Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Edexcel GCSE History (Crime and punishment in Britain c1000-present) Smart practice A mixed round aimed at your weak spots
Unit 1
c1000-c1500: Crime and punishment in medieval England
Unit 2
c1500-c1700: Crime and punishment in early modern England
Unit 3
c1700-c1900: Crime and punishment in eighteenth- and nineteenth-century Britain
Unit 4
c1900-present: Crime and punishment in modern Britain
Unit 5
Historic environment: Whitechapel, c1870-c1900: crime, policing and the inner city
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/17

Policing in the national and regional context, c1870-c1900

Practise 18 exam-style questions on Policing in the national and regional context, c1870-c1900 for Edexcel GCSE History (Crime and punishment in Britain c1000-present). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 18 questions
  • 2–8 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
18 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

2 marks

Describe one feature of the Turf Fraud scandal of 1877.

Model answer

In the Turf Fraud scandal, senior detectives at Scotland Yard were found to have taken bribes from two swindlers, Harry Benson and William Kurr, to warn them when the police were about to act. At the 'Trial of the Detectives' at the Old Bailey in 1877 three detectives were sentenced to two years in prison, which badly damaged trust in Scotland Yard.

Explanation

The first mark is for a clear feature of the scandal, such as the swindle, the bribery of detectives, the trial or its results; the second is for a precise detail about that same feature. The best answers often link the scandal to the creation of the CID in 1878. Keep to one feature and support it.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    A valid feature of the Turf Fraud scandal identified, e.g. two swindlers ran fake betting schemes / they cheated a wealthy Frenchwoman of a large sum / they bribed senior detectives at Scotland Yard to warn them / several detectives were put on trial at the Old Bailey in 1877 / three detectives were found guilty and sent to prison / the scandal damaged public trust in Scotland Yard's detectives / it led to a Home Office inquiry and the creation of the CID in 1878.

    Award 1 mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. Two swindlers ran fake betting schemes (1). Harry Benson and William Kurr sent out circulars and a fake racing newspaper to persuade people, mainly in France, to invest money in a 'system' of betting on horse races (1). e.g. They cheated a wealthy Frenchwoman (1). The Comtesse (Madame) de Goncourt lost about £10,000 before the fraud was discovered (1). e.g. They bribed Scotland Yard detectives (1). Senior detectives, including Meiklejohn and Druscovich, took money to warn the swindlers when the police were about to act (1). e.g. The detectives were put on trial (1). At the 'Trial of the Detectives' at the Old Bailey in 1877, three detectives were each sentenced to two years in prison, while a fourth, Chief Inspector Clarke, was acquitted (1). e.g. It led to the creation of the CID (1). A Home Office committee investigated the detective branch, and in 1878 it was reorganised as the Criminal Investigation Department under Howard Vincent (1). Accept approximate figures for the money. Accept 'Trial of the Detectives' and 'de Goncourt frauds'. Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.

  2. 1 mark

    Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for the swindle: Harry Benson and William Kurr, fake betting 'system' and a fake racing paper; for the victim: Madame de Goncourt lost about £10,000; for the bribes: detectives such as Meiklejohn and Druscovich warned the swindlers; for the trial: Old Bailey, 1877, three detectives (Meiklejohn, Druscovich and Palmer) sentenced to two years, Clarke acquitted; for the results: a Home Office committee and the creation of the CID in 1878 under Howard Vincent.

    The supporting information must develop the feature given for the first mark. Do not credit a general comment such as 'it was a big scandal'. Do not credit dates for the CID other than 1878.

Question 2

2 marks

Describe one feature of the Special Irish Branch set up at Scotland Yard in 1883.

Model answer

The Special Irish Branch was set up at Scotland Yard in March 1883 to deal with the Fenian bombing campaign in Britain. It was a small group of CID detectives who watched Irish republican suspects in London and at the ports, and in May 1884 Scotland Yard itself was damaged by a Fenian bomb.

