Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/7

Non-fiction: evaluating and comparing both texts (Q4)

Practise 28 exam-style questions on Non-fiction: evaluating and comparing both texts (Q4) for OCR GCSE English Language (Component 1). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 28 questions
  • 18 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

18 marks

Read Text 1 and Text 2 below. Then answer the question that follows.

Text 1
From The Old Red Sandstone, a book about rocks and fossils by Hugh Miller, published in 1841

Hugh Miller became a famous Scottish geologist and writer, but he started his working life as an apprentice stonemason. In this extract he remembers his first day of work in a stone quarry, when he was seventeen.

[1] It was twenty years, last February, since I set out a little before sunrise to make my first acquaintance with a life of labor and restraint, and I have rarely had a heavier heart than on that morning. I was but a slim, loose-jointed boy at the time--fond of the pretty intangibilities of romance, and of dreaming when broad awake; and, woeful change! I was now going to work at what Burns has instanced in his "Twa Dogs" as one of the most disagreeable of all employments--to work in a quarry. Bating the passing uneasiness occasioned by a few gloomy anticipations, the portion of my life which had already gone by had been happy beyond the common lot. I had been a wanderer among rocks and woods--a reader of curious books when I could get them--a gleaner of old traditionary stories; and now I was going to exchange all my day-dreams, and all my amusements, for the kind of life in which men toil every day that they may be enabled to eat, and eat every day that they may be enabled to toil!

[2] The quarry in which I wrought lay on the southern shore of a noble inland bay, or frith, rather, with a little clear stream on the one side, and a thick fir wood on the other. It had been opened in the Old Red Sandstone of the district, and was overtopped by a huge bank of diluvial clay, which rose over it in some places to the height of nearly thirty feet, and which at this time was rent and shivered, wherever it presented an open front to the weather, by a recent frost. A heap of loose fragments, which had fallen from above, blocked up the face of the quarry, and my first employment was to clear them away. The friction of the shovel soon blistered my hands; but the pain was by no means very severe, and I wrought hard and willingly, that I might see how the huge strata below, which presented so firm and unbroken a frontage, were to be torn up and removed. Picks, and wedges, and levers were applied by my brother-workmen; and simple and rude as I had been accustomed to regard these implements, I found I had much to learn in the way of using them. They all proved inefficient, however; and the workmen had to bore into one of the inferior strata, and employ gunpowder. The process was new to me, and I deemed it a highly amusing one: it had the merit, too, of being attended with some such degree of danger as a boating or rock excursion, and had thus an interest independent of its novelty. We had a few capital shots: the fragments flew in every direction; and an immense mass of the diluvium came toppling down, bearing with it two dead birds, that in a recent storm had crept into one of the deeper fissures, to die in the shelter. I felt a new interest in examining them. The one was a pretty cock goldfinch, with its hood of vermilion, and its wings inlaid with the gold to which it owes its name, as unsoiled and smooth as if it had been preserved for a museum. The other, a somewhat rarer bird, of the woodpecker tribe, was variegated with light blue and a grayish yellow. I was engaged in admiring the poor little things, more disposed to be sentimental, perhaps, than if I had been ten years older, and thinking of the contrast between the warmth and jollity of their green summer haunts, and the cold and darkness of their last retreat, when I heard our employer bidding the workmen lay by their tools. I looked up, and saw the sun sinking behind the thick fir wood beside us, and the long, dark shadows of the trees stretching downwards towards the shore.

[3] This was no very formidable beginning of the course of life I had so much dreaded. To be sure, my hands were a little sore, and I felt nearly as much fatigued as if I had been climbing among the rocks; but I had wrought and been useful, and had yet enjoyed the day fully as much as usual.

Glossary: labor - labour (American spelling); restraint - lack of freedom; intangibilities of romance - imaginary things from stories; Burns, "Twa Dogs" - Robert Burns, the Scottish poet, and his poem "The Twa Dogs" (The Two Dogs); Bating - apart from; anticipations - worries about the future; beyond the common lot - more than most people's; gleaner - collector; wrought - worked; frith - firth, a long inlet of the sea; diluvial clay, diluvium - clay and stones once thought to have been left by an ancient flood; rent and shivered - split and shattered; strata - layers of rock (inferior strata: lower layers); rude - rough, simple; bore - drill a hole; capital shots - excellent explosions; vermilion - bright red; variegated - marked with patches of different colours; grayish - greyish (American spelling); haunts - places they often went to; lay by - put away

Text 2
From the Autobiography of Andrew Carnegie, published in 1920 after his death and edited by John C. Van Dyke

In 1848, when Andrew Carnegie was twelve, his poor family left Scotland for the United States, where he later became one of the richest men in the world. In this extract from his autobiography he describes his first jobs.

[1] The great question now was, what could be found for me to do. I had just completed my thirteenth year, and I fairly panted to get to work that I might help the family to a start in the new land. The prospect of want had become to me a frightful nightmare. My thoughts at this period centered in the determination that we should make and save enough of money to produce three hundred dollars a year--twenty-five dollars monthly, which I figured was the sum required to keep us without being dependent upon others. Every necessary thing was very cheap in those days.

[...]

[2] Soon after this incident my father found it necessary to give up hand-loom weaving and to enter the cotton factory of Mr. Blackstock, an old Scotsman in Allegheny City, where we lived. In this factory he also obtained for me a position as bobbin boy, and my first work was done there at one dollar and twenty cents per week. It was a hard life. In the winter father and I had to rise and breakfast in the darkness, reach the factory before it was daylight, and, with a short interval for lunch, work till after dark. The hours hung heavily upon me and in the work itself I took no pleasure; but the cloud had a silver lining, as it gave me the feeling that I was doing something for my world--our family. I have made millions since, but none of those millions gave me such happiness as my first week's earnings. I was now a helper of the family, a breadwinner, and no longer a total charge upon my parents. [...]

[3] Soon after this Mr. John Hay, a fellow-Scotch manufacturer of bobbins in Allegheny City, needed a boy, and asked whether I would not go into his service. I went, and received two dollars per week; but at first the work was even more irksome than the factory. I had to run a small steam-engine and to fire the boiler in the cellar of the bobbin factory. It was too much for me. I found myself night after night, sitting up in bed trying the steam gauges, fearing at one time that the steam was too low and that the workers above would complain that they had not power enough, and at another time that the steam was too high and that the boiler might burst.

[4] But all this it was a matter of honor to conceal from my parents. They had their own troubles and bore them. I must play the man and bear mine. My hopes were high, and I looked every day for some change to take place. What it was to be I knew not, but that it would come I felt certain if I kept on. Besides, at this date I was not beyond asking myself what Wallace would have done and what a Scotsman ought to do. Of one thing I was sure, he ought never to give up.

[5] One day the chance came. Mr. Hay had to make out some bills. He had no clerk, and was himself a poor penman. He asked me what kind of hand I could write, and gave me some writing to do. The result pleased him, and he found it convenient thereafter to let me make out his bills. I was also good at figures; and he soon found it to be to his interest--and besides, dear old man, I believe he was moved by good feeling toward the white-haired boy, for he had a kind heart and was Scotch and wished to relieve me from the engine--to put me at other things, less objectionable except in one feature.

[6] It now became my duty to bathe the newly made spools in vats of oil. Fortunately there was a room reserved for this purpose and I was alone, but not all the resolution I could muster, nor all the indignation I felt at my own weakness, prevented my stomach from behaving in a most perverse way. I never succeeded in overcoming the nausea produced by the smell of the oil. Even Wallace and Bruce proved impotent here. But if I had to lose breakfast, or dinner, I had all the better appetite for supper, and the allotted work was done. A real disciple of Wallace or Bruce could not give up; he would die first.

[7] My service with Mr. Hay was a distinct advance upon the cotton factory, and I also made the acquaintance of an employer who was very kind to me. Mr. Hay kept his books in single entry, and I was able to handle them for him; but hearing that all great firms kept their books in double entry, and after talking over the matter with my companions, John Phipps, Thomas N. Miller, and William Cowley, we all determined to attend night school during the winter and learn the larger system. So the four of us went to a Mr. Williams in Pittsburgh and learned double-entry bookkeeping.

Glossary: panted - longed; want - poverty; centered - centred (American spelling); this incident - a scene left out of this extract, in which his mother angrily rejected a suggestion that he should earn money by selling small goods around the docks; hand-loom weaving - weaving cloth by hand on a loom; Allegheny City - a town next to Pittsburgh, in the United States; bobbin boy - a boy who changed the bobbins (reels of thread) on the machines in a cotton mill; a total charge upon - completely dependent on; Scotch - Scottish; irksome - tiresome, unpleasant; fire the boiler - keep the fire under the boiler burning; steam gauges - dials showing the pressure of the steam; honor - honour (American spelling); play the man - behave like a grown man; Wallace, Bruce - William Wallace and Robert the Bruce, heroes of Scottish history; penman - writer of handwriting; hand - handwriting; figures - arithmetic; toward - towards; perverse - stubbornly unhelpful; impotent - powerless; single entry, double entry - a simple and a more complete way of keeping a firm's accounts

Question 4 is about Text 1, The Old Red Sandstone by Hugh Miller and Text 2, Autobiography by Andrew Carnegie.

'Both texts show that hard work can bring happiness.'

