Question 1
40 marksWrite about a time in your life when you had to tell someone a difficult truth.
Your response could be real or imagined.
Your response will be marked for the accurate and appropriate use of vocabulary, spelling, punctuation and grammar.
(24 marks for content and organisation, 16 marks for technical accuracy)
Model answer
My alarm went off at 4.50 every morning for seven years, and for seven years, at 4.55, my mum knocked on my door with a slice of toast and said, 'Rise and shine, champ.'
Nobody rises and shines at 4.55. You crawl. You fumble for your goggles in the dark. You sit in the passenger seat of a cold car with your hair still wet from a shower you didn't need, because in forty minutes you will be in the water anyway, and you watch the street lights go past, orange and empty, while the radio talks quietly to nobody.
I started swimming when I was eight, because the leisure centre ran a taster session and I was the only one who didn't cry. By ten I was in the county squad. By thirteen I had a shelf of medals, a coach who talked constantly about 'the regional times', and shoulders so broad that my school blazer had to be bought two sizes up. And by fifteen I hated it so much that, some mornings, standing on the edge of the pool with the chlorine stinging my nose, I imagined simply walking away: out through the changing rooms in my dripping costume, across the car park, and never coming back.
I didn't, of course. Because of Mum.
It was just the two of us. Mum worked at the bakery on the high street, starting at seven, so she drove me to the pool for 5.15, sat in the car park for an hour and a half, and then went straight to work. Every day. For seven years. She knew all the other parents by their cars. She knew the cleaner by name. She kept a blanket on the back seat, a flask and a stack of crossword books, and when I came out at 6.45 she always asked the same thing - 'How was it?' - and I always said 'Fine', and she always smiled as if 'fine' were the best word in the world.
How do you tell someone who has given up seven years of mornings for you that you don't want it any more?
I practised. I practised in the shower, in the pool, under the water where nobody could hear. I typed it into the notes on my phone and deleted it. I tried to start a dozen times in the car, and each time the words got as far as my teeth and stopped, like swimmers touching the end of a lane.
In the end I said it on a Tuesday in February, in the car park, at 5.14, with the heater roaring and the engine still running. I hadn't planned it. I just looked at the leisure centre, with its blue lights and its smell of chlorine leaking out through the walls, and heard myself say it.
'Mum, I don't want to do this any more.'
She didn't say anything. She turned the engine off. Without it, the car went very quiet, and the windscreen slowly misted over, and I waited for her face to crumple: for the disappointment, for the speech about everything she had given up.
Instead, very slowly, she began to laugh.
'Oh, thank goodness,' she said.
I stared at her.
'I hate it,' she said. 'I hate this car park. I hate this flask. I've hated it since you were about eleven, but you seemed so -' She waved a hand at the pool. 'I thought it was your thing. I didn't want to be the one who took it away from you.'
We sat there for a long time, in the fogged-up car, laughing and then not laughing, while the other parents pulled into the spaces around us. Then she started the engine, and instead of turning into the drop-off bay, she drove straight past it, out onto the ring road, to the all-night cafe by the retail park, where we ate fried-egg sandwiches at six o'clock in the morning like a pair of escaped prisoners.
I still swim sometimes: lengths, on Sunday afternoons, with nobody timing me. Mum still wakes up at 4.50 - she says her body has forgotten how not to. But on Saturdays now we go back to that cafe, at a sensible hour, and she asks me how things are, and I tell her the truth.
It turns out to be much easier the second time.
Explanation
This reaches Level 5 because the pressure of the unspoken truth builds through precise details of the early-morning routine and the mother's sacrifice, the moment of telling is delayed and then dramatised through silence, and her unexpected reaction overturns the reader's expectations. The ending returns to the idea of honesty without preaching. Interrupted speech and times are punctuated accurately. Weaker answers reveal the truth with no build-up or summarise the conversation instead of dramatising it.
Mark scheme
-
24 marks
Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation). Communicate clearly, effectively and imaginatively, selecting and adapting tone, style and register for different forms, purposes and audiences. Organise information and ideas, using structural and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion of texts.
Level 5 (20-24 marks): Sophisticated ability to communicate clearly, effectively and imaginatively. Shapes audience response with subtlety, with sophisticated and sustained use of tone, style and register. Manipulates complex ideas, utilising a range of structural and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion.
Level 4 (15-19 marks): Secure ability to communicate clearly, effectively and imaginatively. Organises material for particular effect, with effective use of tone, style and register. Manages information and ideas, with structural and grammatical features used cohesively and deliberately across the text.
Level 3 (10-14 marks): Clear ability to communicate clearly, effectively and imaginatively. Selects material and stylistic or rhetorical devices to suit audience and purpose, with appropriate use of tone, style and register. Develops and connects appropriate information and ideas; structural and grammatical features and paragraphing make meaning clear.
