Question 1
12 marksRead the text below. Then answer the question that follows.
Text 2
From the Autobiography of Andrew Carnegie, published in 1920 after his death and edited by John C. Van Dyke
In 1848, when Andrew Carnegie was twelve, his poor family left Scotland for the United States, where he later became one of the richest men in the world. In this extract from his autobiography he describes his first jobs.
[1] The great question now was, what could be found for me to do. I had just completed my thirteenth year, and I fairly panted to get to work that I might help the family to a start in the new land. The prospect of want had become to me a frightful nightmare. My thoughts at this period centered in the determination that we should make and save enough of money to produce three hundred dollars a year--twenty-five dollars monthly, which I figured was the sum required to keep us without being dependent upon others. Every necessary thing was very cheap in those days.
[...]
[2] Soon after this incident my father found it necessary to give up hand-loom weaving and to enter the cotton factory of Mr. Blackstock, an old Scotsman in Allegheny City, where we lived. In this factory he also obtained for me a position as bobbin boy, and my first work was done there at one dollar and twenty cents per week. It was a hard life. In the winter father and I had to rise and breakfast in the darkness, reach the factory before it was daylight, and, with a short interval for lunch, work till after dark. The hours hung heavily upon me and in the work itself I took no pleasure; but the cloud had a silver lining, as it gave me the feeling that I was doing something for my world--our family. I have made millions since, but none of those millions gave me such happiness as my first week's earnings. I was now a helper of the family, a breadwinner, and no longer a total charge upon my parents. [...]
[3] Soon after this Mr. John Hay, a fellow-Scotch manufacturer of bobbins in Allegheny City, needed a boy, and asked whether I would not go into his service. I went, and received two dollars per week; but at first the work was even more irksome than the factory. I had to run a small steam-engine and to fire the boiler in the cellar of the bobbin factory. It was too much for me. I found myself night after night, sitting up in bed trying the steam gauges, fearing at one time that the steam was too low and that the workers above would complain that they had not power enough, and at another time that the steam was too high and that the boiler might burst.
[4] But all this it was a matter of honor to conceal from my parents. They had their own troubles and bore them. I must play the man and bear mine. My hopes were high, and I looked every day for some change to take place. What it was to be I knew not, but that it would come I felt certain if I kept on. Besides, at this date I was not beyond asking myself what Wallace would have done and what a Scotsman ought to do. Of one thing I was sure, he ought never to give up.
[5] One day the chance came. Mr. Hay had to make out some bills. He had no clerk, and was himself a poor penman. He asked me what kind of hand I could write, and gave me some writing to do. The result pleased him, and he found it convenient thereafter to let me make out his bills. I was also good at figures; and he soon found it to be to his interest--and besides, dear old man, I believe he was moved by good feeling toward the white-haired boy, for he had a kind heart and was Scotch and wished to relieve me from the engine--to put me at other things, less objectionable except in one feature.
[6] It now became my duty to bathe the newly made spools in vats of oil. Fortunately there was a room reserved for this purpose and I was alone, but not all the resolution I could muster, nor all the indignation I felt at my own weakness, prevented my stomach from behaving in a most perverse way. I never succeeded in overcoming the nausea produced by the smell of the oil. Even Wallace and Bruce proved impotent here. But if I had to lose breakfast, or dinner, I had all the better appetite for supper, and the allotted work was done. A real disciple of Wallace or Bruce could not give up; he would die first.
[7] My service with Mr. Hay was a distinct advance upon the cotton factory, and I also made the acquaintance of an employer who was very kind to me. Mr. Hay kept his books in single entry, and I was able to handle them for him; but hearing that all great firms kept their books in double entry, and after talking over the matter with my companions, John Phipps, Thomas N. Miller, and William Cowley, we all determined to attend night school during the winter and learn the larger system. So the four of us went to a Mr. Williams in Pittsburgh and learned double-entry bookkeeping.