Explanation

A good answer gives one clear feature of the Special Irish Branch, such as why it was set up, how it was organised or what it did, and supports it with a precise detail such as the bombing campaign of the 1880s. It is a good example of the CID becoming more specialised. Do not drift into modern counter-terrorism.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    A valid feature of the Special Irish Branch identified, e.g. it was set up in response to the Fenian bombing campaign in Britain / it was a small group of CID detectives based at Scotland Yard / it watched Irish republicans in London and at ports / Scotland Yard itself was bombed in 1884 / it later became the Special Branch / its work widened to watching anarchists and foreign revolutionaries and protecting important people.

    Award 1 mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. It was set up because of Fenian bombings (1). In March 1883 Irish republicans (Fenians) set off bombs in London, including one at government offices in Whitehall, and the Special Irish Branch was formed to deal with this campaign (1). e.g. It was part of the CID (1). It was made up of a small number of experienced detectives working from the Criminal Investigation Department's headquarters at Scotland Yard (1). e.g. It watched suspected bombers (1). Its officers kept watch on Irish republicans in London and checked travellers at the ports to stop explosives being brought in (1). e.g. It was itself a target (1). In May 1884 a bomb exploded at Scotland Yard, damaging the offices used by the Special Irish Branch (1). e.g. It became the Special Branch (1). The word 'Irish' was later dropped, as the branch also watched anarchists and foreign revolutionaries and guarded royalty and visiting rulers (1). Accept approximate dates (1883-84) and figures. Sources disagree about when 'Irish' was dropped (dates from 1886 to the early 1890s are given), so accept any date in that range and do not require one. Credit the work of officers such as William Melville. Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.

  2. 1 mark

    Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for its origins: the Fenian dynamite campaign of the early 1880s and the Whitehall bomb of March 1883; for its organisation: a small group of CID detectives at Scotland Yard; for its work: watching suspects in London and at the ports; for the attack: the bomb at Scotland Yard in May 1884; for its later development: Special Branch, watching anarchists and foreign revolutionaries and protecting royalty.

    The supporting information must develop the feature given for the first mark. Do not credit a general comment such as 'it fought terrorism' without saying how, or details of twentieth-century counter-terrorism.

Question 3

4 marks

Source A: From How London Lives, a book by the journalist W. J. Gordon, published in 1890. The book explained to the public how London's services, such as its food supply, street cleaning and police, were organised. Here Gordon describes the work of the Metropolitan Police, using figures from the Commissioner's yearly report.

The yearly report of the Chief Commissioner shows how varied are the present duties of the police. There is the supervision of some 36,000 habitual criminals, 'licence-holders or supervisees,' who have to report themselves from time to time, and whose photographs find their place in the police albums, which over a thousand police, constabulary, prison-warders, and railway officials go to head-quarters to search in the course of the year. There is the control of nearly a thousand common lodging-houses. ... The everyday life of a policeman can hardly be called monotonous. From the outset he is supposed to be a walking cyclopaedia, and he never knows what is coming next. He must always be on the alert. He may have to make an arrest - 75,000 arrests by the London police in a year; or attend a fire - 1,000 fires attended by the police in a year; or carry a ballot-box at a vestry election ... or take a man to the hospital - 6,300 people taken to the London hospitals by policemen in the year! And should he make a mistake in any of these matters, the Chief Commissioner will probably hear that his men are all hopelessly useless and corrupt.

How could you follow up Source A to find out more about the range of duties carried out by the Metropolitan Police in the late 1880s? In your answer, you must give the question you would ask and the type of source you could use.

Set out your answer under these four headings:
Detail in Source A that I would follow up:
Question I would ask:
What type of source I could use:
How this might help answer my question:

Model answer

Detail in Source A that I would follow up: '75,000 arrests by the London police in a year'.
Question I would ask: Which offences led to the largest number of arrests in London in the late 1880s?
What type of source I could use: The tables of arrests in the annual reports of the Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis.
How this might help answer my question: The tables list the number of arrests for each type of offence, so I could see whether drunkenness and other minor offences took up most of the police's work.

