Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/7

Fiction: evaluating a statement (Q4)

Practise 33 exam-style questions on Fiction: evaluating a statement (Q4) for AQA GCSE English Language (Paper 1). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 33 questions
  • 20 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

20 marks

Read the following extract, then answer the question at the end.

The Last Sailing
by Eilidh Munro (fictional)

This extract is from the opening of a novel set in the 1990s. Fourteen-year-old Shona is travelling alone from Glasgow to live with her grandmother on a small island in the Hebrides, off the west coast of Scotland.

[1] The last ferry of the night left Oban at twenty to nine, and by the time it had cleared the harbour Shona had counted every passenger on board. There were two lorry drivers playing cards at a corner table, a man asleep under a newspaper, a woman knitting something long and grey, and a family of four eating chips out of paper with their fingers. And there was Shona herself, fourteen years old, with a rucksack between her feet and a holdall that held everything she had decided was worth bringing. The seats in the lounge were orange plastic, bolted to the floor in rows, and the whole room smelled of diesel and vinegar and wet coats.

[2] Her Walkman had died somewhere near Crianlarich, so she listened to the engines instead. They throbbed up through the soles of her trainers and into her knees. In one coat pocket was a phonecard with forty units left on it; in the other was her grandmother's letter, read so many times that it had gone soft at the folds, like cloth. It said the boat got in at half past eleven. It said Shona would be met. It said nothing else at all, because her grandmother did not believe in saying more than was needed.

[3] At ten o'clock she went up on deck. The wind had dropped, and the mainland was a string of lights behind them, small and yellow and steady, as if someone had left a necklace lying on a dark table. She watched it for a long time. Then, without any warning, the lights began to go out.

[4] The fog did not roll in, the way it did in films. It simply arrived, from everywhere at once, as though the air itself had thickened and turned pale. First the lights went, swallowed one by one. Then the white wake behind the ship softened and was gone. The rail under her hands grew beaded with cold, and the deck lamps hung in the murk like dandelion clocks, each one furred with its own small halo. The whole world shrank to a few yards of wet steel. Somewhere above her the foghorn sounded - one long note, so low and mournful that she felt it in her teeth - and from far away, out in the blankness, something answered.

[5] The engines slowed. The ship crept forward like someone feeling for a stair in the dark. Shona thought of Buchanan Street bus station that morning: her mother standing outside the window with the bright, fixed smile she had worn all week, one hand pressed flat against the glass until the bus began to move. It's only till Christmas, she had said. Maybe Easter. Shona had not waved back. She regretted it now, with the fog pressing damply against her face, and the regret sat in her chest like a stone she could not put down.

[6] 'First time over?'

[7] A deckhand in a yellow oilskin had come up beside her. He was old, with a beard like wire wool, and he did not seem to notice the fog at all.

[8] 'I came once before,' said Shona. 'When I was six.'

[9] 'You'll be Ishbel Morrison's granddaughter.' It was not a question. 'She's been in at the ferry office every day this week, asking was the boat running.'

[10] Shona stared at him. She could not imagine her grandmother asking anybody anything.

[11] The pier, when it came, came all at once: black timbers, a single lamp, a slipway glistening with weed. At the very end of it a torch beam was moving slowly from side to side, the way you might sweep a field for something you had lost. Behind the torch stood a small figure in a man's waxed jacket, much smaller than Shona remembered, holding herself very still.

[12] Her grandmother did not hug her. She took the holdall, weighed it in one hand, and said, 'You'll be cold.' Then she turned the torch onto the road ahead, so that Shona could see where to put her feet, and the two of them walked up from the harbour together into the fog, where there were no lights at all except the one they carried.

Focus this part of your answer on the second part of the source, from paragraph [4] to the end.

A student said, "In this part of the story, the fog makes Shona's journey feel frightening and lonely. By the end, though, the writer suggests that she is not as alone as she thinks."

To what extent do you agree?

In your response, you could:
- consider your own impressions of Shona's feelings during the crossing and her arrival
- evaluate how the writer presents the fog and Shona's arrival
- support your response with references to the text.

Model answer

I agree with much of this statement, but I would adjust both halves. The fog certainly isolates Shona, but I think it makes the journey eerie and sad rather than truly frightening; and while the ending does suggest she is not alone, Munro keeps that comfort understated, so the reader is left hopeful rather than fully reassured.

The fog's arrival is described as something uncanny. Munro begins by denying the reader's expectations: it "did not roll in, the way it did in films. It simply arrived, from everywhere at once". The plain verb "arrived" makes it seem deliberate, almost like a visitor, and the idea that the air had "thickened and turned pale" makes the whole world strange. The sequence of losses - the lights "swallowed one by one", the wake that "softened and was gone" - steadily strips away every connection to the mainland and her old life. The short sentence "The whole world shrank to a few yards of wet steel" is the heart of the loneliness: Shona's world is reduced to the cold rail under her hands.

However, I do not think it is purely frightening. The deck lamps "like dandelion clocks, each one furred with its own small halo" are delicate and almost beautiful, an image from childhood rather than horror. The foghorn, "so low and mournful that she felt it in her teeth", is more sad than threatening, and when "something answered" from the blankness, the effect is eerie but also suggests that even in the fog there is a call and a reply. That small exchange foreshadows the end.