Glossary: panted - longed; want - poverty; centered - centred (American spelling); this incident - a scene left out of this extract, in which his mother angrily rejected a suggestion that he should earn money by selling small goods around the docks; hand-loom weaving - weaving cloth by hand on a loom; Allegheny City - a town next to Pittsburgh, in the United States; bobbin boy - a boy who changed the bobbins (reels of thread) on the machines in a cotton mill; a total charge upon - completely dependent on; Scotch - Scottish; irksome - tiresome, unpleasant; fire the boiler - keep the fire under the boiler burning; steam gauges - dials showing the pressure of the steam; honor - honour (American spelling); play the man - behave like a grown man; Wallace, Bruce - William Wallace and Robert the Bruce, heroes of Scottish history; penman - writer of handwriting; hand - handwriting; figures - arithmetic; toward - towards; perverse - stubbornly unhelpful; impotent - powerless; single entry, double entry - a simple and a more complete way of keeping a firm's accounts
Question 3 is about Text 2, Autobiography by Andrew Carnegie.
Look at paragraphs 4 to 6.
Explore how Andrew Carnegie uses language and structure to present his determination not to give up.
Support your ideas by using relevant subject terminology. [12]
Model answer
Carnegie presents his determination as a code of honour that he holds to even when his body fails him, and he frames the whole section with the idea of not giving up. Paragraph 4 begins with suffering turned into duty: it was 'a matter of honor to conceal' his fears, and the abstract noun 'honor' makes hiding them a moral choice rather than mere pride. The parallel sentences 'They had their own troubles and bore them. I must play the man and bear mine.' repeat the verb 'bear', so the boy copies his parents' endurance, while the modal 'must' and the idiom 'play the man' show a child forcing himself to act like an adult. Hope follows in the plain clause 'My hopes were high', and the inverted word order of 'What it was to be I knew not, but that it would come I felt certain' sets uncertainty against confidence, giving the boy's faith a formal, almost biblical weight. The allusion to 'what Wallace would have done' makes Scotland's heroes his model, and the paragraph ends on a creed: 'Of one thing I was sure, he ought never to give up.' The absolute 'never' and the shift to 'he', a general Scotsman, turn personal resolve into a national rule.
Structurally, the short sentence 'One day the chance came.' opens paragraph 5 as a reward for persistence. The paragraph's long final sentence is broken by dashes and the affectionate aside 'dear old man', which slows the pace to express gratitude to Mr. Hay. Yet it ends with the understatement 'less objectionable except in one feature', which foreshadows the next trial and leads straight into paragraph 6, so the section moves in a cycle of hardship, hope, reward and fresh hardship.
In paragraph 6, Carnegie turns his struggle into comedy. The parallel negatives 'not all the resolution I could muster, nor all the indignation I felt' build up his willpower, only for the personified stomach to behave 'in a most perverse way'; the formal, Latinate diction makes the battle between mind and body amusing. The bathos of 'Even Wallace and Bruce proved impotent here' shows that even his heroes cannot defeat the smell of oil, and the antithesis 'if I had to lose breakfast, or dinner, I had all the better appetite for supper' turns failure into a joke. The plain clause 'the allotted work was done' shows that, whatever his stomach did, the duty was completed. Finally, the hyperbole 'A real disciple of Wallace or Bruce could not give up; he would die first' echoes the end of paragraph 4. This circular structure makes determination the frame of the section, while the mock-heroic tone suggests the older narrator smiling at the boy he was, admiring his resolve and gently laughing at it.
Explanation
Strong answers move between language and structure: the parallel sentences about bearing troubles, the allusions to Wallace and Bruce, the comic personification of the stomach, and the framing of the section by 'give up' at the end of paragraphs 4 and 6. Every term used should be accurate and connected to how it presents Carnegie's determination, including the gentle humour of the older narrator looking back. Retelling the jobs, spotting features without saying what they do, and quoting from outside paragraphs 4 to 6 keep answers in the lower levels.
Mark scheme
-
12 marks
Levels of response (12 marks). AO2: Explain, comment on and analyse how writers use language and structure to achieve effects and influence readers, using relevant subject terminology to support their views.
Level 6 (11-12 marks): A skilled analysis which demonstrates a sophisticated appreciation of how the writer has used language and structure to achieve effects and influence the reader. Candidates' analysis of both language and structure is consistent and detailed. Precisely selected and integrated subject terminology deployed to enhance the response.
