Question 1
6 marksRead the extract below. Then answer the question that follows.
The Pickwick Papers
by Charles Dickens (1837)
This extract is taken from the novel The Pickwick Papers by Charles Dickens, published in 1837. Mr Pickwick and his friends are spending Christmas Day with their friend Mr Wardle and his family in the country, and the whole party, including Mr Pickwick's servant, Sam Weller, has gone out on to the ice. Mr Pickwick has just told off his friend Mr Winkle for pretending that he could skate.
[1] While Mr. Pickwick was delivering himself of the sentiment just recorded, Mr. Weller and the fat boy, having by their joint endeavours cut out a slide, were exercising themselves thereupon, in a very masterly and brilliant manner. Sam Weller, in particular, was displaying that beautiful feat of fancy-sliding which is currently denominated 'knocking at the cobbler's door,' and which is achieved by skimming over the ice on one foot, and occasionally giving a postman's knock upon it with the other. It was a good long slide, and there was something in the motion which Mr. Pickwick, who was very cold with standing still, could not help envying.
[2] 'It looks a nice warm exercise that, doesn't it?' he inquired of Wardle, when that gentleman was thoroughly out of breath, by reason of the indefatigable manner in which he had converted his legs into a pair of compasses, and drawn complicated problems on the ice.
[3] 'Ah, it does, indeed,' replied Wardle. 'Do you slide?'
[4] 'I used to do so, on the gutters, when I was a boy,' replied Mr. Pickwick.
[5] 'Try it now,' said Wardle.
[6] 'Oh, do, please, Mr. Pickwick!' cried all the ladies.
[7] 'I should be very happy to afford you any amusement,' replied Mr. Pickwick, 'but I haven't done such a thing these thirty years.'
[8] 'Pooh! pooh! Nonsense!' said Wardle, dragging off his skates with the impetuosity which characterised all his proceedings. 'Here; I'll keep you company; come along!' And away went the good-tempered old fellow down the slide, with a rapidity which came very close upon Mr. Weller, and beat the fat boy all to nothing.
[9] Mr. Pickwick paused, considered, pulled off his gloves and put them in his hat; took two or three short runs, baulked himself as often, and at last took another run, and went slowly and gravely down the slide, with his feet about a yard and a quarter apart, amidst the gratified shouts of all the spectators.
[10] 'Keep the pot a-bilin', Sir!' said Sam; and down went Wardle again, and then Mr. Pickwick, and then Sam, and then Mr. Winkle, and then Mr. Bob Sawyer, and then the fat boy, and then Mr. Snodgrass, following closely upon each other's heels, and running after each other with as much eagerness as if their future prospects in life depended on their expedition.
[11] It was the most intensely interesting thing, to observe the manner in which Mr. Pickwick performed his share in the ceremony; to watch the torture of anxiety with which he viewed the person behind, gaining upon him at the imminent hazard of tripping him up; to see him gradually expend the painful force he had put on at first, and turn slowly round on the slide, with his face towards the point from which he had started; to contemplate the playful smile which mantled on his face when he had accomplished the distance, and the eagerness with which he turned round when he had done so, and ran after his predecessor, his black gaiters tripping pleasantly through the snow, and his eyes beaming cheerfulness and gladness through his spectacles. [...]
[12] The sport was at its height, the sliding was at the quickest, the laughter was at the loudest, when a sharp smart crack was heard. There was a quick rush towards the bank, a wild scream from the ladies, and a shout from Mr. Tupman. A large mass of ice disappeared; the water bubbled up over it; Mr. Pickwick's hat, gloves, and handkerchief were floating on the surface; and this was all of Mr. Pickwick that anybody could see.
[13] Dismay and anguish were depicted on every countenance; the males turned pale, and the females fainted; Mr. Snodgrass and Mr. Winkle grasped each other by the hand, and gazed at the spot where their leader had gone down, with frenzied eagerness; while Mr. Tupman, by way of rendering the promptest assistance, and at the same time conveying to any persons who might be within hearing, the clearest possible notion of the catastrophe, ran off across the country at his utmost speed, screaming 'Fire!' with all his might.
Glossary: denominated - called; indefatigable - tireless; baulked himself - stopped himself suddenly; expedition - speed; gaiters - cloth coverings for the ankles and lower legs
In paragraphs 9 to 11, how does the writer use language and structure to show what Mr Pickwick is like as he slides?
Support your views with reference to the text.
Model answer
Dickens presents Mr Pickwick as a dignified man who takes even sliding very seriously. Paragraph 9 is one long sentence built from a list of careful actions - he 'paused, considered, pulled off his gloves and put them in his hat' - and the false starts, 'took two or three short runs, baulked himself as often', delay the slide itself. When he finally goes, the adverbs 'slowly and gravely' and the exact measurement of his feet, 'about a yard and a quarter apart', create a comic picture of a cautious, solemn man doing a childish thing in front of 'all the spectators'.