How far do you agree with this statement?

In your answer you should:
• discuss what the writers find hard about their work
• explain how far you agree that their work brings the writers happiness
• compare the ways the writers present their feelings about work.

Support your response with quotations from Text 1 and Text 2. [18]

Model answer

I partly agree. Both writers find some happiness through hard work, but they find it in different places. For Miller, much of the pleasure lies in the day itself, though as much in its novelty and natural beauty as in the labour; for Carnegie, who admits that he took 'no pleasure' in the work, happiness lies almost entirely in what it brought his family and his future.

The writers come to work with opposite feelings. Miller dreads it: he 'rarely had a heavier heart', and he cites Burns to call quarrying one of 'the most disagreeable of all employments', because he must exchange 'all my day-dreams' for 'a life of labor and restraint'. Carnegie, by contrast, 'fairly panted to get to work', because 'The prospect of want had become to me a frightful nightmare'. Miller fears losing his freedom; Carnegie fears poverty. Yet the hardship is far greater in Text 2. Carnegie's blunt short sentences, 'It was a hard life.' and 'It was too much for me.', lead to nights 'sitting up in bed trying the steam gauges' in fear 'that the boiler might burst', and to a nausea 'I never succeeded in overcoming'; Miller's only injury is blistered hands. Both writers make light of suffering, though: Miller through understatement, 'by no means very severe', and Carnegie through comic bathos, as 'Even Wallace and Bruce proved impotent' against the smell of oil.

On whether the work itself brings happiness, Text 1 agrees far more. Miller 'wrought hard and willingly', curious to see how 'the huge strata below' would be 'torn up and removed', and he found the blasting 'a highly amusing one', its danger like 'a boating or rock excursion', as though work had become play. Carnegie states plainly that 'in the work itself I took no pleasure'. But Miller's happiness is not wholly in the labour either. The most loving writing in Text 1 describes the dead goldfinch 'with its hood of vermilion' and the 'long, dark shadows of the trees' at sunset, which suggests that nature and imagination, the 'day-dreams' he thought he was losing, came with him to the quarry. His bleak chiasmus, that men 'toil every day that they may be enabled to eat, and eat every day that they may be enabled to toil', is never quite withdrawn.

Where the texts meet is in the satisfaction of being useful. Miller ends proud that 'I had wrought and been useful'; Carnegie's pride is far stronger, as he becomes 'a helper of the family, a breadwinner', and his antithesis, 'none of those millions gave me such happiness as my first week's earnings', sets a fortune against a boy's wage. Coming from one of the richest men in the world, this has a powerful impact on the reader: it suggests that money earned for others is worth more than wealth gained for oneself. Carnegie's happiness also comes from progress, since his persistence is rewarded when 'One day the chance came' and his new work is 'a distinct advance'; Miller's is relief that the day was 'no very formidable beginning'.

Structure, perspective and time explain these differences. Miller describes a single day in a circular shape, from the life 'I had so much dreaded' to a day he 'enjoyed ... fully as much as usual', so his happiness is a sudden surprise; Carnegie moves through a chronological series of jobs marked by exact wages, 'one dollar and twenty cents per week' and then 'two dollars per week', so his is slow and earned. Both are older men looking back, and both lean on Scottish models: Miller on Burns to express dread, Carnegie on his hero, asking 'what Wallace would have done', to express determination, so that for Carnegie work is above all a test of character. Miller, writing in 1841 about a day twenty years earlier, became a geologist, which may explain his delight in rock; Carnegie's autobiography, published in 1920, tells a rags-to-riches story in which early hardship has become a source of pride.

Overall, I agree with the statement more for Text 1, where a day of labour turns out to be enjoyable, though partly through things other than the work, than for Text 2, where hard work brought happiness only through its rewards. Both texts support the statement fully only if happiness means the pride of being useful rather than pleasure in the work.

Explanation

What lifts this response to the top levels is the distinction it draws between happiness found in the labour itself and happiness found in what labour brings. On that basis it judges the statement closer to true for Miller, who enjoys his first day partly through novelty and nature, than for Carnegie, who took 'no pleasure' in the work but treasured his 'first week's earnings'. Comparison is sustained in every paragraph, from the writers' opposite fears before work to their shared pride in being useful and the effect of hindsight, structure and their very different later lives. Candidates who discuss Miller and Carnegie separately, list Carnegie's jobs in order, or agree without telling the two kinds of happiness apart do not reach the higher marks.

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO4: Evaluate texts critically and support this with appropriate textual references.
    Level 6 (11-12 marks): A sustained critical evaluation demonstrating a perceptive and considered response to the statement and a full explanation of the impact of the texts on the reader. Comments are supported by apt, skilfully selected and integrated textual references.
    Level 5 (9-10 marks): An informed critical evaluation showing a thoughtful response to the statement and clear consideration of the impact of the texts on the reader. Comments are supported by persuasive textual references.
    Level 4 (7-8 marks): A response with developed evaluative comments addressing the statement and some comments about the impact on the reader. Comments are supported by well-chosen textual references.
    Level 3 (5-6 marks): A response with clear evaluative comments and some awareness of the impact on the reader. Comments are supported by appropriate textual references.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): A response with straightforward evaluative comments and a little awareness of the impact on the reader. Comments are supported by some appropriate textual references.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): A limited description of content. Comments are supported by copying or paraphrase.
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    Max 12 if only one text is considered: OCR's guidance is 'There are 0 marks for AO3 where only one text is considered' (OCR J351/02 mark scheme, June 2025), so only the AO4 mark can be awarded.
    OCR's guidance: 'The first two bullet points of the question prompt candidates to evaluate the text (AO4) and the third bullet point prompts candidates to compare the texts (AO3).' Candidates may answer the bullet points in combination and integrate evaluation and comparison throughout; OCR says this 'is a valid approach which may achieve the highest levels' (OCR J351/01 mark scheme, June 2024). Where the candidate's answer consistently meets the criteria, the higher mark should be awarded.
    Candidates may evaluate these ideas (agreeing and disagreeing; not a checklist):
    Text 1, agreeing: the day turns out far better than he feared: 'This was no very formidable beginning of the course of life I had so much dreaded', 'enjoyed the day fully as much as usual'; the blasting was 'a highly amusing one'; he works 'hard and willingly' and is proud that 'I had wrought and been useful'. Text 1, disagreeing: much of his happiness comes from novelty and nature (the gunpowder's 'novelty', the goldfinch's 'hood of vermilion', the sunset), not from the labour itself; he still sees toil as joyless, 'men toil every day that they may be enabled to eat', and he ends 'fatigued' with sore hands; it is only one day. Text 2, agreeing: 'none of those millions gave me such happiness as my first week's earnings'; pride as 'a helper of the family, a breadwinner'; his persistence is rewarded ('One day the chance came'); 'a distinct advance' and night school show work leading to progress. Text 2, disagreeing: 'in the work itself I took no pleasure'; 'It was too much for me'; nights 'sitting up in bed trying the steam gauges'; 'I never succeeded in overcoming the nausea'; his happiness comes from money and helping the family, not from the work. Perceptive evaluation distinguishes happiness found in the work from happiness found in what it brings, reaches a judgement of how far for each text (for example, Text 1 closer to agreeing for the work itself; Text 2 agreeing only for its results), considers the impact on the reader, and links this to purpose and context: Miller's circular account of a single day that defeats his dread; Carnegie's later fame as a millionaire, which gives his first wages special weight.

  2. 6 marks

    Levels of response (6 marks). AO3: Compare writers' ideas and perspectives as well as how these are conveyed across two or more texts.
    Level 6 (6 marks): A detailed, interwoven comparison which explores writers' ideas and perspectives and how they are conveyed.
    Level 5 (5 marks): A sustained comparison of writers' ideas and perspectives and how they are conveyed.
    Level 4 (4 marks): A developed comparison of writers' ideas and perspectives and how they are conveyed.
    Level 3 (3 marks): A clear comparison of writers' ideas and perspectives which begins to consider how they are conveyed.
    Level 2 (2 marks): A response which identifies main points of comparison between writers' ideas and perspectives.
    Level 1 (1 mark): A response which makes simple points of comparison between writers' ideas and perspectives.
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    OCR: 'There are 0 marks for AO3 where only one text is considered.' OCR's examples of simple points of comparison include repeating the words of the statement and writing about both texts side by side so that comparisons have to be inferred (OCR J351/02 mark scheme, June 2025).
    Candidates may compare these points (not a checklist):
    Both begin with dread or difficulty, but Text 1 resolves it within one day (a circular structure from 'dreaded' to 'enjoyed'), while Text 2 moves through a series of jobs in chronological order -> Miller's happiness is sudden and surprising, Carnegie's slow and earned. Methods: Text 1 uses long descriptive sentences and nature imagery ('the sun sinking behind the thick fir wood'); Text 2 uses precise money details ('one dollar and twenty cents per week') and short declaratives ('It was a hard life.') -> Miller finds beauty, Carnegie counts the cost. Both use Scottish reference points: Miller cites Burns to express dread; Carnegie cites Wallace and Bruce to express determination. Both treat physical suffering lightly: Miller through understatement ('by no means very severe'); Carnegie through comic bathos ('Even Wallace and Bruce proved impotent here'). Perspective: both are older men looking back, Miller twenty years later, Carnegie as a millionaire ('I have made millions since') -> hindsight may make hardship seem happier than it felt. Higher-level comparison is integrated throughout and compares how feelings are conveyed as well as what they are.

