Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/7

Narrative writing: story openings (Q5)

Practise 30 exam-style questions on Narrative writing: story openings (Q5) for AQA GCSE English Language (Paper 1). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 30 questions
  • 40 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

40 marks

A science fiction magazine is running a writing competition for students aged 14 to 16. The best entries will be published on its website.

Write the opening part of a story set on board a spaceship that has been travelling between the stars for three hundred years.

(24 marks for content and organisation
16 marks for technical accuracy)

Model answer

On the morning the sky breaks, Juno Arkady is on her knees in Seed Bay Four, counting beans.

She counts them every morning: one hundred broad beans in the left tray, one hundred in the right, each one pressed into the grey growing gel with the tip of her little finger. It is her job, as it was her mother's job, and her grandmother's before that. The Long Patience has been travelling between the stars for three hundred years, and in all that time nobody on board has ever been allowed to waste a seed.

'Day one hundred and nine thousand, five hundred and seventy-four,' says the Captain's voice from the speakers, warm and slow, the way it says it every morning. 'All systems normal. Distance to New Haven: eighty-one years. Be patient. Be grateful. Be kind.'

'Be patient, be grateful, be kind,' Juno murmurs with everyone else on the deck, without thinking about it. Eighty-one years. She will be ninety-six when the ship arrives. If she is lucky, someone will wheel her to a window and she will see a real planet before she dies. Her children will walk on it. Her grandchildren will forget there was ever a ship at all.

She presses in bean number sixty-three.

Above her, the sky is doing what it always does at this hour: shading from the soft grey of dawn into the clean, cloudless blue of the Commons ceiling. It is a beautiful sky. Juno has looked at it every day of her life. She knows it is not real - that it is light, played across a curved white panel forty metres above the crops, so that the people of the Long Patience will not go mad from looking at metal - but she has never minded. A painted sky is still a sky. It still turns pink at Evening Bell. It still has stars at night, the right stars, the ones the ship is sailing through.

Bean sixty-four. Sixty-five.

Then the sky flickers.

It is so quick that she thinks at first she has blinked. A stutter, like a held breath. Around the bay, a few heads lift from the trays. Old Pell, who has worked in Seed Bay Four since before Juno was born, straightens slowly, one hand pressed to the small of his back.

The sky flickers again - and this time it goes out.

For one long second the ceiling is dark. Not black: dark, grey, wet, and moving. Juno stares upwards with a bean pinched between her fingers. Something is running down the panel in long, shivering lines. Something is beating against it, softly, with a sound she has never heard in her life but somehow knows, the way you might know a word in a language your ancestors spoke.

Then the blue snaps back. Clean, cloudless, perfect. The Captain's voice says, 'Minor display fault. Please continue with your duties,' and the heads in the bay bend back to the trays one by one, like flowers closing.

Juno doesn't move.

'Pell,' she whispers. 'Did you see it?'

The old man does not look at her. He is looking at his hands, which are shaking. 'See what?' he says.

But his voice is wrong, and when at last he lifts his eyes to hers, she sees that he is afraid - not surprised, but afraid, the way people are when something they have spent a lifetime not saying is suddenly very close to being said.

Juno looks up at the perfect sky. She thinks of the long, shivering lines and the soft, insistent drumming, and the word for it rises in her throat from some deep place that three hundred years of travelling should have emptied.

Rain.

Somewhere above the ceiling of the world, it is raining.

Explanation

This opening reaches the top band because it builds a convincing world through small, controlled details - the bean count, the Captain's motto, the painted sky - instead of paragraphs of explanation. The disruption is brief and precisely described, another character's fear deepens it, and the single-word paragraph and closing line turn the whole premise of the story upside down. Common pitfalls are opening with a block of technical explanation, rushing to an alien attack or an arrival, and inventing terms that are never made clear.

