Question 1
4 marksExplain one way in which Lord Raglan's command of the British army at the Battle of Balaclava (1854) was similar to General Haig's command of the British army at the Battle of the Somme (1916).
Model answer
One similarity is that both commanders directed their battles from a distance, so they depended on orders passed down to subordinates who could not see or know what they did. At Balaclava, Raglan watched from the Sapoune Heights, high above the valleys. His fourth order, telling the cavalry to 'try to prevent the enemy carrying away the guns', was carried down by Captain Nolan to Lord Lucan, who could not see the guns Raglan meant. The order was misunderstood, and the Light Brigade charged down the wrong valley. At the Somme, Haig commanded from his headquarters at Montreuil, far behind the lines, and Rawlinson's Fourth Army carried out the attack. Once the infantry left their trenches on 1 July 1916, telephone wires were cut by shellfire and messages sent by runner took hours, so commanders often did not know what was happening and could not change their plans in time.
Explanation
The best answers state the similarity, such as commanding from a distance through subordinates, disagreements with those subordinates, or blame for heavy losses, and support it with precise detail from both battles, such as Raglan's fourth order and the breakdown of communications on 1 July 1916. Describing the Charge of the Light Brigade with only a passing mention of Haig stays in Level 1.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO2: 2 marks. AO1: 2 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): Features of the period are analysed to explain a similarity. [AO2] Specific information about the topic is added to support the comparison, showing good knowledge and understanding of the periods. [AO1]
Level 1 (1-2 marks): Simple or generalised comment is offered about a similarity. [AO2] Generalised information about the topic is included, showing limited knowledge and understanding of the periods. [AO1]
0 marks: No rewardable material.
Performance in AO1 and AO2 is interdependent. An answer displaying no qualities of AO2 cannot be awarded more than the top of Level 1, no matter how strong performance is in AO1; markers should note that the expectation for AO1 is that candidates demonstrate both knowledge and understanding.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Valid similarities, each needing specific information from both battles for Level 2: (1) Both directed the battle from a distance and depended on orders passed down to subordinates, who could not see or know what the commander did, so orders were misunderstood or came too late. Balaclava: Raglan watched from the Sapoune Heights, high above the valleys; his orders were written out by his Quartermaster-General, Richard Airey, and carried by aides on horseback; his fourth order, telling the cavalry to advance and 'try to prevent the enemy carrying away the guns', was taken by Captain Nolan to Lord Lucan in the North Valley, who could not see the guns on the Causeway Heights that Raglan meant, and the Light Brigade charged down the wrong valley. Somme: Haig's General Headquarters was at Montreuil, far behind the lines; Rawlinson's Fourth Army planned and carried out the attack of 1 July 1916; once the infantry left their trenches, telephone wires were cut by shellfire and runners took hours, so commanders often did not know what was happening and could not change the plan in time (credit pigeons, flares and the lack of portable radio). (2) Both commanders' plans were weakened by disagreements with their subordinates: Raglan's orders were questioned and misread by Lucan, and Lucan and Lord Cardigan, brothers-in-law who disliked each other, hardly spoke; Haig wanted deep objectives and a breakthrough, with cavalry ready to exploit it, whereas Rawlinson preferred a limited 'bite and hold' attack, and the compromise spread the bombardment over a wider and deeper area. (3) Both were blamed for heavy losses: Raglan for the loss of the Light Brigade (of about 670-700 men, about 110 killed and about 270-300 casualties in all), although he blamed Lucan, who was recalled to Britain; Haig for the 57,470 British casualties on 1 July, including 19,240 killed, and about 420,000 British casualties in the whole battle (accept 400,000-420,000), which led critics to call him 'Butcher' Haig (credit that other historians defend him). Level 1: a generalised similarity (e.g. 'both made mistakes') or detail about only one commander. Do not credit: differences (e.g. that Raglan could watch the battle while Haig could not, or the scale of the losses); claims that Haig went over the top with his men or that Raglan led the charge.