Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/7

Fiction: evaluating the extract (Q4)

Practise 30 exam-style questions on Fiction: evaluating the extract (Q4) for Edexcel GCSE English Language (Paper 1). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 30 questions
  • 15 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

15 marks

Read the extract below. Then answer the question that follows.

The Pickwick Papers
by Charles Dickens (1837)

This extract is taken from the novel The Pickwick Papers by Charles Dickens, published in 1837. Mr Pickwick and his friends are spending Christmas Day with their friend Mr Wardle and his family in the country, and the whole party, including Mr Pickwick's servant, Sam Weller, has gone out on to the ice. Mr Pickwick has just told off his friend Mr Winkle for pretending that he could skate.

[1] While Mr. Pickwick was delivering himself of the sentiment just recorded, Mr. Weller and the fat boy, having by their joint endeavours cut out a slide, were exercising themselves thereupon, in a very masterly and brilliant manner. Sam Weller, in particular, was displaying that beautiful feat of fancy-sliding which is currently denominated 'knocking at the cobbler's door,' and which is achieved by skimming over the ice on one foot, and occasionally giving a postman's knock upon it with the other. It was a good long slide, and there was something in the motion which Mr. Pickwick, who was very cold with standing still, could not help envying.

[2] 'It looks a nice warm exercise that, doesn't it?' he inquired of Wardle, when that gentleman was thoroughly out of breath, by reason of the indefatigable manner in which he had converted his legs into a pair of compasses, and drawn complicated problems on the ice.

[3] 'Ah, it does, indeed,' replied Wardle. 'Do you slide?'

[4] 'I used to do so, on the gutters, when I was a boy,' replied Mr. Pickwick.

[5] 'Try it now,' said Wardle.

[6] 'Oh, do, please, Mr. Pickwick!' cried all the ladies.

[7] 'I should be very happy to afford you any amusement,' replied Mr. Pickwick, 'but I haven't done such a thing these thirty years.'

[8] 'Pooh! pooh! Nonsense!' said Wardle, dragging off his skates with the impetuosity which characterised all his proceedings. 'Here; I'll keep you company; come along!' And away went the good-tempered old fellow down the slide, with a rapidity which came very close upon Mr. Weller, and beat the fat boy all to nothing.

[9] Mr. Pickwick paused, considered, pulled off his gloves and put them in his hat; took two or three short runs, baulked himself as often, and at last took another run, and went slowly and gravely down the slide, with his feet about a yard and a quarter apart, amidst the gratified shouts of all the spectators.

[10] 'Keep the pot a-bilin', Sir!' said Sam; and down went Wardle again, and then Mr. Pickwick, and then Sam, and then Mr. Winkle, and then Mr. Bob Sawyer, and then the fat boy, and then Mr. Snodgrass, following closely upon each other's heels, and running after each other with as much eagerness as if their future prospects in life depended on their expedition.

[11] It was the most intensely interesting thing, to observe the manner in which Mr. Pickwick performed his share in the ceremony; to watch the torture of anxiety with which he viewed the person behind, gaining upon him at the imminent hazard of tripping him up; to see him gradually expend the painful force he had put on at first, and turn slowly round on the slide, with his face towards the point from which he had started; to contemplate the playful smile which mantled on his face when he had accomplished the distance, and the eagerness with which he turned round when he had done so, and ran after his predecessor, his black gaiters tripping pleasantly through the snow, and his eyes beaming cheerfulness and gladness through his spectacles. [...]

[12] The sport was at its height, the sliding was at the quickest, the laughter was at the loudest, when a sharp smart crack was heard. There was a quick rush towards the bank, a wild scream from the ladies, and a shout from Mr. Tupman. A large mass of ice disappeared; the water bubbled up over it; Mr. Pickwick's hat, gloves, and handkerchief were floating on the surface; and this was all of Mr. Pickwick that anybody could see.

[13] Dismay and anguish were depicted on every countenance; the males turned pale, and the females fainted; Mr. Snodgrass and Mr. Winkle grasped each other by the hand, and gazed at the spot where their leader had gone down, with frenzied eagerness; while Mr. Tupman, by way of rendering the promptest assistance, and at the same time conveying to any persons who might be within hearing, the clearest possible notion of the catastrophe, ran off across the country at his utmost speed, screaming 'Fire!' with all his might.

Glossary: denominated - called; indefatigable - tireless; baulked himself - stopped himself suddenly; expedition - speed; gaiters - cloth coverings for the ankles and lower legs

In this extract, there is an attempt to create humour.

Evaluate how successfully this is achieved.

Support your views with detailed reference to the text.

Model answer

Dickens is extremely successful in creating humour, because he describes a simple winter game in grand, serious language and builds it up so carefully that the final accident becomes both shocking and absurd.

The main source of humour is the gap between the narrator's elaborate style and the trivial events. Sam's trick is 'that beautiful feat of fancy-sliding which is currently denominated' (that is, called) 'knocking at the cobbler's door', described with the formality of a lecture. Wardle has 'converted his legs into a pair of compasses, and drawn complicated problems on the ice', a witty metaphor that turns his skating into geometry. This mock-serious tone makes even small moments funny.

