Question 1
15 marksRead the extract below. Then answer the question that follows.
The Pickwick Papers
by Charles Dickens (1837)
This extract is taken from the novel The Pickwick Papers by Charles Dickens, published in 1837. Mr Pickwick and his friends are spending Christmas Day with their friend Mr Wardle and his family in the country, and the whole party, including Mr Pickwick's servant, Sam Weller, has gone out on to the ice. Mr Pickwick has just told off his friend Mr Winkle for pretending that he could skate.
[1] While Mr. Pickwick was delivering himself of the sentiment just recorded, Mr. Weller and the fat boy, having by their joint endeavours cut out a slide, were exercising themselves thereupon, in a very masterly and brilliant manner. Sam Weller, in particular, was displaying that beautiful feat of fancy-sliding which is currently denominated 'knocking at the cobbler's door,' and which is achieved by skimming over the ice on one foot, and occasionally giving a postman's knock upon it with the other. It was a good long slide, and there was something in the motion which Mr. Pickwick, who was very cold with standing still, could not help envying.
[2] 'It looks a nice warm exercise that, doesn't it?' he inquired of Wardle, when that gentleman was thoroughly out of breath, by reason of the indefatigable manner in which he had converted his legs into a pair of compasses, and drawn complicated problems on the ice.
[3] 'Ah, it does, indeed,' replied Wardle. 'Do you slide?'
[4] 'I used to do so, on the gutters, when I was a boy,' replied Mr. Pickwick.
[5] 'Try it now,' said Wardle.
[6] 'Oh, do, please, Mr. Pickwick!' cried all the ladies.
[7] 'I should be very happy to afford you any amusement,' replied Mr. Pickwick, 'but I haven't done such a thing these thirty years.'
[8] 'Pooh! pooh! Nonsense!' said Wardle, dragging off his skates with the impetuosity which characterised all his proceedings. 'Here; I'll keep you company; come along!' And away went the good-tempered old fellow down the slide, with a rapidity which came very close upon Mr. Weller, and beat the fat boy all to nothing.
[9] Mr. Pickwick paused, considered, pulled off his gloves and put them in his hat; took two or three short runs, baulked himself as often, and at last took another run, and went slowly and gravely down the slide, with his feet about a yard and a quarter apart, amidst the gratified shouts of all the spectators.
[10] 'Keep the pot a-bilin', Sir!' said Sam; and down went Wardle again, and then Mr. Pickwick, and then Sam, and then Mr. Winkle, and then Mr. Bob Sawyer, and then the fat boy, and then Mr. Snodgrass, following closely upon each other's heels, and running after each other with as much eagerness as if their future prospects in life depended on their expedition.
[11] It was the most intensely interesting thing, to observe the manner in which Mr. Pickwick performed his share in the ceremony; to watch the torture of anxiety with which he viewed the person behind, gaining upon him at the imminent hazard of tripping him up; to see him gradually expend the painful force he had put on at first, and turn slowly round on the slide, with his face towards the point from which he had started; to contemplate the playful smile which mantled on his face when he had accomplished the distance, and the eagerness with which he turned round when he had done so, and ran after his predecessor, his black gaiters tripping pleasantly through the snow, and his eyes beaming cheerfulness and gladness through his spectacles. [...]
[12] The sport was at its height, the sliding was at the quickest, the laughter was at the loudest, when a sharp smart crack was heard. There was a quick rush towards the bank, a wild scream from the ladies, and a shout from Mr. Tupman. A large mass of ice disappeared; the water bubbled up over it; Mr. Pickwick's hat, gloves, and handkerchief were floating on the surface; and this was all of Mr. Pickwick that anybody could see.
[13] Dismay and anguish were depicted on every countenance; the males turned pale, and the females fainted; Mr. Snodgrass and Mr. Winkle grasped each other by the hand, and gazed at the spot where their leader had gone down, with frenzied eagerness; while Mr. Tupman, by way of rendering the promptest assistance, and at the same time conveying to any persons who might be within hearing, the clearest possible notion of the catastrophe, ran off across the country at his utmost speed, screaming 'Fire!' with all his might.
Glossary: denominated - called; indefatigable - tireless; baulked himself - stopped himself suddenly; expedition - speed; gaiters - cloth coverings for the ankles and lower legs
In this extract, there is an attempt to create humour.
Evaluate how successfully this is achieved.
Support your views with detailed reference to the text.
Model answer
Dickens is extremely successful in creating humour, because he describes a simple winter game in grand, serious language and builds it up so carefully that the final accident becomes both shocking and absurd.
The main source of humour is the gap between the narrator's elaborate style and the trivial events. Sam's trick is 'that beautiful feat of fancy-sliding which is currently denominated' (that is, called) 'knocking at the cobbler's door', described with the formality of a lecture. Wardle has 'converted his legs into a pair of compasses, and drawn complicated problems on the ice', a witty metaphor that turns his skating into geometry. This mock-serious tone makes even small moments funny.
Mr Pickwick himself is the centre of the comedy. He is dignified and polite, 'I should be very happy to afford you any amusement', but he admits that he 'used to do so, on the gutters, when I was a boy', and has not done it 'these thirty years'. The contrast between his dignity and the childish game is the heart of the humour. His preparations are absurdly careful: he 'paused, considered, pulled off his gloves and put them in his hat', makes several false starts and then goes down 'slowly and gravely' with his feet 'about a yard and a quarter apart'. The precise measurement makes the picture vivid and ridiculous.
