"Buddhists should not grieve when someone dies."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Buddhist teachings about death encourage calm acceptance, but this does not necessarily mean that Buddhists should feel no grief at all.
There are strong reasons to support the statement. Death is the clearest example of anicca: everything that is born must die, and the Dhammapada teaches that there is nowhere in the world where one can escape death (128). According to the Second Noble Truth, suffering comes from craving and attachment, and the Dhammapada says that from attachment springs grief (212). The Salla Sutta teaches that weeping and lamentation bring no benefit to the dead and only harm the mourner, so the wise person removes the 'arrow' of grief. When Kisa Gotami brought her dead child to the Buddha, he sent her to find a mustard seed from a house where no one had died; finding none, she understood that death is universal and found peace. At the Buddha's own death, the Mahaparinibbana Sutta describes how the enlightened disciples remained calm and mindful, while those not yet free from attachment wept. Theravada funerals reinforce this with the chant 'Anicca vata sankhara', and some Tibetan Buddhists believe that excessive grief can disturb the dead person's consciousness in the bardo. Belief in rebirth, or for Pure Land Buddhists in rebirth in Amida's Pure Land, means that death is a transition rather than an end.
However, there are also strong reasons to disagree. Grief is a natural human response to loss, and the Buddha did not condemn ordinary people for feeling it. As the Buddha's death approached, his devoted attendant Ananda wept, and the Buddha comforted him rather than scolding him. Kisa Gotami was not told off for her grief; the Buddha guided her gently towards understanding. Compassion (karuna) means recognising suffering, including one's own, and trying to suppress grief completely could make it worse. Buddhist rituals actually give grief a healthy outlet: almsgiving and merit transfer, memorial services, the 49 days of rites in Tibet and Japan, and festivals like Obon all allow mourners to express their love in positive ways. Many modern Buddhist teachers encourage people to be mindful of their grief and accept it rather than deny it. Non-religious people such as Humanists also see grieving as an important and healthy process.
Weighing these views, I think the statement is too harsh if it means Buddhists should feel nothing. Buddhist teaching is not that one should stop caring, but that one should avoid clinging and despair. Feeling sadness at a loss is natural; what Buddhism offers is a way to work through it, through reflection on impermanence, generous action for the dead and the support of the sangha, towards calm acceptance. Only fully enlightened beings are free from grief. So Buddhists should not grieve excessively or cling to the dead, but grieving itself is a natural step on the path to understanding.
Explanation
The best answers use teachings such as the Salla Sutta, Dhammapada 212 and the Kisa Gotami story to support the statement, and the example of Ananda, compassion and the role of mourning rituals to challenge it. One-sided answers cannot go above Level 2. A top conclusion distinguishes between natural grief and attachment or despair.