Mr Pickwick himself is the centre of the comedy. He is dignified and polite, 'I should be very happy to afford you any amusement', but he admits that he 'used to do so, on the gutters, when I was a boy', and has not done it 'these thirty years'. The contrast between his dignity and the childish game is the heart of the humour. His preparations are absurdly careful: he 'paused, considered, pulled off his gloves and put them in his hat', makes several false starts and then goes down 'slowly and gravely' with his feet 'about a yard and a quarter apart'. The precise measurement makes the picture vivid and ridiculous.

Dickens then speeds up the pace. The polysyndeton 'and then Mr. Pickwick, and then Sam, and then Mr. Winkle' creates a breathless chain of sliders, and the hyperbole 'as if their future prospects in life depended on their expedition' mocks their seriousness. Paragraph 11 is a long, admiring sentence that treats sliding as 'the ceremony' and his fear of being caught as a 'torture of anxiety'. The humour here is affectionate rather than cruel, because we also see 'the playful smile' and his eyes 'beaming cheerfulness and gladness through his spectacles'. We laugh with him as well as at him.

The climax is cleverly structured. The tricolon 'The sport was at its height, the sliding was at the quickest, the laughter was at the loudest' raises the mood to its peak, so that the 'sharp smart crack' is a sudden reversal. After the list of 'hat, gloves, and handkerchief', the understatement 'this was all of Mr. Pickwick that anybody could see' is darkly funny: the signs of his gentlemanly dignity float on the water while the man himself has vanished. The reactions are exaggerated for comic effect, 'the males turned pale, and the females fainted', while Mr Snodgrass and Mr Winkle can only grasp each other by the hand and gaze at the spot. The best joke is saved for last. Mr Tupman, 'by way of rendering the promptest assistance', runs off across the country screaming 'Fire!', the most useless response imaginable, made funnier by the narrator's straight-faced irony.

Some readers might feel uncomfortable laughing when a man has disappeared under the ice, and the long, formal sentences may slow the comedy for a modern reader. However, the narrator's detached, playful tone invites us to laugh rather than fear, and the slow build-up makes the sudden crack and the absurd reactions all the more effective. Overall, the humour is sustained and skilfully controlled throughout the extract.

Explanation

Top-level answers make a sustained judgement about how well the humour works across the whole extract, explaining how the mock-serious style, Mr Pickwick's dignity, the build-up of pace and the comic reactions make us laugh, and perhaps weighing where the humour is less comfortable. Simply identifying funny moments or retelling the events stays in the lower levels. Do not speculate about what happens to Mr Pickwick after the extract ends.

Mark scheme
  1. 15 marks

    Levels of response (15 marks). AO4: Evaluate texts critically and support this with appropriate textual references.
    Level 5 (13-15 marks): Evaluation of ideas, events, themes or settings. There is a sustained and detached critical overview and judgement about the text. The selection of references is apt and discriminating and is persuasive in clarifying the points being made.
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): Analysis of ideas, events, themes or settings. Well-informed and developed critical judgement is offered about the text. The selection of references is appropriate, detailed and fully supports the points being made.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): Explanation of ideas, events, themes or settings. Informed judgement is offered about the text. The selection of references is appropriate and relevant to the points being made.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): Comment on ideas, events, themes or settings. Straightforward opinions with limited judgements are offered about the text. The selection of references is valid, but not developed.
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Description of ideas, events, themes or settings. Limited assertions are offered about the text. The use of references is limited.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Reward responses that evaluate how successfully the extract creates humour. References to the writer's techniques should only be credited at Level 2 and above if they support the critical judgement of the text. Responses may include: - the extract successfully creates humour through the contrast between grand, formal language and a trivial game, and between Mr Pickwick's dignity and his childish delight, ending in a comic catastrophe; - mock-heroic diction: 'delivering himself of the sentiment just recorded', 'exercising themselves thereupon, in a very masterly and brilliant manner', 'that beautiful feat of fancy-sliding which is currently denominated'; - the metaphor of Wardle having 'converted his legs into a pair of compasses, and drawn complicated problems on the ice'; - Mr Pickwick's formal politeness ('I should be very happy to afford you any amusement') contrasts with his memory of sliding 'on the gutters, when I was a boy'; - Wardle's impetuous 'Pooh! pooh! Nonsense!' and his race down the slide; - Mr Pickwick's cautious preparations and false starts, 'slowly and gravely', 'about a yard and a quarter apart', 'amidst the gratified shouts of all the spectators'; - the polysyndeton of 'and then ... and then' and the hyperbole 'as if their future prospects in life depended on their expedition'; - the long mock-serious sentence of paragraph 11 ('the ceremony', 'torture of anxiety', 'imminent hazard') ends in warmth ('beaming cheerfulness and gladness through his spectacles'), so the humour is affectionate; - the tricolon 'The sport was at its height, the sliding was at the quickest, the laughter was at the loudest' builds to the sudden 'sharp smart crack'; - the list 'hat, gloves, and handkerchief' and the understatement 'this was all of Mr. Pickwick that anybody could see'; - the exaggerated reactions: 'the males turned pale, and the females fainted', and Mr Snodgrass and Mr Winkle gazing at the spot 'with frenzied eagerness'; - the bathos of Mr Tupman, 'by way of rendering the promptest assistance', running off screaming 'Fire!', with the narrator's ironic, straight-faced explanation; - some may feel that the humour sits uneasily with a man disappearing under the ice, or that the long formal sentences slow the comedy, and they must explain and support their view.