Mark scheme
  1. 24 marks

    Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation).
    Level 4 (19-24 marks): Compelling, convincing communication. Upper (22-24): convincing and compelling; tone, style and register assuredly matched to purpose and audience; extensive, ambitious vocabulary, sustained crafting of devices; varied, inventive structure; convincing, complex ideas; fluent paragraphs, seamless discourse markers. Lower (19-21): convincing; register convincingly matched; extensive vocabulary, conscious crafting of devices; varied, effective structure; highly engaging, developed complex ideas; consistently coherent paragraphs.
    Level 3 (13-18 marks): Consistent, clear communication. Upper (16-18): consistently clear; tone, style and register consistently matched; increasingly sophisticated vocabulary, successful devices; effective structure; engaging, connected ideas; coherent paragraphs, integrated discourse markers. Lower (13-15): generally clear; register generally matched; vocabulary chosen for effect, appropriate devices; usually effective structure; connected ideas; usually coherent paragraphs.
    Level 2 (7-12 marks): Some successful communication. Upper (10-12): some sustained success; sustained attempt to match tone, style and register; conscious vocabulary, some devices; some structural features; increasingly varied linked ideas; some paragraphs and discourse markers. Lower (7-9): some success; attempts to match register; begins to vary vocabulary; attempts structural features; some linked ideas; attempts paragraphs.
    Level 1 (1-6 marks): Simple, limited communication. Upper (4-6): communicates simply; simple awareness of tone and register; simple vocabulary and devices; simple structural features; one or two ideas, simply linked; random paragraphing. Lower (1-3): limited communication; occasional sense of register; simple vocabulary; little or no structure; one or two unlinked ideas; no paragraphs.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): purpose: to open a story - to establish character, setting and situation and make readers want to read on; audience: readers and judges of a science fiction competition aged 14 to 16, who will want an imaginative but believable world; form: the opening part of a narrative, in paragraphs, with a consistent narrative voice. Ideas a strong response might develop: what life is like for people who have never known anything but the ship (routines, rules, mottos, jobs passed down the generations); a character whose ordinary day is interrupted; the ship's world revealed through detail rather than explanation (an artificial sky, recycled water, a countdown to arrival, a wall of names); a disturbing hint that the ship, or its purpose, is not what everyone has been told. Structures: in medias res during a routine task; a slow build of normality followed by a sudden disruption; repetition of a ritual phrase or a count; a narrowing focus on one moment; reactions of other characters that deepen the mystery; a final line that reveals a single unsettling truth. Techniques: precise, invented but consistent vocabulary; contrast between the controlled environment and something natural; symbolism (seeds, sky, windows); varied sentence lengths and one-word paragraphs for impact. An opening need not explain the mystery; a response that races through the whole plot (the voyage, the discovery, the arrival) in a few paragraphs, or that front-loads the opening with explanation of the technology, is limited, because events and ideas are told rather than developed and crafted.

  2. 16 marks

    Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
    Level 4 (13-16 marks): sentence demarcation consistently secure and consistently accurate; a wide range of punctuation used with a high level of accuracy; a full range of appropriate sentence forms for effect; Standard English used consistently and appropriately, with secure control of complex grammatical structures; a high level of accuracy in spelling, including ambitious vocabulary; extensive and ambitious vocabulary.
    Level 3 (9-12 marks): sentence demarcation mostly secure and mostly accurate; a range of punctuation, mostly used with success; a variety of sentence forms for effect; Standard English mostly used appropriately, with mostly controlled grammatical structures; generally accurate spelling, including complex and irregular words; increasingly sophisticated vocabulary.
    Level 2 (5-8 marks): sentence demarcation mostly secure and sometimes accurate; some control of a range of punctuation; attempts a variety of sentence forms; some use of Standard English, with some control of agreement; some accurate spelling of more complex words; varied vocabulary.
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): occasional sentence demarcation; some evidence of conscious punctuation; a simple range of sentence forms; occasional use of Standard English, with limited control of agreement; accurate basic spelling; simple vocabulary.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): technical accuracy is judged across the whole response: secure sentence demarcation; a wide range of punctuation used accurately, including dialogue and announcements in inverted commas, colons and semi-colons, dashes and parenthetical commas for embedded explanation; a full range of sentence forms for effect, including single-word sentences used deliberately; Standard English and secure grammar, including a sustained tense (present or past) and controlled shifts into the future or the past when characters think about arrival or history; invented names and terms spelled and capitalised consistently; numbers handled consistently (in words or figures); a high level of accuracy in spelling, including ambitious vocabulary (for example 'atmosphere', 'artificial', 'environment', 'generation', 'occurred'); extensive and precise vocabulary. A response with nothing meaningful to assess scores 0 on both points.

