Question 1
18 marksRead Text 1 and Text 2 below. Then answer the question that follows.
Text 1
From The Old Red Sandstone, a book about rocks and fossils by Hugh Miller, published in 1841
Hugh Miller became a famous Scottish geologist and writer, but he started his working life as an apprentice stonemason. In this extract he remembers his first day of work in a stone quarry, when he was seventeen.
[1] It was twenty years, last February, since I set out a little before sunrise to make my first acquaintance with a life of labor and restraint, and I have rarely had a heavier heart than on that morning. I was but a slim, loose-jointed boy at the time--fond of the pretty intangibilities of romance, and of dreaming when broad awake; and, woeful change! I was now going to work at what Burns has instanced in his "Twa Dogs" as one of the most disagreeable of all employments--to work in a quarry. Bating the passing uneasiness occasioned by a few gloomy anticipations, the portion of my life which had already gone by had been happy beyond the common lot. I had been a wanderer among rocks and woods--a reader of curious books when I could get them--a gleaner of old traditionary stories; and now I was going to exchange all my day-dreams, and all my amusements, for the kind of life in which men toil every day that they may be enabled to eat, and eat every day that they may be enabled to toil!
[2] The quarry in which I wrought lay on the southern shore of a noble inland bay, or frith, rather, with a little clear stream on the one side, and a thick fir wood on the other. It had been opened in the Old Red Sandstone of the district, and was overtopped by a huge bank of diluvial clay, which rose over it in some places to the height of nearly thirty feet, and which at this time was rent and shivered, wherever it presented an open front to the weather, by a recent frost. A heap of loose fragments, which had fallen from above, blocked up the face of the quarry, and my first employment was to clear them away. The friction of the shovel soon blistered my hands; but the pain was by no means very severe, and I wrought hard and willingly, that I might see how the huge strata below, which presented so firm and unbroken a frontage, were to be torn up and removed. Picks, and wedges, and levers were applied by my brother-workmen; and simple and rude as I had been accustomed to regard these implements, I found I had much to learn in the way of using them. They all proved inefficient, however; and the workmen had to bore into one of the inferior strata, and employ gunpowder. The process was new to me, and I deemed it a highly amusing one: it had the merit, too, of being attended with some such degree of danger as a boating or rock excursion, and had thus an interest independent of its novelty. We had a few capital shots: the fragments flew in every direction; and an immense mass of the diluvium came toppling down, bearing with it two dead birds, that in a recent storm had crept into one of the deeper fissures, to die in the shelter. I felt a new interest in examining them. The one was a pretty cock goldfinch, with its hood of vermilion, and its wings inlaid with the gold to which it owes its name, as unsoiled and smooth as if it had been preserved for a museum. The other, a somewhat rarer bird, of the woodpecker tribe, was variegated with light blue and a grayish yellow. I was engaged in admiring the poor little things, more disposed to be sentimental, perhaps, than if I had been ten years older, and thinking of the contrast between the warmth and jollity of their green summer haunts, and the cold and darkness of their last retreat, when I heard our employer bidding the workmen lay by their tools. I looked up, and saw the sun sinking behind the thick fir wood beside us, and the long, dark shadows of the trees stretching downwards towards the shore.
[3] This was no very formidable beginning of the course of life I had so much dreaded. To be sure, my hands were a little sore, and I felt nearly as much fatigued as if I had been climbing among the rocks; but I had wrought and been useful, and had yet enjoyed the day fully as much as usual.
Glossary: labor - labour (American spelling); restraint - lack of freedom; intangibilities of romance - imaginary things from stories; Burns, "Twa Dogs" - Robert Burns, the Scottish poet, and his poem "The Twa Dogs" (The Two Dogs); Bating - apart from; anticipations - worries about the future; beyond the common lot - more than most people's; gleaner - collector; wrought - worked; frith - firth, a long inlet of the sea; diluvial clay, diluvium - clay and stones once thought to have been left by an ancient flood; rent and shivered - split and shattered; strata - layers of rock (inferior strata: lower layers); rude - rough, simple; bore - drill a hole; capital shots - excellent explosions; vermilion - bright red; variegated - marked with patches of different colours; grayish - greyish (American spelling); haunts - places they often went to; lay by - put away
Text 2
From the Autobiography of Andrew Carnegie, published in 1920 after his death and edited by John C. Van Dyke
In 1848, when Andrew Carnegie was twelve, his poor family left Scotland for the United States, where he later became one of the richest men in the world. In this extract from his autobiography he describes his first jobs.
