Question 1
40 marksWriting for audience, impact and purpose
You should spend about 1 hour on this task. You will be assessed on the quality of your extended response. You should plan and check your work carefully.
Your school is holding a careers evening for Year 11 students and their parents and carers.
Write the words of a speech for the careers evening to argue that apprenticeships deserve as much respect as university degrees.
You should:
• explain why many students and parents see university as the better choice
• describe what an apprenticeship can offer a young person
• argue that students and their families should take apprenticeships seriously.
[40]
Model answer
Good evening, everyone. I'm Tilly, I'm in Year 11, and like most people in this hall, I've spent the last few months being asked the same question at every family gathering: 'So, which university are you going to?'
Notice the question. Not 'What do you want to do?' Not even 'Are you going to university?' Simply 'Which one?' -- as if the only real choice were the name on the hoodie. Tonight I want to argue that this question is too narrow, and that an apprenticeship deserves exactly the same respect as a degree.
First, let's be fair to university, because there are good reasons why so many families see it as the gold standard. For generations, a degree has been the ticket to a professional career -- the thing parents worked hard to give their children, and sometimes the thing they never had the chance to do themselves. University is familiar. Our teachers have been there. The open days are glossy, the league tables are easy to compare, and the path is clear and reassuring: choose your A levels, write your personal statement, pack your bags. Apprenticeships, by contrast, can seem mysterious, and the word can still carry an unfair whiff of 'second best'.
So let me describe what an apprenticeship actually is today. It is a real job, with a real wage and holiday pay, combined with structured training: part of your paid working hours is set aside for study. Apprenticeships range from level 2, the equivalent of GCSEs, all the way up to degree apprenticeships -- the equivalent of a bachelor's or even a master's degree. And here is the part that makes parents sit up: apprentices do not pay for their training. University tuition fees in England are now more than nine thousand pounds a year. A degree apprentice can finish with the same level of qualification, several years of experience on their CV, and a salary instead of a loan.
My cousin Rohan is three years into an engineering apprenticeship. When I asked him what the best part was, I expected him to say the money. He didn't. He said it was being trusted -- being handed a real problem on a Tuesday morning and expected to help solve it. At eighteen, he was learning from people who had done the job for thirty years. By twenty, he was helping to train the new starters.
Now, I am not standing here to tell anyone that university is a mistake. For some careers it is essential; for some people, three years of study is exactly what they need. My argument is simpler: an apprenticeship is not a consolation prize for people who 'couldn't get in'. It is a different route -- demanding, often fiercely competitive and, for many young people, the better fit. The people who win the best places are the ones who prepared, researched and took the option seriously from the start.
So what should we do?
Students: when you research your future, research both routes with the same care. Look at the jobs you are interested in and find out how people actually got into them. You may discover that the path you assumed was the only one is simply the most talked about.
Parents and carers: when your child mentions an apprenticeship, please don't hear 'giving up'. Ask the questions you would ask about a university course. What will they learn? Who will teach them? Where could this lead? You may find the answers more impressive than you expected.
And to all of us: let's change the question we ask at family gatherings. Instead of 'Which university?', let's try 'What do you want to learn -- and what is the best way to learn it?'
The answer might be a lecture hall. It might be a workshop, a hospital ward, a design studio or an office. Both answers deserve a round of applause.
Thank you.
Explanation
By speaking to both of its audiences, this speech reaches the top of both mark grids: it opens with a question every family will recognise, treats the case for university fairly, and then turns firmly to its argument with accurate, well-chosen facts and a vivid personal example. Its structure is framed by that opening question, which is rewritten at the end, and separate advice to students and to parents shows the form being adapted to the occasion; sentence forms such as balanced comparisons and short rebuttals are controlled throughout. Weaker answers simply attack university, list benefits like 'you get paid' without developing them, or forget that parents are in the room.
Mark scheme
-
24 marks
Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation). AO5: Communicate clearly, effectively and imaginatively, selecting and adapting tone, style and register for different forms, purposes and audiences. AO5: Organise information and ideas, using structural and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion of texts.
Level 6 (21-24 marks): The form is deliberately adapted to position the reader, showing a sophisticated control of purpose and effect. Tone, style and register are ambitiously selected and deployed to enhance the purpose of the task. There is a skilfully controlled overall structure, with paragraphs and grammatical features used to support coherence and cohesion and achieve a range of effects.
Level 5 (17-20 marks): The form is confidently adapted and shows a secure understanding of purpose and audience. There is a sustained use of tone, style and register to fulfil the purpose of the task. There is a controlled overall structure, with paragraphs and grammatical features used to support coherence and cohesion and achieve particular effects.
Level 4 (13-16 marks): The form is adapted to show a clear understanding of purpose and audience. Tone, style and register are chosen to match the task. There is a well-managed overall structure, with paragraphs and grammatical features used to support coherence and cohesion, and sometimes for effect.
