Question 1
15 marksYou are writing a post for a German website for young people who are interested in science.
Write approximately 90 words in German. You must write something about each bullet point.
Describe:
• the science subject you enjoy most at school, and why
• an experiment that went well or badly
• a science subject or a job in science that you would like to study or do in the future.
Model answer
An meiner Schule haben wir sechs Stunden Naturwissenschaften pro Woche. Chemie mag ich am liebsten, weil wir oft Versuche machen. Physik finde ich schwieriger, weil es dort so viel Mathe gibt. Letzten Monat haben wir im Chemieunterricht einen Versuch mit Feuer gemacht. Leider hat mein Freund zu viel Papier ins Feuer geworfen, und plötzlich war das Feuer riesig. Zum Glück ist nichts passiert, aber wir hatten alle Angst, und unser Chemielehrer war sehr böse. Wenn ich achtzehn bin, möchte ich Chemie studieren, weil ich später neue Medikamente entwickeln will.
Explanation
Opinions in the present (Chemie mag ich am liebsten, weil wir oft Versuche machen), the perfect for the experiment (haben wir ... einen Versuch gemacht; hat ... geworfen) and möchte or will for the future cover the three time frames. Versuch is the listed word for 'experiment'. Common errors are leaving the verb in second place after weil, and a wrong participle for werfen (geworfen, not gewerft).
Mark scheme
-
10 marks
Levels of response: AO2 (10 marks).
Level 5 (9-10): all three bullet points are covered; communication is clear; ideas are regularly developed with a lot of relevant information being conveyed.
Level 4 (7-8): all three bullet points are covered; communication is mostly clear but perhaps with occasional lapses in clarity; ideas are often developed with quite a lot of relevant information being conveyed.
Level 3 (5-6): at least two bullet points are covered; communication is generally clear but there are likely to be lapses in clarity; a few ideas may be developed and some relevant information is conveyed.
Level 2 (3-4): at least one bullet point is covered; communication is sometimes clear and there are regular lapses in clarity; little relevant information is conveyed.
Level 1 (1-2): at least one bullet point is covered; communication is often not clear and there are very many lapses in clarity; very little relevant information is conveyed.
0: the content does not meet the standard required for a mark at this tier.All three bullet points must be covered, but they need not be covered equally; a student with some coverage of all three can reach full marks. When awarding a mark, consider all aspects of the descriptors, not only the number of bullet points covered. If everything written for a bullet cannot be understood, that bullet is not covered and the maximum is 6. Accept any plausible response to a bullet even if a time or place is not stated; a past or future event told with a present-tense verb and a clear time marker still covers the bullet if the message is clear (the verb counts for AO3). The amount of information is judged against about 90 words (9-10 a lot, 7-8 quite a lot, 5-6 some, 3-4 little, 1-2 very little); the word count is approximate - mark all the work, even well beyond 90 words; considerably fewer than 90 words cannot convey a lot of information. Within a level, give the higher mark if the work is closer to the level above. The writing need not look like an email, post or article: it is the content that is marked. A future bullet is covered by any future time reference: werden + infinitive, ich möchte, ich will or ich würde gern + infinitive, a conditional (es wäre toll; ich hätte gern), or a present tense with a future time marker (Nächsten Sommer fahre ich nach Wien). What covers each bullet:
Bullet 1 - the science subject you enjoy most at school, and why (present time frame): accept one statement about the science subject the student prefers or enjoys, or an opinion of science lessons in general (including enjoying none), any tense; a reason develops the answer but is not needed to cover the bullet - e.g. Ich finde Biologie spannend (I find biology exciting) / Chemie mag ich am liebsten (I like chemistry best) / Unsere Chemielehrerin ist toll, also mag ich Chemie (our chemistry teacher is great, so I like chemistry). A list of subjects with no opinion or preference does not cover it.
Bullet 2 - an experiment that went well or badly (past time frame): accept one statement about any experiment or practical, at school or elsewhere; accept any past time reference - e.g. Wir haben einen Versuch mit Wasser gemacht (we did an experiment with water) / Mein Versuch hat nicht funktioniert (my experiment did not work) / Es gab ein kleines Feuer (there was a small fire). Experiment, beyond the list, is credited equally with the listed Versuch.
Bullet 3 - a science subject or a job in science that you would like to study or do in the future (future time frame): accept one plan or wish; accept any future or conditional time reference - e.g. Ich möchte Biologie studieren (I would like to study biology) / Ich werde Tierärztin (I am going to be a vet) / Ich würde gern in einem Krankenhaus arbeiten (I would like to work in a hospital). A plan not to study science, with a reason, also covers it. -
5 marks
Levels of response: AO3 (5 marks).