Question 2

15 marks

Read the extract below. Then answer the question that follows.

Barchester Towers
by Anthony Trollope (1857)

This extract is taken from the novel Barchester Towers by Anthony Trollope, published in 1857. Mrs Proudie, the wife of the new Bishop of Barchester, is holding a grand evening party at the bishop's palace, helped by the bishop's chaplain, Mr Slope. One of the guests, Signora Madeline Neroni, who cannot walk, has been carried in and laid on a sofa, and her brother, Ethelbert (Bertie) Stanhope, has been chatting to the bishop in the crowded space behind it.

[1] The sofa had certainly been so placed that those who were behind it found great difficulty in getting out; there was but a narrow gangway, which one person could stop. This was a bad arrangement, and one which Bertie thought it might be well to improve.

[2] "Take care, Madeline," said he, and turning to the fat rector, added, "Just help me with a slight push."

[3] The rector's weight was resting on the sofa and unwittingly lent all its impetus to accelerate and increase the motion which Bertie intentionally originated. The sofa rushed from its moorings and ran half-way into the middle of the room. Mrs. Proudie was standing with Mr. Slope in front of the signora, and had been trying to be condescending and sociable; but she was not in the very best of tempers, for she found that, whenever she spoke to the lady, the lady replied by speaking to Mr. Slope. Mr. Slope was a favourite, no doubt, but Mrs. Proudie had no idea of being less thought of than the chaplain. She was beginning to be stately, stiff, and offended, when unfortunately the castor of the sofa caught itself in her lace train, and carried away there is no saying how much of her garniture. Gathers were heard to go, stitches to crack, plaits to fly open, flounces were seen to fall, and breadths to expose themselves; a long ruin of rent lace disfigured the carpet, and still clung to the vile wheel on which the sofa moved.

[...]

[4] We know what was the wrath of Juno when her beauty was despised. We know to what storms of passion even celestial minds can yield. As Juno may have looked at Paris on Mount Ida, so did Mrs. Proudie look on Ethelbert Stanhope when he pushed the leg of the sofa into her lace train.

[5] "Oh, you idiot, Bertie!" said the signora, seeing what had been done and what were to be the consequences.

[6] "Idiot!" re-echoed Mrs. Proudie, as though the word were not half strong enough to express the required meaning; "I'll let him know--" and then looking round to learn, at a glance, the worst, she saw that at present it behoved her to collect the scattered debris of her dress.

[7] Bertie, when he saw what he had done, rushed over the sofa and threw himself on one knee before the offended lady. His object, doubtless, was to liberate the torn lace from the castor, but he looked as though he were imploring pardon from a goddess.

[8] "Unhand it, sir!" said Mrs. Proudie. From what scrap of dramatic poetry she had extracted the word cannot be said, but it must have rested on her memory, and now seemed opportunely dignified for the occasion.

[9] "I'll fly to the looms of the fairies to repair the damage, if you'll only forgive me," said Ethelbert, still on his knees.

[10] "Unhand it, sir!" said Mrs. Proudie with redoubled emphasis, and all but furious wrath. This allusion to the fairies was a direct mockery and intended to turn her into ridicule. So at least it seemed to her. "Unhand it, sir!" she almost screamed.

[11] "It's not me; it's the cursed sofa," said Bertie, looking imploringly in her face and holding up both his hands to show that he was not touching her belongings, but still remaining on his knees.

[12] Hereupon the Signora laughed; not loud, indeed, but yet audibly. And as the tigress bereft of her young will turn with equal anger on any within reach, so did Mrs. Proudie turn upon her female guest.

[13] "Madam!" she said--and it is beyond the power of prose to tell of the fire which flashed from her eyes.

[14] The signora stared her full in the face for a moment, and then turning to her brother said playfully, "Bertie, you idiot, get up."

[15] By this time the bishop, and Mr. Slope, and her three daughters were around her, and had collected together the wide ruins of her magnificence. The girls fell into circular rank behind their mother, and thus following her and carrying out the fragments, they left the reception-rooms in a manner not altogether devoid of dignity. Mrs. Proudie had to retire and re-array herself.

Glossary: castor - a small wheel on the leg of a piece of furniture; garniture - trimmings and decorations; flounces - wide frills sewn on to a dress; Juno - the queen of the gods in Roman myths, who was furious when the prince Paris judged another goddess more beautiful than her; debris - broken pieces

In this extract, there is an attempt to create humour.

Evaluate how successfully this is achieved.

Support your views with detailed reference to the text.

Model answer

Trollope is extremely successful in creating humour, because he combines a farcical accident with a narrator who describes it in a mock-serious, grand style. The comedy comes from the gap between the triviality of a torn dress and the epic language used about it, and from the way Mrs Proudie's pride sets her up for a fall.