Dickens then speeds up the pace. The polysyndeton 'and then Mr. Pickwick, and then Sam, and then Mr. Winkle' creates a breathless chain of sliders, and the hyperbole 'as if their future prospects in life depended on their expedition' mocks their seriousness. Paragraph 11 is a long, admiring sentence that treats sliding as 'the ceremony' and his fear of being caught as a 'torture of anxiety'. The humour here is affectionate rather than cruel, because we also see 'the playful smile' and his eyes 'beaming cheerfulness and gladness through his spectacles'. We laugh with him as well as at him.
The climax is cleverly structured. The tricolon 'The sport was at its height, the sliding was at the quickest, the laughter was at the loudest' raises the mood to its peak, so that the 'sharp smart crack' is a sudden reversal. After the list of 'hat, gloves, and handkerchief', the understatement 'this was all of Mr. Pickwick that anybody could see' is darkly funny: the signs of his gentlemanly dignity float on the water while the man himself has vanished. The reactions are exaggerated for comic effect, 'the males turned pale, and the females fainted', while Mr Snodgrass and Mr Winkle can only grasp each other by the hand and gaze at the spot. The best joke is saved for last. Mr Tupman, 'by way of rendering the promptest assistance', runs off across the country screaming 'Fire!', the most useless response imaginable, made funnier by the narrator's straight-faced irony.
Some readers might feel uncomfortable laughing when a man has disappeared under the ice, and the long, formal sentences may slow the comedy for a modern reader. However, the narrator's detached, playful tone invites us to laugh rather than fear, and the slow build-up makes the sudden crack and the absurd reactions all the more effective. Overall, the humour is sustained and skilfully controlled throughout the extract.
Explanation
Top-level answers make a sustained judgement about how well the humour works across the whole extract, explaining how the mock-serious style, Mr Pickwick's dignity, the build-up of pace and the comic reactions make us laugh, and perhaps weighing where the humour is less comfortable. Simply identifying funny moments or retelling the events stays in the lower levels. Do not speculate about what happens to Mr Pickwick after the extract ends.
Mark scheme
-
15 marks
Levels of response (15 marks). AO4: Evaluate texts critically and support this with appropriate textual references.
Level 5 (13-15 marks): Evaluation of ideas, events, themes or settings. There is a sustained and detached critical overview and judgement about the text. The selection of references is apt and discriminating and is persuasive in clarifying the points being made.
Level 4 (10-12 marks): Analysis of ideas, events, themes or settings. Well-informed and developed critical judgement is offered about the text. The selection of references is appropriate, detailed and fully supports the points being made.
Level 3 (7-9 marks): Explanation of ideas, events, themes or settings. Informed judgement is offered about the text. The selection of references is appropriate and relevant to the points being made.
Level 2 (4-6 marks): Comment on ideas, events, themes or settings. Straightforward opinions with limited judgements are offered about the text. The selection of references is valid, but not developed.
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Description of ideas, events, themes or settings. Limited assertions are offered about the text. The use of references is limited.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Reward responses that evaluate how successfully the extract creates humour. References to the writer's techniques should only be credited at Level 2 and above if they support the critical judgement of the text. Responses may include: - the extract successfully creates humour through the contrast between grand, formal language and a trivial game, and between Mr Pickwick's dignity and his childish delight, ending in a comic catastrophe; - mock-heroic diction: 'delivering himself of the sentiment just recorded', 'exercising themselves thereupon, in a very masterly and brilliant manner', 'that beautiful feat of fancy-sliding which is currently denominated'; - the metaphor of Wardle having 'converted his legs into a pair of compasses, and drawn complicated problems on the ice'; - Mr Pickwick's formal politeness ('I should be very happy to afford you any amusement') contrasts with his memory of sliding 'on the gutters, when I was a boy'; - Wardle's impetuous 'Pooh! pooh! Nonsense!' and his race down the slide; - Mr Pickwick's cautious preparations and false starts, 'slowly and gravely', 'about a yard and a quarter apart', 'amidst the gratified shouts of all the spectators'; - the polysyndeton of 'and then ... and then' and the hyperbole 'as if their future prospects in life depended on their expedition'; - the long mock-serious sentence of paragraph 11 ('the ceremony', 'torture of anxiety', 'imminent hazard') ends in warmth ('beaming cheerfulness and gladness through his spectacles'), so the humour is affectionate; - the tricolon 'The sport was at its height, the sliding was at the quickest, the laughter was at the loudest' builds to the sudden 'sharp smart crack'; - the list 'hat, gloves, and handkerchief' and the understatement 'this was all of Mr. Pickwick that anybody could see'; - the exaggerated reactions: 'the males turned pale, and the females fainted', and Mr Snodgrass and Mr Winkle gazing at the spot 'with frenzied eagerness'; - the bathos of Mr Tupman, 'by way of rendering the promptest assistance', running off screaming 'Fire!', with the narrator's ironic, straight-faced explanation; - some may feel that the humour sits uneasily with a man disappearing under the ice, or that the long formal sentences slow the comedy, and they must explain and support their view.