpose and audience; extensive, ambitious vocabulary, sustained crafting of devices; varied, inventive structure; convincing, complex ideas; fluent paragraphs, seamless discourse markers. Lower (19-21): convincing; register convincingly matched; extensive vocabulary, conscious crafting of devices; varied, effective structure; highly engaging, developed complex ideas; consistently coherent paragraphs.
    Level 3 (13-18 marks): Consistent, clear communication. Upper (16-18): consistently clear; tone, style and register consistently matched; increasingly sophisticated vocabulary, successful devices; effective structure; engaging, connected ideas; coherent paragraphs, integrated discourse markers. Lower (13-15): generally clear; register generally matched; vocabulary chosen for effect, appropriate devices; usually effective structure; connected ideas; usually coherent paragraphs.
    Level 2 (7-12 marks): Some successful communication. Upper (10-12): some sustained success; sustained attempt to match tone, style and register; conscious vocabulary, some devices; some structural features; increasingly varied linked ideas; some paragraphs and discourse markers. Lower (7-9): some success; attempts to match register; begins to vary vocabulary; attempts structural features; some linked ideas; attempts paragraphs.
    Level 1 (1-6 marks): Simple, limited communication. Upper (4-6): communicates simply; simple awareness of tone and register; simple vocabulary and devices; simple structural features; one or two ideas, simply linked; random paragraphing. Lower (1-3): limited communication; occasional sense of register; simple vocabulary; little or no structure; one or two unlinked ideas; no paragraphs.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Purpose: to argue a point of view on whether tourists should pay a daily charge to visit popular cities, with the money going to residents. Audience: readers of a travel magazine - keen travellers who may resent extra costs; the most persuasive responses appeal to their love of the places they visit. Form: a magazine article with a headline and perhaps a strapline, a hook, developed paragraphs and a conclusion. Students may agree, disagree or take a balanced view: reward the quality of the writing, not the opinion. Points that support the statement might include: overcrowded streets and sights; residents priced out by rising rents and holiday lets; local shops replaced by souvenir stalls; tourists use services (streets, bins, toilets, transport) largely paid for by local taxpayers; day-trippers may spend little but add to the pressure; the money could fund housing, repairs, conservation and transport; some cities already charge visitors in some form; it encourages visitors to think of themselves as guests. Points against it might include: it could price out poorer travellers, students and families; it may deter visitors and hurt businesses that depend on tourism; a small charge may not reduce crowds; the money may not reach residents; it adds bureaucracy; tourists already contribute by spending money; other measures (booking systems, limits on cruise ships, promoting off-peak travel) may work better. A top-band response is likely to: open with a vivid scene that makes readers feel the residents' point of view; build the fairness argument clearly; mention real practices in general terms without inventing figures; answer objections with practical suggestions such as exemptions; use devices with control (contrast between visitor and resident, wordplay, rhetorical questions); and end with an echo of the opening. Weaker responses tend to describe a holiday without arguing, or be hostile to all tourists.

  2. 16 marks

    Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
    Level 4 (13-16 marks): sentence demarcation consistently secure and consistently accurate; a wide range of punctuation used with a high level of accuracy; a full range of appropriate sentence forms for effect; Standard English used consistently and appropriately, with secure control of complex grammatical structures; a high level of accuracy in spelling, including ambitious vocabulary; extensive and ambitious vocabulary.
    Level 3 (9-12 marks): sentence demarcation mostly secure and mostly accurate; a range of punctuation, mostly used with success; a variety of sentence forms for effect; Standard English mostly used appropriately, with mostly controlled grammatical structures; generally accurate spelling, including complex and irregular words; increasingly sophisticated vocabulary.
    Level 2 (5-8 marks): sentence demarcation mostly secure and sometimes accurate; some control of a range of punctuation; attempts a variety of sentence forms; some use of Standard English, with some control of agreement; some accurate spelling of more complex words; varied vocabulary.
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): occasional sentence demarcation; some evidence of conscious punctuation; a simple range of sentence forms; occasional use of Standard English, with limited control of agreement; accurate basic spelling; simple vocabulary.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Technical accuracy is judged across the whole response, separately from the quality of the ideas. Look for: secure sentence demarcation (no comma splices or run-on sentences); a wide range of punctuation used accurately (colons, semi-colons, dashes, apostrophes such as 'residents'' and 'Europe's', commas in lists of cities); a full range of sentence forms for effect, including short sentences for emphasis and complex sentences that weigh objections; Standard English with secure control of grammar, including agreement and consistent tense; accurate spelling, including ambitious vocabulary the task invites (e.g. 'overwhelmed', 'residents', 'accommodation', which is often misspelt, 'exemptions', 'conservation'); and extensive, precise vocabulary. A response with nothing meaningful to assess scores 0 on both points.