The humour begins with understatement. Bertie thinks the 'bad arrangement' of the sofa 'might be well to improve', and his casual request for 'a slight push' from the 'fat rector' is comically at odds with the result. The pseudo-scientific language of the rector's weight lending 'all its impetus' and the nautical metaphor of the sofa that 'rushed from its moorings' make a piece of furniture sound like a runaway ship. Crucially, just before the accident we learn that Mrs Proudie is 'beginning to be stately, stiff, and offended' because she will not be 'less thought of than the chaplain'. Her vanity makes her the perfect victim, so the reader enjoys her humiliation rather than pitying her.

The description of the damage is a comic highlight. The rapid list, 'Gathers were heard to go, stitches to crack, plaits to fly open, flounces were seen to fall', gives the destruction a rhythm like a string of small explosions, and the grand phrase 'a long ruin of rent lace' treats a dress like a fallen city. Calling the castor 'the vile wheel' adds mock outrage. This is capped by the mock-heroic comparison with 'the wrath of Juno when her beauty was despised'. Setting a bishop's wife's anger beside a goddess's is absurd, and it is the narrator's straight-faced tone, 'We know to what storms of passion even celestial minds can yield', that makes it so funny.

The dialogue is equally effective. Bertie kneels 'as though he were imploring pardon from a goddess', continuing the classical joke, while Mrs Proudie's theatrical 'Unhand it, sir!' is repeated three times, rising until 'she almost screamed'. The narrator's sly speculation about 'what scrap of dramatic poetry she had extracted the word' shows her reaching for dignity and missing it. Bertie's excuse, 'It's not me; it's the cursed sofa', is wonderfully childish, blaming the furniture while holding up 'both his hands'.

The ending is structured as a series of deflations. The tigress simile exaggerates her fury, and the narrator claims that 'it is beyond the power of prose' to describe the fire in her eyes, yet the signora punctures it all with 'Bertie, you idiot, get up.' The final image of the daughters falling 'into circular rank' and 'carrying out the fragments', like a solemn procession, is brilliantly ridiculous, and the understatement 'not altogether devoid of dignity' leaves the reader smiling.

If there is a weakness, it is that the humour relies heavily on the narrator telling us how to see Mrs Proudie, and some readers may find the classical allusions distancing or feel that the joke is entirely at one character's expense. However, the controlled, ironic voice is exactly what makes the scene work: Trollope sustains the joke from the first push to the final retreat, so the humour builds rather than fades.

Explanation

Level 5 answers judge how successfully humour is created across the whole extract - the farcical accident, Mrs Proudie's vanity, the mock-heroic narrator and the deflating ending - and use methods such as the list of damage, the Juno comparison and the repeated 'Unhand it, sir!' to support that judgement. Weaker answers simply say the scene is funny, retell it, or spot techniques without explaining why they make the reader laugh.

Mark scheme
  1. 15 marks

    Levels of response (15 marks). AO4: Evaluate texts critically and support this with appropriate textual references.
    Level 5 (13-15 marks): Evaluation of ideas, events, themes or settings. There is a sustained and detached critical overview and judgement about the text. The selection of references is apt and discriminating and is persuasive in clarifying the points being made.
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): Analysis of ideas, events, themes or settings. Well-informed and developed critical judgement is offered about the text. The selection of references is appropriate, detailed and fully supports the points being made.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): Explanation of ideas, events, themes or settings. Informed judgement is offered about the text. The selection of references is appropriate and relevant to the points being made.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): Comment on ideas, events, themes or settings. Straightforward opinions with limited judgements are offered about the text. The selection of references is valid, but not developed.
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Description of ideas, events, themes or settings. Limited assertions are offered about the text. The use of references is limited.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Reward responses that evaluate how successfully the attempt to create humour is achieved. References to the writer's techniques should only be credited at Level 2 and above if they support the critical judgement of the text. Responses may include: - the extract successfully creates humour through a farcical accident, a proud victim and a narrator whose mock-serious commentary invites the reader to laugh at Mrs Proudie's loss of dignity; - the understatement of a 'bad arrangement' which Bertie 'thought it might be well to improve', and his casual request for 'a slight push', contrast comically with the chaos that follows; - pseudo-scientific language (the rector's weight lending 'all its impetus') and the nautical metaphor of the sofa that 'rushed from its moorings' make a piece of furniture behave like a runaway ship; - Mrs Proudie's annoyance that the signora answers Mr Slope, and her refusal to be 'less thought of than the chaplain', establish her vanity, so the reader enjoys rather than pities her humiliation; she is 'beginning to be stately, stiff, and offended' just before the accident; - the mock-sympathetic 'unfortunately' and the castor that 'caught itself' give the accident a life of its own; - the rapid list 'Gathers were heard to go, stitches to crack, plaits to fly open, flounces were seen to fall, and breadths to expose themselves' gives the destruction a comic rhythm; 'a long ruin of rent lace' and 'the vile wheel' use grand, outraged language for a torn dress; - the mock-heroic comparison with 'the wrath of Juno when her beauty was despised' and the 'storms of passion' of 'celestial minds' places a dress on the level of a goddess's wounded pride; - Bertie kneeling 'as though he were imploring pardon from a goddess' continues the classical joke, and his promise to 'fly to the looms of the fairies' is absurdly extravagant; - the theatrical 'Unhand it, sir!', repeated three times with rising force until 'she almost screamed', and the narrator's speculation about 'what scrap of dramatic poetry she had extracted the word' mock her attempt at dignity; - Bertie's childish excuse, 'It's not me; it's the cursed sofa', while holding up 'both his hands'; - the tigress simile and 'it is beyond the power of prose to tell of the fire which flashed from her eyes' exaggerate her fury, which the signora punctures with the bathos of 'Bertie, you idiot, get up.'; - the exit, with the daughters falling 'into circular rank' and 'carrying out the fragments', and the litotes 'not altogether devoid of dignity', turns her retreat into a mock ceremony; - some may feel that the humour relies heavily on the narrator's commentary, or on classical allusions that modern readers may not know, or that it is all at one character's expense; others may see the controlled, ironic voice as the source of its success.

