Question 1
40 marksBoys Don't Cry
You are advised to spend about 45 minutes on this question.
You should use the part of the novel described below and your knowledge of the whole novel to answer this question.
'Melanie is easy to blame but hard to condemn.' Write about Melanie and how she is presented at different points in the novel.
In your response you should:
- refer to the part of the novel described below and the novel as a whole
- show your understanding of characters and events in the novel. [40]
5 of this question's marks are allocated for accuracy in spelling, punctuation and the use of vocabulary and sentence structures.
The part of the novel to use (described, not printed, because the novel is in copyright): Look at the part of Chapter 6 where Melanie phones Dante, about an hour after leaving Emma with him, from the moment the phone rings and Dante hears her voice until she rings off, having told him that she is not coming back.
Model answer
Melanie appears in person only at the very start of 'Boys Don't Cry', in Chapters 1, 3 and 5, and then as a voice on the phone in Chapter 6. At first sight she is easy to blame: she hands her eleven-month-old daughter to a teenager who had no idea he was a father, and she does not come back. Yet Blackman makes her very hard to condemn. Melanie is presented not as a villain who abandons her baby but as a frightened young woman who has had almost no support herself, and the novel keeps turning the reader's judgement back on the people who are doing the judging.
The phone call in Chapter 6 is where the case for sympathy begins. Dante, alone with Emma, expects her back at any minute; instead she tells him that she is not coming back. The most striking thing she says is that "the thoughts in my head scare me". The simple, almost childlike words suggest that she is struggling with her mental health and is afraid of what she might do, so her leaving becomes an act of protection as well as escape. She also tells him that Emma deserves someone who can look after her properly, which shows that she is thinking of her daughter's needs rather than only her own. Blackman makes the scene more powerful by giving us nothing but her voice. She is already out of reach, and Dante's desperate begging changes nothing. The phone becomes a symbol of the distance between them, and of the way the decision has been taken out of his hands.
Earlier chapters prepare for this moment, and they make the reader question first impressions. In Chapter 1, before Dante knows the truth, he judges her harshly: "Mel wasn't even nineteen yet," he thinks, and he wonders how she could be "stupid enough to have a kid". Blackman builds dramatic irony here, because the chapter ends with Melanie's blunt revelation, "Dante, you're the dad." The short, plain sentence turns his judgement back on himself. When he refuses to believe her in Chapter 3 and asks, "How can you be sure it's mine?", her angry reply in Chapter 5, "I don't sleep around, Dante.", defends her dignity. Her use of his name makes the line direct and personal, and her anger shows how tired she is of being judged.
Melanie's explanations in Chapter 5 reveal how little help she has had. She tells Dante that she could not go through with an abortion or with adoption, that her mother threw her out, and that her aunt would only take her in if the baby was given up. At another point she tells him, "I brought myself up, Dante." The phrase "brought myself up" suggests a childhood without care, and she says that her own father did not care enough about her "to stick around". Melanie has been abandoned herself, and she asks what she knows about "bringing up a kid". Her self-doubt makes her leaving understandable, if not easy to forgive.
Blackman also shows that Melanie is not careless. In Chapter 1 she changes Emma's nappy confidently and explains to Dante how "you whip out the old nappy", which shows a practical skill he does not yet have. She has cared for Emma for eleven months, and the birth certificate shows that she has given her daughter a full name, Emma Cassandra Angelina Dyson. Her departure is therefore presented as a painful choice made by someone at the end of her strength, not as indifference.
Blackman also makes Melanie harder to condemn by making her mirror Dante. Both are teenagers whose futures have been changed by one night, and both are judged for it. Dante's first instinct is to escape too: he feels that Melanie has left him with "a straitjacket of anxiety", a metaphor that shows he feels trapped and resentful. The difference is that he stays. Aunt Jackie's remark in Chapter 26, that some people get to walk away and some do not, sums up the contrast between them. Yet Blackman never lets that remark become a simple verdict on Melanie, because the reader has already heard her explain that she left so that Emma could have someone able to look after her properly.
In conclusion, Melanie is easy to blame but, as Blackman presents her, very hard to condemn. Her few words, especially on the phone in Chapter 6, reveal a young woman frightened by her own thoughts and let down by her own family, and the dramatic irony of Chapter 1 warns the reader against judging her as quickly as Dante does. Blackman does not excuse her leaving, but she makes us understand it, and in doing so she asks who really failed Emma: the mother who left, or the adults who left that mother to cope alone.
Explanation
A top-band answer engages with the claim, using the Chapter 6 phone call as a springboard to show how Melanie's words (her fear of her own thoughts, her wish for Emma to be properly cared for) make her hard to condemn, and then weighs blame against sympathy across the novel. It analyses methods such as the dramatic irony of Chapter 1 and the way her voice reaches us only through Dante. Weaker answers simply condemn her as a bad mother, or agree with the claim without analysing how Blackman creates sympathy.
Mark scheme
-
35 marks
Levels of response (35 marks). AO1 and AO2 are equally weighted in this question. (Eduqas's bands 5 to 1 are Levels 5 to 1.)