Explanation

Use one of Gordon's figures or duties as your detail and ask a question that would test or explain it. Gordon says he took his figures from the Commissioner's yearly report, so the annual reports are an excellent choice of source, but you must explain what information they contain. Avoid vague answers such as 'police records'.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    A detail in Source A that could form the basis of a follow-up enquiry into the range of police duties, e.g. 'the supervision of some 36,000 habitual criminals' / 'whose photographs find their place in the police albums' / 'the control of nearly a thousand common lodging-houses' / '75,000 arrests by the London police in a year' / '6,300 people taken to the London hospitals by policemen'.

    Award 1 mark for selecting a detail in the source that could form the basis of a follow-up enquiry and 1 mark for an appropriate follow-up question. Award 1 mark for identification of an appropriate source to use in a follow-up enquiry and 1 mark for an answer that explains how the information it contains could help answer the chosen follow-up question. e.g. Detail in Source A that I would follow up: 'the supervision of some 36,000 habitual criminals' (1). Question I would ask: How did the Metropolitan Police keep track of habitual criminals who had been released from prison? (1). What type of source I could use: the records of the Convict Supervision Office at Scotland Yard, including the Register of Habitual Criminals and its photograph albums (1). How this might help answer my question: they recorded each supervised criminal's details, photograph and the times he reported to the police, showing how the system worked in practice (1). e.g. Detail: '75,000 arrests by the London police in a year' (1). Question: Which offences led to the largest number of arrests in London in the late 1880s? (1). Type of source: the tables of arrests in the annual reports of the Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis (1). How it might help: they list arrests by type of offence, so I could see whether drunkenness and minor offences made up most of the work (1). e.g. Detail: 'the control of nearly a thousand common lodging-houses' (1). Question: How did the police inspect common lodging houses and what did they check? (1). Type of source: the police registers of common lodging houses kept under the Common Lodging Houses Acts (1). How it might help: they recorded each registered house, the number of lodgers allowed and the results of inspections (1). (No mark for a question that is not linked to following up Source A, e.g. 'because it would be an interesting question to ask'.) Accept other appropriate alternatives.

  2. 1 mark

    An appropriate follow-up question linked to the detail chosen and to the range of police duties, e.g. How did the police supervise habitual criminals? / Which offences led to most arrests? / How were common lodging houses inspected? / How much time did non-criminal duties take up?

    The question must follow up the chosen detail and stay within the enquiry. Do not credit a question addressed to Gordon or about his book, or a question so narrow that it is about one unnamed constable.

  3. 1 mark

    An appropriate type of source that could help answer the question, e.g. the Commissioner's annual reports / the Register of Habitual Criminals and the photograph albums at Scotland Yard / the police registers of common lodging houses / the Police Gazette / police station occurrence books.

    Credit a specific type of source that existed at the time and could contain the information needed for the question asked. Do not credit vague answers such as 'records', 'a book', 'the internet' or 'a newspaper' with no indication of which one or what it contains, unless the explanation in the last section makes clear what specific information it contains. Do not credit modern history books, websites, documentaries or interviewing someone. If the question is not valid, a source chosen to answer it cannot be credited.

  4. 1 mark

    An explanation of how the information in the chosen source could help answer the question, e.g. the Register would show the details and reporting of supervised criminals / the annual reports would give arrests by offence / the lodging-house registers would show inspections.

    The explanation must say what information the chosen source would contain and how that would answer the question. Do not credit 'it would tell me the answer', 'it would be reliable' on its own, or an explanation that does not match the source or the question.

Question 4

8 marks

Study Sources A and B.

Source A: From the record in Hansard of a statement made in the House of Commons on 13 November 1888 by the Home Secretary, Henry Matthews. He read out letters that had passed between Sir Charles Warren and the Home Office after the Home Office objected to an article Warren had written in Murray's Magazine. The Home Office had reminded Warren of an 1879 rule that officials must not publish anything about their department without permission.

[From Warren's reply to the Home Office, 8 November 1888:] ... I have to point out that, had I been told that such a Circular was to be in force, I should not have accepted the post of Commissioner of Police. I have to point out that my duties and those of the Metropolitan Police are governed by statute, and that the Secretary of State for the Home Department has not the power under the statute of issuing orders for the Police Force. This Circular, if put in force, would practically enable everyone anonymously to attack the Police Force without in any way permitting the Commissioner to correct false statements ...