The loneliness the reader feels most is emotional, not physical. The fog brings back her mother's "bright, fixed smile" and the hand "pressed flat against the glass". The adjective "fixed" suggests the smile was a mask, and the remembered words, "It's only till Christmas, she had said. Maybe Easter", show a promise already slipping. The simile "like a stone she could not put down" makes Shona's regret heavy and permanent. So the fog is less the cause of her loneliness than a mirror for it.

The second half of the statement is convincing. The deckhand's news that her grandmother has been "in at the ferry office every day this week, asking was the boat running" overturns Shona's view of her, and Munro gives her reaction its own paragraph: "She could not imagine her grandmother asking anybody anything." The torch beam moving "the way you might sweep a field for something you had lost" is the most moving simile in the passage, because it shows Shona is precious to someone. Yet the grandmother "did not hug her", says only "You'll be cold", and is "holding herself very still". Her love is shown in actions - taking the holdall, lighting the road "so that Shona could see where to put her feet" - rather than in words.

The final image balances both halves of the statement. They walk "into the fog, where there were no lights at all except the one they carried". The darkness is still there, but the light is now shared, which suggests that Shona is not alone, even though her new life remains uncertain.

Explanation

A Level 4 answer weighs each part of the statement: it might argue that the fog is eerie and mournful rather than frightening, that Shona's loneliness is really emotional, and that the grandmother's love is real but understated. It analyses how the writer's imagery (the dandelion clocks, the torch sweeping "for something you had lost"), short sentences and the final image of shared light shape the reader's response. Common pitfalls are drifting back to the ferry lounge or the mainland lights in paragraphs [1] to [3], which are outside the named part, and listing techniques without evaluating their effect.

Mark scheme
  1. 20 marks

    Levels of response (20 marks). AO4 (critical evaluation).
    Level 4 (16-20 marks): Perceptive, detailed evaluation: a convincing and critical response to the focus of the statement; perceptive understanding of the writer's methods; a range of judicious textual detail; evaluates critically and in detail the effect(s) on the reader.
    Level 3 (11-15 marks): Clear, relevant evaluation: a clear and relevant response to the focus of the statement; clear understanding of the writer's methods; a range of relevant textual references; evaluates clearly the effect(s) on the reader.
    Level 2 (6-10 marks): Some evaluation: some response to the focus of the statement; some understanding of the writer's methods; some appropriate textual reference(s); some evaluative comment(s) on the effect(s) on the reader.
    Level 1 (1-5 marks): Simple, limited comment: a simple, limited response to the focus of the statement; limited understanding of the writer's methods; simple, limited textual reference(s); simple, limited evaluative comment(s) on the effect(s) on the reader.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): A response, or a section of one, about events outside paragraphs [4] to [12] (e.g. the passengers in the lounge, the grandmother's letter or the mainland lights in paragraph [3]) can attain only Level 1 or Level 2 for that section; the rest of the response can attain any level. Reference to the writer's methods may be implicit, and so may 'I agree / I don't agree'. Points may include: the fog subverts expectation ("did not roll in, the way it did in films") and simply "arrived, from everywhere at once", which makes it uncanny and inescapable; the sequence of losses, the lights "swallowed one by one" and the wake "softened and was gone", cutting her off from the mainland (supports 'lonely'); the short sentence "The whole world shrank to a few yards of wet steel" - isolation and cold; the deck lamps "like dandelion clocks, each one furred with its own small halo" - delicate, even beautiful, which challenges 'frightening'; the foghorn "so low and mournful that she felt it in her teeth" and the moment when "something answered" - eerie, but also a call and answer that foreshadows her being met; the ship that "crept forward like someone feeling for a stair in the dark" - uncertainty; the memory of her mother's "bright, fixed smile" and hand "pressed flat against the glass", and the regret "like a stone she could not put down" - her loneliness is emotional more than caused by the fog; the deckhand's news that her grandmother had been "in at the ferry office every day this week, asking was the boat running", and Shona's disbelief, given its own paragraph - the turning point for the second part of the statement; the torch beam moving "the way you might sweep a field for something you had lost" - she is searched for and valued; the grandmother who "did not hug her" and says only "You'll be cold" - love shown through actions and understated, so some may argue the comfort is limited; the final image, walking "into the fog, where there were no lights at all except the one they carried" - the darkness remains, but the light is now shared. Level 4 responses respond convincingly to both parts (e.g. that the fog mirrors rather than causes Shona's loneliness, and that the ending offers understated rather than complete reassurance) with perceptive analysis of methods (imagery, sentence forms, the deckhand's revelation, the final image) and judicious, embedded references. Responses that mainly retell the crossing are unlikely to rise above Level 2.

Question 2

20 marks

Read the following extract, then answer the question at the end.

White Fang
by Jack London (1906)

This extract is the opening of a novel by the American writer Jack London. It is set in the frozen wilderness of the far north-west of North America, in the depths of winter.