Question 2

18 marks

Read Text 1 and Text 2 below. Then answer the question that follows.

Text 1
From A Memoir of Thomas Bewick, Written by Himself, an autobiography by Thomas Bewick, published in 1862 after his death

Thomas Bewick became a famous wood engraver, best known for his pictures of birds and animals. In this extract from the memoir he wrote in the last years of his life, which was published long after his death, he remembers his schooldays in Northumberland in the 1760s, after an unhappy start with a harsh first schoolmaster.

[1] As soon as another schoolmaster (James Burn) was appointed, I was sent to him; and he happened to be of a directly opposite character to the late one. With him I was quite happy, and learned as fast as any other of the boys, and with as great pleasure. After the death of this much respected young man, who lived only a very few years after his appointment, my learning any more at Mickley school was at an end.

[2] Some time after this, my father put me to school under the care of the Rev. C. Gregson, of Ovingham; and well do I remember the conversation that passed between them on the occasion. It was little to my credit; for my father began by telling him that I was so very unguidable that he could not manage me, and he begged of my new master that he would undertake that task, and they both agreed that "to spare the rod was to spoil the child." This precept was, I think, too severely acted upon, sometimes upon trivial occasions and sometimes otherwise.

[3] I was for some time kept at reading, writing, and figures,--how long, I know not, but I know that as soon as my question was done upon my slate, I spent as much time as I could find in filling with my pencil all the unoccupied spaces, with representations of such objects as struck my fancy; and these were rubbed out, for fear of a beating, before my question was given in. As soon as I reached Fractions, Decimals, &c., I was put to learn Latin, and in this I was for some time complimented by my master for the great progress I was making; but, as I never knew for what purpose I had to learn it, and was wearied out with getting off long tasks, I rather flagged in this department of my education, and the margins of my books, and every space of spare and blank paper, became filled with various kinds of devices or scenes I had met with; and these were accompanied with wretched rhymes explanatory of them. As soon as I filled all the blank spaces in my books, I had recourse, at all spare times, to the gravestones and the floor of the church porch, with a bit of chalk, to give vent to this propensity of mind of figuring whatever I had seen. At that time I had never heard of the word "drawing;" nor did I know of any other paintings besides the king's arms in the church, and the signs in Ovingham of the Black Bull, the White Horse, the Salmon, and the Hounds and Hare. I always thought I could make a far better hunting scene than the latter: the others were beyond my hand. I remember once of my master overlooking me while I was very busy with my chalk in the porch, and of his putting me very greatly to the blush by ridiculing and calling me a conjurer. My father, also, found a deal of fault for "mispending my time in such idle pursuits;" but my propensity for drawing was so rooted that nothing could deter me from persevering in it; and many of my evenings at home were spent in filling the flags of the floor and the hearth-stone with my chalky designs.

[4] After I had long scorched my face in this way, a friend, in compassion, furnished me with some paper upon which to execute my designs. Here I had more scope. Pen and ink, and the juice of the brambleberry, made a grand change. These were succeeded by a camel-hair pencil and shells of colours; and, thus supplied, I became completely set up; but of patterns, or drawings, I had none. The beasts and birds, which enlivened the beautiful scenery of woods and wilds surrounding my native hamlet, furnished me with an endless supply of subjects. I now, in the estimation of my rustic neighbours, became an eminent painter, and the walls of their houses were ornamented with an abundance of my rude productions, at a very cheap rate. These chiefly consisted of particular hunting scenes, in which the portraits of the hunters, the horses, and of every dog in the pack, were, in their opinion, as well as my own, faithfully delineated.

Glossary: the late one - the previous schoolmaster, who had died; Mickley - a village in Northumberland near Bewick's home; Ovingham - a village beside the River Tyne in Northumberland; the rod - a stick used to beat children as a punishment; precept - rule; my question - the sum I had been set; getting off - learning by heart; flagged - grew tired and lost interest; devices - designs, pictures; had recourse - turned; propensity - natural urge; figuring - picturing, drawing; the king's arms - the royal coat of arms, painted on a board in the church; the signs - the painted signs of the village inns; putting me very greatly to the blush - making me blush with shame; mispending - misspending, wasting; flags - flagstones, flat stones forming a floor; hearth-stone - the flat stone in front of a fireplace, close to the fire; furnished - supplied; execute - carry out, make; camel-hair pencil - a fine paintbrush made of animal hair; shells of colours - paints kept in shells; patterns - pictures to copy; rude productions - rough, simple pictures; delineated - drawn

Text 2
In the Margins
From an autobiographical essay by Imogen Fennimore (fictional), an illustrator of children's books, 2022

In this essay, Imogen Fennimore looks back on being told off for drawing in lessons at secondary school.

[1] My Year 8 maths exercise book still exists. It lives in a box in my studio, under a pile of old sketchbooks, and every so often I take it out to remind myself who I used to be. The sums are mostly wrong. The margins are magnificent. Down the edge of every page marches a procession of creatures: owls in spectacles, a fox in a bow tie, a dragon curled round a long division like a cat round a hot-water bottle. It looks less like a maths book than a zoo that has escaped into a classroom.

[2] I was not a naughty child. I did not shout out, or throw things, or lose my homework more than anyone else. My crime was quieter and, as far as my teachers were concerned, more annoying: I could not stop drawing. A pen in my hand behaved like a dog let off its lead. It went where it wanted.

[3] "Are you listening, or are you drawing?" Mr Haskins would ask, and the honest answer -- both -- never seemed to be the right one. One afternoon in a history lesson he held my exercise book up in front of the whole class and turned the pages slowly, so that everyone could see the knights and horses galloping across the Battle of Hastings. Did I think, he asked, that I was going to earn my living as a cartoonist? Twenty-nine faces laughed. I went red to the roots of my hair, shut the book, and for a week I drew nothing at all.

[4] It was the longest week of my school life. I sat with my hands pressed flat on the desk, like a pianist who has been forbidden to touch a piano. The words of the lessons slid past me and away. Without a pen to anchor me, my mind drifted out of the window, over the playing fields and off towards the hills. I heard less, not more. Not drawing, it turned out, was far more distracting than drawing.

[5] Years later I found out that I had not imagined this. In a study published in 2009, a psychologist at the University of Plymouth asked forty people to listen to a deliberately dull telephone message; half of them shaded in printed shapes while they listened. In a surprise memory test afterwards, the doodlers remembered 29 per cent more. I have sometimes thought of posting a copy to Mr Haskins.

[6] Rescue came from an unexpected direction. At the end of that silent week, our art teacher, Ms Oduya, found me eating my lunch on the steps behind the art block and asked to see the book everyone had laughed at. She turned the pages without a word -- the same slow turning, I remember thinking, but the opposite of a performance. Then she went to her cupboard and came back with a hardback sketchbook: black, as thick as a brick, its pages still smelling of the shop.

[7] "This is for the things that don't fit in the margins," she said. "Fill it, and I'll find you another."

[8] I filled eleven before I left school.

[9] I want to be fair to Mr Haskins. He had thirty children to teach and an exam course to finish, and a pupil sketching horses through the Norman Conquest must have looked like a pupil who did not care. Nor was he entirely wrong. A drawing can be a hiding place as well as a window, and there were lessons I drew my way through because I did not want to admit that I was lost.

[10] Today I illustrate children's books for a living. Last month, at a book festival, a boy of about ten slid his own exercise book across the signing table, half proud and half ashamed. The margins were full of dragons. I signed it, and in the corner I drew a small fox in a bow tie. "Keep going," I told him. "But listen as well." It is the advice I needed in Year 8, and I needed both halves of it.

Question 4 is about Text 1, A Memoir of Thomas Bewick by Thomas Bewick and Text 2, In the Margins by Imogen Fennimore (fictional).

'Both writers show that the adults around them did more to hold back their talent than to help it.'

How far do you agree with this statement?

In your answer you should:
• discuss how the adults in each text respond to the writers' drawing
• explain how far you agree that the adults did more to hold back the writers' talent than to help it
• compare the ways the texts present the adults' responses to the writers' drawing.

Support your response with quotations from Text 1 and Text 2. [18]

Model answer

I agree with the statement far more for Bewick than for Fennimore. In both texts the adults in charge first treat drawing as a fault, but Bewick's talent grows almost entirely in spite of his father and teachers, whereas Fennimore's is rescued by a second teacher, and the writer's fair-minded hindsight makes simple blame impossible.

Both writers are punished or shamed by the adults responsible for them, though in ways that reflect their different times. Bewick's father and master agree that 'to spare the rod was to spoil the child', so his slate drawings are 'rubbed out, for fear of a beating': the threat of violence literally erases his work. Mr Haskins uses words rather than the rod, but his attack is more public: he 'held my exercise book up in front of the whole class', and the short sentence 'Twenty-nine faces laughed.' isolates the humiliation. Both adults mock as well as punish -- Bewick's master is 'ridiculing and calling me a conjurer', while Mr Haskins sarcastically asks whether the writer will earn a living 'as a cartoonist' -- but the tones differ. Bewick's understated 'too severely acted upon', softened further by 'I think', leaves the reader to judge the cruelty, whereas Fennimore's physical detail 'red to the roots of my hair' makes us feel the shame.