Level 5 (29-35 marks): AO1: Sustain focus on the task, including overview, convey ideas with consistent coherence and use an appropriate register; use a sensitive and evaluative approach to the task and analyse the extract and wider text critically; show a perceptive understanding of the extract and wider text, engaging fully, perhaps with some originality in their personal response; their responses include pertinent, direct references from across the extract and wider text, including quotations. AO2: Analyse and appreciate writers' use of language, form and structure; make assured reference to meanings and effects exploring and evaluating the way meaning and ideas are conveyed through language structure and form; use precise subject terminology in an appropriate context.
Level 4 (22-28 marks): AO1: Sustain focus on the task, convey ideas with considerable coherence and use an appropriate register; use a thoughtful approach to the task; show a secure understanding of key aspects of the extract and wider text, with considerable engagement; support and justify their responses by well-chosen direct reference to the extract and wider text, including quotations. AO2: Discuss and increasingly analyse writers' use of language, form and structure; make thoughtful reference to the meanings and effects of stylistic features used by the writer; use apt subject terminology.
Level 3 (15-21 marks), Level 2 (8-14 marks), Level 1 (1-7 marks): Eduqas's descriptors for these levels are given word for word at the start of the comments.
0 marks: Nothing worthy of credit.Level 3 (15-21 marks): AO1: Focus on the task, convey ideas with general coherence and use a mostly appropriate register; use a straightforward approach to the task; show an understanding of key aspects of the extract and wider text, with engagement; support and justify their responses by appropriate direct reference to the extract and wider text, including quotations. AO2: Comment on and begin to analyse writers' use of language, form and structure; make some reference to meanings and effects; use relevant subject terminology.
Level 2 (8-14 marks): AO1: Have some focus on the task, convey ideas with some coherence and sometimes use an appropriate register; use a limited approach to the task; show some understanding of key aspects of the extract and wider text, with some engagement; support and justify their responses by some direct reference to the extract and wider text, including some quotations. AO2: Recognise and make simple comments on writers' use of language, form and structure; may make limited reference to meanings and effects; may use some relevant subject terminology.
Level 1 (1-7 marks): AO1: Have limited focus on the task, convey ideas with occasional coherence and may sometimes use an appropriate register; use a simple approach to the task; show a basic understanding of some key aspects of the extract and wider text, with a little engagement; may support and justify their responses by some general reference to the extract and wider text, perhaps including some quotations. AO2: May make generalised comments on writers' use of language, form and structure; may make basic reference to meanings and effects; may use some subject terminology but not always accurately.
Indicative content. Responses may include: AO1: - Overview: Melanie appears only at the start (Chapters 1, 3 and 5, then on the phone in Chapter 6); leaving Emma invites blame, but Blackman builds sympathy for her; credit answers that agree or disagree with the claim; - In the moment: she will not come back; Emma deserves someone who can look after her properly; she is frightened by her own thoughts; Dante begs her to return; - Earlier: Dante's judgement of her in Chapter 1, the birth certificate and her revelation; her anger at his doubt and her explanations in Chapter 5 (abortion, adoption, her mother throwing her out, her aunt's condition, moving up north); - Wider: she mirrors Dante (one young parent leaves, the other stays) and is judged as he is; her own lack of family support; Jackie's "Some get to walk away" (Chapter 26) as a possible verdict on her. AO2: - Dramatic irony in Chapter 1: Dante judges a young mother before he learns he is the father; the blunt revelation that ends the chapter; - Her voice reaches us only through Dante's narration, and in Chapter 6 only down the phone, which shows her distance and makes her hard to judge; - Simple, direct language: "the thoughts in my head scare me"; "I brought myself up"; - Structure: she is never seen again after Chapter 6, so the reader's final view of her rests on her own explanations. This is not a checklist. Please reward valid alternatives.
The extract is described, not printed, because the novel is in copyright: credit accurate, detailed reference to this part of the novel (quotation from memory or close paraphrase) as reference to the extract. -
5 marks
SPaG. AO4 (5 marks).
High performance (4-5 marks): In the context of the Level of Demand of the question, Learners spell and punctuate with consistent accuracy, and consistently use vocabulary and sentence structures to achieve effective control of meaning.
Intermediate performance (2-3 marks): In the context of the Level of Demand of the question, Learners spell and punctuate with considerable accuracy, and use a considerable range of vocabulary and sentence structures to achieve general control of meaning.
Threshold performance (1 mark): In the context of the Level of Demand of the question, Learners spell and punctuate with reasonable accuracy, and use a reasonable range of vocabulary and sentence structures; any errors do not hinder meaning in the response.
0 marks: Candidates do not reach the threshold performance outlined in the performance descriptor above.AO4 is judged on the whole response: accuracy in spelling and punctuation, and the range and control of vocabulary and sentence structures. Content is credited only in the levels point. Award 0 where the candidate does not reach threshold performance (Eduqas: 5 of this question's marks are allocated for accuracy in spelling, punctuation and the use of vocabulary and sentence structures).