"Living by the mitzvot is more important than waiting for the Messiah."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Many Jews would agree that living by the mitzvot is more important than waiting for the Messiah. The mitzvot are God's commands for life here and now: the Torah says that a person who keeps them 'shall live in them' (Leviticus 18:5), and Deuteronomy teaches that God's commandment 'is not in heaven' but 'very nigh unto thee... that thou mayest do it' (Deuteronomy 30:11-14). The 613 mitzvot give clear guidance for every part of daily life, whereas no one knows when the Messiah will come or exactly what he will be like. Jewish tradition itself puts practice first: Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai taught that if you are planting a sapling when someone announces the Messiah, you should finish planting before you go to greet him. The Talmud condemns those who try to calculate the date of the end (Sanhedrin 97b), and history shows the dangers of messianic excitement, as when many Jews followed Shabbetai Tzvi, who later converted to Islam.
It can also be argued that both Orthodox and Reform Jews, in different ways, put the mitzvot first. Orthodox Jews believe that keeping the mitzvot is the best way to prepare for the Messiah and can even hasten his coming: the Talmud teaches that if all Israel kept two Shabbatot properly, they would be redeemed (Shabbat 118b). Reform Jews believe that the Messianic Age will only come through human beings keeping the ethical mitzvot and working for tikkun olam, following Micah's teaching to 'do justly, and to love mercy' (Micah 6:8). Pirkei Avot also teaches that Jews should serve God without seeking a reward.
On the other hand, belief in the Messiah is a central part of Jewish faith. Maimonides made it the twelfth of his Thirteen Principles, and the Ani Ma'amin declares that Jews wait every day for his coming. The Talmud teaches that when a person comes before God for judgement, one question asked is, 'Did you hope for salvation?' (Shabbat 31a), so hoping for the Messiah is itself a religious duty, not an optional extra. Jews pray for the Messiah three times a day in the Amidah and in grace after meals. The messianic hope gives meaning and direction to the mitzvot, because it shows the goal towards which history is moving, and it has given Jews strength to survive exile and persecution. Chabad Hasidim believe that focusing on the Messiah is urgent and that every Jew should be eager for his coming. Humanists would agree that living ethically now matters most, but they would reject the idea that moral rules come from God, as well as the idea of a Messiah.
In conclusion, I agree with the statement in one sense: the mitzvot are certain and within reach, while the Messiah's coming is unknown, so it makes sense for daily life to focus on keeping God's commandments. However, I think the statement sets up a false choice. In Judaism, 'waiting' for the Messiah does not mean doing nothing; it means living by the mitzvot in hope. As the Talmud's question 'Did you hope for salvation?' shows, the hope and the practice belong together, and the best way for a Jew to wait for the Messiah is to keep the mitzvot faithfully.
Explanation
A Level 5 answer recognises that for many Jews the mitzvot and the messianic hope are connected, not opposed, and uses sources on both sides (the sapling saying, Sanhedrin 97b and Shabbat 118b against Maimonides, Ani Ma'amin and Shabbat 31a). Answers that treat 'waiting' as simply doing nothing miss the Jewish understanding of active hope. A strong conclusion questions the choice the statement sets up.