Yet the adults' power to hold the writers back is very different. Bewick insists that 'nothing could deter me from persevering in it', and his long, cumulative sentences show the urge simply moving elsewhere: from slate to margins to 'the gravestones and the floor of the church porch', then to the 'hearth-stone' at home, until he had 'long scorched my face'. The list of surfaces makes his persistence seem unstoppable. Fennimore, by contrast, obeys: 'for a week I drew nothing at all'. The simile 'like a pianist who has been forbidden to touch a piano' makes the ban feel like a torment, and the paradox 'Not drawing, it turned out, was far more distracting than drawing.' shows the teacher's response harming learning as well as art. In the short term, then, Mr Haskins does more damage; but the deeper neglect is in Text 1, where no adult teaches Bewick anything about art: 'of patterns, or drawings, I had none'.

Both texts do show help, in each case a gift of materials, but where it comes from matters. Bewick's turning point is 'a friend, in compassion, furnished me with some paper', and the short sentence 'Here I had more scope.' marks the release; his 'rustic neighbours' then treat him as 'an eminent painter'. None of this comes from his father or teachers: James Burn made him 'quite happy' and his master 'complimented' his Latin, but nobody responsible for him encourages his drawing. In Text 2 the rescue comes from inside the school. Fennimore signals it structurally, 'Rescue came from an unexpected direction.', and sets Ms Oduya's silent reading of the book against Mr Haskins's: 'the same slow turning ... but the opposite of a performance'. Her promise, 'Fill it, and I'll find you another', is answered by a one-sentence paragraph, 'I filled eleven before I left school.', proving that one adult's help outweighed another's mockery.

The writers' adult perspectives also affect how far we agree. Bewick, writing in old age, is wryly self-critical rather than bitter -- the conversation 'was little to my credit', his verses 'wretched rhymes' -- and his purpose is to trace how he became an artist rather than to accuse anyone, which suits a time when the rod was an accepted part of schooling. Fennimore, writing in 2022, argues for doodling with a psychologist's evidence, yet deliberately defends the teacher: 'I want to be fair to Mr Haskins.' The admission 'Nor was he entirely wrong', with the metaphor of drawing as 'a hiding place as well as a window', shows that even the adult who held the writer back had a point, and the ending passes on balanced advice to a boy: 'Keep going ... But listen as well.'

Overall, Text 1 largely bears the statement out: the adults in charge of Bewick mostly held him back, and his talent survived through his own stubbornness and a friend's kindness. Text 2 bears it out only in part: Mr Haskins nearly silenced the writer, but Ms Oduya's gift did more to shape a career, and Fennimore's hindsight presents the teacher's failings as understandable rather than simply harmful.

Explanation

A top-level answer for AO4 splits its verdict: the statement is largely true of Bewick, whose father and teachers held him back while his help came from a friend and his 'rustic neighbours', but only partly true of Fennimore, for whom Ms Oduya's gift outweighs Mr Haskins's mockery. For AO3 it pairs the two childhoods in every paragraph, on punishment and shame, on how far the adults could stop the drawing, on where help came from and on the writers' hindsight, comparing methods such as Bewick's understatement with the vivid detail of Fennimore's humiliation. Its quotations from both texts are short, and it weighs purpose, perspective and period, from the rod as an accepted part of eighteenth-century schooling to Fennimore's fairness towards a teacher with 'thirty children to teach'. Responses that take Bewick and Fennimore in separate halves, narrate the two childhoods, or accept the statement in full without counting the help each writer was given are held to the lower levels.

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO4: Evaluate texts critically and support this with appropriate textual references.
    Level 6 (11-12 marks): A sustained critical evaluation demonstrating a perceptive and considered response to the statement and a full explanation of the impact of the texts on the reader. Comments are supported by apt, skilfully selected and integrated textual references.
    Level 5 (9-10 marks): An informed critical evaluation showing a thoughtful response to the statement and clear consideration of the impact of the texts on the reader. Comments are supported by persuasive textual references.
    Level 4 (7-8 marks): A response with developed evaluative comments addressing the statement and some comments about the impact on the reader. Comments are supported by well-chosen textual references.
    Level 3 (5-6 marks): A response with clear evaluative comments and some awareness of the impact on the reader. Comments are supported by appropriate textual references.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): A response with straightforward evaluative comments and a little awareness of the impact on the reader. Comments are supported by some appropriate textual references.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): A limited description of content. Comments are supported by copying or paraphrase.
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    Max 12 if only one text is considered: OCR's guidance is 'There are 0 marks for AO3 where only one text is considered' (OCR J351/02 mark scheme, June 2025), so only the AO4 mark can be awarded.
    OCR's guidance: 'The first two bullet points of the question prompt candidates to evaluate the text (AO4) and the third bullet point prompts candidates to compare the texts (AO3).' Candidates may answer the bullet points in combination and integrate evaluation and comparison throughout; OCR says this 'is a valid approach which may achieve the highest levels' (OCR J351/01 mark scheme, June 2024). Where the candidate's answer consistently meets the criteria, the higher mark should be awarded.
    Candidates may evaluate these ideas (agreeing and disagreeing; not a checklist):
    Text 1, agreeing: the father calls him 'unguidable' and agrees 'to spare the rod was to spoil the child'; drawings on the slate are 'rubbed out, for fear of a beating'; Latin is taught with no explained purpose; the master is 'ridiculing and calling me a conjurer'; the father 'found a deal of fault'; no one teaches him: 'of patterns, or drawings, I had none'.
    Text 1, disagreeing: James Burn made him 'quite happy'; the master 'complimented' his progress in Latin; the decisive help comes from 'a friend, in compassion', whose paper gave him 'more scope'; his 'rustic neighbours' admire him as 'an eminent painter' and hang his pictures. Some may argue that opposition only strengthened him: 'nothing could deter me from persevering in it'.
    Text 2, agreeing: Mr Haskins turns the book into a public show, 'Did I think, he asked, that I was going to earn my living as a cartoonist?'; 'Twenty-nine faces laughed'; the writer stops drawing for a week.
    Text 2, disagreeing: Ms Oduya's sketchbook and 'Fill it, and I'll find you another'; 'I filled eleven before I left school'; the writer's fairness, 'I want to be fair to Mr Haskins' and 'Nor was he entirely wrong'; the adult writer now helps a child: 'Keep going ... But listen as well.'
    Perceptive evaluation weighs how far: in Text 1 the parents and teachers mostly hold him back and help comes from outside school and home, so the statement fits better; in Text 2 one teacher's kindness outweighs another's mockery, and the writer's balanced hindsight complicates any simple blame. It may consider context (eighteenth-century schooling in which beating was normal; a modern school with exam pressure and thirty pupils), purpose (an old man's memoir recording how he became an artist; an essay arguing for doodling while staying fair) and impact (Bewick's calm understatement, 'too severely acted upon', against the vivid humiliation of 'red to the roots of my hair').

  2. 6 marks

    Levels of response (6 marks). AO3: Compare writers' ideas and perspectives as well as how these are conveyed across two or more texts.
    Level 6 (6 marks): A detailed, interwoven comparison which explores writers' ideas and perspectives and how they are conveyed.
    Level 5 (5 marks): A sustained comparison of writers' ideas and perspectives and how they are conveyed.
    Level 4 (4 marks): A developed comparison of writers' ideas and perspectives and how they are conveyed.
    Level 3 (3 marks): A clear comparison of writers' ideas and perspectives which begins to consider how they are conveyed.
    Level 2 (2 marks): A response which identifies main points of comparison between writers' ideas and perspectives.
    Level 1 (1 mark): A response which makes simple points of comparison between writers' ideas and perspectives.
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    OCR: 'There are 0 marks for AO3 where only one text is considered.' OCR's examples of simple points of comparison include repeating the words of the statement and writing about both texts side by side so that comparisons have to be inferred (OCR J351/02 mark scheme, June 2025).
    Candidates may compare these points (not a checklist):
    Both are mocked by a teacher: Bewick's master is 'ridiculing and calling me a conjurer' while he draws in the church porch -> Mr Haskins makes a public show of the book in front of the class -> Text 2's mockery is more humiliating, but Text 1's adults also threaten beatings, which is harsher.
    Both turning points are gifts of materials: 'a friend, in compassion, furnished me with some paper' -> 'a hardback sketchbook' with spoken encouragement -> Bewick's helper is outside school; Fennimore's is a teacher.
    Responses to opposition: Bewick is defiant, 'nothing could deter me' -> Fennimore gives up for a week, 'for a week I drew nothing at all' -> the modern writer seems more vulnerable.
    Form and style: Bewick's long, cumulative sentences list every surface he drew on (slate, margins, gravestones, porch, hearth-stone) -> Fennimore's crafted essay uses dialogue, short paragraphs and a closing echo.
    Perspectives: an old man looking back with gentle irony, 'It was little to my credit' -> a modern adult who is fair to the teacher and uses research to argue that doodling helps.
    Endings: Bewick's success is local, pictures on neighbours' walls 'at a very cheap rate' -> Fennimore's is a career, and the writer passes help on to the next child.

Question 3

18 marks

Read Text 1 and Text 2 below. Then answer the question that follows.

