Question 1
4 marksExplain one way in which the tribunals that heard claims for exemption from military service in the Second World War (1939-45) were different from the tribunals of the First World War (1916-18).
Model answer
One difference is who sat on the tribunals. In the First World War, local tribunals were made up of local councillors and other well-known local men, who usually had no legal training. A military representative attended the hearings to argue that the army needed men, and he could appeal against any exemption. As a result, only about 300 conscientious objectors were given absolute exemption. In the Second World War, each tribunal was chaired by a lawyer, usually a county court judge, and included a trade union member, but there was no military representative. Applicants also had a right of appeal to appellate tribunals chaired by High Court judges. These tribunals were more willing to accept claims of conscience: of about 61,000 men and women who applied, nearly 3,000 received unconditional exemption, and most of the rest were given civilian work or non-combatant duties.
Explanation
A Level 2 answer states one clear difference, such as the military representative in 1916-18 compared with tribunals chaired by judges in 1939-45, and supports it with specific detail from both wars, such as the numbers given absolute or unconditional exemption. Saying only that tribunals were 'fairer' in the Second World War stays in Level 1. Do not suggest that every objector was exempted in 1939-45: about 18,000 were rejected.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO2: 2 marks. AO1: 2 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): Features of the period are analysed to explain a difference. [AO2] Specific information about the topic is added to support the comparison, showing good knowledge and understanding of the periods. [AO1]
Level 1 (1-2 marks): Simple or generalised comment is offered about a difference. [AO2] Generalised information about the topic is included, showing limited knowledge and understanding of the periods. [AO1]
0 marks: No rewardable material.
Performance in AO1 and AO2 is interdependent. An answer displaying no qualities of AO2 cannot be awarded more than the top of Level 1, no matter how strong performance is in AO1; markers should note that the expectation for AO1 is that candidates demonstrate both knowledge and understanding.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Valid differences, each needing specific information from both wars for Level 2: (1) Who sat on the tribunals: in 1916-18 local tribunals were made up of local councillors and other local notables, usually with no legal training, and a military representative attended to argue that men were needed by the army and could appeal against exemptions; in 1939-45 each tribunal was chaired by a lawyer, usually a county court judge (a sheriff in Scotland), included a trade union member (and a woman member when the applicant was a woman), and had no military representative. (2) Outcomes: in 1916-18 only a few hundred of at least 16,000 conscientious objectors received absolute exemption (estimates range from about 200 to 350; estimates of the total vary up to about 20,000), and most were given non-combatant service or conditional exemption for work of national importance, or were refused; in 1939-45, of about 60,000 men and 1,000 women who applied, nearly 3,000 received unconditional exemption and most received conditional exemption (civilian work such as farming, forestry or hospital work) or non-combatant duties, although about 18,000 were rejected. (3) Appeals: in 1916-18 appeals went to county appeal tribunals, and the Central Tribunal heard cases only with leave, which was rarely granted; in 1939-45 applicants had a right of appeal to appellate tribunals chaired by High Court judges, and about a third appealed, about half of whose decisions were changed. (4) The law and the government's attitude: in 1916 there was confusion about whether tribunals should grant absolute exemption to objectors, and few did; from 1939 the law clearly allowed unconditional registration, and the Prime Minister, Neville Chamberlain, told Parliament in 1939 that even the most extreme objectors could be registered without conditions. Level 1: a generalised difference (e.g. 'tribunals were fairer in the Second World War') or detail about only one war. Do not credit: claims that all objectors in the Second World War were exempted; claims that there were no tribunals in the First World War; similarities (e.g. both could reject applications; both questioned applicants about their beliefs).