Question 2

40 marks

A website for young writers is running a ghost story competition. The entries will be judged by readers aged 14 to 16.

Write the opening part of a story in which a student on a school trip to a castle keeps seeing a girl that nobody else can see.

(24 marks for content and organisation
16 marks for technical accuracy)

Model answer

Nobody warns you, when you sign the permission slip, that the school trip might be the last normal day of your life.

It started badly, but in the usual ways. The coach smelled of crisps and somebody's mum's perfume. Callum Reid was sick into a carrier bag before we were even off the motorway. Mr Dutta stood at the front in his special trip fleece, the bright blue one that makes him look like a lifeboat, and reminded us six times that Harrowcliff Castle was 'a site of enormous historical significance' and not a climbing frame.

It was raining when we got there. Of course it was. Harrowcliff is the kind of castle that looks as if it has been rained on for eight hundred years: a jagged grey ruin on a hill above the river, all broken towers and arrow slits and walls with nothing behind them, like a stage set someone forgot to finish. A guide in a velvet tunic and a floppy hat met us at the gatehouse. He told us his name was Master Thomas and that he would be leading us through 'the turbulent history of this mighty fortress'. Lily Okafor said, quite loudly, that she would rather be dead, and everyone laughed, and Mr Dutta gave her the look.

That was when I first saw the girl.

She was standing on top of the north tower. Right on the top, where the stairs had fallen away and the stone ended in a ragged edge against the sky. She was about my age, maybe younger, in a long grey dress that hung straight down as if it were soaked through, and she was looking down into the courtyard. At us. At me.

I assumed she was part of the show - one of those actors they hire to make history come alive. I even nudged Lily and said, 'Bet she's freezing up there.'

Lily looked up. Then she looked at me.

'Who?' she said.

I looked back at the tower. The girl was still there. She hadn't moved at all. The rain was driving sideways across the courtyard, flattening everyone's hair, bending the long grass; but her dress didn't stir, and her hair, which was long and dark, didn't lift.

'Her,' I said. 'On the tower. In grey.'

Lily squinted. 'Jas, there's nobody there.'

I laughed, because I thought she was winding me up. And then I stopped laughing, because she wasn't.

I saw the girl four more times that afternoon. In the window of the Great Hall, which has no floor and no roof, only a long drop to the cellars. In the doorway of the chapel. At the far end of the wall walk, standing quite still while Master Thomas told us about the siege, and how the defenders had starved. And once - the worst time - right beside the coach in the car park, close enough to touch, her face pale and solemn and her eyes fixed on mine, while thirty people walked past her talking about chips.

Nobody else saw her. I asked. I asked until Callum started calling me Ghost Girl, and Mr Dutta asked if I was feeling all right, and I said yes, because what else do you say?

At four o'clock we climbed back onto the coach. I took a seat near the front this time, as far as possible from the back window. I didn't look out. I kept my eyes on my phone and my headphones in and my heart going like a drum, and I told myself that it was over. We were leaving. Whatever she was, she belonged to the castle, and the castle was staying where it was.

Mr Dutta walked down the aisle, counting heads, his pen tapping the clipboard. He did it twice. Then he stood at the front, frowning.

'That's odd,' he said, to nobody in particular. 'I make it thirty-one.'

There are thirty of us in 10C.

Explanation

This opening reaches the top band because the comic, realistic voice of the school trip makes the uncanny details stand out: the girl's dress does not move in the wind, and nobody else can see her. Each sighting escalates, the narrator becomes increasingly isolated, and the final head count delivers a twist that brings the ghost out of the castle in one short line. Common pitfalls are opening with a long list of who sat where on the coach, explaining the ghost's history through a convenient guide, and ending with the ghost vanishing so that there is nothing left to read on for.