Question 4

40 marks

A famous museum in Britain has been asked to return a collection of historic objects to the country they were taken from more than a century ago.

'Museums should give back treasures that were taken from other countries in the past, however famous or valuable they are.'

Write an article for a broadsheet newspaper in which you explain your point of view on this statement.

(24 marks for content and organisation
16 marks for technical accuracy)

Model answer

Whose Treasure Is It, Anyway?
Britain's great museums hold some of humanity's most precious objects. The question is whether they should be holding all of them.

In a quiet gallery of a famous London museum, there is a glass case I have visited three times. Inside it is a small bronze head, its features calm and dignified, made by an artist whose name nobody in the room seems to know. A label explains, in a few careful sentences, that it was 'acquired' in the late nineteenth century. It says much less about how. The last time I was there, a family stood beside me, and the mother said something quietly to her son, in a language I did not understand, that made him look at the head for a very long time. I have often wondered what she told him.

Britain's museums are among the finest in the world. Many are free to enter, carefully curated and visited by millions. For many people, they are the only chance they will ever have to see the art and objects of civilisations far from home. Those who defend keeping collections intact make serious arguments. Some objects have been preserved and studied more carefully here than they might have been elsewhere. Great museums, they argue, are 'universal' institutions that tell the story of all humanity in one place. And if every object taken from abroad were returned, the galleries would be emptied - so where would the process stop?

These arguments deserve respect. But I do not think they outweigh one central fact: some of these objects were taken, not given.

Much of what sits in our museums arrived legitimately - bought, exchanged, excavated with permission or donated. But some was seized during wars, carried off by soldiers or removed by people who had power over those who made it. The Benin Bronzes, for instance, were taken by British forces in 1897 during a military expedition in which much of Benin City was destroyed. To many people in what is now Nigeria, they are not just beautiful artworks; they are their history, their kings and their ancestors. Seeing them displayed in another country, under labels written by others, must feel rather like seeing your family photographs hanging in a stranger's living room.

The argument that objects are safer here is weaker than it once was. Many of the countries asking for their treasures back now have modern museums, skilled curators and the means to care for them. Some British institutions have already returned objects - several universities and museums have handed back Benin Bronzes in recent years - and their collections have not collapsed. Visitors still come. Relationships have grown stronger, not weaker.

That said, the statement's 'however famous or valuable' needs care. Every case is different. Some objects were legally bought; some come from places whose borders and governments have changed; some are claimed by more than one group. Returns should be decided case by case, honestly and carefully, in genuine partnership with the people who ask. Return need not mean an empty gallery, either. Objects could be shared through long-term loans and joint exhibitions, and museums could tell the full, uncomfortable truth about how their collections were gathered. A museum that says 'this is how we came to have this, and this is what we are doing about it' would be more honest - and more interesting.

Museums exist to help us understand the world and our place in it. Part of that understanding is admitting when we have done wrong. Giving back what was taken by force is not an attack on Britain's history; it is the sign of a country mature enough to face it.

Perhaps one day I will stand in a gallery in Nigeria and see a bronze head like that one, surrounded by the people whose ancestors made it. I suspect it will look even more beautiful there.

Explanation

This response is top band because it explains a nuanced view with care: it gives the case for 'universal' museums a fair hearing, identifies the central fact that some objects were 'taken, not given', and then qualifies the statement's 'however famous or valuable' with case-by-case solutions such as loans and joint exhibitions. Its one historical example is accurate and stated in general terms, while the observed opening in the gallery, the family-photographs analogy and the closing image of the bronze head 'at home' show sustained, conscious crafting in a register that suits a broadsheet. Common pitfalls are sweeping claims that everything was stolen (or that nothing was), inaccurate history, and a tone that is either flippant or lecturing.

