Tutor HuntResources Philosophy Resources
Is It An Oversimplification To Claim That Some Ways Of Knowing Give Us Facts While Others Provide Interpretations?
Date : 14/11/2016
Author Information
Uploaded by : Kelvin
Uploaded on : 14/11/2016
Subject : Philosophy
We know
about the world through the four different ways of knowing: sense perception,
language, reason and emotion. Each serves its powerful role in building our
knowledge of the external world. Facts are things that are known to be true
while interpretation is the act of explaining through a particular view. It is
an oversimplification to categorize the different Ways of Knowing into providing
facts and providing interpretations . Each way of knowing gives it own unique
interpretation, but at the same time providing us with a certain degree of
fact. Sense
perception gains us the information through the five senses. I can know a
certain phenomenon through experiencing it by seeing, touching, smelling,
hearing or tasting it. Independently, sense perception can provide one with
objective facts. By nature, it provides unprocessed raw data of the world, but
can be hindered by disabilities such as colour blindness. The sense of sight,
as I believe, is the most powerful sense perception. The whole world can be
seen through the eye, thus light can be considered the dominant phenomenon of
the external world, and therefore I believe that sense perception provides more
objective facts than any other Ways of Knowing. Astrologists, by observing the
sky, can obtain some remarkable facts about the universe. For example, Mr
Hubble recorded the recessional velocities of different galaxies and their
distance from The Milky Way Galaxy, he obtained a linear relationship and
further deduced that the universe cannot be older than 13.6 billion years. With
senses, we interpret how the world is like, but judgments are influenced by
prior knowledge and personal preferences. For example, by looking at a piece of
Ivory ornament, one may think that it is beautiful and love it a lot but since
I know that Ivory is obtained through killing innocent elephants, the ornament
to me is marked as inhumanity thus it can be seen that sense perception deals
with both fact and interpretation. Language in
my perspective, is a way of knowing that involves a high degree of
interpretation and lesser fact. For instance, if I hear a news that a business
is doing badly, I acquired the knowledge that is doing badly. However, this
knowledge is not very useful at all, it is too broad and not objective since I
can have multiple interpretations of the news. Possible interpretations can be
that the business is losing customers, did not pass the quality check etc. The
reason for certain interpretations is again based on the nature of a person. A
person s education, cultural background, personal experience can affect the
interpretations of an issue, and highly possible for others to interpret it
differently. Reading a piece of article for example, the message convicted
varies between the readers. Therefore debates are very commonly seen. Language
itself also contains a high degree of biasness. In where I live for example,
China, due to the cultural background of the success of the Communist Party, news
always give this impression that they are the greatest people of all time
Chairman Mao is glorified a million times. However that is not the case, news
and media are only selective reporting, so that they can control the
interpretations of people. Therefore, to me, the language as a way of knowing
gives my interpretation rather than an objective fact. Reasoning is
a collective endeavour by which people construct meaning together by
exchanging, modifying and improving their ideas and opinions. Compared to
language, reason has a lower degree of interpretation but a higher degree of
fact. Due to its nature, reasoning is persuasive and this limits down different
interpretations and provides a more solid fact. However, for a single
phenomenon, there exist more than one way to reason. Reasoning can be
subjective due to culture a Christian will reason a phenomenon with God or the
teachings from the bible which other religions do not agree on. It can also be
subjective due to the limited knowledge a female will usually say that girls live
a tougher life than guys do, and vice versa this is of course due to the
limited knowledge as a person can t be living two lives, or I should say we
assume that it is not possible. Objective reasoning based on scientific
theories and mathematics can provide facts Newton s law of gravitation is
proven to be valid for all masses in the universe. Last but not
least, emotion. It is very different to the other Ways of Knowing, Emotion shapes
thoughts, influences behaviour, and steers the pursuit of knowledge. In other
words, it assists other Ways of Knowing or actually controls them. Emotion creates
the desire to do, to know. For example, a scientists researches on the same
topic for his entire life, the force driving him is a strong emotion attached
to the topic he is pursuing, or something that he wants to acquire. Without
emotion, there is no wants to know, no expansion of knowledge. Thus I believe
that it is the most important way of knowing. Emotion acts as a basis of
reasoning, to persuade a truth, there is an emotion in you that you want to
veto or support a certain issue. The language that a person speaks is also
greatly influenced by his emotions, describing the same person, two different
people can speak completely different thoughts. Due to personal preferences,
one can speak critically about another, thus emotion makes language subjective.
Emotion also affects how our brain respond to our senses. For instance, a
bottle half filled with water a positive minded person will say that it is
half full while a negative person will say that is half empty. It can be seen
that emotion is very influential to how we know and what we know. In
conclusion to this essay, every way of knowing provides interpretation and
facts. Some provides more interpretation while others more facts. They are all
inter-related in a way to pursuit the truth emotion as a way of knowing, is
the origin of the Ways of Knowing.
This resource was uploaded by: Kelvin