[1] Dark spruce forest frowned on either side the frozen waterway. The trees had been stripped by a recent wind of their white covering of frost, and they seemed to lean towards each other, black and ominous, in the fading light. A vast silence reigned over the land. The land itself was a desolation, lifeless, without movement, so lone and cold that the spirit of it was not even that of sadness. There was a hint in it of laughter, but of a laughter more terrible than any sadness - a laughter that was mirthless as the smile of the sphinx, a laughter cold as the frost and partaking of the grimness of infallibility. It was the masterful and incommunicable wisdom of eternity laughing at the futility of life and the effort of life. It was the Wild, the savage, frozen-hearted Northland Wild.

[2] But there was life, abroad in the land and defiant. Down the frozen waterway toiled a string of wolfish dogs. Their bristly fur was rimed with frost. Their breath froze in the air as it left their mouths, spouting forth in spumes of vapour that settled upon the hair of their bodies and formed into crystals of frost. Leather harness was on the dogs, and leather traces attached them to a sled which dragged along behind. The sled was without runners. It was made of stout birch-bark, and its full surface rested on the snow. The front end of the sled was turned up, like a scroll, in order to force down and under the bore of soft snow that surged like a wave before it. On the sled, securely lashed, was a long and narrow oblong box. There were other things on the sled - blankets, an axe, and a coffee-pot and frying-pan; but prominent, occupying most of the space, was the long and narrow oblong box.

[3] In advance of the dogs, on wide snowshoes, toiled a man. At the rear of the sled toiled a second man. On the sled, in the box, lay a third man whose toil was over, - a man whom the Wild had conquered and beaten down until he would never move nor struggle again. It is not the way of the Wild to like movement. Life is an offence to it, for life is movement; and the Wild aims always to destroy movement. It freezes the water to prevent it running to the sea; it drives the sap out of the trees till they are frozen to their mighty hearts; and most ferociously and terribly of all does the Wild harry and crush into submission man - man who is the most restless of life, ever in revolt against the dictum that all movement must in the end come to the cessation of movement.

[4] But at front and rear, unawed and indomitable, toiled the two men who were not yet dead. Their bodies were covered with fur and soft-tanned leather. Eyelashes and cheeks and lips were so coated with the crystals from their frozen breath that their faces were not discernible. This gave them the seeming of ghostly masques, undertakers in a spectral world at the funeral of some ghost. But under it all they were men, penetrating the land of desolation and mockery and silence, puny adventurers bent on colossal adventure, pitting themselves against the might of a world as remote and alien and pulseless as the abysses of space.

[5] They travelled on without speech, saving their breath for the work of their bodies. On every side was the silence, pressing upon them with a tangible presence. It affected their minds as the many atmospheres of deep water affect the body of the diver. It crushed them with the weight of unending vastness and unalterable decree. It crushed them into the remotest recesses of their own minds, pressing out of them, like juices from the grape, all the false ardours and exaltations and undue self-values of the human soul, until they perceived themselves finite and small, specks and motes, moving with weak cunning and little wisdom amidst the play and inter-play of the great blind elements and forces.

[6] An hour went by, and a second hour. The pale light of the short sunless day was beginning to fade, when a faint far cry arose on the still air. It soared upward with a swift rush, till it reached its topmost note, where it persisted, palpitant and tense, and then slowly died away. It might have been a lost soul wailing, had it not been invested with a certain sad fierceness and hungry eagerness. The front man turned his head until his eyes met the eyes of the man behind. And then, across the narrow oblong box, each nodded to the other.

Focus this part of your answer on the second part of the source, from paragraph [3] to the end.

A student said, "In this part of the story, the men seem completely powerless against the Wild. The writer makes the ending, when the cry is heard, the most frightening moment in the extract."

To what extent do you agree?

In your response, you could:
- consider your own impressions of the men and their situation
- evaluate how the writer presents the power of the Wild
- support your response with references to the text.

Model answer

I disagree with the first part of the statement more than the second. London certainly presents the Wild as overwhelmingly powerful, but he insists that the men are defiant, so "completely powerless" is too strong. The cry at the end is frightening, but I would argue that its power comes from how quietly the men respond to it, and that the most terrifying idea in the extract is the silence that crushes them before it.

The case for powerlessness is strong. The third man "whose toil was over" is revealed only after the verb "toiled" has been used for the two living men, so the box becomes a coffin in the reader's mind with a sudden chill. He is "a man whom the Wild had conquered and beaten down", and the capital letter and military verbs turn nature into a deliberate enemy. The shift into the present tense, "It is not the way of the Wild to like movement. Life is an offence to it", makes this sound like a law of the universe. The list that follows - freezing water, driving the sap from trees - builds to a climax on man, whom the Wild will "harry and crush into submission".

Yet the same sentence calls man "ever in revolt", and the next paragraph opens with a defiant "But": the two men are "unawed and indomitable". The phrase "not yet dead" is ominous, but "But under it all they were men" is an assertion of human dignity. The antithesis "puny adventurers bent on colossal adventure" captures the balance perfectly: they are tiny, but their courage is enormous. So the reader admires them rather than simply pitying them.