Question 3

15 marks

Read the extract below. Then answer the question that follows.

Far from the Madding Crowd
by Thomas Hardy (1874)

This extract is taken from the novel Far from the Madding Crowd by Thomas Hardy, published in 1874. Gabriel Oak, a young farmer, has fallen in love with Bathsheba Everdene, who is staying with her aunt near his farm. He has called at the aunt's cottage to ask Bathsheba to marry him, but her aunt has told him that Bathsheba already has a dozen young men, so he has set off home.

[1] When Gabriel had gone about two hundred yards along the down, he heard a "hoi-hoi!" uttered behind him, in a piping note of more treble quality than that in which the exclamation usually embodies itself when shouted across a field. He looked round, and saw a girl racing after him, waving a white handkerchief.

[2] Oak stood still-and the runner drew nearer. It was Bathsheba Everdene. Gabriel's colour deepened: hers was already deep, not, as it appeared, from emotion, but from running.

[3] "Farmer Oak-I-" she said, pausing for want of breath pulling up in front of him with a slanted face, and putting her hand to her side.

[4] "I have just called to see you," said Gabriel, pending her further speech.

[5] "Yes-I know that!" she said, panting like a robin, her face red and moist from her exertions, like a peony petal before the sun dries off the dew. "I didn't know you had come (pant) to ask to have me, or I should have come in from the garden instantly. I ran after you to say (pant) that my aunt made a mistake in sending you away from courting me (pant)--"

[6] Gabriel expanded. "I'm sorry to have made you run so fast, my dear," he said, with a grateful sense of favours to come. "Wait a bit till you've found your breath."

[7] "-It was quite a mistake-aunt's telling you I had a young man already." Bathsheba went on. "I haven't a sweetheart at all (pant), and I never had one, and I thought that, as times go with women, it was such a pity to send you away thinking that I had several."

[8] "Really and trewly I am glad to hear that!" said Farmer Oak, smiling one of his long special smiles, and blushing with gladness. He held out his hand to take hers, which, when she had eased her side by pressing it there, was prettily extended upon her bosom to still her loud-beating heart. Directly he seized it she put it behind her, so that it slipped through his fingers like an eel.

[9] "I have a nice snug little farm," said Gabriel, with half a degree less assurance than when he had seized her hand.

[10] "Yes; you have."

[11] "A man has advanced me money to begin with, but still, it will soon be paid off, and, though I am only an every-day sort of man, I have got on a little since I was a boy." Gabriel uttered "a little" in a tone to show her that it was the complacent form of "a great deal." He continued: "When we are married, I am quite sure I can work twice as hard as I do now."

[12] He went forward and stretched out his arm again. Bathsheba had overtaken him at a point beside which stood a low, stunted holly-bush, now laden with red berries. Seeing his advance take the form of an attitude threatening a possible enclosure, if not compression, of her person she edged off round the bush.

[13] "Why, Farmer Oak," she said, over the top, looking at him with rounded eyes, "I never said I was going to marry you."

[14] "Well-that is a tale!" said Oak, with dismay." To run after anybody like this, and then say you don't want me!"

[15] "What I meant to tell you was only this," she said eagerly, and yet half conscious of the absurdity of the position she had made for herself; "that nobody has got me yet as a sweetheart, instead of my having a dozen, as my aunt said; I hate to be thought men's property in that way, though possibly I shall be had some day. Why, if I'd wanted you I shouldn't have run after you like this; 'twould have been the forwardest thing! But there was no harm in hurrying to correct a piece of false news that had been told you."

[16] "Oh, no-no harm at all." But there is such a thing as being too generous in expressing a judgment impulsively, and Oak added with a more appreciative sense of all the circumstances-"Well, I am not quite certain it was no harm."

Glossary: down - an open, grassy hill; peony - a large garden flower, often deep pink or red; courting - trying to win someone as a husband or wife; advanced me money - lent me money; forwardest - boldest; most improper for a young woman

In this extract, there is an attempt to create humour.

Evaluate how successfully this is achieved.

Support your views with detailed reference to the text.

Model answer

Hardy creates humour very successfully, mostly through a misunderstanding that the reader sees before Gabriel does, and through a narrator who describes a simple country courtship in grand, ironic language.

The humour begins in the opening sentence. A girl's shout of 'hoi-hoi!' is described as 'a piping note of more treble quality than that in which the exclamation usually embodies itself when shouted across a field'. The elaborate, almost scientific phrasing for such a simple noise is comic in itself, and it establishes the narrator's amused distance from the characters.

