Question 1
20 marksRead the following extract, then answer the question at the end.
The Last Sailing
by Eilidh Munro (fictional)
This extract is from the opening of a novel set in the 1990s. Fourteen-year-old Shona is travelling alone from Glasgow to live with her grandmother on a small island in the Hebrides, off the west coast of Scotland.
[1] The last ferry of the night left Oban at twenty to nine, and by the time it had cleared the harbour Shona had counted every passenger on board. There were two lorry drivers playing cards at a corner table, a man asleep under a newspaper, a woman knitting something long and grey, and a family of four eating chips out of paper with their fingers. And there was Shona herself, fourteen years old, with a rucksack between her feet and a holdall that held everything she had decided was worth bringing. The seats in the lounge were orange plastic, bolted to the floor in rows, and the whole room smelled of diesel and vinegar and wet coats.
[2] Her Walkman had died somewhere near Crianlarich, so she listened to the engines instead. They throbbed up through the soles of her trainers and into her knees. In one coat pocket was a phonecard with forty units left on it; in the other was her grandmother's letter, read so many times that it had gone soft at the folds, like cloth. It said the boat got in at half past eleven. It said Shona would be met. It said nothing else at all, because her grandmother did not believe in saying more than was needed.
[3] At ten o'clock she went up on deck. The wind had dropped, and the mainland was a string of lights behind them, small and yellow and steady, as if someone had left a necklace lying on a dark table. She watched it for a long time. Then, without any warning, the lights began to go out.
[4] The fog did not roll in, the way it did in films. It simply arrived, from everywhere at once, as though the air itself had thickened and turned pale. First the lights went, swallowed one by one. Then the white wake behind the ship softened and was gone. The rail under her hands grew beaded with cold, and the deck lamps hung in the murk like dandelion clocks, each one furred with its own small halo. The whole world shrank to a few yards of wet steel. Somewhere above her the foghorn sounded - one long note, so low and mournful that she felt it in her teeth - and from far away, out in the blankness, something answered.
[5] The engines slowed. The ship crept forward like someone feeling for a stair in the dark. Shona thought of Buchanan Street bus station that morning: her mother standing outside the window with the bright, fixed smile she had worn all week, one hand pressed flat against the glass until the bus began to move. It's only till Christmas, she had said. Maybe Easter. Shona had not waved back. She regretted it now, with the fog pressing damply against her face, and the regret sat in her chest like a stone she could not put down.
[6] 'First time over?'
[7] A deckhand in a yellow oilskin had come up beside her. He was old, with a beard like wire wool, and he did not seem to notice the fog at all.
[8] 'I came once before,' said Shona. 'When I was six.'
[9] 'You'll be Ishbel Morrison's granddaughter.' It was not a question. 'She's been in at the ferry office every day this week, asking was the boat running.'
[10] Shona stared at him. She could not imagine her grandmother asking anybody anything.
[11] The pier, when it came, came all at once: black timbers, a single lamp, a slipway glistening with weed. At the very end of it a torch beam was moving slowly from side to side, the way you might sweep a field for something you had lost. Behind the torch stood a small figure in a man's waxed jacket, much smaller than Shona remembered, holding herself very still.
[12] Her grandmother did not hug her. She took the holdall, weighed it in one hand, and said, 'You'll be cold.' Then she turned the torch onto the road ahead, so that Shona could see where to put her feet, and the two of them walked up from the harbour together into the fog, where there were no lights at all except the one they carried.
Focus this part of your answer on the second part of the source, from paragraph [4] to the end.
A student said, "In this part of the story, the fog makes Shona's journey feel frightening and lonely. By the end, though, the writer suggests that she is not as alone as she thinks."
To what extent do you agree?
In your response, you could:
- consider your own impressions of Shona's feelings during the crossing and her arrival
- evaluate how the writer presents the fog and Shona's arrival
- support your response with references to the text.
Model answer
I agree with much of this statement, but I would adjust both halves. The fog certainly isolates Shona, but I think it makes the journey eerie and sad rather than truly frightening; and while the ending does suggest she is not alone, Munro keeps that comfort understated, so the reader is left hopeful rather than fully reassured.
The fog's arrival is described as something uncanny. Munro begins by denying the reader's expectations: it "did not roll in, the way it did in films. It simply arrived, from everywhere at once". The plain verb "arrived" makes it seem deliberate, almost like a visitor, and the idea that the air had "thickened and turned pale" makes the whole world strange. The sequence of losses - the lights "swallowed one by one", the wake that "softened and was gone" - steadily strips away every connection to the mainland and her old life. The short sentence "The whole world shrank to a few yards of wet steel" is the heart of the loneliness: Shona's world is reduced to the cold rail under her hands.