The fifth paragraph is where they come closest to powerlessness, and for me it is the most frightening section. The silence presses on them "with a tangible presence", and the simile of "the many atmospheres of deep water" on "the body of the diver" makes it a physical weight. The repetition of "It crushed them", and the image of their pride being pressed out "like juices from the grape" until they are "specks and motes", is relentless. This is a horror of insignificance, more disturbing than any physical threat.

The ending is frightening in a different, sharper way. After the flat, monotonous "An hour went by, and a second hour", the "faint far cry" breaks the silence. The long sentence that follows - the cry "soared upward with a swift rush", then "persisted, palpitant and tense, and then slowly died away" - mimics the shape of the howl. London first offers a ghostly comparison, a "lost soul wailing", then corrects it: the cry has "a certain sad fierceness and hungry eagerness". The word "hungry" turns a ghost into a predator, and the reader realises the men are being hunted.

What makes the ending chilling is its restraint. The men do not speak; "each nodded to the other" "across the narrow oblong box". The repeated box reminds us of the dead man between them, and the silent nod suggests that they already know what the cry means. So I agree that the ending is deeply frightening, but the men's grim composure also shows that, even here, they are not completely powerless.

Explanation

A Level 4 answer tests 'completely powerless' against the writer's insistence that the men are "unawed and indomitable", and weighs the ending against the crushing silence of paragraph [5] before deciding what is most frightening. It analyses methods such as personification of the Wild, repetition, antithesis, the long sentence that mimics the cry and the understated nod across the coffin, and evaluates their effect on the reader. Common pitfalls are writing about the forest and the laughing Wild in paragraph [1], which is outside the named part, and agreeing with both parts without weighing the evidence.

Mark scheme
  1. 20 marks

    Levels of response (20 marks). AO4 (critical evaluation).
    Level 4 (16-20 marks): Perceptive, detailed evaluation: a convincing and critical response to the focus of the statement; perceptive understanding of the writer's methods; a range of judicious textual detail; evaluates critically and in detail the effect(s) on the reader.
    Level 3 (11-15 marks): Clear, relevant evaluation: a clear and relevant response to the focus of the statement; clear understanding of the writer's methods; a range of relevant textual references; evaluates clearly the effect(s) on the reader.
    Level 2 (6-10 marks): Some evaluation: some response to the focus of the statement; some understanding of the writer's methods; some appropriate textual reference(s); some evaluative comment(s) on the effect(s) on the reader.
    Level 1 (1-5 marks): Simple, limited comment: a simple, limited response to the focus of the statement; limited understanding of the writer's methods; simple, limited textual reference(s); simple, limited evaluative comment(s) on the effect(s) on the reader.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): A response, or a section of one, about events outside paragraphs [3] to [6] (e.g. the frowning spruce forest and the laughing Wild in paragraph [1], or the dogs and the sled in paragraph [2]) can attain only Level 1 or Level 2 for that section; the rest of the response can attain any level. Reference to the writer's methods may be implicit, and so may 'I agree / I don't agree'. Points may include: the repeated verb "toiled" and the delayed reveal of the third man "whose toil was over" - the box becomes a coffin; the personified Wild as conqueror, "a man whom the Wild had conquered and beaten down" (supports 'powerless'); the shift into the present tense, "It is not the way of the Wild to like movement. Life is an offence to it" - a universal law; the list building to a climax on man, whom the Wild will "harry and crush into submission"; but man as "ever in revolt", and the turn "But at front and rear, unawed and indomitable" - defiance, which challenges 'completely powerless'; the ominous "not yet dead"; faces like "ghostly masques, undertakers in a spectral world" - death imagery; the assertion "But under it all they were men" and the antithesis "puny adventurers bent on colossal adventure"; the silence "pressing upon them with a tangible presence" and the diver simile ("the many atmospheres of deep water") - a physical weight; the repetition "It crushed them" and the image "like juices from the grape", reducing them to "specks and motes" - many may judge this horror of insignificance the most frightening part; the monotony of "An hour went by, and a second hour"; the "faint far cry" in a long sentence that mimics the howl, "palpitant and tense, and then slowly died away"; the correction from "a lost soul wailing" to "a certain sad fierceness and hungry eagerness" - ghost becomes predator; the restrained ending, "each nodded to the other" "across the narrow oblong box" - silent understanding, composure and dread, with the coffin between them. Level 4 responses respond convincingly and critically to both parts - e.g. that the men are dwarfed but defiant, and that the ending frightens through restraint rather than drama, or that the crushing silence is more terrifying - with perceptive comment on methods (personification, repetition, antithesis, sentence length, the delayed reveal, the understated ending) and judicious, embedded references. Responses that mainly retell what happens are unlikely to rise above Level 2.

Question 3

20 marks

Read the following extract, then answer the question at the end.

Turmeric
by Harpreet Sandhu (fictional)

This extract is from the beginning of a short story. Jas, who is fifteen and lives in Birmingham, has travelled with her parents to her father's home village in Punjab, in northern India, for the wedding of her cousin Simran.