Text 1
From Across Patagonia, a travel book by Lady Florence Dixie, published in 1880

In 1879 Lady Florence Dixie travelled on horseback across Patagonia, in the far south of South America, with her husband and a small party of companions. In this extract from her travel book, the riders are on their way back to their camp.

[1] As we rode along, our attention was attracted by a faint smell of burning, and presently thick clouds of smoke came rolling towards us. We pressed wonderingly on, anxious to discover the whereabouts of the fire, which we trusted lay somewhere far from our camp. Reaching a slight eminence, we were able to command a view of the country ahead. A cry of dismay escaped our lips as we looked around, and drawing rein, we stared blankly at one another. A fearful sight lay before us. To our left, right in front, and gradually wreathing the hills to our right, a huge prairie fire came rushing rapidly along. Dense masses of smoke curled aloft, and entirely obscured the sky; the flames, which shot fiercely up, cast a strange yellow glare over everything. Even whilst we watched, a strong gust of wind swept the fire with incredible swiftness towards us, and in a second we were enveloped in such a dense cloud of smoke that we were unable to see one another. The situation had now become critical, and not a moment was to be lost. Half choked, and bewildered by the suddenness with which the danger had come upon us, we scarcely knew what course to take. Already our horses were snorting with fear, as the crackling of the burning grass and bushes came nearer and nearer. To run away from the coming fire was useless; the alternative was to face it at a gallop, and get through it if possible. To throw our guanaco mantles over our heads, and draw them as tightly round us as we could, was the work of a second, and then digging our spurs into our horses, we dashed forward, every one for himself. The moments that followed seemed an eternity. As I urged my unwilling horse forward, the sense of suffocation grew terrible, I could scarcely draw breath, and the panting animal seemed to stagger beneath me. The horrible crackling came nearer and nearer; I became conscious of the most intolerable heat, and my head began to swim round. My horse gave two or three furious plunges, and then burst madly forward. Almost choked, come what might, I could bear the mantle over my head no longer, and tore it off me. The sudden sense of relief that came over me as I did so, I shall never forget. I looked up, the air was comparatively clear, and the fire behind me. By some miracle I had passed through it unhurt! I looked for my companions, and, to my inexpressible joy, saw them emerge one by one from the black mass of smoke, which was now rapidly receding into the distance. Congratulations and exclamations over, we retraced our steps to try and discover how we had managed to escape so luckily. The reason was soon apparent. By a piece of fortune we had happened to ride over a narrow pebbly tract of ground, where the grass was extremely sparse, and where there were but few bushes; had chance led us over any other track, where the grass was thick and tall, we could scarcely ever have got through the danger. Our poor horses had suffered a good deal as it was, their feet and legs being scorched and singed severely.

[2] Our thoughts now flew to our camp, and to Storer and I'Aria, whom we had left behind there. That they had escaped we had little doubt, but for our tents and chattels we felt there was no hope. The landscape seemed completely changed by the fire, all around, as far as we could see, stretched black smoking plains, and the outlines of the hills had become quite unfamiliar to us.

[3] With rather heavy hearts we pushed forward, eagerly scanning the country for some indication which might guide us to the quarter where our camp had stood. If, as we had every reason to believe, our things were burnt, our Patagonian trip was at an end, for the present, at all events. Fortunately things did not turn out so badly. Presently my husband, who was riding in advance of the others, gave a shout, and made signals for us to come on. I need hardly say that we did not lose a moment in joining him, and a welcome sight, as we got up to him, met our eyes. Some two or three hundred yards below the hill on which we were, we perceived our little white tents standing safe and unharmed on a narrow green tract of land, which looked like a smiling island in the midst of the vast black plain. Storer and I'Aria, too, we could see moving about, and, overjoyed, we galloped down towards them, they running out to meet us, having suffered no little anxiety, on their parts, as to what might have happened to us.

Glossary: wonderingly - puzzled, curious; trusted - hoped; eminence - a small hill; command a view - see clearly over; drawing rein - pulling on the reins to stop our horses; wreathing - curling round; prairie - a huge stretch of open grassland; aloft - high into the air; obscured - hid; enveloped - wrapped, surrounded; guanaco - a South American animal related to the llama; mantles - cloaks (here made of guanaco skin); spurs - spikes on a rider's heels, used to urge a horse on; intolerable - unbearable; plunges - violent leaps forward; come what might - whatever happened; inexpressible - too great to put into words; tract - stretch of land; sparse - thin, scattered; singed - burnt on the surface; Storer and I'Aria - two members of the party who had stayed at the camp; chattels - belongings; quarter - area

Text 2
Holding the Line
From an article by Wren Cawthorne (fictional) in a countryside magazine, 2025

In this magazine article, Wren Cawthorne, a volunteer who helps firefighters on the moors of northern England, describes the night a wildfire spread across Scarrow Moor.

[1] Six weeks on, Scarrow Moor still smells like the morning after a bonfire. Walk up from the cattle grid at Top Gate and the path carries you, quite suddenly, out of brown heather and into black. Not grey, not charcoal: black, as if someone had tipped a pot of ink over the hillside and left it to dry.

[2] I was there the night it burned. I am not a firefighter. I am a volunteer with the Scarrow Moor Fire Group -- a dozen farmers, two gamekeepers, a retired chemistry teacher and me, a part-time library assistant who grew up in the village below. Each spring the fire service trains us to do three things: carry heavy kit up steep ground, find every track on the moor in the dark, and do exactly what we are told. The firefighters are in charge. We are extra pairs of hands.

[3] The message came at twenty to eight on a Saturday evening in April, after five weeks without rain: "Moor fire, Top Gate, all available." By the time I reached the car park, the sky above the ridge had turned the colour of a bruise, purple at the edges and a sore, sickly yellow in the middle. You could taste the fire before you could see it.

[4] Up on the top, it was not one fire but a hundred, strung along a ragged front half a mile long. Where the heather was old and deep, the flames stood taller than a man. Where it was short, they crept and flickered, nosing forward into the dry grass like something hungry. And the noise -- nobody warns you about the noise. Underneath, a steady roar, like traffic on a motorway; on top of it, a constant snapping and popping, as if a thousand twigs were being broken at once.

[5] We worked in a line behind the fire crews, ten of us with beaters: flat rubber flaps on long poles that you bring down on the flames, again and again, to smother them. Lift, swing, slap. Lift, swing, slap. It sounds simple. Within twenty minutes my shoulders were burning almost as fiercely as the heather. The heat came in waves, tightening the skin across my face, and the smoke found every gap -- collar, cuffs, the edge of my mask -- until my eyes streamed and every breath tasted of burnt toast.

[6] For an hour, we held it. The flames reached the gravel track we had chosen as our line and stopped there, sulking, unable to cross. Somebody further along actually cheered.

[7] Then the wind changed.

[8] It happened in seconds. The smoke swung round like a door slamming, and suddenly the fire was not in front of us but beside us, racing up a gully towards the ridge faster than any of us could have run. Fire loves a slope. The crew commander's voice came over the radio, flat and calm: "Everyone back to the track. Now." We went. Nobody argued, nobody stopped to look back, and I have never in my life been so grateful to be told what to do.

[9] By dawn the flames were out, beaten back by the crews and by a helicopter that dipped its bucket into the reservoir again and again, like a heron fishing. But a moorland fire does not end when the flames do. Beneath the heather lies peat, in places several metres deep, and peat can smoulder underground for days, even weeks, breaking out again long after everyone has gone home. Firefighters were damping down on Scarrow for nine days.

[10] What we lost is harder to count. By late April the nesting season has begun, and curlews and golden plovers lay their eggs on open ground. I try not to think about how many nests were on that hillside. The heather will come back, slowly, over years. Where the peat itself burned, though, the damage is measured in centuries: peat builds up by about a millimetre a year at best.

[11] The investigators think it started with a disposable barbecue left on a rock beside the path. I am not going to lecture anyone. But if you love these hills, please leave the barbecue at home, take your bottles and cigarette ends away with you, and if you ever see smoke on the moor, do not try to be a hero. Get well away from it and ring 999.

[12] Last weekend I walked back up to Top Gate. The black is still there. But at its edge, pushing up through the ash, were the first green spikes of cotton grass, bright as new paint. The moor, it seems, is not finished with us. I hope we are not finished with it.

Glossary: gamekeepers - people employed to look after wildlife and land on a country estate; beaters - tools for putting out small fires by smothering them; damping down - soaking burnt ground to stop it catching fire again; peat - dark, spongy soil made of plants that have rotted very slowly (it burns easily when dry); curlews and golden plovers - birds that nest on the ground on moorland

Question 4 is about Text 1, Across Patagonia by Lady Florence Dixie and Text 2, Holding the Line by Wren Cawthorne (fictional).

'Both texts show that people are powerless against fire.'

How far do you agree with this statement?

In your answer you should:
• discuss what we learn about the fires and the people caught up in them
• explain how far you agree that people are powerless against fire
• compare the ways the texts present people facing fire.

Support your response with quotations from Text 1 and Text 2. [18]

Model answer

For the most part I agree: both writers show fire as a force that people cannot truly control, especially once the wind takes hold. However, they differ in how much they think people can do. Dixie's party survives mainly through luck, whereas Cawthorne shows trained people holding a fire back for a while and finally putting it out, so Text 2 suggests that people are limited rather than completely powerless.