Level 5 (5): a good variety of vocabulary; regular attempts at complexity of language and structure; references to all three time frames which are mainly successful; errors are mainly minor, but some major errors may occur, particularly in complex structures.
Level 4 (4): a variety of vocabulary; some attempts at complexity of language and structure; references to at least two different time frames which are mainly successful; errors are mainly minor but some major errors may occur.
Level 3 (3): some variety of vocabulary; occasional attempts at complexity; references to at least two different time frames, although these may not always be successful; some major errors and regular minor errors, but overall more accurate than inaccurate.
Level 2 (2): a limited variety of vocabulary; the language is mainly simple, with perhaps some longer sentences with linking words; there may be no successful references to different time frames; frequent major and minor errors; generally inaccurate.
Level 1 (1): the range of vocabulary is narrow and/or repetitive; the language is simple and sentences are short or not properly constructed; no successful references to different time frames; frequent major and minor errors; highly inaccurate.
0: the language does not meet the standard required for Level 1 at this tier.A mark of zero for AO2 automatically results in a mark of zero for AO3, but, apart from that, the AO2 mark does not limit the mark for AO3. Assess the whole response, even irrelevant parts; a short piece is unlikely to show enough variety for a high AO3 mark. Best fit across four strands: variety of vocabulary, complexity, time frames, accuracy. For 5 marks there must be references to all three time frames; for 4, at least two. A time frame may be shown by one example, and the verb need not be totally correct if the message is clear; time frames are not tenses (Morgen gehe ich ins Kino is future). Complexity (AQA's glossary): zu + infinitive, um ... zu, modals, object pronouns, denn / weil / da / obwohl, zuerst / trotzdem / leider, negatives, comparatives, a range of tenses, subordinate and relative clauses - not a tick list. Overlap question: Higher-only grammar 'would not be expected in this question' (AQA, s1-WH-COM p5).
AQA's glossary (s1-WH-MS p15): Major error = 'An error which adversely affects communication. Some examples are: Incorrect verb forms. Incorrect use of pronoun.' (AQA's examples: 'Du mag meine Stadt.' 'Gestern ich einkaufen.') Minor error = 'An error which does not affect communication. Some examples are: Incorrect but close to correct spellings. Incorrect genders and errors of agreement. Incorrect or missing accents unless these alter the meaning. Word order errors where communication is not affected.' (AQA's examples: 'Es gibt gut Geschafte.' 'Mann kann shwimmen gehen.') In this task, for example: major - Letzten Monat wir machen (tense); hat ... werfen (verb form); minor - unser Lehrerin (agreement); weil wir machen Versuche (word order).
Umlauts, ß and capitals: students type their answers. The site gives them a bar with ä ö ü ß, but they may still leave these out. A missing or wrong umlaut is a minor error unless it changes the word. In this task it changes the word in: möchte/mochte, würde/wurde. Count these as errors that alter the meaning (AQA rejects 'mochte' for möchte and lists 'Ich mochte mit Tieren arbeiten' as a major error). A missing or added umlaut in a plural (Bruder/Brüder, Mutter/Mütter) is at most a minor error: the specification says it is "not normally individually credit-bearing" at Higher too (3.2.2.1). ß typed as ss, or ss as ß, is never more than a minor error (AQA's dictation scheme calls 'weiss for weiß' minor). Swiss ss spelling (Strasse, gross) is correct. ae, oe and ue typed for ä, ö and ü count as the right letter and are never an error (site rule, not AQA's). A missing capital on a noun is at most a minor error (site rule, following AQA's dictation ruling: 'Any lack of capital letters for nouns should be ignored for assessment purposes').
Any standard variety of German is accepted: German, Austrian or Swiss usage (Jänner or Januar, Erdäpfel or Kartoffeln, Velo or Fahrrad, Swiss ss for ß). This is a course rule: AQA's documents have no ruling on varieties. Equal credit is given for correct language beyond the Higher vocabulary and grammar lists (spec 4.7).
Gender identity (specification 4.7): 'Students should not be disadvantaged on the basis of their gender identity and/or how they refer to the gender identity of others in their exam responses. Students' preferred ways of referring to themselves and others through the use of pronouns, gendered language and grammatical agreements will be credited by examiners, regardless of whether such usage has been adopted by official language bodies in the target language-speaking countries.' Accept forms such as Schüler*innen, Lehrer:innen and LehrerInnen and neopronouns, and never count them as errors.