[1] Four days before the wedding, the fog does not lift until eleven, and when it does, the whole village seems to have been building something behind it. In the field next to my grandmother's house, six men on bamboo ladders are hauling up a tent the size of a sports hall, striped red and yellow like a giant's sweet. A tractor has brought three hundred plastic chairs, and a boy of about ten is unloading them on his own, two at a time, with enormous seriousness. Marigolds hang in orange ropes from every railing. Behind the cowshed, two cooks have set a pan as wide as a paddling pool over a fire of split logs and are frying jalebis, squeezing batter into the oil in loops and spirals and lifting them out, glossy and orange, to drown in syrup.

[2] I am filming all of it on my phone, which is how I have spent most of this trip: at arm's length. My Punjabi works fine in Birmingham, at the kitchen table at home, but here it comes out in a Brummie accent, and my aunties laugh at it, kindly, the way you laugh at a dog walking on its back legs. They call me London wali, the London girl. I have stopped explaining that Birmingham is not London. Nobody here thinks the difference matters.

[3] In the afternoon the women gather in the courtyard for the maiyan. Simran sits on a low wooden stool in an old yellow suit she will never wear again, and one by one the aunties scoop turmeric paste from a steel bowl and rub it into her face, her arms, her hands and feet, until she glows like something carved from butter. They are singing - not proper songs but teasing verses made up on the spot, about the groom's big ears and his mother's terrible driving - and between the verses someone thumps the little drum in her lap and someone else shrieks with laughter. The courtyard smells of turmeric and mustard oil and woodsmoke, and the low sun comes slanting through the dust, gold on gold. I keep my phone up. On the screen, everyone looks very small.

[4] Simran catches me filming and pulls a monster face, the turmeric cracking at the corners of her mouth. Then, for half a second, when the aunties look away, her face does something else. It drops, like a curtain when the cord is cut. And then she is laughing again, and I tell myself I imagined it.

[5] I find her that evening on the roof. Every flat roof in the village has someone on it, a dark shape against the lit windows, and beyond the houses the fields are black and silent, though I can smell them: cold earth, and the wet green smell of young wheat. Simran has a shawl round her shoulders and is looking at the road that leads out of the village, as if she can see along it all the way to the airport.

[6] 'What's it like?' she says, without turning round. 'Living so far away from everyone.'

[7] I start to tell her that it isn't that far, that there are flights, that we video-call Biji, my grandmother, every Sunday. Then I realise she isn't asking about me. By the summer she will be in Canada, in a city she has only seen on a laptop screen, with a husband she loves, she says, but has mostly known through that same screen. And it hits me, standing there, that my dad did this. Twenty years ago he stood on a roof like this one and looked at that road.

[8] 'It's like being two people,' I say. It is the truest thing I have said in Punjabi all week, and I say it badly, and she understands it anyway.

[9] Below us, someone switches on the fairy lights, and the whole house leaps out of the dark, strung with gold from the roof to the gate. In the field the dhol starts up, a big drum beaten with sticks, so deep that I feel it in my ribs before I hear it. Simran wipes her eyes with the end of her shawl and leaves a yellow streak across her cheek. Then she holds out her hand.

[10] 'Come on, London wali,' she says. 'Dance.'

[11] I put my phone in my pocket, and I do not take it out again all night.

Focus this part of your answer on the second part of the source, from paragraph [4] to the end.

A student said, "In this part of the story, Simran turns out to be much less happy about her wedding than she seems. The writer shows that the conversation on the roof brings Jas and Simran closer together."

To what extent do you agree?

In your response, you could:
- consider your own impressions of Simran's feelings
- evaluate how the writer presents the conversation on the roof and what follows
- support your response with references to the text.

Model answer

I agree with the second part of the statement more than the first. The conversation on the roof clearly brings the cousins closer, and the ending shows Jas joining in rather than watching. However, I think "much less happy" oversimplifies Simran. The writer presents her as torn rather than unhappy: she is afraid of leaving, not necessarily of marrying.

The first hint comes in the courtyard. Simran pulls "a monster face", playing up for the camera, but the turmeric cracking "at the corners of her mouth" suggests that the mask is not quite holding. Then her face "drops, like a curtain when the cord is cut". The theatrical simile implies that her happiness has been a performance, and the speed of "half a second" makes it unsettling. Jas's response, "I tell myself I imagined it", shows that she, too, would rather not see it. This supports the first part of the statement.

On the roof, though, Simran's feelings become more specific. She is "looking at the road that leads out of the village, as if she can see along it all the way to the airport". The road suggests departure, and her question, "What's it like? ... Living so far away from everyone", spoken "without turning round", shows that her fear is about distance and loss rather than the wedding itself. The detail that her husband is someone "she loves, she says, but has mostly known through that same screen" is the most ambiguous phrase in the extract. The interrupting "she says" casts a shadow of doubt, but it is Jas's doubt as much as Simran's.