In both texts the decisive moment belongs to the wind, not to people. In Text 1, 'a strong gust of wind swept the fire with incredible swiftness towards us', and the riders are suddenly 'unable to see one another'; in Text 2, after an hour of success, 'Then the wind changed.' The methods differ, though. Dixie's long sentences pile danger on danger, with the repeated 'nearer and nearer' building panic, while Cawthorne isolates the turning point in a one-line paragraph, so that the reader feels the shock in a single beat before the fire races off 'faster than any of us could have run'. Both writers show how little time people have to think: Dixie's party 'stared blankly at one another' and 'scarcely knew what course to take', and for Cawthorne 'It happened in seconds', the smoke swinging round 'like a door slamming'.

Yet neither group is simply passive, and here the texts begin to separate. The riders make a quick, brave decision -- 'the alternative was to face it at a gallop' -- and protect themselves with their 'guanaco mantles', but then ride 'every one for himself', each person struggling alone as Dixie urges her 'unwilling horse forward'. Cawthorne's volunteers, by contrast, act together: 'We worked in a line behind the fire crews', and the rhythmic repetition of 'Lift, swing, slap.' shows effort that is shared and organised. 'For an hour, we held it.' The personification of the flames as 'sulking, unable to cross' shows people briefly in control, as Dixie's riders never are. Even at the moment of escape the difference remains: Cawthorne's group obeys a calm 'Everyone back to the track. Now.', whereas Dixie's riders must save themselves.

What finally saves people is the clearest contrast. Dixie credits luck again and again: 'By some miracle I had passed through it unhurt!', 'By a piece of fortune', 'had chance led us over any other track'. This repeated vocabulary of chance strongly supports the statement, and in this extract the tents are found 'standing safe and unharmed' without any explanation of how. In Text 2, 'By dawn the flames were out, beaten back by the crews and by a helicopter'. Radios, training and modern equipment, which travellers alone in Patagonia in 1879 did not have, make a real difference. However, both writers admit that fire outlasts human effort. The riders' horses are 'scorched and singed severely' and the landscape is 'completely changed' into 'black smoking plains'; Cawthorne warns that peat 'can smoulder underground for days, even weeks' and that 'the damage is measured in centuries'.

The writers' purposes explain their different endings. Dixie, whose travel book sets out to thrill readers with adventure, does not ask how the fire started, and she ends with relief at a 'smiling island in the midst of the vast black plain'. Cawthorne, writing to inform and warn readers who 'love these hills', says that it probably 'started with a disposable barbecue', and urges them to 'leave the barbecue at home' and 'ring 999'. This suggests that, although people may be powerless once a fire is raging, they have real power to prevent one. Both texts end with life amid blackness, but Cawthorne's 'first green spikes of cotton grass' show the moor healing itself rather than being healed by people.

Overall, I mostly agree. Both texts show people overwhelmed by the speed of fire and saved as much by luck or retreat as by their own efforts, which makes Dixie's breathless account especially vivid for the reader. But Text 2, unlike Text 1, shows that organised people can slow a fire, put it out in time and stop the next one starting, so powerless is too strong a word for Cawthorne's account.

Explanation

A top answer mostly agrees but tests the statement, weighing the luck and helplessness in Text 1 ('By some miracle', 'every one for himself') and the retreat and lasting damage in Text 2 against the riders' quick decisions and against Cawthorne's organised fire-fighting, final success and warnings, so that people in Text 2 appear limited rather than powerless. Both texts appear in every paragraph, which compares the wind in each, luck against training, and methods such as Dixie's long, breathless sentences beside Cawthorne's one-line paragraph and personification, with purpose and period kept in view. Answers that write up each fire separately, narrate the two events, or agree without ever testing the statement earn only middle or low marks.

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO4: Evaluate texts critically and support this with appropriate textual references.
    Level 6 (11-12 marks): A sustained critical evaluation demonstrating a perceptive and considered response to the statement and a full explanation of the impact of the texts on the reader. Comments are supported by apt, skilfully selected and integrated textual references.
    Level 5 (9-10 marks): An informed critical evaluation showing a thoughtful response to the statement and clear consideration of the impact of the texts on the reader. Comments are supported by persuasive textual references.
    Level 4 (7-8 marks): A response with developed evaluative comments addressing the statement and some comments about the impact on the reader. Comments are supported by well-chosen textual references.
    Level 3 (5-6 marks): A response with clear evaluative comments and some awareness of the impact on the reader. Comments are supported by appropriate textual references.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): A response with straightforward evaluative comments and a little awareness of the impact on the reader. Comments are supported by some appropriate textual references.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): A limited description of content. Comments are supported by copying or paraphrase.
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    Max 12 if only one text is considered: OCR's guidance is 'There are 0 marks for AO3 where only one text is considered' (OCR J351/02 mark scheme, June 2025), so only the AO4 mark can be awarded.
    OCR's guidance: 'The first two bullet points of the question prompt candidates to evaluate the text (AO4) and the third bullet point prompts candidates to compare the texts (AO3).' Candidates may answer the bullet points in combination and integrate evaluation and comparison throughout; OCR says this 'is a valid approach which may achieve the highest levels' (OCR J351/01 mark scheme, June 2024). Where the candidate's answer consistently meets the criteria, the higher mark should be awarded.
    Candidates may evaluate these ideas (agreeing and disagreeing; not a checklist):
    Text 1, agreeing: the riders 'stared blankly at one another' and 'scarcely knew what course to take'; the fire is on three sides; 'every one for himself'; survival is put down to luck: 'By some miracle', 'By a piece of fortune', 'had chance led us over any other track'; the horses are 'scorched and singed severely'; the landscape is 'completely changed'; they feel 'there was no hope' for the camp.
    Text 1, disagreeing: they make a quick, brave decision ('the alternative was to face it at a gallop') and protect themselves with their 'guanaco mantles'; Dixie forces her 'unwilling horse forward'; all of them get through, and the camp is 'standing safe and unharmed' (the extract does not say how it was saved).
    Text 2, agreeing: 'Then the wind changed.'; the fire races 'faster than any of us could have run'; the volunteers must retreat ('Everyone back to the track. Now.'); peat 'can smoulder underground for days, even weeks'; 'the damage is measured in centuries'; nesting birds suffer; the moor heals itself ('the first green spikes of cotton grass').
    Text 2, disagreeing: organised, trained people 'held it' for an hour and the flames stopped, 'sulking, unable to cross'; 'By dawn the flames were out, beaten back by the crews and by a helicopter'; the fire was caused by people ('a disposable barbecue'), so people can also prevent fires ('leave the barbecue at home', 'ring 999').
    Perceptive evaluation might judge that both texts show people powerless once the wind takes over, but that Text 1 relies on luck while Text 2 shows what training and teamwork can achieve; that power lies more in preventing fire than in fighting it; or that the statement fits Text 1 better than Text 2. It may consider impact on the reader (Dixie's breathless terror and relief; Cawthorne's calm, expert voice), purpose (an adventure to thrill readers; an article to inform and warn) and context (travellers alone in a remote wilderness in 1879; a fire service with radios and a helicopter in 2025).

  2. 6 marks

    Levels of response (6 marks). AO3: Compare writers' ideas and perspectives as well as how these are conveyed across two or more texts.
    Level 6 (6 marks): A detailed, interwoven comparison which explores writers' ideas and perspectives and how they are conveyed.
    Level 5 (5 marks): A sustained comparison of writers' ideas and perspectives and how they are conveyed.
    Level 4 (4 marks): A developed comparison of writers' ideas and perspectives and how they are conveyed.
    Level 3 (3 marks): A clear comparison of writers' ideas and perspectives which begins to consider how they are conveyed.
    Level 2 (2 marks): A response which identifies main points of comparison between writers' ideas and perspectives.
    Level 1 (1 mark): A response which makes simple points of comparison between writers' ideas and perspectives.
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    OCR: 'There are 0 marks for AO3 where only one text is considered.' OCR's examples of simple points of comparison include repeating the words of the statement and writing about both texts side by side so that comparisons have to be inferred (OCR J351/02 mark scheme, June 2025).
    Candidates may compare these points (not a checklist):
    - Response to the fire: Dixie's party rides through it to escape -> Cawthorne's group walks towards it to fight it.
    - People together: 'every one for himself' -> 'We worked in a line behind the fire crews', under a commander's orders -> Text 2 shows people more able to act together.
    - What saves people: luck and chance ('By some miracle', 'By a piece of fortune') -> training, obedience and equipment -> but both are finally at the mercy of the wind ('a strong gust of wind'; 'Then the wind changed.').
    - Methods: Dixie's long, breathless sentences, repetition ('nearer and nearer') and exclamation ('By some miracle I had passed through it unhurt!') -> Cawthorne's short sentences, one-line paragraphs and personification of the fire ('like something hungry', 'sulking').
    - Endings: a 'smiling island in the midst of the vast black plain' -> 'the first green spikes of cotton grass' -> both end with life amid destruction, but Text 2 adds a warning to readers.
    - Perspective: a traveller in an unfamiliar land, for whom the fire is a danger to her party -> a local volunteer, for whom it is damage to a loved place and its wildlife, with a human cause.
    Higher-level answers interweave these comparisons of ideas and methods throughout, making explicit which text presents people as more or less powerful.