However, I do not think it is purely frightening. The deck lamps "like dandelion clocks, each one furred with its own small halo" are delicate and almost beautiful, an image from childhood rather than horror. The foghorn, "so low and mournful that she felt it in her teeth", is more sad than threatening, and when "something answered" from the blankness, the effect is eerie but also suggests that even in the fog there is a call and a reply. That small exchange foreshadows the end.
The loneliness the reader feels most is emotional, not physical. The fog brings back her mother's "bright, fixed smile" and the hand "pressed flat against the glass". The adjective "fixed" suggests the smile was a mask, and the remembered words, "It's only till Christmas, she had said. Maybe Easter", show a promise already slipping. The simile "like a stone she could not put down" makes Shona's regret heavy and permanent. So the fog is less the cause of her loneliness than a mirror for it.
The second half of the statement is convincing. The deckhand's news that her grandmother has been "in at the ferry office every day this week, asking was the boat running" overturns Shona's view of her, and Munro gives her reaction its own paragraph: "She could not imagine her grandmother asking anybody anything." The torch beam moving "the way you might sweep a field for something you had lost" is the most moving simile in the passage, because it shows Shona is precious to someone. Yet the grandmother "did not hug her", says only "You'll be cold", and is "holding herself very still". Her love is shown in actions - taking the holdall, lighting the road "so that Shona could see where to put her feet" - rather than in words.
The final image balances both halves of the statement. They walk "into the fog, where there were no lights at all except the one they carried". The darkness is still there, but the light is now shared, which suggests that Shona is not alone, even though her new life remains uncertain.
Explanation
A Level 4 answer weighs each part of the statement: it might argue that the fog is eerie and mournful rather than frightening, that Shona's loneliness is really emotional, and that the grandmother's love is real but understated. It analyses how the writer's imagery (the dandelion clocks, the torch sweeping "for something you had lost"), short sentences and the final image of shared light shape the reader's response. Common pitfalls are drifting back to the ferry lounge or the mainland lights in paragraphs [1] to [3], which are outside the named part, and listing techniques without evaluating their effect.
Mark scheme
-
20 marks
Levels of response (20 marks). AO4 (critical evaluation).
Level 4 (16-20 marks): Perceptive, detailed evaluation: a convincing and critical response to the focus of the statement; perceptive understanding of the writer's methods; a range of judicious textual detail; evaluates critically and in detail the effect(s) on the reader.
Level 3 (11-15 marks): Clear, relevant evaluation: a clear and relevant response to the focus of the statement; clear understanding of the writer's methods; a range of relevant textual references; evaluates clearly the effect(s) on the reader.
Level 2 (6-10 marks): Some evaluation: some response to the focus of the statement; some understanding of the writer's methods; some appropriate textual reference(s); some evaluative comment(s) on the effect(s) on the reader.
Level 1 (1-5 marks): Simple, limited comment: a simple, limited response to the focus of the statement; limited understanding of the writer's methods; simple, limited textual reference(s); simple, limited evaluative comment(s) on the effect(s) on the reader.
0 marks: nothing to reward.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): A response, or a section of one, about events outside paragraphs [4] to [12] (e.g. the passengers in the lounge, the grandmother's letter or the mainland lights in paragraph [3]) can attain only Level 1 or Level 2 for that section; the rest of the response can attain any level. Reference to the writer's methods may be implicit, and so may 'I agree / I don't agree'. Points may include: the fog subverts expectation ("did not roll in, the way it did in films") and simply "arrived, from everywhere at once", which makes it uncanny and inescapable; the sequence of losses, the lights "swallowed one by one" and the wake "softened and was gone", cutting her off from the mainland (supports 'lonely'); the short sentence "The whole world shrank to a few yards of wet steel" - isolation and cold; the deck lamps "like dandelion clocks, each one furred with its own small halo" - delicate, even beautiful, which challenges 'frightening'; the foghorn "so low and mournful that she felt it in her teeth" and the moment when "something answered" - eerie, but also a call and answer that foreshadows her being met; the ship that "crept forward like someone feeling for a stair in the dark" - uncertainty; the memory of her mother's "bright, fixed smile" and hand "pressed flat against the glass", and the regret "like a stone she could not put down" - her loneliness is emotional more than caused by the fog; the deckhand's news that her grandmother had been "in at the ferry office every day this week, asking was the boat running", and Shona's disbelief, given its own paragraph - the turning point for the second part of the statement; the torch beam moving "the way you might sweep a field for something you had lost" - she is searched for and valued; the grandmother who "did not hug her" and says only "You'll be cold" - love shown through actions and understated, so some may argue the comfort is limited; the final image, walking "into the fog, where there were no lights at all except the one they carried" - the darkness remains, but the light is now shared. Level 4 responses respond convincingly to both parts (e.g. that the fog mirrors rather than causes Shona's loneliness, and that the ending offers understated rather than complete reassurance) with perceptive analysis of methods (imagery, sentence forms, the deckhand's revelation, the final image) and judicious, embedded references. Responses that mainly retell the crossing are unlikely to rise above Level 2.