Mark scheme
  1. 24 marks

    Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation).
    Level 4 (19-24 marks): Compelling, convincing communication. Upper (22-24): convincing and compelling; tone, style and register assuredly matched to purpose and audience; extensive, ambitious vocabulary, sustained crafting of devices; varied, inventive structure; convincing, complex ideas; fluent paragraphs, seamless discourse markers. Lower (19-21): convincing; register convincingly matched; extensive vocabulary, conscious crafting of devices; varied, effective structure; highly engaging, developed complex ideas; consistently coherent paragraphs.
    Level 3 (13-18 marks): Consistent, clear communication. Upper (16-18): consistently clear; tone, style and register consistently matched; increasingly sophisticated vocabulary, successful devices; effective structure; engaging, connected ideas; coherent paragraphs, integrated discourse markers. Lower (13-15): generally clear; register generally matched; vocabulary chosen for effect, appropriate devices; usually effective structure; connected ideas; usually coherent paragraphs.
    Level 2 (7-12 marks): Some successful communication. Upper (10-12): some sustained success; sustained attempt to match tone, style and register; conscious vocabulary, some devices; some structural features; increasingly varied linked ideas; some paragraphs and discourse markers. Lower (7-9): some success; attempts to match register; begins to vary vocabulary; attempts structural features; some linked ideas; attempts paragraphs.
    Level 1 (1-6 marks): Simple, limited communication. Upper (4-6): communicates simply; simple awareness of tone and register; simple vocabulary and devices; simple structural features; one or two ideas, simply linked; random paragraphing. Lower (1-3): limited communication; occasional sense of register; simple vocabulary; little or no structure; one or two unlinked ideas; no paragraphs.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Purpose: to explain a point of view on whether museums should return treasures taken from other countries in the past. Audience: readers of a broadsheet newspaper - informed adults interested in history and culture who expect accuracy, nuance and a measured tone. Form: a broadsheet article with a headline and strapline, an engaging opening, developed paragraphs and a conclusion. Students may agree, disagree or take a balanced view: reward the quality of the writing, not the opinion. Points that support the statement might include: some objects were taken by force during wars or under unequal power; they can have deep cultural, spiritual or historical meaning for the communities they came from; many countries now have museums able to care for them; returning them is a matter of justice and honesty about history; it can strengthen relationships between nations; some British institutions have already returned objects. Points against it might include: great museums let millions of people see the cultures of the world in one place, often for free; many objects were acquired legally (bought, exchanged, donated or excavated with permission); questions of conservation and care; disputes over who the rightful owner is when borders and governments have changed; the fear of emptying collections ('where would it stop?'); legal restrictions on what some museums may give away; alternatives such as long-term loans, shared ownership and joint exhibitions. A top-band response is likely to: open with a thoughtful, observed scene; refer to real examples in general, accurate terms without overclaiming; distinguish between objects taken by force and those acquired legitimately; consider case-by-case solutions; use an apt analogy and other devices with control; and end with a resonant image. Weaker responses tend to make inaccurate historical claims, or argue simply 'give it all back' or 'finders keepers' without reasons.

  2. 16 marks

    Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
    Level 4 (13-16 marks): sentence demarcation consistently secure and consistently accurate; a wide range of punctuation used with a high level of accuracy; a full range of appropriate sentence forms for effect; Standard English used consistently and appropriately, with secure control of complex grammatical structures; a high level of accuracy in spelling, including ambitious vocabulary; extensive and ambitious vocabulary.
    Level 3 (9-12 marks): sentence demarcation mostly secure and mostly accurate; a range of punctuation, mostly used with success; a variety of sentence forms for effect; Standard English mostly used appropriately, with mostly controlled grammatical structures; generally accurate spelling, including complex and irregular words; increasingly sophisticated vocabulary.
    Level 2 (5-8 marks): sentence demarcation mostly secure and sometimes accurate; some control of a range of punctuation; attempts a variety of sentence forms; some use of Standard English, with some control of agreement; some accurate spelling of more complex words; varied vocabulary.
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): occasional sentence demarcation; some evidence of conscious punctuation; a simple range of sentence forms; occasional use of Standard English, with limited control of agreement; accurate basic spelling; simple vocabulary.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Technical accuracy is judged across the whole response, separately from the quality of the ideas. Look for: secure sentence demarcation (no comma splices or run-on sentences); a wide range of punctuation used accurately (colons, semi-colons, dashes, inverted commas around words such as 'acquired' and 'universal', apostrophes such as 'humanity's' and 'stranger's'); a full range of sentence forms for effect, including complex sentences that hold concession and argument together; Standard English with secure control of grammar, including agreement and consistent tense when moving between past events and present debate; accurate spelling, including ambitious vocabulary the task invites (e.g. 'artefacts', the usual UK spelling, 'acquired', 'legitimate', 'heritage', 'colonial'); and extensive, precise vocabulary. A broadsheet article calls for formal Standard English throughout. A response with nothing meaningful to assess scores 0 on both points.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.