Mark scheme
  1. 24 marks

    Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation).
    Level 4 (19-24 marks): Compelling, convincing communication. Upper (22-24): convincing and compelling; tone, style and register assuredly matched to purpose and audience; extensive, ambitious vocabulary, sustained crafting of devices; varied, inventive structure; convincing, complex ideas; fluent paragraphs, seamless discourse markers. Lower (19-21): convincing; register convincingly matched; extensive vocabulary, conscious crafting of devices; varied, effective structure; highly engaging, developed complex ideas; consistently coherent paragraphs.
    Level 3 (13-18 marks): Consistent, clear communication. Upper (16-18): consistently clear; tone, style and register consistently matched; increasingly sophisticated vocabulary, successful devices; effective structure; engaging, connected ideas; coherent paragraphs, integrated discourse markers. Lower (13-15): generally clear; register generally matched; vocabulary chosen for effect, appropriate devices; usually effective structure; connected ideas; usually coherent paragraphs.
    Level 2 (7-12 marks): Some successful communication. Upper (10-12): some sustained success; sustained attempt to match tone, style and register; conscious vocabulary, some devices; some structural features; increasingly varied linked ideas; some paragraphs and discourse markers. Lower (7-9): some success; attempts to match register; begins to vary vocabulary; attempts structural features; some linked ideas; attempts paragraphs.
    Level 1 (1-6 marks): Simple, limited communication. Upper (4-6): communicates simply; simple awareness of tone and register; simple vocabulary and devices; simple structural features; one or two ideas, simply linked; random paragraphing. Lower (1-3): limited communication; occasional sense of register; simple vocabulary; little or no structure; one or two unlinked ideas; no paragraphs.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): purpose: to open a story - to establish character, setting and situation and make readers want to read on; audience: readers aged 14 to 16 judging a ghost story competition, who will respond to a believable teenage voice; form: the opening part of a narrative, in paragraphs, with a consistent narrative voice. Ideas a strong response might develop: the realistic, often comic texture of a school trip (the coach, the teacher, a costumed guide, friends) as a contrast to the uncanny; the castle's history hinted at (a siege, a fall, a lost child); the girl's appearances, each more unsettling than the last; the narrator's growing isolation as nobody believes them; a sign that the girl is following them away from the castle. Structures: a humorous opening that makes the shift to fear more effective; repetition of the sightings with escalation; a single question or reaction as a turning point; a final line or twist that brings the ghost out of the castle. Techniques: dialogue with distinct voices; precise physical details that mark the girl as wrong (her clothes or hair unaffected by wind and rain); irony; a short final paragraph for impact. An opening need not explain who the girl is; a response that races through the whole plot (the trip, the ghost, the explanation, the ending) in a few paragraphs is limited, because events are told rather than developed and crafted.

  2. 16 marks

    Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
    Level 4 (13-16 marks): sentence demarcation consistently secure and consistently accurate; a wide range of punctuation used with a high level of accuracy; a full range of appropriate sentence forms for effect; Standard English used consistently and appropriately, with secure control of complex grammatical structures; a high level of accuracy in spelling, including ambitious vocabulary; extensive and ambitious vocabulary.
    Level 3 (9-12 marks): sentence demarcation mostly secure and mostly accurate; a range of punctuation, mostly used with success; a variety of sentence forms for effect; Standard English mostly used appropriately, with mostly controlled grammatical structures; generally accurate spelling, including complex and irregular words; increasingly sophisticated vocabulary.
    Level 2 (5-8 marks): sentence demarcation mostly secure and sometimes accurate; some control of a range of punctuation; attempts a variety of sentence forms; some use of Standard English, with some control of agreement; some accurate spelling of more complex words; varied vocabulary.
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): occasional sentence demarcation; some evidence of conscious punctuation; a simple range of sentence forms; occasional use of Standard English, with limited control of agreement; accurate basic spelling; simple vocabulary.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): technical accuracy is judged across the whole response: secure sentence demarcation; a wide range of punctuation used accurately, including dialogue from several characters, phrases quoted within the narration, question marks, dashes and semi-colons, and apostrophes; a full range of sentence forms for effect; Standard English and secure grammar in the narration (an informal teenage voice is credited when grammar and agreement remain controlled), with a consistent past tense; a high level of accuracy in spelling, including ambitious vocabulary (for example 'permission', 'significance', 'turbulent', 'siege', 'solemn', 'believe'); extensive and precise vocabulary. A response with nothing meaningful to assess scores 0 on both points.