Level 2 (5-9 marks): Some ability to communicate clearly, effectively and imaginatively. Shows an awareness of audience and purpose, with straightforward use of tone, style and register. Expresses and orders information and ideas; uses paragraphs and a range of structural and grammatical features.
Level 1 (1-4 marks): Limited ability to communicate clearly, effectively and imaginatively. Offers a basic response, with audience and/or purpose not fully established. Expresses information and ideas, with limited use of structural and grammatical features.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Purpose: to write a real or imagined piece about a time when the candidate had to tell someone a difficult truth. This may involve a range of approaches, including: description, anecdote, speech, narrative and literary techniques. Audience: the writing is for a general readership. Candidates can choose to write for an adult audience or an audience of young people. Form: the response may be narrative, descriptive or monologue. There should be clear organisation and structure with an introduction, development of points and a conclusion. Some candidates may intentionally adapt their language and style to their audience by using, for example, a more informal or colloquial approach. Candidates may introduce some literary elements. Responses may: - write about telling a parent, carer, friend, coach, teacher, sibling or grandparent something they did not want to hear: a decision, a confession, a worry, an unwelcome opinion or bad news; - establish the relationship and why the truth is hard to tell: the other person's feelings, sacrifices or expectations, and the writer's fear of the consequences; - build tension through delay, rehearsal, false starts and the setting of the conversation; - dramatise the moment itself, using dialogue, silence and gesture, and the other person's reaction, which may be unexpected; - reflect on what the honesty cost or gained, and how the relationship changed; - write in the first person, or in the third person, retelling an experience they were not directly involved in; - use appropriate techniques for creative writing: vocabulary, imagery, language techniques; - use a voice that attempts to make the piece interesting and believable for the chosen audience; - demonstrate particular understanding of the form used; - be written in a register and style appropriate for the chosen form, which may include colloquial elements, dialogue within description or narrative, or a sustained single voice in a monologue. Higher-level responses may build the pressure of the unspoken truth through precise detail; give the listener a believable, perhaps surprising, response; and shape an ending that reflects on honesty without stating a moral. Less successful responses may reveal the truth in the first lines with little build-up; summarise the conversation rather than dramatising it; or end with a stated lesson. Mark by best fit across the whole response; the task may be interpreted freely, but the response should be recognisably about telling someone a difficult truth. An unfinished response cannot access the full range of marks for organisation and structure.
-
16 marks
Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy). Candidates must use a range of vocabulary and sentence structures for clarity, purpose and effect, with accurate spelling and punctuation.
Level 5 (14-16 marks): Sophisticated ability to write for clarity, purpose and effect. Uses an extensive vocabulary strategically; rare spelling errors do not detract from overall meaning. Punctuates writing with accuracy to aid emphasis and precision, using a range of sentence structures accurately and selectively to achieve particular effects.
Level 4 (11-13 marks): Secure ability to write for clarity, purpose and effect. Uses a wide, selective vocabulary with only occasional spelling errors. Positions a range of punctuation for clarity, managing sentence structures for deliberate effect.
Level 3 (8-10 marks): Sound ability to write for clarity, purpose and effect. Uses a varied vocabulary and spells words containing irregular patterns correctly. Uses accurate and varied punctuation, adapting sentence structure to contribute positively to purpose and effect.
Level 2 (5-7 marks): Some ability to write for clarity, purpose and effect. Writes with a range of correctly spelt vocabulary, e.g. words with regular patterns such as prefixes, suffixes, double consonants. Uses punctuation with control, creating a range of sentence structures, including coordination and subordination.
Level 1 (1-4 marks): Limited ability to write for clarity, purpose and effect. Uses basic vocabulary, often misspelled. Uses punctuation with basic control, creating undeveloped, often repetitive, sentence structures.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Mark technical accuracy across the whole response, by best fit. Look for: sentences correctly demarcated (no comma splices or run-on sentences); a range of punctuation used accurately and for effect - commas in complex sentences, apostrophes, colons, semi-colons, dashes, brackets and ellipses; dialogue punctuated correctly (speech marks, a new line for each new speaker, punctuation inside the speech marks); a range of sentence structures - simple, compound and complex, with coordination and subordination, and short or minor sentences, questions and exclamations used selectively for effect; an extensive vocabulary used strategically and spelt correctly, including words with irregular patterns; Standard English and consistent control of tense, except for deliberately non-standard voice in dialogue. Look for accurate punctuation of dialogue, including interrupted speech marked with a dash, and consistent presentation of times; repetition used for rhythm and effect must be clearly deliberate. Level 5 needs accuracy and deliberate, selective control throughout; rare spelling errors do not prevent it, and ambitious vocabulary is credited even when occasionally misspelt. Frequent comma splices, missing paragraphs or uncontrolled tense shifts keep a response below Level 4 however ambitious its vocabulary. A response with nothing worth credit scores 0 on both points.