[1] The great question now was, what could be found for me to do. I had just completed my thirteenth year, and I fairly panted to get to work that I might help the family to a start in the new land. The prospect of want had become to me a frightful nightmare. My thoughts at this period centered in the determination that we should make and save enough of money to produce three hundred dollars a year--twenty-five dollars monthly, which I figured was the sum required to keep us without being dependent upon others. Every necessary thing was very cheap in those days.
[...]
[2] Soon after this incident my father found it necessary to give up hand-loom weaving and to enter the cotton factory of Mr. Blackstock, an old Scotsman in Allegheny City, where we lived. In this factory he also obtained for me a position as bobbin boy, and my first work was done there at one dollar and twenty cents per week. It was a hard life. In the winter father and I had to rise and breakfast in the darkness, reach the factory before it was daylight, and, with a short interval for lunch, work till after dark. The hours hung heavily upon me and in the work itself I took no pleasure; but the cloud had a silver lining, as it gave me the feeling that I was doing something for my world--our family. I have made millions since, but none of those millions gave me such happiness as my first week's earnings. I was now a helper of the family, a breadwinner, and no longer a total charge upon my parents. [...]
[3] Soon after this Mr. John Hay, a fellow-Scotch manufacturer of bobbins in Allegheny City, needed a boy, and asked whether I would not go into his service. I went, and received two dollars per week; but at first the work was even more irksome than the factory. I had to run a small steam-engine and to fire the boiler in the cellar of the bobbin factory. It was too much for me. I found myself night after night, sitting up in bed trying the steam gauges, fearing at one time that the steam was too low and that the workers above would complain that they had not power enough, and at another time that the steam was too high and that the boiler might burst.
[4] But all this it was a matter of honor to conceal from my parents. They had their own troubles and bore them. I must play the man and bear mine. My hopes were high, and I looked every day for some change to take place. What it was to be I knew not, but that it would come I felt certain if I kept on. Besides, at this date I was not beyond asking myself what Wallace would have done and what a Scotsman ought to do. Of one thing I was sure, he ought never to give up.
[5] One day the chance came. Mr. Hay had to make out some bills. He had no clerk, and was himself a poor penman. He asked me what kind of hand I could write, and gave me some writing to do. The result pleased him, and he found it convenient thereafter to let me make out his bills. I was also good at figures; and he soon found it to be to his interest--and besides, dear old man, I believe he was moved by good feeling toward the white-haired boy, for he had a kind heart and was Scotch and wished to relieve me from the engine--to put me at other things, less objectionable except in one feature.
[6] It now became my duty to bathe the newly made spools in vats of oil. Fortunately there was a room reserved for this purpose and I was alone, but not all the resolution I could muster, nor all the indignation I felt at my own weakness, prevented my stomach from behaving in a most perverse way. I never succeeded in overcoming the nausea produced by the smell of the oil. Even Wallace and Bruce proved impotent here. But if I had to lose breakfast, or dinner, I had all the better appetite for supper, and the allotted work was done. A real disciple of Wallace or Bruce could not give up; he would die first.
[7] My service with Mr. Hay was a distinct advance upon the cotton factory, and I also made the acquaintance of an employer who was very kind to me. Mr. Hay kept his books in single entry, and I was able to handle them for him; but hearing that all great firms kept their books in double entry, and after talking over the matter with my companions, John Phipps, Thomas N. Miller, and William Cowley, we all determined to attend night school during the winter and learn the larger system. So the four of us went to a Mr. Williams in Pittsburgh and learned double-entry bookkeeping.
Glossary: panted - longed; want - poverty; centered - centred (American spelling); this incident - a scene left out of this extract, in which his mother angrily rejected a suggestion that he should earn money by selling small goods around the docks; hand-loom weaving - weaving cloth by hand on a loom; Allegheny City - a town next to Pittsburgh, in the United States; bobbin boy - a boy who changed the bobbins (reels of thread) on the machines in a cotton mill; a total charge upon - completely dependent on; Scotch - Scottish; irksome - tiresome, unpleasant; fire the boiler - keep the fire under the boiler burning; steam gauges - dials showing the pressure of the steam; honor - honour (American spelling); play the man - behave like a grown man; Wallace, Bruce - William Wallace and Robert the Bruce, heroes of Scottish history; penman - writer of handwriting; hand - handwriting; figures - arithmetic; toward - towards; perverse - stubbornly unhelpful; impotent - powerless; single entry, double entry - a simple and a more complete way of keeping a firm's accounts
Question 4 is about Text 1, The Old Red Sandstone by Hugh Miller and Text 2, Autobiography by Andrew Carnegie.
'Both texts show that hard work can bring happiness.'
How far do you agree with this statement?
In your answer you should:
• discuss what the writers find hard about their work
• explain how far you agree that their work brings the writers happiness
• compare the ways the writers present their feelings about work.