Question 3

40 marks

Your local library is running a crime-writing competition for teenagers. The winning stories will be printed in a booklet.

Write the opening part of a story about a detective who is called to a locked room in a country hotel that has been cut off by snow.

(24 marks for content and organisation
16 marks for technical accuracy)

Model answer

The tractor dropped Detective Inspector Ruth Okonjo at the gates of Greyfell House at a quarter to eight in the morning, and drove away before she had finished saying thank you.

She didn't blame the farmer. The snow had been falling for two days and two nights, and the hills had disappeared under it as completely as if someone had pulled a white sheet over them. No car had reached Greyfell since Thursday. The phone lines were down. The only signal for miles came from a single bar of mobile reception on the hotel's top landing, which was how the manager had managed to call the police at all, at four o'clock that morning, in a voice so calm and so precise that Ruth had known at once that something was very wrong.

She waded up the long drive, snow to her knees, her breath smoking. Greyfell House rose ahead of her out of the white: a grim grey Victorian mansion with too many chimneys and narrow windows that seemed to watch her coming. Every one of them was lit.

The manager met her at the door. His name was Mr Fennimore: a thin man in a waistcoat, with a face the colour of porridge.

'Inspector. Thank you for coming. We have not touched anything. I made sure that nobody touched anything.'

'Who's missing?'

'Mr Aldous Crane. Room Eleven - the Blue Room.' He swallowed. 'He rang for tea at midnight. When the maid took it up, there was no answer. The door was locked from the inside, Inspector. The key was still in the lock; we could see it through the keyhole. In the end we had to take the door off its hinges.'

'And?'

'And he was not there.'

The Blue Room was at the end of a long, creaking corridor on the second floor. Ruth stood in the doorway for a long time before she went in, the way she had been taught, letting the room tell her what it wanted to tell her.

It was a large room, cold and very tidy. A four-poster bed, its covers turned back, a dent still in the pillow. A suitcase on the stand, half unpacked: three white shirts, folded with precision. On the bedside table, a cup of tea, untouched, with a skin on it. Beside it lay a paperback, open and face down, its spine cracked: a detective novel. Somebody's idea of a joke, she thought, and then wondered whose.

The door had been locked from the inside. The key lay on the carpet where it had fallen when the door was lifted away. The only other way out was the window, and the window was frozen shut, sealed with a thick crust of ice that had clearly not been disturbed for days. Beyond it, two floors down, the lawn stretched away towards the woods, smooth and white and perfect.

Ruth crossed the room and pressed her forehead to the cold glass, cupping her hands around her eyes.

Not quite perfect.

A line of footprints ran across the snow below. A single line of a man's prints, deep and evenly spaced. She followed them with her eyes from the edge of the woods, across the lawn, all the way to the wall of the hotel directly beneath the window of the Blue Room, where they simply stopped.

For a moment she didn't understand what was bothering her. Then she did, and the back of her neck went cold.

The prints didn't start at the hotel and lead away into the woods, the way an escaping man's would.

They started in the woods. And they led towards the house.

Explanation

This opening reaches the top band because it mirrors the detective's method: the focus narrows from the buried landscape to the house, the room and finally a single line of footprints, and each clue is precise enough for the reader to puzzle over alongside her. Small details - the untouched tea, the three folded shirts, the detective novel - suggest character and possibility, and the final reversal deepens the mystery instead of solving it. Common pitfalls are rushing to a gory discovery, having the detective explain everything in a speech, and solving the crime by the end of the opening.