The roof conversation is where the cousins come closer. Jas first answers with practical details, but "Then I realise she isn't asking about me." This moment of understanding is a turning point, and it widens into a realisation about her own family: "my dad did this. Twenty years ago he stood on a roof like this one and looked at that road." The repeated road links generations of leaving. Jas's reply, "It's like being two people", is simple but profound, and the repeated 'and' in "all week, and I say it badly, and she understands it anyway" shows that their connection goes deeper than language.

The ending brings the two parts of the statement together. The fairy lights make "the whole house" leap "out of the dark", a sudden burst of joy, and the dhol is felt "in my ribs before I hear it", suggesting that Jas now feels the celebration from the inside. Simran "wipes her eyes" and leaves "a yellow streak across her cheek": tears and turmeric mix sadness with celebration in one image. Then she "holds out her hand". The nickname "London wali" now sounds affectionate, and the command "Dance" invites Jas in.

The final one-sentence paragraph, "I put my phone in my pocket, and I do not take it out again all night", shows that Jas has stopped recording life and started living it. So the conversation does bring the cousins closer, but Simran's sadness exists alongside real joy. She is not much less happy than she seems; she is happy and afraid at once, which is exactly what Jas means by "being two people".

Explanation

A Level 4 answer tests 'much less happy' against the evidence: the face that "drops, like a curtain" suggests a performance, but the roof conversation shows that Simran's fear is about distance, so she is torn rather than simply unhappy. It evaluates how the turning point "Then I realise she isn't asking about me.", the shared idea of "being two people" and the symbolic ending with the phone show the cousins drawing closer. Common pitfalls are writing about the wedding preparations in paragraphs [1] to [3], which are outside the named part, and retelling the conversation without analysing the writer's methods.

Mark scheme
  1. 20 marks

    Levels of response (20 marks). AO4 (critical evaluation).
    Level 4 (16-20 marks): Perceptive, detailed evaluation: a convincing and critical response to the focus of the statement; perceptive understanding of the writer's methods; a range of judicious textual detail; evaluates critically and in detail the effect(s) on the reader.
    Level 3 (11-15 marks): Clear, relevant evaluation: a clear and relevant response to the focus of the statement; clear understanding of the writer's methods; a range of relevant textual references; evaluates clearly the effect(s) on the reader.
    Level 2 (6-10 marks): Some evaluation: some response to the focus of the statement; some understanding of the writer's methods; some appropriate textual reference(s); some evaluative comment(s) on the effect(s) on the reader.
    Level 1 (1-5 marks): Simple, limited comment: a simple, limited response to the focus of the statement; limited understanding of the writer's methods; simple, limited textual reference(s); simple, limited evaluative comment(s) on the effect(s) on the reader.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): A response, or a section of one, about events outside paragraphs [4] to [11] (e.g. the wedding preparations, Jas's accent and the aunties' teasing, or the turmeric ceremony in paragraph [3]) can attain only Level 1 or Level 2 for that section; the rest of the response can attain any level. Reference to the writer's methods may be implicit, and so may 'I agree / I don't agree'. Points may include: the playful "monster face" for the camera, with the turmeric "cracking at the corners of her mouth" - the mask is not quite holding; the theatrical simile "It drops, like a curtain when the cord is cut" and the brevity of "half a second" - happiness as performance (supports the first part); Jas's denial, "I tell myself I imagined it"; the watchers on "Every flat roof" and the sensory "cold earth, and the wet green smell of young wheat" - the place she is leaving; Simran "looking at the road that leads out of the village, as if she can see along it all the way to the airport" - departure and fear; the question "Living so far away from everyone", asked "without turning round" - vulnerability, and a fear of distance rather than of marriage; the ambiguous "a husband she loves, she says, but has mostly known through that same screen" - the interrupting 'she says' casts doubt; the turning point "Then I realise she isn't asking about me."; Jas's realisation that "my dad did this" and stood "on a roof like this one" - three generations linked by the road; "It's like being two people" and "I say it badly, and she understands it anyway" - connection beyond language (supports the second part); the house that "leaps out of the dark" and the dhol felt "in my ribs before I hear it" - joy felt from the inside; the tears and turmeric in "a yellow streak across her cheek" - sadness and celebration in one image; "Then she holds out her hand." and the nickname "London wali", now affectionate, with the command "Dance"; the final one-sentence paragraph "I put my phone in my pocket" - Jas stops observing and joins in. Students may argue that Simran is anxious and torn rather than unhappy, and that the roof brings Jas closer to her family's history as well as to Simran. Level 4 responses respond convincingly to both parts - e.g. that Simran's happiness and fear coexist, and that the closeness grows from shared experience of being 'two people' - with perceptive comment on methods (simile, ambiguity, first-person present-tense narration, symbolism of the screen, road and phone, the final paragraph) and judicious, embedded references. Responses that mainly retell what happens are unlikely to rise above Level 2.

Question 4

20 marks

Read the following extract, then answer the question at the end.

Safe Crossing Times
by Tom Ridley (fictional)

This extract is from a short story. Holy Island, or Lindisfarne, off the coast of Northumberland, can be reached by a causeway road only at low tide: twice a day the sea covers it. Thirteen-year-old Ellie and her father have spent the day on the island and are driving back to the mainland.