[From Matthews's answer, 10 November 1888:] ... In my judgment the claim thus put forward by you as Commissioner of Police, to disregard the instructions of the Secretary of State, is altogether inadmissible, and accordingly I have only to accept your resignation. ...

[Matthews to the House of Commons, 13 November 1888:] The Government accepted the resignation of Sir Charles Warren on the ground stated in the Correspondence I have read, and on no other ground. The failure of the police to discover the author of the recent crimes in the Metropolis, and the differences of opinion between Sir Charles Warren and Mr. Monro, had nothing to do with the action of the Government ...

Source B: From the record in Hansard of questions asked in the House of Commons on 20 November 1888, ten days after Henry Matthews accepted Warren's resignation. On 17 November The Times had published a letter from Warren, which said that the full correspondence between him and the Home Office would give a different impression of his actions. The two MPs quoted here, Robert Cunninghame Graham and Charles Conybeare, were Liberals, members of the opposition.

MR. CUNNINGHAME GRAHAM (Lanark, N.W.) asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department, If his attention has been directed to the second paragraph of a letter addressed by Sir Charles Warren to The Times of the 17th instant, in which he says that ... in many cases he has received instructions apparently contrary to Statute, he has protested, and, in protesting, taken legal advice; and, if he will inform the House what those instructions "apparently contrary to Statute" were? ...

THE SECRETARY OF STATE (Mr. MATTHEWS) (Birmingham, E.) I presume that Sir Charles Warren's published letter refers to the voluminous Correspondence on Departmental matters between the Home Office and Scotland Yard. It is unusual to lay a Correspondence of this kind upon the Table of the House; and part of it is altogether confidential. I will, however, state generally that I know of no occasion on which I have given to Sir Charles Warren directions apparently or really contrary to the Statute. ...

MR. CONYBEARE (Cornwall, Camborne) ... as the whole question turns on the relations that have existed for some time between the late Chief Commissioner and the Home Office, is it not desirable to enable the House and the public to arrive at a conclusion between the Home Office and the late Chief Commissioner? ...

MR. MATTHEWS I do not think it is necessary that the whole Correspondence should be laid before the House. As I have stated, a great deal of it cannot be.

How useful are Sources A and B for an enquiry into the relationship between the Home Secretary and the Commissioner of the Metropolitan Police in 1888? Explain your answer, using Sources A and B and your knowledge of the historical context.

Model answer

Source A is useful because it contains the actual correspondence between the two men. Warren claims that 'the Secretary of State for the Home Department has not the power under the statute of issuing orders for the Police Force', while Matthews replies that this claim was 'altogether inadmissible' and accepts his resignation. This shows a basic disagreement about who controlled the police: under the Metropolitan Police Act the Commissioner worked under the Home Secretary's authority, but Warren believed he should run the force without interference. As letters written at the time and read out in Parliament, this is strong evidence. However, Matthews chose what to read, and he insisted that 'The failure of the police' to catch the murderer had 'nothing to do' with the resignation, which suited a minister under attack. Warren later complained in The Times that the full correspondence would give 'an entirely different impression', which suggests this source does not tell the whole story. It also says nothing about earlier quarrels, such as the one that led Monro to resign as head of the CID in August 1888.

Source B is useful because it shows that the dispute did not end with the resignation. Warren had claimed that 'in many cases' he had received instructions 'apparently contrary to Statute', while Matthews replied that he knew of 'no occasion' when he had done so. An MP said that 'the whole question turns on the relations that have existed for some time' between the Commissioner and the Home Office, which suggests a long quarrel; Matthews had admitted on 13 November that Warren had offered to resign before. As the official record of Parliament, it reports accurately what was said and gives both sides. However, Warren's words are only reported second-hand by an opposition MP who was critical of the government, and Matthews refused to publish the full correspondence because part of it was 'altogether confidential', so no one could check who was right.