Question 4

18 marks

Read Text 1 and Text 2 below. Then answer the question that follows.

Text 1
From Canyons of the Colorado, an expedition journal by John Wesley Powell, published in 1895

In 1869 the American explorer and geologist John Wesley Powell led a small expedition in wooden boats down the Colorado River and through the Grand Canyon. In this extract from his journal, which is written in the present tense, he describes the events of 14 August 1869.

[1] At daybreak we walk down the bank of the river, on a little sandy beach, to take a view of a new feature in the canyon. Heretofore hard rocks have given us bad river; soft rocks, smooth water; and a series of rocks harder than any we have experienced sets in. The river enters the gneiss! We can see but a little way into the granite gorge, but it looks threatening.

[2] After breakfast we enter on the waves. At the very introduction it inspires awe. The canyon is narrower than we have ever before seen it; the water is swifter; there are but few broken rocks in the channel; but the walls are set, on either side, with pinnacles and crags; and sharp, angular buttresses, bristling with wind- and wave-polished spires, extend far out into the river.

[3] Ledges of rock jut into the stream, their tops sometimes just below the surface, sometimes rising a few or many feet above; and island ledges and island pinnacles and island towers break the swift course of the stream into chutes and eddies and whirlpools. We soon reach a place where a creek comes in from the left, and, just below, the channel is choked with boulders, which have washed down this lateral canyon and formed a dam, over which there is a fall of 30 or 40 feet; but on the boulders foothold can be had, and we make a portage. Three more such dams are found. Over one we make a portage; at the other two are chutes through which we can run.

[4] As we proceed the granite rises higher, until nearly a thousand feet of the lower part of the walls are composed of this rock.

[5] About eleven o'clock we hear a great roar ahead, and approach it very cautiously. The sound grows louder and louder as we run, and at last we find ourselves above a long, broken fall, with ledges and pinnacles of rock obstructing the river. There is a descent of perhaps 75 or 80 feet in a third of a mile, and the rushing waters break into great waves on the rocks, and lash themselves into a mad, white foam. We can land just above, but there is no foothold on either side by which we can make a portage. It is nearly a thousand feet to the top of the granite; so it will be impossible to carry our boats around, though we can climb to the summit up a side gulch and, passing along a mile or two, descend to the river. This we find on examination; but such a portage would be impracticable for us, and we must run the rapid or abandon the river. There is no hesitation. We step into our boats, push off, and away we go, first on smooth but swift water, then we strike a glassy wave and ride to its top, down again into the trough, up again on a higher wave, and down and up on waves higher and still higher until we strike one just as it curls back, and a breaker rolls over our little boat. Still on we speed, shooting past projecting rocks, till the little boat is caught in a whirlpool and spun round several times. At last we pull out again into the stream. And now the other boats have passed us. The open compartment of the "Emma Dean" is filled with water and every breaker rolls over us. Hurled back from a rock, now on this side, now on that, we are carried into an eddy, in which we struggle for a few minutes, and are then out again, the breakers still rolling over us. Our boat is unmanageable, but she cannot sink, and we drift down another hundred yards through breakers--how, we scarcely know. We find the other boats have turned into an eddy at the foot of the fall and are waiting to catch us as we come, for the men have seen that our boat is swamped. They push out as we come near and pull us in against the wall. Our boat bailed, on we go again.

Glossary: heretofore - until now; gneiss - a very hard rock with bands of minerals in it (pronounced 'nice'); gorge - a narrow valley with steep rocky sides; introduction - very start; pinnacles - tall, pointed columns of rock; crags - steep, rough masses of rock; buttresses - masses of rock jutting out from a cliff; chutes - narrow channels where water flows fast; eddies - currents that circle round, often behind rocks; lateral canyon - a side canyon; portage - carrying the boats and supplies over land past a dangerous stretch of river; gulch - a narrow, steep-sided valley; impracticable - impossible to carry out; trough - the low point between two waves; breaker - a heavy wave that breaks into foam; the "Emma Dean" - Powell's boat, named after his wife; unmanageable - impossible to steer; swamped - filled with water; bailed - with the water scooped out

Text 2
Don't Stand Up
From an article by Freya Pennock (fictional) in an outdoor adventure magazine, 2023

In this article from an outdoor adventure magazine, the writer describes a first white-water rafting trip on a river in the Scottish Highlands.

[1] "If you fall in, whatever you do, don't try to stand up." Isla, our guide, said it cheerfully, the way you might tell someone where the biscuits are kept. Then she said it again, not cheerfully at all.

[2] I should explain that I am not a water person. I learned to swim at thirty-one, in a leisure centre pool, and I have spent most of my holidays since admiring the sea from a safe distance with an ice cream. So when my brother booked a white-water rafting trip for my fortieth birthday, I assumed it was a joke. It was not a joke. It was non-refundable.

[3] The briefing took place on a shingle bank beside a river the colour of strong tea. Eight of us were squeezed into wetsuits, buoyancy aids and helmets while Isla explained the rules. Rapids are graded from one to six, she said: six is the kind that hardly anyone attempts, and today's biggest was a three. If you go overboard, lie on your back with your feet pointing downstream and your toes at the surface, and let the river carry you. Put your feet down and one of them can be trapped between rocks. "The river is stronger than you," she said. "Don't argue with it." Someone laughed. I did not.

[4] For the first mile, the river seemed to have heard none of this. It slid between birch woods, smooth and polite, and the only sound was the drip from our paddles. A heron lifted off a rock ahead of us, unhurried, as if it had watched a thousand nervous beginners float past and expected nothing of us. I began to think my brother had wasted his money. Then I heard it.

[5] It began as a hiss, like a radio left on in another room, and grew into a roar that seemed to come up through the floor of the raft. Isla, perched at the back, stopped smiling. "Forward paddle," she called. "Hard!"

[6] What followed lasted perhaps twenty seconds, and I remember it the way you remember a dream: in pieces, out of order, impossibly bright. The front of the raft rose, and rose, and then dropped into a trough so deep that the next wave towered above my head. Cold water slapped my face, filled my mouth, poured down the neck of my wetsuit. Somebody was yelling my name. My paddle hit nothing, then rock, then air. The raft buckled around a boulder like a book snapping shut, and then the river simply let go of it, and we shot out sideways into a pool of slow, spinning foam.

[7] I was not in the raft. I discovered this calmly, almost politely, as if someone had told me the time. Underwater, everything was green and roaring and oddly peaceful. Then my buoyancy aid hauled me up into the light, and the advice I had half ignored on the bank arrived in my head in Isla's voice: back, feet, toes. I lay back. I pointed my feet downstream. The river carried me, as promised, and it did not feel like drowning. It felt like being held.

[8] Isla grabbed the shoulders of my buoyancy aid, leaned back and landed me in the bottom of the raft like a large, astonished fish. Everyone was laughing, me included, though my hands were shaking so badly that I could barely grip my paddle.

[9] I have thought a lot since about why that moment felt so good. Part of it, I suspect, is that the danger was real but borrowed. The first people to take boats down rivers like this had no helmets, no guide and no idea what waited round the next bend. I had a woman with a whistle who had done it hundreds of times. And yet the fear was entirely mine, and so was the moment when I stopped fighting and let the water hold me up.

[10] We ran three more rapids before lunch, and I stayed in the raft for all of them. But the instruction I keep coming back to is the first one. Don't stand up. Don't argue with what is stronger than you. Lie back, keep your feet up, and trust that you will float.

Glossary: buoyancy aids - padded jackets that help the wearer float

Question 4 is about Text 1, Canyons of the Colorado by John Wesley Powell and Text 2, Don't Stand Up by Freya Pennock (fictional).

'In both texts, the writers come through the rapid more by luck than by skill.'

How far do you agree with this statement?

In your answer you should:
• discuss what happens to each writer in the rapid
• explain how far you agree that the writers come through the rapid more by luck than by skill
• compare the ways the texts present the struggle with the river.

Support your response with quotations from Text 1 and Text 2. [18]

Model answer

I partly agree for Text 1 but largely disagree for Text 2. Inside the rapid both writers lose control, and Powell's crew genuinely need luck, although their judgement and teamwork decide how much; Pennock's run looks just as chaotic, but the writer comes through because of someone else's skill and a plan that works exactly as promised.

At the worst moment, both texts support the statement, because nobody is steering any more. Powell's single breathless sentence carries the boat 'up again on a higher wave, and down and up on waves higher and still higher' until 'a breaker rolls over our little boat', and the passive verbs turn the crew into objects: the boat 'is caught in a whirlpool', and they are 'Hurled back from a rock, now on this side, now on that'. He admits that the boat stays afloat only because 'she cannot sink', not because anyone steers it, and that they drift through 'how, we scarcely know'. Pennock conveys the same helplessness through shorter, fragmented sentences instead of Powell's long one, and the writer is acted on rather than acting: cold water 'filled my mouth', 'Somebody was yelling my name', and the raft escapes only because 'the river simply let go of it'. The flat statement 'I was not in the raft.' suggests that the writer hardly noticed falling out.

