"Jews should accept the creation story in Genesis as literally true."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Some Jews would agree that the creation story should be accepted as literally true. Many Orthodox Jews believe in Torah min HaShamayim, that the Torah was given word for word by God to Moses, and Maimonides' eighth principle of faith affirms that the whole Torah comes from God. If God is the author, they argue, everything in it must be true, and if one part is treated as a mere story, people might start to doubt the rest, including the mitzvot. Some Orthodox Jews, especially many Haredi Jews, therefore accept that God created the world in six days and point out that the Jewish calendar counts its years from creation. The Ten Commandments themselves base Shabbat on the fact that 'in six days the LORD made heaven and earth' and rested on the seventh (Exodus 20:11), so the six days have a central place in Jewish practice. They also argue that scientific theories change over time, but God's word is eternal, and that an omnipotent God could easily create the world in six days.
However, many Jews disagree. Even within Orthodox Judaism there is a long tradition of non-literal interpretation. The rabbis taught that 'the Torah speaks in the language of human beings', meaning that it expresses deep truths in a way people can understand. The Mishnah treats the account of creation as a profound mystery not to be taught casually (Chagigah 2:1), which suggests it is not a simple description. Maimonides, one of the greatest Jewish thinkers, taught that verses which seem to conflict with reason should be read figuratively. The text itself gives hints: there are 'days', evening and morning, before the sun is created on the fourth day, and Genesis 1 and 2 describe creation in different orders. For these reasons many Orthodox Jews accept that the universe is billions of years old while still believing that the Torah is God's word.
Reform Jews go further. They believe the Torah was written by humans inspired by God, so Genesis teaches spiritual truths rather than science: that God is the Creator, that creation is good and that every human being is made in God's image. These truths do not depend on the days being 24 hours long, so Reform Jews accept the Big Bang and evolution as the way God brought the world into being. Atheists and Humanists, such as Richard Dawkins, would argue that science explains the origin of the universe and of life without any need for God, and that Genesis is an ancient myth.
In conclusion, I do not think Jews need to accept the creation story as literally true. Jewish tradition itself, from the rabbis to Maimonides, has always allowed it to be interpreted, and its most important teachings remain true however the 'days' are understood. Nevertheless, I can understand why some Orthodox Jews read it literally: for them, accepting every word as God's is an act of faith and trust. What all these Jews share is the belief that God is the Creator and that the world and human life are good and have purpose.
Explanation
The best answers show that there is a range of views within Judaism, not just 'Orthodox literal, Reform not literal', using traditional sources such as Maimonides and the Mishnah as well as scientific and non-religious views. Answers that only argue about science versus religion miss the religious debate. A strong conclusion distinguishes the meaning of the story from its literal details.