Mark scheme
  1. 24 marks

    Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation).
    Level 4 (19-24 marks): Compelling, convincing communication. Upper (22-24): convincing and compelling; tone, style and register assuredly matched to purpose and audience; extensive, ambitious vocabulary, sustained crafting of devices; varied, inventive structure; convincing, complex ideas; fluent paragraphs, seamless discourse markers. Lower (19-21): convincing; register convincingly matched; extensive vocabulary, conscious crafting of devices; varied, effective structure; highly engaging, developed complex ideas; consistently coherent paragraphs.
    Level 3 (13-18 marks): Consistent, clear communication. Upper (16-18): consistently clear; tone, style and register consistently matched; increasingly sophisticated vocabulary, successful devices; effective structure; engaging, connected ideas; coherent paragraphs, integrated discourse markers. Lower (13-15): generally clear; register generally matched; vocabulary chosen for effect, appropriate devices; usually effective structure; connected ideas; usually coherent paragraphs.
    Level 2 (7-12 marks): Some successful communication. Upper (10-12): some sustained success; sustained attempt to match tone, style and register; conscious vocabulary, some devices; some structural features; increasingly varied linked ideas; some paragraphs and discourse markers. Lower (7-9): some success; attempts to match register; begins to vary vocabulary; attempts structural features; some linked ideas; attempts paragraphs.
    Level 1 (1-6 marks): Simple, limited communication. Upper (4-6): communicates simply; simple awareness of tone and register; simple vocabulary and devices; simple structural features; one or two ideas, simply linked; random paragraphing. Lower (1-3): limited communication; occasional sense of register; simple vocabulary; little or no structure; one or two unlinked ideas; no paragraphs.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): purpose: to open a story - to establish character, setting and situation and make readers want to read on; audience: teenage readers of a crime-writing booklet, who will enjoy a puzzle; form: the opening part of a narrative, in paragraphs, with a consistent narrative voice. Ideas a strong response might develop: the isolated setting that seals in the suspects (snow, cut-off phones, a remote house); a detective with a distinct personality and method; the locked room itself, presented as a set of precise clues (the key in the lock, a frozen window, objects left behind); other characters glimpsed as possible witnesses or suspects; a detail that does not fit. Structures: a methodical build-up that mirrors the detective's thinking; a narrowing focus from the landscape to the house to the room to a single clue; a final reversal that deepens the puzzle. Techniques: pathetic fallacy; precise, observational detail; dialogue that characterises (for example a manager's careful formality); short sentences at moments of realisation; foreshadowing. Violence need not be shown: a disappearance or a theft can be as gripping as a body. An opening need not solve the crime; a response that races through the investigation and the solution in a few paragraphs is limited, because events are told rather than developed and crafted.

  2. 16 marks

    Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
    Level 4 (13-16 marks): sentence demarcation consistently secure and consistently accurate; a wide range of punctuation used with a high level of accuracy; a full range of appropriate sentence forms for effect; Standard English used consistently and appropriately, with secure control of complex grammatical structures; a high level of accuracy in spelling, including ambitious vocabulary; extensive and ambitious vocabulary.
    Level 3 (9-12 marks): sentence demarcation mostly secure and mostly accurate; a range of punctuation, mostly used with success; a variety of sentence forms for effect; Standard English mostly used appropriately, with mostly controlled grammatical structures; generally accurate spelling, including complex and irregular words; increasingly sophisticated vocabulary.
    Level 2 (5-8 marks): sentence demarcation mostly secure and sometimes accurate; some control of a range of punctuation; attempts a variety of sentence forms; some use of Standard English, with some control of agreement; some accurate spelling of more complex words; varied vocabulary.
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): occasional sentence demarcation; some evidence of conscious punctuation; a simple range of sentence forms; occasional use of Standard English, with limited control of agreement; accurate basic spelling; simple vocabulary.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): technical accuracy is judged across the whole response: secure sentence demarcation; a wide range of punctuation used accurately, including dialogue between characters of different status, dashes for interruption, colons introducing lists of clues, semi-colons and apostrophes; a full range of sentence forms for effect; Standard English and secure grammar, including a consistent past tense with the past perfect for events before the detective arrives; titles and names capitalised consistently (Detective Inspector, the Blue Room); a high level of accuracy in spelling, including ambitious vocabulary (for example 'Inspector', 'Victorian', 'precision', 'disappeared', 'hinges', 'disturbed'); extensive and precise vocabulary. A response with nothing meaningful to assess scores 0 on both points.