Before the rapid, however, both texts show skill, though it belongs to different people. Powell's crew judge for themselves: they 'walk down the bank of the river ... to take a view', 'approach it very cautiously', choose which dams have 'chutes through which we can run', and reject a portage only 'on examination'. The short sentence 'There is no hesitation.' shows nerve as well as necessity, since they 'must run the rapid or abandon the river'. Pennock's judgement is borrowed from Isla, whose briefing on the shingle bank tells the group to 'lie on your back with your feet pointing downstream'. The writer had 'half ignored' it, yet the article's structure makes it decisive: planted early, the instruction returns in Isla's voice, 'back, feet, toes', and the river carries the writer 'as promised'. That phrase shows that the outcome was expected, not lucky. So the skill is the travellers' own in Text 1 and mostly the guide's in Text 2, but in both it limits what luck has to do.

Rescue follows the same pattern. Powell's boat is saved by the rest of the crew, who have come through and wait in an eddy, 'for the men have seen that our boat is swamped', ready to 'push out as we come near'. Isla, similarly, 'leaned back and landed me in the bottom of the raft like a large, astonished fish', a comic simile at the writer's own expense. In both texts, other people's skill finishes what luck began. Yet the writers' own parts differ: Powell's 'we' is a crew that fights back ('we struggle for a few minutes, and are then out again'), while Pennock's 'I' survives by doing the opposite, in the moment 'when I stopped fighting and let the water hold me up'. For Pennock, the vital skill was trust.

The different forms and times explain why luck matters more in Text 1. Powell's journal of 1869, written in the present tense and the plural 'we', records an expedition into the unknown and never claims credit; its understated last sentence, 'Our boat bailed, on we go again', simply moves on, so its silence about skill may partly be modesty. Pennock's 2023 magazine article reflects afterwards on why the moment felt so good: the danger was 'real but borrowed', on a river whose biggest rapid that day 'was a three', with a guide 'who had done it hundreds of times'. It even draws the contrast itself, picturing the first river-runners with 'no helmets, no guide and no idea what waited round the next bend', a description that fits Powell's crew exactly. Where nobody knows what lies ahead, even careful judgement can only go so far. For the reader, Powell's breathless syntax leaves us as unsure as the crew, while Pennock's calm reflection reassures.

In the end, the statement is partly true of Text 1, where a skilled, watchful crew still has to trust to luck inside the rapid, but not of Text 2, where the writer comes through because an expert's plan worked.

Explanation

The statement is partly true of Powell and hardly true at all of Pennock, and the strongest answers reach that split verdict by comparing the two rapids within every paragraph: the river taking control in both, the skill that comes beforehand (Powell's scouting, Isla's briefing that returns 'as promised'), the other people who complete each rescue, and the gap between an 1869 journal of an unknown river and a 2023 article about a guided trip. They see that skill need not belong to the writer, and they back every point with short quotations from both texts. Retelling each rapid in turn, treating any danger as proof of luck, or accepting the statement untested leaves an answer in the bottom half of the mark range.

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO4: Evaluate texts critically and support this with appropriate textual references.
    Level 6 (11-12 marks): A sustained critical evaluation demonstrating a perceptive and considered response to the statement and a full explanation of the impact of the texts on the reader. Comments are supported by apt, skilfully selected and integrated textual references.
    Level 5 (9-10 marks): An informed critical evaluation showing a thoughtful response to the statement and clear consideration of the impact of the texts on the reader. Comments are supported by persuasive textual references.
    Level 4 (7-8 marks): A response with developed evaluative comments addressing the statement and some comments about the impact on the reader. Comments are supported by well-chosen textual references.
    Level 3 (5-6 marks): A response with clear evaluative comments and some awareness of the impact on the reader. Comments are supported by appropriate textual references.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): A response with straightforward evaluative comments and a little awareness of the impact on the reader. Comments are supported by some appropriate textual references.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): A limited description of content. Comments are supported by copying or paraphrase.
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    Max 12 if only one text is considered: OCR's guidance is 'There are 0 marks for AO3 where only one text is considered' (OCR J351/02 mark scheme, June 2025), so only the AO4 mark can be awarded.
    OCR's guidance: 'The first two bullet points of the question prompt candidates to evaluate the text (AO4) and the third bullet point prompts candidates to compare the texts (AO3).' Candidates may answer the bullet points in combination and integrate evaluation and comparison throughout; OCR says this 'is a valid approach which may achieve the highest levels' (OCR J351/01 mark scheme, June 2024). Where the candidate's answer consistently meets the criteria, the higher mark should be awarded.
    Candidates may evaluate these ideas (agreeing and disagreeing; not a checklist):
    Text 1, agreeing: once in the rapid the crew lose control and the river acts on them ('a breaker rolls over our little boat', 'caught in a whirlpool and spun round several times', 'Hurled back from a rock, now on this side, now on that'); 'Our boat is unmanageable'; they drift through the breakers 'how, we scarcely know'; the boat survives because 'she cannot sink', not because it is steered; there is no skilful choice of route, only 'we must run the rapid or abandon the river'.
    Text 1, disagreeing: judgement frames the run: at daybreak they 'walk down the bank ... to take a view', they 'approach it very cautiously', and they rule out a portage only 'on examination'; earlier they choose between portages and 'chutes through which we can run'; the crew work their way out ('At last we pull out again into the stream', 'we struggle for a few minutes, and are then out again'); the other boats get through ('the other boats have passed us') and their crews, who 'have seen that our boat is swamped', wait in an eddy and pull Powell's boat 'in against the wall'; 'There is no hesitation.' shows nerve as well as necessity.
    Text 2, agreeing: the writer has no skill to offer ('I am not a water person'); in the rapid 'My paddle hit nothing, then rock, then air'; the raft is freed only because 'the river simply let go of it'; the writer is thrown out without knowing it ('I was not in the raft.').
    Text 2, disagreeing: survival follows a plan: the briefing ('lie on your back with your feet pointing downstream') returns at the crucial moment ('back, feet, toes') and 'The river carried me, as promised'; the guide's expertise ('Forward paddle ... Hard!', a guide 'who had done it hundreds of times', who 'grabbed the shoulders of my buoyancy aid'); the equipment and the graded river ('today's biggest was a three') make the danger 'real but borrowed'; the writer's own part is to stop fighting and 'let the water hold me up'.
    Perceptive evaluation might separate the writer's own skill from other people's (Pennock is saved by the guide's skill and by following instructions, not by luck); see that Powell's luck is the luck of a careful crew on an unknown river, where judgement can only go so far; weigh the impact of Powell's passive verbs and 'how, we scarcely know' against Pennock's calm 'as promised'; or consider purpose and context: a leader's journal of an 1869 journey into the unknown, which rarely claims credit, against a 2023 magazine article about a guided leisure trip that reflects on what kept the writer safe. Credit any judgement (agree, disagree or partly agree) supported from both texts.

  2. 6 marks

    Levels of response (6 marks). AO3: Compare writers' ideas and perspectives as well as how these are conveyed across two or more texts.
    Level 6 (6 marks): A detailed, interwoven comparison which explores writers' ideas and perspectives and how they are conveyed.
    Level 5 (5 marks): A sustained comparison of writers' ideas and perspectives and how they are conveyed.
    Level 4 (4 marks): A developed comparison of writers' ideas and perspectives and how they are conveyed.
    Level 3 (3 marks): A clear comparison of writers' ideas and perspectives which begins to consider how they are conveyed.
    Level 2 (2 marks): A response which identifies main points of comparison between writers' ideas and perspectives.
    Level 1 (1 mark): A response which makes simple points of comparison between writers' ideas and perspectives.
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    OCR: 'There are 0 marks for AO3 where only one text is considered.' OCR's examples of simple points of comparison include repeating the words of the statement and writing about both texts side by side so that comparisons have to be inferred (OCR J351/02 mark scheme, June 2025).
    Candidates may compare these points (not a checklist):
    - Both present the worst moment as a loss of control, with the river doing the acting: Powell's 'is caught', 'Hurled back', 'we are carried into an eddy' / Pennock's 'the river simply let go of it' and 'The river carried me' -> but Powell's 'we' is a crew that fights back ('we struggle'), while Pennock's 'I' is a passenger who has to stop fighting.
    - Preparation: Powell's crew scout and judge for themselves ('to take a view', 'on examination'); Pennock's judgement is borrowed from an expert in a briefing on 'a shingle bank' -> skill belongs to the travellers in Text 1 and mainly to the guide in Text 2.
    - Structure: Powell sets the decision ('There is no hesitation.') against one long, breathless sentence of waves, so the run reads as something endured rather than steered; Pennock places the briefing early and brings it back at the crucial moment ('back, feet, toes'), so the structure itself suggests that preparation, not luck, saves the writer.
    - Rescue: the other boats waiting in an eddy to pull Powell's boat 'in against the wall' / Isla landing the writer 'like a large, astonished fish' -> in both, other people's skill finishes what luck began, but Pennock makes it comic.
    - Voice: Powell's understated journal claims no credit and gives no verdict ('how, we scarcely know', 'Our boat bailed, on we go again'); Pennock's reflective, self-mocking article explains what kept the writer safe ('Part of it, I suspect, is that the danger was real but borrowed').
    - Context: an unknown river in 1869 with no safety equipment / a graded river in 2023 with helmets, buoyancy aids and a guide -> Pennock's article draws the contrast itself ('no helmets, no guide and no idea what waited round the next bend'), and the description fits Powell's crew exactly.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.