Support your response with quotations from Text 1 and Text 2. [18]
Model answer
I partly agree. Both writers find some happiness through hard work, but they find it in different places. For Miller, much of the pleasure lies in the day itself, though as much in its novelty and natural beauty as in the labour; for Carnegie, who admits that he took 'no pleasure' in the work, happiness lies almost entirely in what it brought his family and his future.
The writers come to work with opposite feelings. Miller dreads it: he 'rarely had a heavier heart', and he cites Burns to call quarrying one of 'the most disagreeable of all employments', because he must exchange 'all my day-dreams' for 'a life of labor and restraint'. Carnegie, by contrast, 'fairly panted to get to work', because 'The prospect of want had become to me a frightful nightmare'. Miller fears losing his freedom; Carnegie fears poverty. Yet the hardship is far greater in Text 2. Carnegie's blunt short sentences, 'It was a hard life.' and 'It was too much for me.', lead to nights 'sitting up in bed trying the steam gauges' in fear 'that the boiler might burst', and to a nausea 'I never succeeded in overcoming'; Miller's only injury is blistered hands. Both writers make light of suffering, though: Miller through understatement, 'by no means very severe', and Carnegie through comic bathos, as 'Even Wallace and Bruce proved impotent' against the smell of oil.
On whether the work itself brings happiness, Text 1 agrees far more. Miller 'wrought hard and willingly', curious to see how 'the huge strata below' would be 'torn up and removed', and he found the blasting 'a highly amusing one', its danger like 'a boating or rock excursion', as though work had become play. Carnegie states plainly that 'in the work itself I took no pleasure'. But Miller's happiness is not wholly in the labour either. The most loving writing in Text 1 describes the dead goldfinch 'with its hood of vermilion' and the 'long, dark shadows of the trees' at sunset, which suggests that nature and imagination, the 'day-dreams' he thought he was losing, came with him to the quarry. His bleak chiasmus, that men 'toil every day that they may be enabled to eat, and eat every day that they may be enabled to toil', is never quite withdrawn.
Where the texts meet is in the satisfaction of being useful. Miller ends proud that 'I had wrought and been useful'; Carnegie's pride is far stronger, as he becomes 'a helper of the family, a breadwinner', and his antithesis, 'none of those millions gave me such happiness as my first week's earnings', sets a fortune against a boy's wage. Coming from one of the richest men in the world, this has a powerful impact on the reader: it suggests that money earned for others is worth more than wealth gained for oneself. Carnegie's happiness also comes from progress, since his persistence is rewarded when 'One day the chance came' and his new work is 'a distinct advance'; Miller's is relief that the day was 'no very formidable beginning'.
Structure, perspective and time explain these differences. Miller describes a single day in a circular shape, from the life 'I had so much dreaded' to a day he 'enjoyed ... fully as much as usual', so his happiness is a sudden surprise; Carnegie moves through a chronological series of jobs marked by exact wages, 'one dollar and twenty cents per week' and then 'two dollars per week', so his is slow and earned. Both are older men looking back, and both lean on Scottish models: Miller on Burns to express dread, Carnegie on his hero, asking 'what Wallace would have done', to express determination, so that for Carnegie work is above all a test of character. Miller, writing in 1841 about a day twenty years earlier, became a geologist, which may explain his delight in rock; Carnegie's autobiography, published in 1920, tells a rags-to-riches story in which early hardship has become a source of pride.
Overall, I agree with the statement more for Text 1, where a day of labour turns out to be enjoyable, though partly through things other than the work, than for Text 2, where hard work brought happiness only through its rewards. Both texts support the statement fully only if happiness means the pride of being useful rather than pleasure in the work.
Explanation
What lifts this response to the top levels is the distinction it draws between happiness found in the labour itself and happiness found in what labour brings. On that basis it judges the statement closer to true for Miller, who enjoys his first day partly through novelty and nature, than for Carnegie, who took 'no pleasure' in the work but treasured his 'first week's earnings'. Comparison is sustained in every paragraph, from the writers' opposite fears before work to their shared pride in being useful and the effect of hindsight, structure and their very different later lives. Candidates who discuss Miller and Carnegie separately, list Carnegie's jobs in order, or agree without telling the two kinds of happiness apart do not reach the higher marks.
Mark scheme
-
12 marks
Levels of response (12 marks). AO4: Evaluate texts critically and support this with appropriate textual references.
Level 6 (11-12 marks): A sustained critical evaluation demonstrating a perceptive and considered response to the statement and a full explanation of the impact of the texts on the reader. Comments are supported by apt, skilfully selected and integrated textual references.
Level 5 (9-10 marks): An informed critical evaluation showing a thoughtful response to the statement and clear consideration of the impact of the texts on the reader. Comments are supported by persuasive textual references.