Question 4

40 marks

Your school is running a short story competition. This year's theme is 'Survival'.

Write the opening part of a story in which a group of friends exploring a cave are cut off when floodwater blocks the way out.

(24 marks for content and organisation
16 marks for technical accuracy)

Model answer

The first thing I noticed was the sound.

We had been underground for nearly three hours by then, Callum, Amira and me, and I had got used to the noises of the cave: the drip of water from the roof, the scrape of our helmets on the rock, the echo of our own voices coming back to us strange and hollow, as if the hill were repeating everything we said to check that it had heard properly. Somewhere far below, there was always the stream, a faint, steady chuckle in the dark.

But now the chuckle had changed. It was louder. Deeper. It sounded less like laughter and more like a crowd.

'Can you hear that?' I said.

Amira was crouched at the edge of the pool in the Cathedral - the huge chamber we had been aiming for all morning - with her head torch tilted up at the roof, where the stalactites hung down in thousands, thin and white, like rain that had frozen halfway to the ground. 'Hear what?'

'The stream.'

She listened. Her face changed.

Callum was already moving. He's the one who knows caves: his dad was in cave rescue for twenty years, and Callum has been going down the big Dales systems since he was eight. He doesn't panic. That was why it frightened me so much to see him run.

'Back,' he said. 'Back to the Letterbox. Now. Leave the bags.'

We left the bags.

I don't remember much about the next ten minutes. I remember the beam of my head torch jerking over wet rock, my breath roaring in my ears, my knees slamming into stone. I remember Amira slipping on the slope above the stream and Callum grabbing her by the strap of her harness. I remember the noise growing behind us, filling the passage, a great brown roar of water coming down from somewhere above - from the moor, from the summer storm that the forecast had promised wouldn't arrive until the evening.

And I remember the Letterbox.

It's the only way in or out of Dowker's Hole: a crawl about ten metres long, low and flat, where the roof comes down so close to the floor that you have to lie on your stomach and push yourself along with your toes, your helmet scraping, your cheek against the cold mud. On the way in, there had been a hand's width of gravel and a trickle of water along the bottom. We had laughed at how small it was. Amira had called it the Letterbox, and the name had stuck, because we were going to post ourselves through it.

When we reached it, the water was already halfway to the roof.

We stood there in the dark, the three of us, with the noise of the flood behind us and the black water in front of us, sliding into the crawl in a smooth, fat, unstoppable tongue. My head torch picked out bits of bracken and froth swirling on the surface. The air in the passage was moving too, pushing past us, cold and fast, into the crawl.

'How long?' Amira said. Her voice was very calm, which is how I knew how scared she was. 'Callum. How long would it take to swim it?'

'You can't swim it. It's too low. You'd get stuck.' Callum was staring at the water. 'You'd have to dive it. Ten metres. In the dark. With no air at the other end, if that side's flooded too.'

'Then what do we do?'

He didn't answer. He took off his glove and laid his hand flat against the rock above the Letterbox, as if he could feel the hill thinking.

'We go back up,' he said at last. 'To the Cathedral. The roof's high there. There'll be air.'

'For how long?'

Again he didn't answer. And in the silence, as we watched, the water touched the roof of the Letterbox, and the last pocket of air beyond it disappeared with a small, polite gulp, like someone swallowing a secret.

Explanation

This opening reaches the top band because it builds danger from a single change in sound, so the reader senses the threat before the characters fully understand it. The calm detail of the cave gives way to a fast, fragmented escape, the naming of the Letterbox is set up early and pays off at the climax, and the final simile seals the friends in with chilling understatement. Common pitfalls are describing the whole caving trip before anything happens, losing control of the action sequence, and rescuing the characters within the opening.