Bathsheba's breathless arrival adds physical comedy. The writer interrupts her speech with '(pant)' again and again, like a stage direction, so that her important message keeps collapsing into gasps. The simile 'panting like a robin' makes her small and bird-like, though the second simile, 'like a peony petal before the sun dries off the dew', is more romantic, perhaps showing her as Gabriel sees her. The comedy depends on ambiguity: she says she ran 'to say ... that my aunt made a mistake in sending you away from courting me', which Gabriel naturally takes as encouragement.

Gabriel's growing confidence is mocked gently. The two-word sentence 'Gabriel expanded.' is a wonderfully economical image of a man swelling with hope, and 'with a grateful sense of favours to come' is ironic, because the reader suspects the favours will not come. His dialect, 'Really and trewly', and his 'long special smiles' make him endearing rather than foolish. When he takes her hand, it 'slipped through his fingers like an eel', a comic simile that captures her slipperiness, and the narrator measures his loss of confidence exactly: 'half a degree less assurance'. His attempt to impress her by saying he has 'got on a little' is undercut when the narrator explains that by 'a little' he really means 'a great deal'. He even takes the wedding for granted: 'When we are married'.

The climax uses physical farce. Gabriel's approach is described in mock-formal language as 'an attitude threatening a possible enclosure, if not compression, of her person', and she 'edged off round the bush'. The image of her speaking 'over the top' of a holly-bush 'with rounded eyes' is almost pantomime. Her line 'I never said I was going to marry you.' is the punchline, and Gabriel's reasonable complaint, 'To run after anybody like this, and then say you don't want me!', voices exactly what the reader is thinking.

Bathsheba's explanation adds a further layer. Her logic, that 'if I'd wanted you I shouldn't have run after you like this', is absurd, and the narrator notes that she is 'half conscious of the absurdity of the position she had made for herself'. The ending is a final, dry joke as Gabriel corrects his polite 'no harm at all' to 'I am not quite certain it was no harm.'

The humour is not laugh-out-loud, and some readers may find the narrator's long sentences slow. There is also a serious edge in 'I hate to be thought men's property', which shows Bathsheba's independence, and in Gabriel's real disappointment. However, this seriousness makes the comedy richer: we laugh at both characters, but we like them too. Overall, the attempt to create humour is highly successful.

Explanation

Level 5 needs a sustained critical judgement of how successfully humour is created across the extract: this answer evaluates the ironic narrator, the central misunderstanding, the comic similes and the farce of the holly-bush, and recognises the serious note that limits but also deepens the comedy. Weaker answers simply say the extract is funny, or list techniques without judging their effect.

Mark scheme
  1. 15 marks

    Levels of response (15 marks). AO4: Evaluate texts critically and support this with appropriate textual references.
    Level 5 (13-15 marks): Evaluation of ideas, events, themes or settings. There is a sustained and detached critical overview and judgement about the text. The selection of references is apt and discriminating and is persuasive in clarifying the points being made.
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): Analysis of ideas, events, themes or settings. Well-informed and developed critical judgement is offered about the text. The selection of references is appropriate, detailed and fully supports the points being made.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): Explanation of ideas, events, themes or settings. Informed judgement is offered about the text. The selection of references is appropriate and relevant to the points being made.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): Comment on ideas, events, themes or settings. Straightforward opinions with limited judgements are offered about the text. The selection of references is valid, but not developed.
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Description of ideas, events, themes or settings. Limited assertions are offered about the text. The use of references is limited.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Reward responses that evaluate how successfully humour is created. References to the writer's techniques should only be credited at Level 2 and above if they support the critical judgement of the text.
    Responses may include:
    - the narrator's elaborate, mock-scientific description of a simple shout ('a piping note of more treble quality than that in which the exclamation usually embodies itself when shouted across a field') sets up an amused, ironic distance
    - Bathsheba's breathless speech is repeatedly interrupted by '(pant)', like a stage direction; the simile 'panting like a robin' is comic, while 'like a peony petal before the sun dries off the dew' is more romantic
    - the central misunderstanding: she ran only to correct 'a piece of false news', but Gabriel takes her words as encouragement, which the reader sees before he does
    - Gabriel's swelling hopes are gently mocked: 'Gabriel expanded.', 'with a grateful sense of favours to come' (irony), 'Really and trewly', 'one of his long special smiles'
    - the simile 'slipped through his fingers like an eel' and the precise 'half a degree less assurance' measure his loss of confidence comically
    - his modest boasting ('a little', which he means as 'a great deal', as the narrator explains) and his assumption 'When we are married'
    - physical farce: the mock-formal 'an attitude threatening a possible enclosure, if not compression, of her person', her edging round the holly-bush and speaking 'over the top' 'with rounded eyes'
    - the punchline 'I never said I was going to marry you.' and Gabriel's 'Well-that is a tale!'; his complaint 'To run after anybody like this, and then say you don't want me!' voices the reader's thought
    - Bathsheba's absurd logic ('if I'd wanted you I shouldn't have run after you like this') and the narrator's remark that she is 'half conscious of the absurdity of the position she had made for herself'
    - the deflating ending: 'Oh, no-no harm at all.' revised to 'I am not quite certain it was no harm.'
    - the humour is gentle rather than cruel; serious notes ('I hate to be thought men's property') and Gabriel's real disappointment may limit the comedy or deepen it.
    Responses should be based on the extract.