[1] The safe crossing times were printed on a card in every shop window on the island, and on a sign at each end of the causeway in red letters as tall as a child. Ellie's father had looked at none of them. He had looked at his watch outside the priory, said 'Plenty of time,' and bought her a second ice cream, and now, at twenty to six on a grey September evening, their old blue Volvo was nosing off the island onto the causeway with the wipers squeaking and the radio playing something cheerful about summer.

[2] The road ran out across the sands in a long grey line, as straight as a ruled pencil mark. Beside it, the tall marker poles of the old Pilgrims' Way strode away across the flats, and on either side the sand lay wet and gleaming, wrinkled like the roof of a mouth. Ahead were the dark trees at Beal and the lorries crawling along the A1 like beetles. Behind, on its crag, the castle sat with its back to the sea, as if it had seen all this before.

[3] Halfway across, the water began. At first it was only a darkening of the sand on the left, like the shadow of a cloud. Then the shadow had an edge, and the edge was moving. It came across the flats in a thin bright line, not fast, not slow, but with a patience that Ellie did not like, joining puddle to puddle until the puddles were a single sheet, and the sheet was sliding towards the road.

[4] 'Dad.'

[5] 'I see it.' He did not slow down. 'It's nothing. It's an inch. People drive through this all the time.'

[6] People did, and some of them ended up on the news: cars up to their windows in the sea, a helicopter hanging over them like a dragonfly. Ellie looked for the refuge hut and found it, ahead and to the right, standing on its long legs beside the bridge where the road crossed the channel.

[7] The water reached the road a hundred metres short of the bridge. It did not rush. It simply arrived, sliding over the tarmac from both sides at once, so that the causeway thinned to a ribbon, then a thread, then nothing at all, and the Volvo was driving into a flat silver mirror that held the whole sky upside down. The engine note deepened, faltered, coughed. Something under the floor knocked twice, like a fist on a door; the dashboard lit up with a scatter of red lights; and the car stopped. The only sounds were the radio, still singing about summer, and the water talking to itself under the wheels.

[8] Her father turned the key. Nothing. He turned it again, and again, harder each time, as if the car could be bullied into starting, and Ellie watched his knuckles whiten and understood, for the first time in her life, that her father did not know what to do.

[9] 'Dad.' Her voice came out calmer than she felt, as though it belonged to someone older. 'We have to get to the hut. Now, before it's any deeper.' She was already unclipping her seat belt, remembering the leaflet in the guest house: if you are cut off, leave your car, go to the refuge, ring 999. 'Bring your phone. Leave everything else.'

[10] The water was over her trainers the moment she stepped down, so cold that it burned, and it pulled at her ankles with a steady sideways pressure, the whole sea leaning on her. They held hands, which they had not done since she was nine. Twenty steps. Thirty. The ladder was green and slippery with weed, and she climbed it first, then turned and reached down for him, and he took her hand and let himself be pulled up, as if she were the parent.

[11] From the doorway of the refuge they watched the sea finish its work. It climbed the Volvo's wheels, its doors, its windows. The headlights, which neither of them had thought to switch off, shone on under the water for a long time, two pale green eyes gazing up at them, and then went out. Her father rang the coastguard in a voice that kept nearly breaking, then sat down on the bench beside her and said nothing at all.

[12] 'Plenty of time,' he said at last, and laughed, a small cracked sound, and put his wet arm round her. Beyond the drowned car the castle had become a black shape against the evening, and out on the flats the tops of the marker poles stood up out of the water in a long dotted line, pointing the way to somewhere neither of them could reach.

Focus this part of your answer on the second part of the source, from paragraph [7] to the end.

A student said, "In this part of the story, Ellie and her father swap roles, and she becomes the adult. The writer makes the ending feel more sad than relieved, even though they are safe."

To what extent do you agree?

In your response, you could:
- consider your own impressions of Ellie and her father
- evaluate how the writer presents the end of the extract
- support your response with references to the text.

Model answer

I largely agree that Ellie and her father swap roles in this part of the story, and that the ending is full of sadness. However, I would qualify both parts. Ellie does act like an adult, but the writer shows that she is frightened too, and the ending mixes sadness with real relief and tenderness, so it is more complex than "more sad than relieved".

The crisis is built through the quiet menace of the sea. The water "did not rush. It simply arrived", which makes it seem patient and unstoppable. The tricolon "the causeway thinned to a ribbon, then a thread, then nothing at all" shows the road shrinking until it vanishes, and "a flat silver mirror that held the whole sky upside down" is beautiful but disorientating. An upside-down world is a fitting symbol for what is about to happen between father and daughter. The engine "deepened, faltered, coughed", and something knocks "like a fist on a door", an ominous simile. The irony of the radio "still singing about summer" while the water is "talking to itself under the wheels" makes the danger more chilling.

The turning point comes when her father turns the key "again, and again, harder each time, as if the car could be bullied into starting", helplessness disguised as force. Ellie "watched his knuckles whiten and understood, for the first time in her life, that her father did not know what to do". This epiphany is the moment the roles begin to swap.