Level 3 (9-12 marks): The form is sustained and shows clear awareness of purpose and audience. Tone, style and register are appropriate for the task, with some inconsistencies. There is a clear overall structure, with paragraphs and grammatical features used, mostly securely, to support coherence and cohesion.OCR's level descriptors, continued: Level 2 (5-8 marks): The form, which is mostly appropriate for purpose and audience, is generally maintained. There is an attempt to use a tone, style and register appropriate to the task. There is some evidence of overall structure, with some use of paragraphs and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion. Level 1 (1-4 marks): There is some attempt to use a form appropriate for purpose and audience. There is a limited attempt to use a tone, style and register appropriate for the task. There is some attempt to structure the response, with limited evidence of paragraphs or grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion. 0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.
Indicative content for this task (not a checklist; reward other effective approaches):
Form and audience: a speech to two audiences at once -- Year 11 students and their parents and carers -- at a formal school event. It needs an opening that wins attention and establishes the speaker, a clearly stated argument, signposting, rhetorical devices used for effect, direct address to each group where it helps, and a strong ending that gives the audience something to do or to remember. The register should be confident and courteous; many parents in the audience may hold the view being challenged.
Bullet 1 (explain why university is seen as better): tradition and family expectations; a degree long seen as the route to professional careers; school culture, open days and league tables making university familiar; apprenticeships less well understood or associated with older ideas of manual work or 'second best'. The best answers treat this view fairly rather than mocking it.
Bullet 2 (describe what an apprenticeship offers): a real job with a wage and training; levels up to degree apprenticeships; no tuition fees for the apprentice; work experience and skills employers value; responsibility, mentoring and independence. Facts should be accurate or kept general; an invented example of a relative or friend is acceptable if it is not presented as a statistic.
Bullet 3 (argue for respect): the routes are different, not better or worse; apprenticeships can be competitive and demanding; advice for students to research both routes and for parents to ask the same questions of both; challenging the language families use.
Level 6 here: the form is deliberately adapted to position a mixed audience -- for example, the speaker opens with a question every family will recognise, concedes the strengths of university to appear fair, and then speaks separately to students and to parents. Tone is ambitiously selected: warm and humorous but with conviction. The structure is skilfully controlled, perhaps with a framing device (a familiar question that is rewritten at the end) and a turn from fair concession to firm argument.
Levels 3-4: a one-sided attack on university; generic points ('you earn money', 'you learn skills') listed without development; facts that are vague or wrong; little awareness that parents are present; an ending that simply repeats the title. -
16 marks
Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy). AO6: Use a range of vocabulary and sentence structures for clarity, purpose and effect, with accurate spelling and punctuation.
Level 4 (13-16 marks): An ambitious range of sentence structures is used to shape meaning and create impact. Accurate punctuation is used to enhance clarity and achieve particular effects. Vocabulary is precise and subtle, expressing complex ideas with clarity. Spelling of irregular and ambitious words is accurate, with very occasional lapses.
Level 3 (9-12 marks): A wide range of sentence structures is used for deliberate purpose and effect. Punctuation is consistently accurate and is used to achieve clarity. Vocabulary is sometimes ambitious and used convincingly for purpose and effect. Spelling, including complex regular words, is accurate; there may be occasional errors with irregular and ambitious words.
Level 2 (5-8 marks): A range of sentence structures is used, mostly securely, and sometimes for purpose and effect. Punctuation is generally accurate with occasional errors. Vocabulary is appropriate and shows some evidence of being selected for deliberate effect. Spelling is generally accurate with occasional errors with common and more complex words.
Level 1 (1-4 marks): Simple sentences are used with some attempt to use more complex structures. Some punctuation is used but there is a lack of control and consistency. Vocabulary is straightforward and relevant. Mostly accurate spelling of simple words.
0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.AO6 guidance for this task:
Sentence structures: balanced sentences that set the two routes side by side ('University tuition fees in England are now more than nine thousand pounds a year. A degree apprentice can finish ...'); concession and rebuttal ('Now, I am not standing here to tell anyone ... My argument is simpler'); rhetorical questions that the speaker answers; imperatives for the closing advice; a short, emphatic sentence to deliver the key point.
Punctuation for effect: colons to introduce a list or a key fact; dashes for asides and emphasis; quotation marks around phrases the speaker is challenging ('second best'); semicolons to balance two views; accurate commas in long sentences describing training and qualifications.
Vocabulary: precise vocabulary for the subject (apprenticeship, qualification, employer, tuition fees, salary, mentor, vocational, professional, competitive, prestigious) and evaluative words that carry the argument (narrow, reassuring, demanding, consolation prize). Ambitious words should be used accurately, not decoratively.
Spelling of words this task is likely to need: apprenticeship, apprentice, university, qualification, professional, opportunity, guarantee, necessary, experience, independence, responsibility, career, colleague, business, receive.
Level 4 rather than Level 3: Level 4 uses an ambitious range of sentence structures to shape the argument and create impact -- for example a balanced comparison followed by a short rebuttal -- with vocabulary that is precise and subtle and secure spelling of words such as apprenticeship and responsibility. Level 3 shows a wide range of accurate sentences and punctuation, but with less deliberate shaping and vocabulary that is only sometimes ambitious.