Question 4

15 marks

Read the extract below. Then answer the question that follows.

The Judge's House
by Bram Stoker (1891)

This extract is taken from the short story The Judge's House by Bram Stoker, published in 1891. Malcolmson, a student, has rented an old house that has stood empty for many years, so that he can study alone for an examination; it is known locally as the Judge's House, because a judge feared for his harsh sentences once lived there. On previous nights an enormous rat has disturbed him as he works, and a doctor in the town has warned him about the house.

[1] For an hour or so he worked all right, and then his thoughts began to wander from his books. The actual circumstances around him, the calls on his physical attention, and his nervous susceptibility were not to be denied. By this time the wind had become a gale, and the gale a storm. The old house, solid though it was, seemed to shake to its foundations, and the storm roared and raged through its many chimneys and its queer old gables, producing strange, unearthly sounds in the empty rooms and corridors. Even the great alarm bell on the roof must have felt the force of the wind, for the rope rose and fell slightly, as though the bell were moved a little from time to time and the limber rope fell on the oak floor with a hard and hollow sound.

[2] As Malcolmson listened to it he bethought himself of the doctor's words, "It is the rope which the hangman used for the victims of the Judge's judicial rancour," and he went over to the corner of the fireplace and took it in his hand to look at it. [...] As he stood there the swaying of the bell on the roof still lifted the rope now and again; but presently there came a new sensation-a sort of tremor in the rope, as though something was moving along it.

[3] Looking up instinctively Malcolmson saw the great rat coming slowly down towards him, glaring at him steadily. He dropped the rope and started back with a muttered curse, and the rat turning ran up the rope again and disappeared, and at the same instant Malcolmson became conscious that the noise of the rats, which had ceased for a while, began again.

[4] All this set him thinking, and it occurred to him that he had not investigated the lair of the rat or looked at the pictures, as he had intended. He lit the other lamp without the shade, and, holding it up went and stood opposite the third picture from the fireplace on the right-hand side where he had seen the rat disappear on the previous night.

[5] At the first glance he started back so suddenly that he almost dropped the lamp, and a deadly pallor overspread his face. His knees shook, and heavy drops of sweat came on his forehead, and he trembled like an aspen. But he was young and plucky, and pulled himself together, and after the pause of a few seconds stepped forward again, raised the lamp, and examined the picture which had been dusted and washed, and now stood out clearly.

[6] It was of a judge dressed in his robes of scarlet and ermine. His face was strong and merciless, evil, crafty, and vindictive, with a sensual mouth, hooked nose of ruddy colour, and shaped like the beak of a bird of prey. The rest of the face was of a cadaverous colour. The eyes were of peculiar brilliance and with a terribly malignant expression. As he looked at them, Malcolmson grew cold, for he saw there the very counterpart of the eyes of the great rat. The lamp almost fell from his hand, he saw the rat with its baleful eyes peering out through the hole in the corner of the picture, and noted the sudden cessation of the noise of the other rats. However, he pulled himself together, and went on with his examination of the picture.

[7] The Judge was seated in a great high-backed carved oak chair, on the right-hand side of a great stone fireplace where, in the corner, a rope hung down from the ceiling, its end lying coiled on the floor. With a feeling of something like horror, Malcolmson recognised the scene of the room as it stood, and gazed around him in an awestruck manner as though he expected to find some strange presence behind him. Then he looked over to the corner of the fireplace-and with a loud cry he let the lamp fall from his hand.

[8] There, in the Judge's arm-chair, with the rope hanging behind, sat the rat with the Judge's baleful eyes, now intensified and with a fiendish leer. Save for the howling of the storm without there was silence.

Glossary: limber - bending easily; rancour - bitter hatred; aspen - a tree whose leaves tremble in the slightest wind; ermine - white fur worn on a judge's robes; cadaverous - pale, like a corpse

In this extract, there is an attempt to create an atmosphere of horror.

Evaluate how successfully this is achieved.

Support your views with detailed reference to the text.

Model answer

Stoker is very successful in creating an atmosphere of horror, because he moves the reader steadily from a vague, stormy unease to a single shocking image, and links every frightening detail - the storm, the rope, the rat and the portrait - into one pattern.

The setting establishes horror at once. The weather intensifies through the rising pattern 'the wind had become a gale, and the gale a storm', and the alliterative 'roared and raged' gives the storm a violent, almost animal voice. The 'strange, unearthly sounds in the empty rooms and corridors' are effective because 'unearthly' hints at the supernatural, while 'empty' reminds us that Malcolmson is completely alone. These are familiar gothic ingredients, and some readers might find them predictable, but they work here because they prepare us for what follows.

The rope is a particularly successful device. The doctor's words, 'the rope which the hangman used for the victims of the Judge's judicial rancour', fill an ordinary bell-rope with death, so when Malcolmson takes it 'in his hand' we are uneasy. The writer then makes an unseen presence travel along it: 'a sort of tremor in the rope, as though something was moving along it'. The vague 'something' is more frightening than a name, and the rat that appears, 'glaring at him steadily', seems to have an unnatural, human intention.