Level 4 (7-8 marks): A response with developed evaluative comments addressing the statement and some comments about the impact on the reader. Comments are supported by well-chosen textual references.
Level 3 (5-6 marks): A response with clear evaluative comments and some awareness of the impact on the reader. Comments are supported by appropriate textual references.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): A response with straightforward evaluative comments and a little awareness of the impact on the reader. Comments are supported by some appropriate textual references.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): A limited description of content. Comments are supported by copying or paraphrase.
0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.Max 12 if only one text is considered: OCR's guidance is 'There are 0 marks for AO3 where only one text is considered' (OCR J351/02 mark scheme, June 2025), so only the AO4 mark can be awarded.
OCR's guidance: 'The first two bullet points of the question prompt candidates to evaluate the text (AO4) and the third bullet point prompts candidates to compare the texts (AO3).' Candidates may answer the bullet points in combination and integrate evaluation and comparison throughout; OCR says this 'is a valid approach which may achieve the highest levels' (OCR J351/01 mark scheme, June 2024). Where the candidate's answer consistently meets the criteria, the higher mark should be awarded.
Candidates may evaluate these ideas (agreeing and disagreeing; not a checklist):
Text 1, agreeing: the day turns out far better than he feared: 'This was no very formidable beginning of the course of life I had so much dreaded', 'enjoyed the day fully as much as usual'; the blasting was 'a highly amusing one'; he works 'hard and willingly' and is proud that 'I had wrought and been useful'. Text 1, disagreeing: much of his happiness comes from novelty and nature (the gunpowder's 'novelty', the goldfinch's 'hood of vermilion', the sunset), not from the labour itself; he still sees toil as joyless, 'men toil every day that they may be enabled to eat', and he ends 'fatigued' with sore hands; it is only one day. Text 2, agreeing: 'none of those millions gave me such happiness as my first week's earnings'; pride as 'a helper of the family, a breadwinner'; his persistence is rewarded ('One day the chance came'); 'a distinct advance' and night school show work leading to progress. Text 2, disagreeing: 'in the work itself I took no pleasure'; 'It was too much for me'; nights 'sitting up in bed trying the steam gauges'; 'I never succeeded in overcoming the nausea'; his happiness comes from money and helping the family, not from the work. Perceptive evaluation distinguishes happiness found in the work from happiness found in what it brings, reaches a judgement of how far for each text (for example, Text 1 closer to agreeing for the work itself; Text 2 agreeing only for its results), considers the impact on the reader, and links this to purpose and context: Miller's circular account of a single day that defeats his dread; Carnegie's later fame as a millionaire, which gives his first wages special weight. -
6 marks
Levels of response (6 marks). AO3: Compare writers' ideas and perspectives as well as how these are conveyed across two or more texts.
Level 6 (6 marks): A detailed, interwoven comparison which explores writers' ideas and perspectives and how they are conveyed.
Level 5 (5 marks): A sustained comparison of writers' ideas and perspectives and how they are conveyed.
Level 4 (4 marks): A developed comparison of writers' ideas and perspectives and how they are conveyed.
Level 3 (3 marks): A clear comparison of writers' ideas and perspectives which begins to consider how they are conveyed.
Level 2 (2 marks): A response which identifies main points of comparison between writers' ideas and perspectives.
Level 1 (1 mark): A response which makes simple points of comparison between writers' ideas and perspectives.
0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.OCR: 'There are 0 marks for AO3 where only one text is considered.' OCR's examples of simple points of comparison include repeating the words of the statement and writing about both texts side by side so that comparisons have to be inferred (OCR J351/02 mark scheme, June 2025).
Candidates may compare these points (not a checklist):
Both begin with dread or difficulty, but Text 1 resolves it within one day (a circular structure from 'dreaded' to 'enjoyed'), while Text 2 moves through a series of jobs in chronological order -> Miller's happiness is sudden and surprising, Carnegie's slow and earned. Methods: Text 1 uses long descriptive sentences and nature imagery ('the sun sinking behind the thick fir wood'); Text 2 uses precise money details ('one dollar and twenty cents per week') and short declaratives ('It was a hard life.') -> Miller finds beauty, Carnegie counts the cost. Both use Scottish reference points: Miller cites Burns to express dread; Carnegie cites Wallace and Bruce to express determination. Both treat physical suffering lightly: Miller through understatement ('by no means very severe'); Carnegie through comic bathos ('Even Wallace and Bruce proved impotent here'). Perspective: both are older men looking back, Miller twenty years later, Carnegie as a millionaire ('I have made millions since') -> hindsight may make hardship seem happier than it felt. Higher-level comparison is integrated throughout and compares how feelings are conveyed as well as what they are.