In paragraph 10 the structure changes. The polysyndeton 'and then ... and then' turns the sliders into a fast, endless chain, and Mr Pickwick becomes just one link in it. The hyperbole 'as if their future prospects in life depended on their expedition' gently mocks how seriously they all take the game.
Paragraph 11 is another very long sentence, built on repeated infinitives - 'to observe', 'to watch', 'to see', 'to contemplate' - which invite the reader to watch Mr Pickwick like a performance. The language is mock-serious: sliding is 'the ceremony', and his fear of being overtaken is a 'torture of anxiety' at the 'imminent hazard' of being tripped up. Yet the sentence ends warmly, with 'the playful smile' on his face and his eyes 'beaming cheerfulness and gladness through his spectacles', while the image of his 'black gaiters tripping pleasantly through the snow' makes him seem light and young again. By the end of the paragraph the hesitant man of paragraph 9 has become an eager, joyful one, and Dickens presents him with affection rather than scorn.
Explanation
Level 3 answers analyse both language (the mock-serious 'ceremony' and 'torture of anxiety', the adverbs 'slowly and gravely', the warm final images) and structure (the delayed start in paragraph 9, the polysyndeton of paragraph 10, the long sentence of repeated infinitives in paragraph 11), showing how Mr Pickwick changes from cautious to joyful. Answers on only language or only structure cannot go above Level 1. A common error is to write mostly about the accident in paragraphs 12 and 13, which are outside the given paragraphs.
Mark scheme
-
6 marks
Levels of response (6 marks). AO2: Explain, comment on and analyse how writers use language and structure to achieve effects and influence readers, using relevant subject terminology to support their views.
Level 3 (5-6 marks): Analysis of how both language and structure are used to achieve effects and influence readers, including use of vocabulary, sentence structure and other language features. The selection of references is discriminating and clarifies the points being made.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): Explanation of how both language and structure are used to achieve effects and influence readers, including use of vocabulary and sentence structure. The selection of references is appropriate and relevant to the points being made.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): Comment on the language and/or structure used to achieve effects and influence readers, including use of vocabulary. The selection of references is valid, but not developed. NB: The mark awarded cannot progress beyond the top of Level 1 if only language OR structure has been considered.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Max 2 if the response considers only language or only structure (Pearson: responses that are unbalanced cannot access Level 2 or above, where analysis of both language and structure is required). Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Reward responses that explain how the writer uses language and structure in paragraphs 9 to 11 to show what Mr Pickwick is like as he slides. Credit only analysis of paragraphs 9 to 11 (the given paragraphs); references to the rest of the extract do not count towards the mark. Responses may include the following points about the language of the text: - the list of verbs 'paused, considered, pulled off his gloves and put them in his hat' presents him as careful and deliberate, even about a game; - 'baulked himself as often' shows his hesitation; - the adverbs 'slowly and gravely' create comic solemnity, at odds with a playful activity; - the precise measurement 'about a yard and a quarter apart' gives a comic picture of his cautious stance; - 'amidst the gratified shouts of all the spectators' shows him as a public spectacle; - mock-serious vocabulary presents the game as a grand event: 'performed his share in the ceremony', 'torture of anxiety', 'imminent hazard'; - 'the painful force he had put on at first' suggests the effort the sliding costs him; - warm, joyful language at the end of paragraph 11, 'the playful smile which mantled on his face' and 'his eyes beaming cheerfulness and gladness through his spectacles', shows his childlike delight; - the image of 'his black gaiters tripping pleasantly through the snow' makes him seem light-footed and young again; - the hyperbole 'as if their future prospects in life depended on their expedition' mocks how seriously everyone takes the game. Responses may include the following points about the structure of the text: - paragraph 9 is one long sentence whose false starts delay the slide itself, so his eventual slow descent is an anticlimax; - in paragraph 10 the polysyndeton 'and then Mr. Pickwick, and then Sam, and then Mr. Winkle' turns the sliders into a fast, endless chain in which Mr Pickwick is one link; - Sam's exclamation in dialect, 'Keep the pot a-bilin', Sir!', starts the quickening pace; - paragraph 11 is one very long sentence built on repeated infinitives ('to observe', 'to watch', 'to see', 'to contemplate'), inviting the reader to watch him like a performance; - paragraph 11 follows a whole circuit of the slide, from anxiety to turning to a smile to running back, so the structure mirrors the cycle of the game; - across the three paragraphs he changes from hesitant to eager and joyful.