The horror deepens through Malcolmson's physical reactions. In paragraph 5 the writer piles up symptoms - 'a deadly pallor', 'His knees shook', 'heavy drops of sweat' - and the simile 'he trembled like an aspen' makes his fear visible. Because we are told he is 'young and plucky', his terror is all the more convincing: if a brave man is this frightened, so are we.

The description of the portrait is the centre of the extract. The list 'strong and merciless, evil, crafty, and vindictive' builds a picture of pure cruelty, the simile of a nose 'shaped like the beak of a bird of prey' makes the Judge a predator, and 'cadaverous' associates him with a corpse. The moment of true horror comes when Malcolmson sees in the Judge's eyes 'the very counterpart of the eyes of the great rat': man and animal, past and present, suddenly merge. The 'sudden cessation of the noise of the other rats' is a clever touch, as silence becomes more threatening than noise.

The structure then builds to a climax. The lamp motif - he 'almost dropped the lamp', then 'The lamp almost fell', and finally 'he let the lamp fall' - charts his loss of control, and the dash before the 'loud cry' creates a pause before the final image. The last paragraph is the most successful of all. The inverted sentence holds back its subject: 'There, in the Judge's arm-chair, with the rope hanging behind, sat the rat'. Its eyes are now 'intensified and with a fiendish leer', and the extract closes in silence 'Save for the howling of the storm'. Nothing is explained, so the reader is left in that silence with Malcolmson.

Some may feel the detailed account of the painting slows the pace, but the slowness is deliberate: it makes us look as closely as Malcolmson does, so we share his recognition. Overall, the writer creates a powerful and sustained atmosphere of horror.

Explanation

The response reaches Level 5 because it sustains an overview (how every detail is linked into one pattern of horror), evaluates setting, events and structure across the whole extract, and uses discriminating references to support its judgement, including a counter-view about pace. Common errors are retelling the story, spotting techniques without judging how well they work, or speculating about what happens after the extract.

Mark scheme
  1. 15 marks

    Levels of response (15 marks). AO4: Evaluate texts critically and support this with appropriate textual references.
    Level 5 (13-15 marks): Evaluation of ideas, events, themes or settings. There is a sustained and detached critical overview and judgement about the text. The selection of references is apt and discriminating and is persuasive in clarifying the points being made.
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): Analysis of ideas, events, themes or settings. Well-informed and developed critical judgement is offered about the text. The selection of references is appropriate, detailed and fully supports the points being made.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): Explanation of ideas, events, themes or settings. Informed judgement is offered about the text. The selection of references is appropriate and relevant to the points being made.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): Comment on ideas, events, themes or settings. Straightforward opinions with limited judgements are offered about the text. The selection of references is valid, but not developed.
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Description of ideas, events, themes or settings. Limited assertions are offered about the text. The use of references is limited.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Reward responses that evaluate how successfully an atmosphere of horror is created. References to the writer's techniques should only be credited at Level 2 and above if they support the critical judgement of the text. Responses should keep to the extract and not speculate about what happens next.
    Responses may include:
    - the extract successfully moves from a vague, stormy unease to a single shocking image, linking the storm, the rope, the rat and the portrait into one pattern of horror
    - the gothic setting: the storm grows ('the wind had become a gale, and the gale a storm'), 'roared and raged', and makes 'strange, unearthly sounds in the empty rooms and corridors', stressing the supernatural and Malcolmson's isolation
    - the rope is linked with death by the doctor's words ('the rope which the hangman used for the victims of the Judge's judicial rancour'), and an unseen presence seems to travel along it: 'a sort of tremor in the rope, as though something was moving along it'
    - the rat 'glaring at him steadily' seems to have a human, hostile intention; the noise of the rats stops and starts as if on a signal
    - Malcolmson's physical reactions ('a deadly pallor', 'His knees shook', 'heavy drops of sweat', the simile 'trembled like an aspen') convey fear to the reader; because he is 'young and plucky', his terror is more convincing
    - the portrait: the list 'strong and merciless, evil, crafty, and vindictive', the simile 'shaped like the beak of a bird of prey' (a predator) and 'cadaverous colour' (a corpse) create a figure of cruelty and death
    - the moment of recognition, 'the very counterpart of the eyes of the great rat', merges man and animal, past and present
    - silence becomes menacing: 'the sudden cessation of the noise of the other rats'
    - the picture shows the room 'as it stood', with the rope; Malcolmson looks round 'as though he expected to find some strange presence behind him'
    - the lamp motif charts his loss of control: 'almost dropped the lamp', 'The lamp almost fell from his hand', 'he let the lamp fall from his hand'
    - the climax: the dash before 'with a loud cry'; the inverted first sentence of the last paragraph delays its subject ('There, in the Judge's arm-chair, with the rope hanging behind, sat the rat'); the 'baleful eyes' are 'now intensified and with a fiendish leer'
    - the short final sentence, 'Save for the howling of the storm without there was silence.', leaves the horror unexplained and the reader suspended
    - some may feel that the long description of the picture slows the pace, or that the gothic features are conventional; such views must be explained and supported

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.