Ellie then takes charge. Her voice comes out "as though it belonged to someone older", and her short imperatives, "Now, before it's any deeper" and "Bring your phone. Leave everything else.", sound like a parent speaking to a child. The simile "as if she were the parent", when she pulls him up the ladder, makes the reversal explicit. However, her voice is "calmer than she felt", and she is relying on "the leaflet in the guest house", so she is a frightened girl following instructions rather than a confident adult. That they held hands, "which they had not done since she was nine", is touching because it shows she is still his child.

The ending is where the statement is most debatable. The sinking of the car is described like a death: the sea "climbed the Volvo's wheels, its doors, its windows", and the headlights become "two pale green eyes gazing up at them, and then went out". This personification makes the car seem like a drowning creature, which is genuinely sad. Her father's voice "kept nearly breaking", and he "said nothing at all".

Yet there is relief and even love here. His repetition of "Plenty of time" turns his carelessness into a rueful joke, and his laugh, "a small cracked sound", is an apology. When he "put his wet arm round her", the father returns as a comforting presence, which suggests the roles are not swapped for good.

The final image is the saddest. The marker poles point "the way to somewhere neither of them could reach", suggesting a lost path and a change between them that cannot be undone. So I agree that sadness dominates, but it is a tender sadness, mixed with relief that they are safe and together.

Explanation

A Level 4 answer agrees that the roles reverse, pinpointing Ellie's epiphany about her father's knuckles and the explicit "as if she were the parent", but qualifies 'becomes the adult' by noticing that her voice is "calmer than she felt". It then weighs the sadness of the drowned car and the final image of the poles against the relief and tenderness of the father's arm round her and his rueful "Plenty of time". Common pitfalls are writing about the father ignoring the crossing times or the first sight of the water in paragraphs [1] to [6], which are outside the named part, and retelling the escape without evaluating the writer's methods.

Mark scheme
  1. 20 marks

    Levels of response (20 marks). AO4 (critical evaluation).
    Level 4 (16-20 marks): Perceptive, detailed evaluation: a convincing and critical response to the focus of the statement; perceptive understanding of the writer's methods; a range of judicious textual detail; evaluates critically and in detail the effect(s) on the reader.
    Level 3 (11-15 marks): Clear, relevant evaluation: a clear and relevant response to the focus of the statement; clear understanding of the writer's methods; a range of relevant textual references; evaluates clearly the effect(s) on the reader.
    Level 2 (6-10 marks): Some evaluation: some response to the focus of the statement; some understanding of the writer's methods; some appropriate textual reference(s); some evaluative comment(s) on the effect(s) on the reader.
    Level 1 (1-5 marks): Simple, limited comment: a simple, limited response to the focus of the statement; limited understanding of the writer's methods; simple, limited textual reference(s); simple, limited evaluative comment(s) on the effect(s) on the reader.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): A response, or a section of one, about events outside paragraphs [7] to [12] (e.g. the father ignoring the crossing times, the view of the causeway and the castle, or the first sight of the water in paragraph [3]) can attain only Level 1 or Level 2 for that section; the rest of the response can attain any level. Reference to the writer's methods may be implicit, and so may 'I agree / I don't agree'. Points may include: the patient menace of water that "did not rush" but "simply arrived"; the diminishing tricolon "a ribbon, then a thread, then nothing at all"; "a flat silver mirror that held the whole sky upside down" - beauty, disorientation, and perhaps a symbol of the reversal to come; the engine that "deepened, faltered, coughed" and the knock "like a fist on a door" - ominous; the irony of the radio "still singing about summer" while the water is "talking to itself under the wheels"; the father turning the key "harder each time, as if the car could be bullied into starting" - helplessness disguised as force; Ellie's epiphany as she watched "his knuckles whiten" and understood "that her father did not know what to do" - the turning point; her voice "calmer than she felt, as though it belonged to someone older" and the imperatives "Bring your phone. Leave everything else." - she takes charge (supports the first part), though 'calmer than she felt' and reliance on the leaflet show she is frightened and following rules; the sea "so cold that it burned", "the whole sea leaning on her"; holding hands, "which they had not done since she was nine" - she is still his child; the minor sentences "Twenty steps. Thirty."; "as if she were the parent" - the reversal made explicit; the sea left to "finish its work" on "the Volvo's wheels, its doors, its windows" - a rising tricolon; the headlights as "two pale green eyes gazing up at them, and then went out" - the car's drowning as a death (supports 'sad'); the father's voice that "kept nearly breaking"; the rueful echo "Plenty of time", the laugh "a small cracked sound", and the "wet arm round her" - apology, comfort and relief, which may challenge 'more sad than relieved' and suggest that the roles are not swapped for good; the marker poles "pointing the way to somewhere neither of them could reach" - a lost path, a change that cannot be undone. Level 4 responses respond convincingly to both parts - e.g. that Ellie acts as an adult while remaining a frightened child, and that the ending blends grief for something lost with tender relief - with perceptive comment on methods (personification, tricolon, sentence forms, irony, symbolism of the mirror and the poles) and judicious, embedded references. Responses that mainly retell what happens are unlikely to rise above Level 2.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.