Level 5 (9-10 marks): An analysis which demonstrates a perceptive understanding of how the writer has used language and structure to achieve effects and influence the reader. Candidates' analysis of both language and structure is reasonably detailed and balanced. Well-chosen subject terminology integrated into explanations.
Level 4 (7-8 marks): A developed explanation which shows a secure understanding of how the writer has used language and structure to achieve effects and influence the reader. Candidates comment on the effects of both language and structure, but the explanation may not be entirely balanced. Relevant terminology should be used to develop ideas.
Level 3 (5-6 marks): A clear explanation which shows a general understanding of how the writer has used language and structure to achieve effects and influence the reader. Candidates refer to language and structure but may not give a full explanation of the effects of both. Some use of relevant subject terminology to support ideas.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): A straightforward commentary which shows some understanding of how the writer has used language and structure to achieve effects and influence the reader. Candidates are likely to refer more fully to either language or structure and note some features without explaining the effects. Some use of subject terminology, though it may not always be relevant.OCR's level descriptors, continued: Level 1 (1-2 marks): A descriptive response which shows limited awareness of how the writer has used language and structure to achieve effects and influence the reader. Little or no use of subject terminology. 0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit. Where the candidate's answer consistently meets the criteria, the higher mark should be awarded.
Max 8 if the response does not achieve a reasonable balance between references to language and to structure: OCR's guidance says such a response 'cannot achieve the higher levels' (OCR J351/01 mark scheme, June 2024), and Levels 5 and 6 need analysis of both that is balanced. Credit only comments on paragraphs 4-6: 'Do NOT award marks for comments based on references to material from outside the specified lines' (OCR J351/01 mark scheme, June 2025).
Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points supported from paragraphs 4-6):
Language: 'a matter of honor to conceal' (abstract noun): hiding suffering becomes a moral duty. 'They had their own troubles and bore them. I must play the man and bear mine.' (parallel sentences, repeated verb 'bore'/'bear', modal 'must', idiom): a boy forcing himself to act like an adult. 'What it was to be I knew not, but that it would come I felt certain if I kept on.' (inverted word order, contrast of 'knew not' and 'felt certain'): faith in the future despite uncertainty. 'what Wallace would have done and what a Scotsman ought to do' (allusion, parallelism, modal 'ought'): national heroes as models. 'Of one thing I was sure, he ought never to give up.' (fronted phrase, absolute 'never'): a personal creed. 'dear old man' (parenthetical aside): warmth and gratitude towards Mr. Hay. 'less objectionable except in one feature' (understatement, foreshadowing): hints at the next trial. 'not all the resolution I could muster, nor all the indignation I felt at my own weakness' (parallel negatives) with 'my stomach ... behaving in a most perverse way' (personification, formal diction): a comic battle between will and body. 'Even Wallace and Bruce proved impotent here.' (allusion, bathos): heroic models defeated by a smell. 'if I had to lose breakfast, or dinner, I had all the better appetite for supper' (antithesis, humour): failure turned into something positive. 'A real disciple of Wallace or Bruce could not give up; he would die first.' (hyperbole, semicolon): mock-heroic exaggeration of his resolve.
Structure: the section is framed by 'give up' at the end of paragraph 4 and the end of paragraph 6, so determination opens and closes it. Paragraph 4 moves from hidden suffering to hope; 'One day the chance came.' opens paragraph 5 as a short turning point; paragraph 6 brings a new setback, giving a pattern of hardship, hope, reward and new hardship. Paragraph 5's long final sentence, interrupted by dashes and an aside, slows down to show gratitude and ends on the hint 'except in one feature', which links to paragraph 6. Short sentences mark key moments ('They had their own troubles and bore them.', 'One day the chance came.'). The shift from 'I' to 'a Scotsman' and 'A real disciple' turns personal resolve into a national code, and the adult narrator's gentle irony ('at this date I was not beyond asking myself') looks back with humour.
Higher-level answers analyse how word choices, humour and the framing of the section present determination, with balanced comments on language and structure. Mid-level answers explain the effects of features they identify. Lower-level answers retell the jobs or list features without effects.