Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of the Bethnal Green disaster (3 March 1943).
Model answer
On 3 March 1943, when the sirens sounded, hundreds of people hurried down the single, dimly lit staircase into the shelter at Bethnal Green Tube station. A woman fell near the bottom of the steps and others fell on top of her, so 173 people, including 62 children, were crushed to death, although no bomb fell.
Explanation
The first mark is for a clear feature of the disaster, such as the crush on the stairs, its causes or the government's secrecy afterwards; the second is for a precise detail, such as the number killed or the conditions on the staircase. Remember that no bomb hit the shelter and that the disaster happened in 1943, not during the Blitz of 1940-41.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of the Bethnal Green disaster (3 March 1943) identified, e.g. 173 people were killed in a crush on the stairs leading into the Bethnal Green Tube shelter / it was caused by a crowd surging down a single, dimly lit staircase / no bomb fell on the shelter / the noise of a new anti-aircraft rocket battery firing nearby may have made people hurry / the government kept the details secret / an inquiry was held in private and its report was not published until 1945.
Award 1 mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. 173 people were killed in a crush (1). When the sirens sounded at about 8.17 p.m., hundreds of people hurried down the steps into the shelter; a woman carrying a child fell near the bottom, others fell on top of her, and 173 people, including 62 children, were crushed to death (1). e.g. It was caused by the conditions on the staircase (1). There was only one entrance, down 19 wet steps lit by a single dim bulb, with no central handrail, so a crowd pressing down from above could not stop (1). e.g. No bomb fell on the shelter (1). People heard the loud, unfamiliar noise of a new anti-aircraft rocket battery firing in nearby Victoria Park and may have thought bombs were falling, so they rushed for the entrance (1). e.g. The government kept the details secret (1). Newspapers were not allowed to name Bethnal Green, the inquiry by the magistrate Laurence Dunne was held in private, and his report was not published until January 1945 (1). Accept 'about 170' killed and 'about 60' injured. Accept that the shelter was in the unfinished Bethnal Green station on the Central line extension. Credit the rumours that spread about the cause, the court case in which Bethnal Green Council was found to have been negligent (1944), or the council's earlier request (1941) for money to make the entrance safer, as supporting information. Do not credit claims that the shelter was hit by a bomb or that the disaster happened during the Blitz of 1940-41. Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for the deaths: 173 killed, including 62 children, and over 60 injured, after a woman fell near the bottom of the stairs a few minutes after the sirens sounded at 8.17 p.m.; for the staircase: one entrance, 19 steps, wet, dimly lit, no central handrail; for the cause of the rush: the noise of a new rocket battery firing in Victoria Park; for secrecy: newspapers could not name the place, the Dunne inquiry was held in private and the report was kept secret until January 1945; for the aftermath: crush barriers, handrails and better lighting were added to shelter entrances, and a court case found Bethnal Green Council negligent.
The supporting information must develop the feature given for the first mark. Do not credit a second, unconnected feature, a repeat of the feature in other words, or a general comment such as 'it was a tragedy' or 'lots of people died'.