Overall, Source A is more useful because it contains the two men's own words at the moment the relationship broke down, but Source B shows that A was only Matthews's selection and that their disagreement over who controlled the police had gone on for some time.

Explanation

Top answers judge each source against the specific enquiry: Source A is direct evidence of the dispute but was selected and read out by Matthews, while Source B gives Warren's side only second-hand and shows Matthews refusing to publish the full correspondence. Use context such as the Monro quarrel, Warren's article and his earlier offers to resign. Avoid treating Hansard as completely reliable simply because it is an official record.

Mark scheme
  1. 8 marks

    Levels of response (8 marks). AO3: 8 marks.
    Level 3 (6-8 marks): Judgements on source utility for the specified enquiry are given, applying valid criteria with developed reasoning which takes into account how the provenance affects the usefulness of the source content. The sources are analysed to support reasoning about their utility. Contextual knowledge is used in the process of interpreting the sources and applying criteria for judgements on their utility.
    Level 2 (3-5 marks): Judgements on source utility for the specified enquiry are given, using valid criteria. Judgements are supported by developed comment related to the content of the sources and/or their provenance. Comprehension and some analysis of the sources is shown by the selection and use of material to support comments on their utility. Contextual knowledge is used directly to support comments on the usefulness of the content of the sources and/or their provenance.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple judgement on utility is given, and supported by undeveloped comment on the content of the sources and/or their provenance. Simple comprehension of the source material is shown by the extraction or paraphrase of some content. Limited contextual knowledge is deployed with links to the sources.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.
    Note: Provenance = nature, origin, purpose. No credit may be given for contextual knowledge unless it is linked to evaluation of the sources. No credit may be given for generic comments on provenance which are not used to evaluate source content.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Source A (Hansard). Content: Warren says he would not have taken the post had he known of the rule, and claims that the Home Secretary 'has not the power under the statute of issuing orders for the Police Force'; he wants to be free to answer critics; Matthews calls this claim 'altogether inadmissible' and accepts his resignation; Matthews tells the Commons that the resignation had nothing to do with the failure to catch the murderer or the quarrel with Monro. Provenance: the actual letters written by the two men at the time, read out by the Home Secretary in Parliament and recorded in Hansard, so it is direct evidence of the dispute; but Matthews chose what to read and wanted to show the government was not to blame for the murders; Warren later complained in a letter to The Times that the full correspondence would give 'an entirely different impression'. Context: under the Metropolitan Police Act the Commissioner acted under the Home Secretary's authority; Warren had clashed with the Home Office over orders and with Monro, who resigned as head of the CID in August 1888 but continued to advise Matthews; Warren's article in Murray's Magazine (November 1888) defended the police in public; the resignation became known just after the murder of Mary Kelly on 9 November; Monro succeeded him. Source B (Hansard, 20 November 1888). Content: Warren had claimed in public that 'in many cases' he had received instructions 'apparently contrary to Statute' and had protested and taken legal advice; Matthews says he knows of 'no occasion' on which he gave directions 'apparently or really contrary to the Statute'; he will not publish the 'voluminous Correspondence', part of which is 'altogether confidential'; an MP says 'the whole question turns on the relations that have existed for some time' between the Commissioner and the Home Office. Provenance: an accurate record of what was said in Parliament ten days after the resignation, giving both sides of the dispute; but Warren's view is reported second-hand by an opposition MP, the questions come from Liberal MPs critical of the government, and because Matthews refused to publish the full correspondence, neither the MPs nor the historian can check who was right. Context: Matthews had already said on 13 November that there had been earlier 'differences of opinion' which led Warren to offer his resignation; Warren had clashed with the Home Office over orders, over Bloody Sunday (November 1887) and over the CID; Monro resigned in August 1888 but went on advising Matthews; East End meetings and newspapers had called for both Matthews and Warren to resign during the murders. Judgement: A is the most direct evidence because it contains the two men's own words at the moment the relationship broke down; B shows that the argument about the Home Secretary's power over the Commissioner went on after the resignation and that the full story was never made public, which warns that A is only Matthews's selection; together they show a long-running dispute over who controlled the police. Do not credit answers that only describe the murders.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.