"The Eightfold Path is too difficult for most people to follow."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Some people would agree that the Eightfold Path is too difficult for most people. Its standards are extremely high. Right speech means never lying, gossiping, speaking harshly or engaging in idle chatter, which most people find almost impossible in everyday life and on social media. Right livelihood rules out many jobs, because the Buddha told lay followers not to trade in weapons, living beings, meat, intoxicants or poisons. Right concentration requires years of disciplined meditation, and right view means fully understanding the Four Noble Truths, impermanence and not-self, which is the work of a lifetime. Traditionally it is Theravada monks and nuns who follow the path fully, keeping the many rules of the Vinaya, while many lay Buddhists aim only to make merit for a better rebirth. Pure Land Buddhists, following Shinran, go further: they teach that in this age ordinary people are so full of passions that they cannot reach enlightenment by their own 'self power' and must rely instead on the 'other power' of Amida Buddha. Modern life, with its long working hours, consumerism and constant distraction, makes the path even harder, and very few people ever become arhats.
However, most Buddhists would disagree. The Buddha taught the Eightfold Path as the Middle Way: it avoids the extremes of luxury and harsh asceticism, so it is not meant to be impossibly severe. The stages are not a ladder that must be climbed perfectly before moving on; they are developed together and gradually, and 'right' (samma) means skilful or complete rather than perfect from the start. Anyone can begin with small steps, such as keeping the Five Precepts, being more honest or practising a few minutes of mindfulness each day. The Buddha taught lay people as well as monks and nuns, for example giving practical advice on family and working life to the layman Sigala. The Dhammapada says that people must make the effort themselves, as the Buddhas only point the way (Dhammapada 276), which suggests the path is meant to be walked by ordinary people. Mahayana belief in Buddha-nature adds that everyone has the potential for enlightenment. In Britain today many Buddhists in groups such as the Triratna Buddhist Community combine the path with jobs and families, and mindfulness courses based on Buddhist practice are widely used, including in the NHS, which shows that parts of the path are accessible to many people.
A Humanist might also argue that much of the path, such as honesty, not harming others and developing compassion, is reasonable and achievable for anyone without religious belief, even though they would not accept karma and rebirth.
In conclusion, I think that following the whole Eightfold Path perfectly is very difficult, which is why it is often pursued most fully by monastics and why Pure Land Buddhism developed. However, the statement goes too far: the path is designed to be followed gradually, and every person can begin it and make progress. Its difficulty is a reason to practise patiently, not a reason to give up.
Explanation
Strong answers distinguish between following the path perfectly and following it gradually, and use Buddhist diversity: monastic and lay practice, the Middle Way, and the Pure Land view that self-effort is not enough. Answers that only say 'it is hard because you have to meditate' stay at Level 1-2. A justified conclusion that weighs these views reaches the top levels.