Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of the Turf Fraud scandal of 1877.
Model answer
In the Turf Fraud scandal, senior detectives at Scotland Yard were found to have taken bribes from two swindlers, Harry Benson and William Kurr, to warn them when the police were about to act. At the 'Trial of the Detectives' at the Old Bailey in 1877 three detectives were sentenced to two years in prison, which badly damaged trust in Scotland Yard.
Explanation
The first mark is for a clear feature of the scandal, such as the swindle, the bribery of detectives, the trial or its results; the second is for a precise detail about that same feature. The best answers often link the scandal to the creation of the CID in 1878. Keep to one feature and support it.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of the Turf Fraud scandal identified, e.g. two swindlers ran fake betting schemes / they cheated a wealthy Frenchwoman of a large sum / they bribed senior detectives at Scotland Yard to warn them / several detectives were put on trial at the Old Bailey in 1877 / three detectives were found guilty and sent to prison / the scandal damaged public trust in Scotland Yard's detectives / it led to a Home Office inquiry and the creation of the CID in 1878.
Award 1 mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. Two swindlers ran fake betting schemes (1). Harry Benson and William Kurr sent out circulars and a fake racing newspaper to persuade people, mainly in France, to invest money in a 'system' of betting on horse races (1). e.g. They cheated a wealthy Frenchwoman (1). The Comtesse (Madame) de Goncourt lost about £10,000 before the fraud was discovered (1). e.g. They bribed Scotland Yard detectives (1). Senior detectives, including Meiklejohn and Druscovich, took money to warn the swindlers when the police were about to act (1). e.g. The detectives were put on trial (1). At the 'Trial of the Detectives' at the Old Bailey in 1877, three detectives were each sentenced to two years in prison, while a fourth, Chief Inspector Clarke, was acquitted (1). e.g. It led to the creation of the CID (1). A Home Office committee investigated the detective branch, and in 1878 it was reorganised as the Criminal Investigation Department under Howard Vincent (1). Accept approximate figures for the money. Accept 'Trial of the Detectives' and 'de Goncourt frauds'. Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for the swindle: Harry Benson and William Kurr, fake betting 'system' and a fake racing paper; for the victim: Madame de Goncourt lost about £10,000; for the bribes: detectives such as Meiklejohn and Druscovich warned the swindlers; for the trial: Old Bailey, 1877, three detectives (Meiklejohn, Druscovich and Palmer) sentenced to two years, Clarke acquitted; for the results: a Home Office committee and the creation of the CID in 1878 under Howard Vincent.
The supporting information must develop the feature given for the first mark. Do not credit a general comment such as 'it was a big scandal'. Do not credit dates for the CID other than 1878.