Mark scheme
  1. 24 marks

    Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation).
    Level 4 (19-24 marks): Compelling, convincing communication. Upper (22-24): convincing and compelling; tone, style and register assuredly matched to purpose and audience; extensive, ambitious vocabulary, sustained crafting of devices; varied, inventive structure; convincing, complex ideas; fluent paragraphs, seamless discourse markers. Lower (19-21): convincing; register convincingly matched; extensive vocabulary, conscious crafting of devices; varied, effective structure; highly engaging, developed complex ideas; consistently coherent paragraphs.
    Level 3 (13-18 marks): Consistent, clear communication. Upper (16-18): consistently clear; tone, style and register consistently matched; increasingly sophisticated vocabulary, successful devices; effective structure; engaging, connected ideas; coherent paragraphs, integrated discourse markers. Lower (13-15): generally clear; register generally matched; vocabulary chosen for effect, appropriate devices; usually effective structure; connected ideas; usually coherent paragraphs.
    Level 2 (7-12 marks): Some successful communication. Upper (10-12): some sustained success; sustained attempt to match tone, style and register; conscious vocabulary, some devices; some structural features; increasingly varied linked ideas; some paragraphs and discourse markers. Lower (7-9): some success; attempts to match register; begins to vary vocabulary; attempts structural features; some linked ideas; attempts paragraphs.
    Level 1 (1-6 marks): Simple, limited communication. Upper (4-6): communicates simply; simple awareness of tone and register; simple vocabulary and devices; simple structural features; one or two ideas, simply linked; random paragraphing. Lower (1-3): limited communication; occasional sense of register; simple vocabulary; little or no structure; one or two unlinked ideas; no paragraphs.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): purpose: to open a story - to establish character, setting and situation and make readers want to read on; audience: students and judges of a school short story competition on the theme of survival; form: the opening part of a narrative, in paragraphs, with a consistent narrative voice. Ideas a strong response might develop: the cave and the group (experience, roles, relationships, who is in charge); the first sign of danger (a change in sound, rising water, moving air, a forecast ignored); the race back towards the exit; the moment of being cut off; a choice about what to do next. Structures: a first line that focuses on a single sense; a calm, detailed build-up that is suddenly broken; a fast, fragmented sequence for the escape; a pause at the flooded exit; a final image that seals the characters in. Techniques: sound imagery; personification of the cave or the water; precise details of caving (helmets, head torches, crawls, chambers); dialogue that shows fear through forced calm; a strong final simile or metaphor. An opening need not show the rescue or the outcome; a response that races through the whole plot (exploring, flooding, escape, rescue) in a few paragraphs is limited, because events are told rather than developed and crafted.

  2. 16 marks

    Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy).
    Level 4 (13-16 marks): sentence demarcation consistently secure and consistently accurate; a wide range of punctuation used with a high level of accuracy; a full range of appropriate sentence forms for effect; Standard English used consistently and appropriately, with secure control of complex grammatical structures; a high level of accuracy in spelling, including ambitious vocabulary; extensive and ambitious vocabulary.
    Level 3 (9-12 marks): sentence demarcation mostly secure and mostly accurate; a range of punctuation, mostly used with success; a variety of sentence forms for effect; Standard English mostly used appropriately, with mostly controlled grammatical structures; generally accurate spelling, including complex and irregular words; increasingly sophisticated vocabulary.
    Level 2 (5-8 marks): sentence demarcation mostly secure and sometimes accurate; some control of a range of punctuation; attempts a variety of sentence forms; some use of Standard English, with some control of agreement; some accurate spelling of more complex words; varied vocabulary.
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): occasional sentence demarcation; some evidence of conscious punctuation; a simple range of sentence forms; occasional use of Standard English, with limited control of agreement; accurate basic spelling; simple vocabulary.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): technical accuracy is judged across the whole response: secure sentence demarcation, even in the fast-paced escape; a wide range of punctuation used accurately, including clipped, tense dialogue, dashes for interruption, colons, semi-colons and apostrophes; a full range of sentence forms for effect, including a deliberate sequence of repeated openings ('I remember ...'); Standard English and secure grammar, including a consistent past tense with the past perfect for earlier events; a high level of accuracy in spelling, including ambitious vocabulary (for example 'stalactites', 'chamber', 'harness', 'echo', 'forecast', 'unstoppable'); extensive and precise vocabulary. A response with nothing meaningful to assess scores 0 on both points.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.